This is clearly one of the Idol performances of Carly's that people will look back on and say, "What were the judges smoking that night?" I suspect all three were just reading what was written on the cards in front of them per Paula's comments to Jason the following week. Simon's "...admit that you've got a boner..." comment speaks volumes in the wake of the Paula-gate scandal.
she sounds Celine Dion really!
jadetanchannel 1 year ago
very boring... hes not good.
zuduzeye 2 years ago
i wanna see the judges sing together
drpro01 2 years ago 3
lol That would be awesome
Jasumi 2 years ago
The judges are on crack. This was not pitchy, it was perfect! I love Carly!
Israelgal 2 years ago
Naja DSDS iat viel Besser :)
Viel moderner und so...
und bessere stimmen.
xXboy95Xx 3 years ago
naughty simon :D yeah nice pun from nickalodean with the icarly girl lol
leahme93 3 years ago
did u guysz hear simon
he won't admit that he has a boner???
hes crazy/
but carly was awesomee!!!
iloveyoulotsz14 3 years ago
lmfao.
"he wont admit he has a boner"
3:55
carly rocks at this song <333
emiiextremex3 3 years ago
simon is just angry cuz she owned his little leona prodigy at this song. cant wait for Carly's career outside of idol, its gonna be AMAZING
BlingyDamon3 3 years ago 2
she looked marvelous that night!
nicholos96 3 years ago
This is clearly one of the Idol performances of Carly's that people will look back on and say, "What were the judges smoking that night?" I suspect all three were just reading what was written on the cards in front of them per Paula's comments to Jason the following week. Simon's "...admit that you've got a boner..." comment speaks volumes in the wake of the Paula-gate scandal.
cbotten106 3 years ago
it is miranda cosgrove at 4:46-4:48 i love carly she sings good
11mercury11 3 years ago
deff deff
kkgurlxoxo 3 years ago
i thought she did pretty goood. carly has a strong voice and she'll makke it far
BTW, is that iCarly's Miranda Cosgrove at 4:48?
AprilSunshineRocks 3 years ago 2
deff deff
kkgurlxoxo 3 years ago
i think she can do it better...
muia91 3 years ago
what the hell was simon saying to paula just before randy spoke? something about wanting milk and getting a donut? eh???
mikeandstephpark 3 years ago
I, no lie, think it's was something naughty. He said like "I have the milk for your donut."
Ick.
elorawhoo 3 years ago
what the hell was simon saying to paula just before randy spoke? something about wanting milk and getting a donut? eh???
mikeandstephpark 3 years ago
love the girl...she is so sweet but she can not hit those notes that the song is about?
butifarra61 3 years ago
she is powerfull & an amazing singer,but she shows NO emotion,& its weird with such an enotional song
winkinsmily 3 years ago
yay m.c.
hotti3420 3 years ago 2