Mariah vs. Aaliyah (Low Notes)

[swacman04]

Mariah wins...so lush, sexy and more audible

[TheExaltedoneAaliyah]

Lol are y'all serious right now? aaliyah low notes >>>>>

[xGOSSIPGIRL95]

LOVE THEM :)

[daiell09]

Mariah, but Aaliyah isn't bad though

[AaliyahBrandyMonica]

there are both amazing. Mariah has a better voice and i like "most" of her music...her new stuff is a bit mehh. Now one shits on Aaliyah though. her voice was more mellow i will say that.

[Dboy4100X3]

I loved Aaliyah's low notes, especially live, their so deep, husky, and bassy.

[5788060]

Aaliyah's notes sound like its just coming so smooth and natural not to much work put in it.

[youngmoneyrealist05]

aaliyah was soprano u guys mariah is a alto aaliyah could sing higher than mariah

[daiell09]

Mariah

[ONENataliaONLY]

I always did love aaliyah's low notes. They are so beautiful and have such a great tone. Mariah of course does too. But, I say Aaliyah notes are have better tone quality.

[TheItGyal]

Both are great !

[Stefano94x]

Aaliyah wins!

[CarlaJou1]

love them both!!! incredible talents, diff strengths...but the are both ICONS but you hardly played lili's vocals, so short, make it fair

[mariahcareynum1fan]

@CarlaJou1

If the duration of the note is short, then the clip will be short.

[Stefano94x]

@mariahcareynum1fan Where is Aaliyah's E3 at 2:21 from? thank you :)

[CarlaJou1]

love them both!!! incredible talents, diff strengths...but the are both ICONS

[AndreiTaiapaSmith]

i love Aaliyah but you got to admit Mariah is the winner !

[mariahthebest1]

Both are amazing I love both of them R.I.P Aaliyah we miss you and great job on the vid.

[mariahcareynum1fan]

@mariahthebest1

Thanks!!!

[laladancer7]

I just love Aaliyah's songs better in general...beats/rhythm and voice...

[youngmoneyrealist05]

they look alike with the hair and sunglasses

[Lukek26]

2 angels. Perfect - #WeLove Liyah and Mimi

[Lukek26]

2 angels. Perfect - #WeLove Liyah and Mimi

[theblueangel28]

yeah. its the angels singing!!

love it

[Chimier]

OMG...just...so close. Mariah reigns, but Aaliyah is the princess.

[armontahje34]

gud video. Aaliyah wins hands down!!

[Dboy4100X3]

Aaliyah just kills those low notes man!!

[blacckty1991]

Love this!!!!

[IcedLipGloss]

what is the song at 0:33 0:42 0:49 0:56 1:13 1:37

[crazy2hazy]

Mariah's are more audible than Aaliyah's, but Aaliyah's sound great too.

[AaliyahDawnTEAM]

Yes the Angels can both Sang!!! i always said that Mariah and Aaliyah had the best low notes..lili and Mimi can even go lower..

i think a Mariah & Aaliyah Vs

Toni & Brandi low note battle would be so epic..

[bajeboi]

great vid

[mariahcareynum1fan]

@bajeboi Thank You! =D

[KingLild2010]

Aaliyah won

[Drich18]

Bb2: Aaliyah

B2: Not sure, probably a tie. I liked Aaliyah's 2nd B2 more thou

C3: Aaliyah

C#3: Mariah

D3: Tie

Eb3: Aaliyah

E3: Tie

F3: Aaliyah

F#3: Mariah

G3: Aaliyah

[lastdarklight]

AHHHHH I LOVE YOU FOR MAKING THIS!

[DonavonKingTV]

Mariah

But I love Aaliyah

Also Aaliyah has done a G2 & A2 before

[calvin999999999]

Eb3: Mariah

E3 1: Tie

E3 2: Mariah, but its an Eb3

E3 3: Mariah

E3 4: Aalyiah

F3 1: Aalyiah

F3 2: Aalyiah

F#3: Aalyiah

G3: Mariah

[calvin999999999]

Based on these notes:

Bb2: Aaliyah (Don't think that is a Bb2 for Mariah)

B2 1: Mariah

B2 2: Aaliyah

C3: Aalyiah

C#3 1: Mariah

C#3 2: Mariah

D3 1: Tie

D3 2: Aalyiah ( i think MC one is a C#3)

[VaunTV]

Aaliyah: B2, C#3, D3, F3

Mariah: Bb2, C3, Eb3, E3

Tie: F#3

[OKzs]

@VaunTV WOW I agree completely with you

Love the Choosey Lover at the end, these Aaliyah songs are taking me back!!

[VaunTV]

lol thanks :)

[Fattakink]

Mariah

Aaliyah can go low but it sounds very forced

[youngmoneyrealist05]

@Fattakink yeah cause aaliyah doesnt really sing low like mariah

[DonkPatrol]

@youngmoneyrealist05 Actually Aaliyah did sing in her lower range quite often on tracks.. I dont recall an aaliyah song where she didnt go G#3 or lower.. Mariah and Aaliyah both seem very comfortable in their lower and higher ranges

[Stefano94x]

@Fattakink Nope. Aaliyah doesn't strain in her lower register. She hits E2, she sounds way more natural and powerful than Mariah, she also has better vocal quality. Aaliyah wins. Mariah is good too, but not THAT good I think.

[Fattakink]

@Stefano94x that supposed E2 i dont believe is her. her live notes compared to these mysterious 2nd octave notes just dont make sense she barely touches C3 live on top of that they sould ever breathy. Mariahs lower register is very solid and strong.

mariahs slays, but Aaliyahs voice was cute i give her that

[Stefano94x]

@Fattakink @Fattakink The 2nd octave notes are from her, no doubt. When you listen to Givin'up, it's evident that the G2 is her. Sadly she couldn't improve, she died at 22 :( Her lower register was pretty extreme, especially because we're speaking about a singer who has never really exploited her vocal range.

[Fattakink]

@Stefano94x G2 is a far as i think she went. i see alot of people extend her range, but most people know that [i forget his name at the moment] did alot of her background singing he also died. Im pretty sure Aaliyah with due time could have been an excellent vocalist, she was promising i know, but the point is [not to be rude]

but when put against a vocal titan like Mariah, baby girl is just that. a baby girl.

[Stefano94x]

@Fattakink I never thought of Mariah as a vocal titan. She is considered such by many, I know she's very good in terms of technique and range, but I find her tone too bland and inconsistent. A vocal titan would be, IMO, Whitney Houston or Aretha Franklin, not her.

Aaliyah also hit F2. I've watched some videos (accurate videos, not fake) and it was a real F2. She said she was a soprano but I actually have some doubts.

[Fattakink]

@Stefano94x oh it for certain Aaliyah was no bodys soprano most of her weight were in her lower register. i tihnk she was in fact a lyric alto

can you provide a link of this F2? i find that very hard to believe.

Mariah yes her technique was very good the control she possess is crazy [perfect to some] and needless to say her range, but its more based on how she used her voice like a actual instrument with good sense of pitch, timing, and creating actual musical structures with her mellisma

[Stefano94x]

@Fattakink

F#2

/watch?v=0_DtZNz0kgo

F2 & F#2 & G2

/watch?v=qgBSty7opII

Mariah has still a good technique, she doesn't sing like before because of the nodules in her vocal chords, but her technique has always been amazing. I don't like her cos I find her tone very flat and inconsistent, especially on upper chest register, but she's without doubt a talented singer.

[Fattakink]

@Stefano94x oh im subscribe to him. i seen his videos and i still doubt them well except that F#2 It sounded like an exhale. i know its in fact her but im not sure if id include that in her vocal range. sorta like whitneys A2. its like a weak breath of air.

and the F2-G2 slide in More than a woman is that man whom for the life of me i can seem to remember his name. i think it was someones shocker or something. idk. i think he was in Lil Waynes Lollipop song

[AnimeBoi19]

@Fattakink he is actually a she LMAO

[youngmoneyrealist05]

@Fattakink aaliyah voice was soft thats why people get confuess about her voice she is a soprano in which mariah carey is an alto

[youngmoneyrealist05]

@Fattakink yeah it sounds force cause shes no alto like mariah if it sounds force then u not a alto or soprano

[Fattakink]

@youngmoneyrealist05 being an alto doesnt mean you can hit extremely low notes easily. look at Toni her lowest note is Bb2. being an alto means most of your vocal weight is in the lower parts of your voice. thats why her belts sound so light because the higher she goes the less weight she is able to "carry"