Supertramp The Logical Song

[MentalTeleprosy]

How was he so great and ahead of his time? A prophet of sorts. Just a channel?

[bellarico28]

And to this day, I am still asking myself the same questions. Who I am?

[draguibus92]

Mark hart, quelle merde : big shit

[cutiepiecr]

Ha, I'm 16, & I vibe off of this at least 3 times a day ! Good post !

[DaviesSpectrum]

I just came here by chance to listen to a great song i heard as a child,THIS MAN IS FLAT AND OUT OF TUNE??? i gues that is what happens when you try to copy a Legend like Roger

[barrontide]

@DaviesSpectrum

Thanks for the comment. I didn't pay too much attention to who was in or out of Supertramp and didn't realize that this wasn't the original singer. Rodger Hodgson really does it so much better on the video response.

[BeetleTheGreen]

I don't know who that guy is, But that's not Roger Hodgson

[MsOrion99]

Falta la magia de Roger Hodgson

[BrokenneckYgor]

I have seen the white man by day, and I have seen the white man by night. I have seen the white man move and at rest. I think he is surely the ugliest creature the Good Lord has seen fit to place upon Earth.---Lao Tse, famed China thinker.

[glennotf]

This is disgusting.

[titidij2]

We miss you Roger.

[huchimo01]

This new guy sucks. What is he doing up there? Looks like he would rather be somewhere else. Where is Roger? Where is Roger?

[HARClX]

Good morning! Pump it up!

[PIGneyDrinksPiss]

i ripped off this song lol #Flopminal

[LancealotWarpio]

I love Supertramp. Great band live.

[MCVANDERM]

One of my favorite bands! Why does he sing so out of tune??? It is unbearable!! Better put on my old 1st 3 elpees ...

[drkam6]

PITIFUL

[TheKsk1997]

Please sign this petition for training teachers and staff on ADHD so our schools can be what they're meant to be: compassionate and humane .. go to the petition site dot com and type 'adhd' in search look for 'Schools Adopt Training ..' .. Thank you and have a Great Week

[ironmannsane1]

Who is this clown?

[dkshotwell]

Without Roger Hodgson this is pointless. Its horriblle "going through the motions for a paycheck" wedding reception dreck.

[Chewbackaification]

I'm 13 and I hate Justin Bieber,Hannah Montanah &all the rest. But I SURE DO LOVE Queen,Dire Straits,Bon Jovi,Kelly Family,Supertramp,Guns'n Roses,Nirvana,Smash Mouth, Pink Floyd,etc. I stand for real music. (thumbs up if you feel the same.)

[Metalmack95]

@Chewbackaification Check out the Band Sonata Arctica and the song Replica. It will change your life. If you like Queen you will love Sonata Arctica :D

[Chewbackaification]

@Metalmack95 thanks a lot. :)

[DuallyDieselFord]

@Chewbackaification Do you want an award?

[lormendi]

@DuallyDieselFord No, he's a 13 year old who knows who the fuck Supertramp is. If that doesn't speak for itself then just be quiet.

[DuallyDieselFord]

@lormendi So I've been listening to Supertramp my whole life as well. He's not special just because he listens to a old band. Old people say todays music sucks but thats what their parents said about Led Zeppelin and Supertramp. I don't know why age is important in music choice

[Chewbackaification]

@DuallyDieselFord Actually,I'm a she. And I just said what I really wanted to say. I think that's why it's called comment section. And no,I assure you. My parents listen to the same music and love it. If you wanna fight, go to any other website. Thanks for your opinion and sorry for the eventual mistakes,english is not my native language.

[DuallyDieselFord]

@Chewbackaification I don't want to fight but I don't know why everyone under age 20 feels the need to post their age. Age is but a number. It shouldn't matter for music

[swatdaman]

@lormendi Ooh ooh ooh I'm 13 years old too! 

[bigbeardoingthangs]

@Chewbackaification Quit frontin' child I used to think Stravinsky was the coolest shit (I also thought if I was seen in public reading Ayn Rand books that girls would think I was cool) then I grew up and realized I was acting like an asperger.

[Chewbackaification]

@bigbeardoingthangs Actually,people hate me and think I'm weird only because I listen to different music. Don't think I'm popular.Appearently,I'm only appreciated here

[drewkuch]

@Chewbackaification Great choices!

[AlmostTooLateNow]

When i was young it seemed that life was so wonderful. Now it all SUCKS!

[phelplitz]

This arrangement and cast of characters performing it is illogical. I wouldn't pay a cover to see it.

[cover821]

im 18 years old and i LOVE Supertramp :)

[MyBebopBlues]

Its not that bad people. Stop whinning and listen to the music already -.-

[aCleverLittleGirl]

these are my exact thought. only not so lyrically inclined.

[jembozzo]

noway, hodgson is a genius, he created this song, and didn't want it to be played by supertramp without him , it's very clear !!

and roger's voice is unique and far more beautiful

[harryandsimba]

Why are people so critical of this version?

It's hardly any different from the original,and the singer's voice is very similar to Hodgson's.

[TubeSalvation]

watch?v=ysNd4QGOgeY

[magyster67]

Ma chi cazzo e questo elementi imbronciato

[zerbrennendannrennen]

Britney Spears stole a part of this for her 'Criminal"

[Jameshistory]

@zerbrennendannrennen When I first heard Britney's song, I thought she was singing this song with a different twist. I knew I heard those lyrics before!

[Yurmash]

Super!

[dado75dr]

Bleah... Sostituire Hodgson con questo qui non ha avuto nessun senso.

[Gho0o0o0o0o0oster]

kids who complain about this song , are still young thinks life is so wonderful

[BoyGeorge47]

does not exist - true

[williehackitt1]

Love john but not the same band without roger

[cellphone96]

GOD DAMN IT SUPERTRAMP WHY ARE YOUR SONGS SO GOOD BUT I NEVER KNOW THE NAME OF THEM!!!!!!

[MrBohica1980]

Can't believe that they actually thought it would be a good idea to ruin such a song.

[tawheedization]

1 of the most logical song about this b.s. society ever rock on !!!!

[jaruan2007]

Con todos mis respetos a este cantante. ¡Esto no es Supertramp! Si no, pregúntenselo a Roger Hodgson. Triste versión... intentando imitar a uno de los más grandes intérpretes....

[petzjak]

aha 240p we meet again..

[J3joooo3]

The hate must came from Justin bieber fans

[maggitymagzmag]

This interrupted my dog's nap.

[turtlliwdnifuoyehthr]

the hate comments are just like on YES videos!

[coreyl456]

Hey at least John Helliwell played bloody marvelous, without him there would be no sax, I agree though Roger is the one and only voice for Supertramp. But give John Helliwell a lot of credit too he is amazing with the sax and makes me laugh too xD

[MrROTD]

I love the sax in this song!!!

[kitkatism1]

Love this song... The words really tell so much of what so many of us are about. Great going!

[mymarilyn26]

Mark Hart no supera a Roger Hodgson pero tiene lo suyo en su aporte y estilo a la banda Británica, en el devenir del tiempo.

[london2z]

It's either the new Supertramp, or Roger's newer live shots. Where are any of the old Supertramp live videos?

[Bicknellable]

This is crap !

[SiriusShaun]

Unfortunately unperformed.

[dazzion333]

Supertramp are not convinced enough that Roger Hodgson is a fundamental part of the band and they keep ignoring a lot of fan's requests to see them all back together again. It's all about proud. Fake proud. Who will tell them that when life is finished there will be no time anymore to play together?

[rihannafan16ify]

I got here from some guy saying that Britney Spears ripped off this song /X-(

[Fearmiglitter]

these songs bring back good memories of when i was younger... [:

[elfernandosabe]

Curios version. Never heard by Mark Hart. Is good equal. Supertramp to all ¡¡!!

[MortySklar]

Thrilling (as much as Roger Hodgson's) even at my age, 76. Yeah, I can remember when I was young and out-of-place.

[TheHellaciousAngel]

ugh! this is not scooter! yes...scooter ripped off the chorus, but scooter did not wright this song....not that i don't like that version because i do but THIS is not scooter........

[fgrio85]

Classic.

[kja427]

What? YouTube does have performances of Supertramp? I wish they had more from 1979; I liked this tune back then.

[TheApomania]

240p we meet again :P

[herman8rrr]

@TheApomania 240p  is that your bank balance ?

[MrMetantropo]

Pienso como fanático de SUPERTRAMP que la banda era un 50 para Rick y un 50 para Roger, pero dejar cantar los temas de Roger a este Mark Hart es una falta de respeto a todo el esfuerzo colocado en la composición de estas canciones y una gran ofensa para todo fan de la banda, lo puedo permitir de una banda homenaje o de covers pero es doloroso saber que cuenta con el aval del gran Rick Davies, muy malo!!!

[FreeBirdStone]

@MrMetantropo estoy de acuerdo, no creo que una banda pueda continuar después de perder su cantante. 

[bk71259]

For Rick to play this song is just WRONG!! His songs couldn't hold a candle compared to Roger's contributions to Supertramp!!!!

[The1chihira]

just stay oung at hart

[patricevert]

These chords played on the Fender Rhodes piano are unforgettable...!

[pimpinhector]

@patricevert It's Wurlitzer 200a not Fender Rhodes

[grgrdb]

SCOOTER!

[Rashy3000]

I still like this one, solid performance by all. Just missing the magic is all.

[piranhavitana]

A very poor version of this song, too painful for my ears to hear it for more than a minute!

[andresihotang]

I hate Justin Bieber. But come on , I prefer hearing his perhaps only great tune 'Smile' rather than this rubbish..

Roger must have cried of hearing this

[andresihotang]

I stopped watching this video at 1:00 !!!

The first and the last.

Enough said

[teton2401]

I think my headache just came back. How can anyone sit through this whole video? Sounds like a band at a wedding. I need my daily dose of Roger Hodgson, the real voice of Supertramp, now! Nothing like seeing Roger, the heart and soul of the band. Without him, Supertramp does not exist.  Current lineup of Supertramp is a cover band.

[london2z]

@teton2401 Like when they took David Clayton Thomas out of B.S. & T.

[badhorsee]

@teton2401 agreed

[demonio351]

@badhorsee que razon tienes... no me termina de llenar.... ¿porque imitan?

[zoidberg3009]

@teton2401 The one by Scooter is better. (in my opinion)

Give it a shot: watch?v=fshtAsRHn_s

[tonyt581]

This Guynsuck's ! why do people . Listen, to such, emagatatioms, ! of magic! Yes spelled it ! Right!

[Violet2r1]

I AM GUESSING AT THE LAST PLACE ON EARTH IS MY PLACE TO FINE THAT METALICA CD YOU LOST OR EIGHTENN BOOK ON SOMETHING BUT IF YOUR WATCHING 29 DVD ABOUT HITCHICKING TO OUR PLACE THAT ONE GOT ANOTHER THING COMMING

[GNR4EVAR]

where do youfind url for youtube/mp3 converter

[Gladysalma]

Where is the magic? It's just so sad!

[supercj8899]

Why cant i find the original?

[andresihotang]

@supercj8899 Supertramp (or label? company?) have removed all the original, HQ live videos some weeks ago..

You are totally unlucky

[tonyvu60]

This voice has no strength.

[marcosrauta]

Supertramp era uma banda com um som inigualável. A separação de Roger e Rick foi a decadência de ambos.... o Roger Hodgson sem o Rick nao causou muita inspiração... ja o supertramp com o Rick nao se aguenta sem o Roger... uma coisa nunca atingirá a excelência sem a outra... infelizmente quem nunca viu a Banda na sua formação original nao saberá o que foi o supertramp: uma verdadeira revolução no Rock.... eu ainda acredito na reunião de ambos...

[rudy71478]

Where is Roger ??..

[Chico4761]

Its too bad knowing how good the band was and they changed everything, I'm sad for that but I still love the band or what they were.

[sslsoares]

R-I-D-Í-C-U-L-O. Rick Davies deveria se manter com suas músicas..

[Navazarian]

Is this from the "It was the best of times" album? It sound exactly like it. Also, I dont get why theres so much negativity towards Mark Hart. I know he doesnt sound exactly like Roger, but c'mon, hes doing a good job and the band sounds awesome still. I love this band.

[krkraz]

Britney: that's the name of a stripper I once knew. "The green party cannot justify why the sin existed then." Again, it can make these a multitude about to explain the waste...

[PinkDiamondFreak]

britney spears song criminal sounds NOTHING like this weird song

[zz1rdystarfish]

I love this SONG!!!!

[SeanMichaelShowalter]

I think the singer is really good, but he was a little off this night. It happens. I'm a professional musician myself, and you can't be perfect every night. Go easy on the guy.

[bobylify]

i dont know how i should feel towards that singer, looks almost like a girl... the voice is amazing regardless

[KarLight13]

naahhhh lets get Roger back!!!!!!!!!!!!

[crazydavedisco]

Why bother without Roger?

[breybrey2dajizzay]

Britney Spears sampled this. nice job on both artists

[tarkan525201]

sure would be nice to find the original studio version wtf

[batfly]

This song just all of a sudden popped into my head for no apparent reason... It's illogical.

[SmokeBojangles]

Who IS The guy Singing? A Scab?

[nirob]

well sorry too say that 824 people don't know shit about music sorry folks

[nirob]

omfg dude sucks!!!!!! hell give me a try out i'll blow his ass away can't believe they let this dude sing!!! sudden death too super tramp

[suitep33]

love supertramp <3

[bigdsears]

Sounds like he's inhailed some helium or something

[StumptownBoy]

Having this bloke sing Roger's songs and destroy them is just a big bowl of wrong.

[RRadRussian]

WTF??? The original song is performed by a guy???!!!

[meatpole55]

im sure he fells the pressure..but at least he rated for the job...its a lot of pressure for him...i remember when i dated this girl whose EX boyfriend had a 12 inch penis ,,and i has 4 inches..but she over came it when i offered her fist sex..we been together 30 years..lol

[ya2121]

@meatpole55 dont you mean you came over her? xD

[MustaffaCuppa]

Ahhh! Sorry but this was awful... I couldn't listen to it all the way through, it was so bad. Come back Roger!

[zzmx5]

Sorry, but this is a travesty that I just can't listen to. I'm not going to watch what I say. I know it sounds absurd. Without Roger it's anything but bloody marvelous.

[MortySklar]

@zzmx5 Are you some kind of logical guy? To me they're both beautiful. "Travesty"?--Did you really try to think of the right word or words? That would put logic to good use.

[zzmx5]

@MortySklar If you want to see what this performance should have been, look up Roger's version live from Rotterdam in 1995 at the Night of the Proms.

[Salva0711]

good rock

[alankeen123]

I will not bash Mark because he is a much better singer than myself, however for me this doesn't work AT ALL. I would rather go see Rodger Hodgson in concert before I would Supertramp. His voice is so beautiful and unique ! HE is the voice of ST. DOn't feel bad, no one else can measure up either Mark.

[lyndonbaldwin]

Nothing wrong with Mark Hart's vocals at all! You have to understand that everyone sings differently, intones differently and sound different. That is the beauty of the human voice. Go Mark!

[wtf66611]

Ummmmm...i like the 1979 original much, much better.

[nikkibailey3407]

this song was butchered!

[Martaaan09]

makes me want to hug a bear

[crazydavedisco]

A pale imitation of the original - nuff said !

[w800user]

I just heard the full version of this song on the radio today and it gave me a vision of when those cops where beating up hippies.

[EMILIOWBT]

yeaaa saludos des Lima Peru . proto aki para deleitarnos con su musica , (y)

[Mielten]

A disgrace! Supertramp as a bad copy of itself!

[soupywoop256]

Very good makes Supertramp very popular

[pippin24]

Oh Yes, remember this one?? I'ts a good one!!!!

[meatpole55]

who the hell is this singing this song...hey all of you dont be mad but im not happy with this PECKERWOOD singer

[dirgon]

I thought contractual agreements between Roger and the band when the split prevented Supertramp from performing any songs written solely by Roger?

[mikeshanteler]

I couldn't listen to this.

[drkam6]

this guy is so wooden, kick him out and BRING ROGER BACK, pitiful performance

[championkhan]

Anyone got a time machine? I got the 2011 blues.

[MrViolero]

Horrivel!

[Winadir]

Roger Hodgson is better than Hart, he was SUPERTRAMP !!! The "real'ogical" leader in 70's and 80's with Rick Davies ...

[arturocobain]

No es lo mismo sin roger hodson

[2010UncleFester]

Buh buh buh buh buh bloody awful , this!

It seems the vast majority of people here agree, that Supertramp without Roger Hodgson is a SHAM. Rick Davies should stick to the mostly mediocre crap that he did and leave the HITS of Roger alone. The stands would empty, except for people desperate to see them. Thank God I had the fortune to see them several times in the 70's at the height of their careers. Fools Overture is BRILLIANT.....your turn Rick! Hodgson's LORD IS IT MINE is amazing!

[de3jb]

@2010UncleFester I saw them on their farewell tour in the 80's at Alpine Valley Music Theater in East try Wisconsin, best show I ever saw,,,,,,,,,,, good thing memories are forever

[BESUGONET]

MEU RICO ROGER HODGSON...

[kingofallwhites]

Bob and John should have saved their money they made back in the 70's and 80's so they wouldn't have to sing in this cover band with a retard like this singing on lead.

[56postman]

NOBODY CAN SING ROGER NO NEVER !!!!!!!!

[transformer1967]

This Mark is an horrible singer who Rick Davies contract for mock Roger... You just see any play of this one at the piano: no comparison...

[viscig60]

I can only assume this guy had a sore throat or was sick at the time of this concert. Great song but he was either not on this night or just gave it his best effort. I know it is not Roger singing.

[nickrock23]

oh my god what the hell is this??

[Comuna]

WHO I AM?? Anyone can tell ya...

[MsPepper112]

all these songs are more than inccedible.back when we were kids  this kicked our ass 's PLEASE WILL SOMEONE TRY TO PUT THIS CATALOG ON LINE HOW STUPID ARE WE THAT WE WON'T DO ....OR TRY TOO DO THIS !!!!!!we have all bunches of "stuffshit" that we don't here.......

'

[UmCaraOldYoung]

Essa é de quando ainda se faziam músicas.

[davcur56]

good song/ but i just now saw the video,, i thought it was a chick singing this/ my bad----dave/ jax. florida

[gahloot]

Rubbish!

[gloriacharly]

tiene buena voz , como para ser un hombre tan sencillo como ÈL

[ivan89705]

saxawhistler

[AprilMaybeMay]

Leave off Mark Hart, he's a cool guy and a fab musician. A crumby youtube recording does not do any performance justice. The original guy isn't there, what would you rather they did, play a sax version?

[sheilaboy44]

LONG LIVE SUPERTRAMP FOR ALL TIME AND LONG LIVE THEIR FANS FOR KEEPING THEM ALIVE IN THEIR HEARTS!!!!!

[bibon02]

that's not right no true supertramp c'est de la mer sans robert hodgson

[Rushgoon1]

higher bpm.

[palmquistutube]

he screwed with the song, he sounds he got a cold....heheheh, I prefer the original...

[palmquistutube]

He screw with the song....I prefer the original......

[Robin4sure]

Why they even bother singing this. It sounds like a bad bar I went to with some dude in the back signing. The Police figured it out. Pink Floyd figured it out. Led Zep even for a couple concerts figured it out. Come on Rick give Roger a call man before your all dead and gone.

[70goldtop]

@Robin4sure No please don't.Stupid gayness.Please don't mention Zep and Floyd in the same sentence as these assholes.If I hear this annoying mess on the radio one more time..........................­..............................