the muay thai knee was 'stronger' because the head was held thus all the power was thrust into the dummy. In the other demonstrations, some of the force drove into the dummy's chest and the rest was put into flinging the dummy back. Its kind of like board breaking holding it on one side and letting the other side dangle free vs, holding both sides giving it support.
lol i remembered i seen this on tv and just shaking my head in disgust at the produces of this peice of shit, I like how they dont take into account the individual weight of each person lol, I thought these guys were suppose to be smart. another thing i like how they label punches and kicks, it's about body mechanics not styles, there's only so many ways to punch and kick.
lol somebody had to do it, some ppl that actually visit this video and watch this bullshit dont have the common sense to figure out the bigger the guy(mass), the harder the punch
theyre just showing the difference in style you could imagine a bigger or smaller persons number vary slightly but the test still proves which strikes are weaker or stronger in comparison to others. All these martial artists are experts in their style i would expect them to deliver a deadly blow regardless of weight.
So did anybody notice the trick of this video? ANYBODY??? Look at it again and see if U can catch it. FACT: they gave the power pressure (in pounds) of which leg use was the most powerful- BUT THEY DIDN'T TELL YOU MUAY THAI's!! All they said was 35mph. FACT: they didnt say mph for the other kicks. So you have no bearings on where MT stands in power placement. Those other kicks couldve been 40mph or 36mph. It's all in how the narrator speaks 2 impress U and the paid technicians
yeah, but though you can block or counter a kick or punch, blocking the knee strike while in a clinch is a lot more difficult. Knowing the pressure is irrelivant
Uhhhh....NO mechucat, knowing the pressure is NOT irrelevant since that was the whole point of the experiment. Try ACTUALLY watching the video. They were using technology to determine which martial art was the one with the most powerful leg use by strictly comparing the numbers. DUH.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
These things are bullshit, I love muay thai but if the knee was that destructive wouldn't fighters die all the time? It's a ring sport practiced all over the place, you don't hear about people dying every time. And they don't kick fucking palm trees, that's from a movie.
Actually many have died in thailand mostly from elbows and internal bleeding! Also in thailand they do train on banana trees. I've been there. I've trained there and i have seen it happen. Thais are very tough!!! You might not tell by their size but they are deadly. I've spared a thai and I got my head spining for the hole day!!! In your country as in my country the training is not so tough!
yes they do you dumb fuck i had to do it in my mma training so stfu you dont even know anything you just think you are smart because you can watch tv and comment on youtube when really your a 13 or 46 yr old virgin that cant get a date.
Have you taken a knee to the chest or any body part...e g your thigh?Trust me, your opinion will change on the spot...and yes people die and no it doesnt happen every day because of stoppages in ring sports...otherwise a lot of people would die in a lot of ring sports, let alone muay thai..even just western boxing...
It depends on the place of Impact, where the hit is. There are alot of things to take into consideration during a fight. and yes, they do practice on trees.
I'm wondering if he didn't hold on to the head, would it really be that powerful. They should have something holding the dummy's head while the other guys took a shot at it. I bet you that the Spinning Back Kick would to the most damage.
It's a little difficult to deliver a powerful knee to the sternum while in a clinch.
Your stupid thats the WHOLE fucking point of this technique... its to STOP him from falling back... inducing more absorption of the knee. They use that with elbows and shit too... fucking funykboodah nigger.
Uh... kickboxing is not Japanese...No, kickboxing doesn't use knees or elbows...(maybe savate but they don't use it in competitions.) and i think the "kickboxing" your talking about is.. karate? hehe..
1) kickboxing IS japanese, made by osamu noguchi, if you think kickboxing is american, please drop dead.
2) i NEVER said kickboxing uses elbows, now your just being even a bigger idiot.
3) nope, im not on about karate, although the parenthood of kickboxing is boxing with various asian martial arts, therefore, yes, karate would be related, but no, im not about no karate.
LOL ouch, i didn't actually think it was American...I thought it was European. LOL Being an idiot for being wrong? hehe... i think the word is ignorant?? You DO know what this word means riiight? :) buuuut... you ARE correct, i did some research, it is Japanese,well Next time when you tell someone to drop dead, don't expect them to not think your a fucking asshole :)
wahahaha, no, your an asshole... i think people that tell others whats what without knowing jack are bigger assholes than people telling you to drop dead=]]
Hey buddy,i just called my self ignorant lol i was just asking you what does ignorant mean, can you tell me? pleeese :) And even though I'm being an "asshole" for retaliating(again, you know what this means right?) at least im not the bully who goes on you tube and goes on a translation site to communicate with your bullshit in another language. Even if your not translating your insults, i can say that your English sucks."whats what without knowing jack."?..are you having fun? :)
Lol dude i said "at least im not the bully who goes on you tube" in those actual words. learn to read :) grow up? lol alright you got me, you win this one :) yay 2 points for snipe :)
mhmm, my english does suck, or should i say ENGRISHHH..Q_Q'
and wtf? "at least im not no bully who goes on you tube"
your grammar freakin' sucks... and how could i bully you behind a computer screen? little boy... grow up <--- thats what you said NOT...."at least im not the bully who goes on you tube" dumb fuck!! BOI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Look BITCH your not as smart as you think you are. I <--- Said American Kickboxing because you said kickboxing is not american....thats when i said there is such a thing as American kickboxing..... and i already fucking said you dumb FUCK that its not originated there. So maybe you should fucking read the fucking text before you bust a nut you fucking fagot.
little boy... learn how to spell... and i did read your gay comment... i know you said it didnt originate in america and i know there is such thing as american kickboxing... 'cause americans steal everything of other countries... AS I WAS SAYING... kickboxing is japanese and you call me a faggot when its obvious you never touched a girl in your life... seriously.. get a life
So you still stand by what you said with Alaska, Canada, Mexico, Central America and South america steals everything from other countries? you are one dumb mother fucker. and even if i never have touched a female in my life, what the FUCK does that got to do with this argument? And where the fuck are you from that your so proud of but cant say? huh you piece of fucking shit.
what you mean "what the fuck does that got to do with this argument"?
your the one going around calling people fags behind the screen acting all so tough, when in real life your proberly a pussy that never spoke to a girl in his life. seriously... get a life... stop acting so tough behind the screen.... keyboard warrior
I make perfect sense your just too fucking stupid... you have no idea what the fuck this is about or you wouldnt even be talking right now you dumb fuck.
Uuum that couldnt be further from the truth...There is actually nothing in common between MT and KB exept they use a four sided ring, unless you are referring to K1...KB is closer to TKD while K1 is a karate invention..The rules of KB are closer to the rules of a full contact tkd competition...Kicks above waist,no shin kicks,sweeps allowed in some,limited or 0 clinching,no elbows,no knees...as for MT kicks allowed below waist,elbows,knees,shin kicks allowed,extended clinching allowed...
I thought it was a very interesting experiment. More so for me because of not just the sheer power that Muay Thai knee strikes show but also the realism it presents over the other martial arts shown. Given what was shown I suggest that the knee strike would be more practically landed than the other kicks shown. That for me was more of interest as well as power.
Since when a knee strike is a kick? It's like saying an elbow strike is a punch.
When you kick your feet make the contact, not the knee. So I wouldn't say the muay thai knee strike is the best kick, just because it's not a kick.
Also, the experiment should have the same guy doing all the kicks (even if it's not practical/possible/whatever). If you know anything about experiments you should know why.
muay thai cheated the guy used 2 moves lol.. its not just a kick its a clinch plus kick /knee...if u clinch u get more power into it u bring tha guy towards u also n drive in. ;
Himemiya613 good point....but most power of the hit comes from doing it just right....and you cant expect a muay thai master to get the kung fu kick perfectly or any other combination for that matter...
they brought experts for the same reason...besides it shows here that the most powerfull kick is muay thai knee...and to me the karate guy looked a lot stronger and heavier...
they need to use the same guy to do those kicks in order to do a proper experiment. the white guy looks like hes taller and weighs a lot more than the asian and black. but i believe that the knee is indeed the most powerful
HAHA no offense and i know this is a while ago, but you really could not sound more of a fag and loser if you tried. ANYBODY with any ground fighting experience would murder you. Just from your retarded comments, it's very easy to tell you have not been in ANY real fights besides probably beating your own cock LOL
And now that I've repeated myself a number of times, I think I've made my point, the facts are what they are: NO constant, NO Legitimate experiment. A test should be able to withstand the most scrutinous anilization, if it's conducted with integrity.
And it is very ignorant of you to assume what I am or am not capable of.
If "professionals" kick full force all the time and no one dies...Well then, it's THEIR kicks that lack power, not mine.
I already knew that pulling somone into my technique (no matter which one it is) will create more force of impact. Anyone with the simiplest understanding of physice knows this. So to me the point of this test was to show how unprofessional and ignorant the guys conducting it are. Just my opinion.
Ok mr. muai thai I know you want the guy doing YOUR style to legitmatly have the best "kick". But The guys doing the test don't have enough scientific expierence to conduct it properly. There is no constant in the test. It leaves people with a false sense of the truth. Well, stupid people anyway. In my expierence, executing that particular MT move is BULL SHIT. It takes too much time, and for the time it does take, the power derived from it is less than impressive.
It defeated the whole purpose of the test. Ofcourse you wouldn't pull a person into your punch during combat that would defeat the purpose of it. You'd need to take the time to grab first and grabing takes too much time.
In a test of force of impact, Obviously they didn't care if someone ran the dummy into a kick, so why didn't someone run the dummy into his kick while a truck pushes him from behind to create a greater FOI? Total Bull shit!
''so why didn't someone run the dummy into his kick while a truck pushes him from behind to create a greater ''
because how realistic is that?
its a part of the technique to pull the opponent into the knee. fighters are doing it all the time
allthough i wouldnt call a knee strike the same as a kick. +im pretty sure the roundhouse middlekick has more power than a knee attack. just watch the episode with an MMA fighter doing a roundhouse kick
How realistic is it to think somone will just stand there and be hit?
I've seem A LOT of fights and in every fight someone is always moving in on the other person. It's not a push but the same physics are applyed, Two opposing forces.
How realistic is it to say a knee has more power if your pushing or pulling the target into the attack, and not doing the same with the other kicks? Remember this is about Force of impact!! Not applicability in combat. Understand the difference?
its very realistic. it happens in like EVERY muay thai fight
as i see it, this experiment is only showing how much force of impact each technique has. if the thai dude wasnt allowed to pull the dummy while he delivered the knee, then it would have been the same technique
u can argue if its fair towards the kicks, but thats the way it is
Well I guess we've expierenced very different types of combat. No one has ever stood still, knowing my maximum kick is coming. And I've never stood still in combat, that's asking to get drilled.
"u can argue if its fair towards the kicks, but thats the way it is"
That's what i've been doing, making the arguement that if you were to add the same ammount of opposing force to the dummy during anyone elses kick it would have had just as much FOI. THis is called a CONSTANT, in an exeriment.
all the things u say is true. i just dont agree with u thinking this is a 'bullshit test'. as i see it, they test different techniques at full power. a knee delivered from clinch gets some if its power from the push. a kick doesnt
and have u never kicked somebody with full power? never got a lucky kick in, which the opponent didnt see coming? nothing to do with the opponent standing still. watch K-1 with world class athletes. they are still getting hit by full force some times
No, I've never kicked anyone with full power. If I did that, the person would be dead. I use the incoming mass from my opponent to create more FOI so I dont have to use full power or anywhere near it. It's far quicker and more efficent. But the truth is, that this is a B-S experiment, and I've already stated why, NO CONSTANT. No matter what scientist you talk to they'll tell you the only legimate way to conduct scientificly respected test is to have a constant.
there are people in K-1 who can probably kick 3 times harder than you. they do it with full force. no people are killed yet. and when its full contact, kicking with full foce IS the most effective. otherwise the proffesionals wouldnt be doing it
and we will never agree about the test. u overanalyze this too much. the test just want to show how much power each technique has when u get hit in real life. it would be bullshit if the thai guy only were allowed to make half of his technique
Sorry dude, now your just talking about shit you don't know. You have no Idea how hard I can kick. I don't need you to belive, in order to know my limits. You're just used to watching all those pussys who fight in competition. LOL, what a joke.
I know what the humanbody is capable of, I've seem people get kicked in half. You wont see that on TV dude, this is real combat I'm talking about, not ring fighting with rules.
And no, full force is not "most effective" SPEED is more important
Look up the Punch part of this test. No one gets to pull the dummy into their punch. Now, if each martial artist had the dummy pushed into their technique at the same rate or force then that would be a constant, which is necessary to conduct a legitimate test.
Bottom line is that the people conducting this test don't use a CONSTANT system of testing. Thus negating any scientific findings. Total Bull-SHit.
I think when it comes down to it, the most practical way to punch someone wouldn't be to pull them to it, that's the point. The most practical Muay Thai Knee happens when being clinched and/or pulled in. That's the point. You only see knees without the pull in movies. The whole pull action is part of the knee technique altogether, whether it seems fair or not. I'm not defending their method, just making sense of it
What you've said is true. But their measuring force of impact in this vid. So If some one is going to pull a dummy into their kick to acheive a greater FOI then the same physics should be applyed for all kicks and punches for this to be a CONTROLLED test. Which it is obviously isn't. We're not talking about aplicability in combat, or technique. I completely understand the technique and why he pulled the dummy into his knee. But we're talking soly Force Of Impact So it shouldn't have been allowed
you also see knees when the person whose kneeing is lunging or flying as well. But very very rarely see a knee without a clinch/pull or without lunging or jumping, it's all apart of it in whole
this show's retarded though.... the fighters mass are way too different -_-;;
for taht small chinese guy to generate almost 1000 pound of force with that flying kick is pretty good... as opposed to only 1500 generated by the tae kwon do guy who weighs probably in the 200s -_-;; now that's sad.
If you pull or push the target into the technique (ANY TECHNIQUE) the force of impact will be increased. They teach this in grade school. Opposing forces create greater force of impact. I can't belive the guys doing this test allowed him to pull the dummy into his knee...THEN say he had the most power. BULL SHIT!
dude look at the dummy, he pulls it a little bit to get it at the right angle, no where near enough to influence the outcome much. He delivers more power because he drives all of the energy in his kneecap, which is much smaller than a foot.
Bc Muay Thai's core is the clinch position where a knew could do the most damage. The most ideal knee in Muay Thai is the one's in the clinch. Only a trained fighter can avoid a good clinch.
I've seen amatures avoid a clinch. It's called cadence. Move with your opponent, staying just out of his range and just inside yours.
Besides, no one else in the test had the dummy pushed into their technique. Like I said, if you push or pull an object into your technique there will ALWAYS be more force of impact. I'm not saying anything negitive about MT, only the people who are conducting the test.
the study does not prove anything...every fighter has a diferent level of skill and power..is imposible to measure anything with so many variables in the experiment
as if those numbers had anything to do with the art, it always depends on the fighter, not the art, the tkd fighter was like 50pounds more then the kungfu guy, no wonder his kick was harder...
being hit by a car at 35 miles an hour ok but how many pounds of pressure? i want to know how it compares to the 1500+ lbs delivered by the spinning back kick.
ok, if my research is correct, a 35 mph collision delivers about a 50g impact, or roughly 1750 lbs of pressure. The difference is, the spinning back kick basically uses the momentum of the spin to deliver the force of the blow, where as the muay thai knee is generated in a much shorter range of motion, which makes it more devestating.
But Melchor Menor is special. Although being a middle weight, he is said to have a kicking power of a heavy weight. In Thailand, he had problem getting matches because he's so good. Except he entered K-1 and lost with a TKO though.
whythehellcantiname - might as well be arrogant, calling me a teenager, but at least he makes some good points... I didn't hear anything that makes sense from you - you just sound like an ass.
Oh, don't get too hard on yourself - you just didn't understand what I meant;)
And yeah - Tony's good:) But again - Chuck was the best;)
And the best thing about karate is that even at his 70 years Chuck is in a good shape. As for the muay masters, I suspect they cannot walk without a cane when they hit 35 years:)
as whythehellcantiname said you're even dumber then me altho you know just as good as i do that tony whould beat chuck he's way to old to match him...<,< (to whythehellcantiname)and augur wikipedia.... what the bloody hell dude only thing that's good for is finding stuff for school not finding anyone's background or whatever related to fights and such.... dumbasses like you just anoy me now shut up watch the clip and stop trying to start pointless arguements.... i rest my case...
this show is Fight Science on National Geographic channel...best fight documentry...covers pretty much all major martial arts including the best weapon
RockyJr17 - I tell you, a person, sounding more retard than you cannot exist! Chuck Norris - karate champion 6 years. Tony Jaa - film action star. Have you seen Tony in a tournament? Well as you said: think before you say something cause you just made yourself look like a retard o.o
Again - inform yourself before speaking... at least your assumption isn't as idiotic as RockyJr17's.
I have an advise - look it up in wikipedia- even if he did fight in tournaments he didn't win any. It would have been a great advertisement for him in wikipedia, don't you think.
and planning on going to thailand next summer^^ been following thai box for quite some time here in belgium and wanna train there for a month and another month just to sightsee allot of thailand:D my bro went there before christmas says it was BEAUTIFULL:o so anyone who wants to go there don't think just go:o it's worth it:D goodluck with training you must be pretty good^^ peace out
Wow rockyJr17 you are a very dumb-ass person... it's really sad to say your a human. Why don't you go outside and round-house kick yourself in the face for the world? Please!
I didn't say he hasn't fought - I said that he has never been a champ. They don't film it of course, but the tournaments there are a really important tradition to the thai people - and for sure they keep track of their champions - not filmed but written. There are about 100000 professional fighters there and my point is he's not the best.
dude.... tony jaa whould eat chuck noris alive o.o the dude aint worth shit 1. he's old as fuck... 2. he has no bloody rythm nor skill.. and 3. he just sucks dude he's nothing more then a lousy actor...:f think before you say something cause you just made yourself look like a retard o.o
if u notice that the expriment is not done reltively fair in terms of built. if they wana really test on which kick is the best. the only thing that should be change is the style and not the muscle. chnaging 2 term in style and amount of muscle is not fair to determine the outcome for the best kick.
it al depends on nothing the taekwondo guy is bigger tan the thai guy and I know from experience and training in taekwondo and muay thai that the power of thai boxing is real the others look good but in the streets it is muay thai or die and for you kung fu and fancy taekwondo fighters find the nearest muay thai gym and do some sparring I dare You
it all depends on the fighters, its not wise to compare martial arts. KungFu guy is smaller than the rest of the fighters, this doesnt mean kungfu kicks are weaker than the others
I think this says noting. The double kick of the kung fu fighter has less damage than the spinning kick, but the kung fu fighter is way smaller en lighter than the taekwondoka. Probably if the taekwondo dude does the double kick it would do much more damage
This is a bad comparison like some of you said as this is a knee and not a kick. I practice muay thai, and in my opinion, it's roundhouse kick is probably one of the most powerful because of the torque. But in karate and tae kwon do, you have the spinning back kick which is really powerful.
yea. u do a roundhouse kick and then the back kick. u said back already.. people who learn muay thai are thought to go in and brutalise. do u think a kick if yours could throw off the balance and give a flashy kick? do u think this is game? in a ring, giving ur back to your opponent is going to heaven. a back kick is too flashy. defeat is only determine when the fighter is down. anytime a flashy move might just end u KID.
EISH EISH EISH EISH SIEZURE
cascocat 1 month ago
They do say how much lbs of force it is but not in this video. In the other one it said 2.5 tons.
HYDE9320 10 months ago
@ 4:26 YOUR SOUL IS MINE!!!!!!
Sandmanificification 11 months ago
lol the whole testing is flawed you have a 125lbs karate man and 200lbs taekwando player haha
yummybacon 1 year ago
@yummybacon I know right?!? Hahaha.
Makavelification 10 months ago
I'm just gonna say it: Bren Foster has huge tits
AkatsukiPR0 1 year ago
Kung Fu Guy: Here stand there so I can run a straight path to jump and kick you.
jgq85 1 year ago
GULP!
raikkonen8 1 year ago
wtf i didnt heard when did they say how many lbs this knee kick was??
donfanto1 1 year ago
@donfanto1
Right? That blows!
44rumblefish 1 year ago
the muay thai knee was 'stronger' because the head was held thus all the power was thrust into the dummy. In the other demonstrations, some of the force drove into the dummy's chest and the rest was put into flinging the dummy back. Its kind of like board breaking holding it on one side and letting the other side dangle free vs, holding both sides giving it support.
ssj7gokurpg 1 year ago
wathever, the kung fu gui was the smaller.... but the tae kuon do guy was bigger than the muay thai guy and even being smaller, it was stronger lol
pedromenozzi1 2 years ago
lols this's what makes knee strikes become common in every martial arts ^.^
SinclairCeltics1990 2 years ago
2.35 loooooooooooooooooollllllllllllll
ttalbot08 2 years ago 2
WTf? the Kung Fu guy is halve the size of the others.
Idealbastard 2 years ago
but if had their size he could not do that jump kick.
DjokaStokic 2 years ago 2
lol i remembered i seen this on tv and just shaking my head in disgust at the produces of this peice of shit, I like how they dont take into account the individual weight of each person lol, I thought these guys were suppose to be smart. another thing i like how they label punches and kicks, it's about body mechanics not styles, there's only so many ways to punch and kick.
Sunfist85 2 years ago
I was just about to post something like this, you beat me to it :).
XBlastburnerX 2 years ago
lol somebody had to do it, some ppl that actually visit this video and watch this bullshit dont have the common sense to figure out the bigger the guy(mass), the harder the punch
Sunfist85 2 years ago 2
theyre just showing the difference in style you could imagine a bigger or smaller persons number vary slightly but the test still proves which strikes are weaker or stronger in comparison to others. All these martial artists are experts in their style i would expect them to deliver a deadly blow regardless of weight.
yorgoman 2 years ago
in germany we have a shwo called Galileo
it copied everything what in this video happens
BangerthBruder2 2 years ago
the MT guy sounded like an old angry koraen man,
lmao. AISH.
AMkoreann 2 years ago
So did anybody notice the trick of this video? ANYBODY??? Look at it again and see if U can catch it. FACT: they gave the power pressure (in pounds) of which leg use was the most powerful- BUT THEY DIDN'T TELL YOU MUAY THAI's!! All they said was 35mph. FACT: they didnt say mph for the other kicks. So you have no bearings on where MT stands in power placement. Those other kicks couldve been 40mph or 36mph. It's all in how the narrator speaks 2 impress U and the paid technicians
VulcanZoar 2 years ago
yeah, but though you can block or counter a kick or punch, blocking the knee strike while in a clinch is a lot more difficult. Knowing the pressure is irrelivant
mechucat 2 years ago
Uhhhh....NO mechucat, knowing the pressure is NOT irrelevant since that was the whole point of the experiment. Try ACTUALLY watching the video. They were using technology to determine which martial art was the one with the most powerful leg use by strictly comparing the numbers. DUH.
UfoAreUFO 2 years ago
cardiac arrest? jesus christ!
1jionone 2 years ago 2
How many lbs of pressure?!?! What the hell!
tedpm206 2 years ago 10
Comment removed
1ONE5FIVE 2 years ago
Yeah thats right your a bad man, your knees are bad. Laff laff lafff little yellow pig.
dam0cles1 2 years ago
wa wa wai wai aish aish aishhh aishhh waaaiii aiiishhhhhhh aarggh aargghr aissshhh aishhhh @ 2:35
biggurs 2 years ago 19
LOL
MrDarkWind 2 years ago
aisshhhhh you forgot one
mbd009 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
These things are bullshit, I love muay thai but if the knee was that destructive wouldn't fighters die all the time? It's a ring sport practiced all over the place, you don't hear about people dying every time. And they don't kick fucking palm trees, that's from a movie.
RasAlGhul4000 2 years ago
Actually many have died in thailand mostly from elbows and internal bleeding! Also in thailand they do train on banana trees. I've been there. I've trained there and i have seen it happen. Thais are very tough!!! You might not tell by their size but they are deadly. I've spared a thai and I got my head spining for the hole day!!! In your country as in my country the training is not so tough!
alxd25 2 years ago 6
its just cuz hes a proffesional not everyone can get those results
yamabukiknight 2 years ago
yes they do you dumb fuck i had to do it in my mma training so stfu you dont even know anything you just think you are smart because you can watch tv and comment on youtube when really your a 13 or 46 yr old virgin that cant get a date.
SlayeroftheSky 2 years ago 4
Have you taken a knee to the chest or any body part...e g your thigh?Trust me, your opinion will change on the spot...and yes people die and no it doesnt happen every day because of stoppages in ring sports...otherwise a lot of people would die in a lot of ring sports, let alone muay thai..even just western boxing...
ngaiflex 2 years ago
It depends on the place of Impact, where the hit is. There are alot of things to take into consideration during a fight. and yes, they do practice on trees.
Zionish 2 years ago
You have no idea what you are saying
jake66664 2 years ago
I farted!
m33lad 2 years ago
I'm wondering if he didn't hold on to the head, would it really be that powerful. They should have something holding the dummy's head while the other guys took a shot at it. I bet you that the Spinning Back Kick would to the most damage.
It's a little difficult to deliver a powerful knee to the sternum while in a clinch.
davidbayala 2 years ago
Muay Thai is awesome :P
Moderm101 2 years ago 3
its a unfair comparison, since with the knee he's bracing the dummy against fallback
funkyboodah 2 years ago
It's also done by the second smalles person, weight is much more importent in power...
TenkennoGunshin 2 years ago
Your stupid thats the WHOLE fucking point of this technique... its to STOP him from falling back... inducing more absorption of the knee. They use that with elbows and shit too... fucking funykboodah nigger.
FrolicEpidemic 2 years ago
yes , this show is called fight science . if i remembered .
MeTroNoMeRythm 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wtf is this dude on?
kickboxing DOES use knees...
there isn't much difference between muay thai and kickboxing
kickboxing is just the japanese version of muay thai apart from they dont use elbows and thai uses like... everything
SnipeZ850 2 years ago
To be quite honest i think its safe to say he knows what he's on about since he's a world champion and...... your not
jamiemillman 2 years ago
Uh... kickboxing is not Japanese...No, kickboxing doesn't use knees or elbows...(maybe savate but they don't use it in competitions.) and i think the "kickboxing" your talking about is.. karate? hehe..
alexanderhong 2 years ago
1) kickboxing IS japanese, made by osamu noguchi, if you think kickboxing is american, please drop dead.
2) i NEVER said kickboxing uses elbows, now your just being even a bigger idiot.
3) nope, im not on about karate, although the parenthood of kickboxing is boxing with various asian martial arts, therefore, yes, karate would be related, but no, im not about no karate.
SnipeZ850 2 years ago
LOL ouch, i didn't actually think it was American...I thought it was European. LOL Being an idiot for being wrong? hehe... i think the word is ignorant?? You DO know what this word means riiight? :) buuuut... you ARE correct, i did some research, it is Japanese,well Next time when you tell someone to drop dead, don't expect them to not think your a fucking asshole :)
alexanderhong 2 years ago
wahahaha, no, your an asshole... i think people that tell others whats what without knowing jack are bigger assholes than people telling you to drop dead=]]
have a nice day
SnipeZ850 2 years ago
Hey buddy,i just called my self ignorant lol i was just asking you what does ignorant mean, can you tell me? pleeese :) And even though I'm being an "asshole" for retaliating(again, you know what this means right?) at least im not the bully who goes on you tube and goes on a translation site to communicate with your bullshit in another language. Even if your not translating your insults, i can say that your English sucks."whats what without knowing jack."?..are you having fun? :)
alexanderhong 2 years ago
mhmm, my english does suck, or should i say ENGRISHHH..Q_Q'
and wtf? "at least im not no bully who goes on you tube"
your grammar freakin' sucks... and how could i bully you behind a computer screen? little boy... grow up
SnipeZ850 2 years ago
Lol dude i said "at least im not the bully who goes on you tube" in those actual words. learn to read :) grow up? lol alright you got me, you win this one :) yay 2 points for snipe :)
alexanderhong 2 years ago
mhmm, my english does suck, or should i say ENGRISHHH..Q_Q'
and wtf? "at least im not no bully who goes on you tube"
your grammar freakin' sucks... and how could i bully you behind a computer screen? little boy... grow up <--- thats what you said NOT...."at least im not the bully who goes on you tube" dumb fuck!! BOI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
FrolicEpidemic 2 years ago
But in english that make sense though XD
alexanderhong 2 years ago
Your not no bully? so you ARE a bully.....
FrolicEpidemic 2 years ago
There is such of a thing called American Kickboxing.... SO.... that means he's correct... just not with the origin.
FrolicEpidemic 2 years ago
who said anything about american kickboxing? america just copies everything every other country has... literally... they cant do their own things...
HOWEVER, kickboxing originated in Japan, not gay america... so0o0 stfu? seriously... get a life
SnipeZ850 2 years ago 4
Look BITCH your not as smart as you think you are. I <--- Said American Kickboxing because you said kickboxing is not american....thats when i said there is such a thing as American kickboxing..... and i already fucking said you dumb FUCK that its not originated there. So maybe you should fucking read the fucking text before you bust a nut you fucking fagot.
FrolicEpidemic 2 years ago
little boy... learn how to spell... and i did read your gay comment... i know you said it didnt originate in america and i know there is such thing as american kickboxing... 'cause americans steal everything of other countries... AS I WAS SAYING... kickboxing is japanese and you call me a faggot when its obvious you never touched a girl in your life... seriously.. get a life
SnipeZ850 2 years ago 3
So you still stand by what you said with Alaska, Canada, Mexico, Central America and South america steals everything from other countries? you are one dumb mother fucker. and even if i never have touched a female in my life, what the FUCK does that got to do with this argument? And where the fuck are you from that your so proud of but cant say? huh you piece of fucking shit.
FrolicEpidemic 2 years ago
what you mean "what the fuck does that got to do with this argument"?
your the one going around calling people fags behind the screen acting all so tough, when in real life your proberly a pussy that never spoke to a girl in his life. seriously... get a life... stop acting so tough behind the screen.... keyboard warrior
SnipeZ850 2 years ago 4
but to continue this fucking bullshit... remember YOUR first comment you hypocritical BITCH !?!?!?!?
FrolicEpidemic 2 years ago
Shut up ure gay and make no sence
saweet999 2 years ago
I make perfect sense your just too fucking stupid... you have no idea what the fuck this is about or you wouldnt even be talking right now you dumb fuck.
FrolicEpidemic 2 years ago
Uuum that couldnt be further from the truth...There is actually nothing in common between MT and KB exept they use a four sided ring, unless you are referring to K1...KB is closer to TKD while K1 is a karate invention..The rules of KB are closer to the rules of a full contact tkd competition...Kicks above waist,no shin kicks,sweeps allowed in some,limited or 0 clinching,no elbows,no knees...as for MT kicks allowed below waist,elbows,knees,shin kicks allowed,extended clinching allowed...
ngaiflex 2 years ago
...didnt you hear the guy talk about muay thai?...that's why it's the deadly art, cuz those are available
SeksYxBoI 2 years ago
I thought it was a very interesting experiment. More so for me because of not just the sheer power that Muay Thai knee strikes show but also the realism it presents over the other martial arts shown. Given what was shown I suggest that the knee strike would be more practically landed than the other kicks shown. That for me was more of interest as well as power.
HIRE2HACK 2 years ago
muay thai all the way!!!
dajazster 2 years ago
Since when a knee strike is a kick? It's like saying an elbow strike is a punch.
When you kick your feet make the contact, not the knee. So I wouldn't say the muay thai knee strike is the best kick, just because it's not a kick.
Also, the experiment should have the same guy doing all the kicks (even if it's not practical/possible/whatever). If you know anything about experiments you should know why.
Brasker 2 years ago 2
0.6 vc? nijustu did 0.8vc rite am i rite snwere me i'm askin!!!
kanegoldbrockfan 2 years ago
muay thai cheated the guy used 2 moves lol.. its not just a kick its a clinch plus kick /knee...if u clinch u get more power into it u bring tha guy towards u also n drive in. ;
doink3 3 years ago
Himemiya613 good point....but most power of the hit comes from doing it just right....and you cant expect a muay thai master to get the kung fu kick perfectly or any other combination for that matter...
they brought experts for the same reason...besides it shows here that the most powerfull kick is muay thai knee...and to me the karate guy looked a lot stronger and heavier...
cajnopecivo 3 years ago
"No one has ever stood still, knowing my maximum kick is coming"
supremeala is in idiot
SA0surv1ve 3 years ago
they need to use the same guy to do those kicks in order to do a proper experiment. the white guy looks like hes taller and weighs a lot more than the asian and black. but i believe that the knee is indeed the most powerful
Himemiya613 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
If K-1 fighters are "professionals" then I'm a Grand Master, LOL!
Peace.
supremeala 3 years ago
all what you say is pure bluff.... peace
apolion666666666 3 years ago
HAHA no offense and i know this is a while ago, but you really could not sound more of a fag and loser if you tried. ANYBODY with any ground fighting experience would murder you. Just from your retarded comments, it's very easy to tell you have not been in ANY real fights besides probably beating your own cock LOL
muayjitsu87 2 years ago
And now that I've repeated myself a number of times, I think I've made my point, the facts are what they are: NO constant, NO Legitimate experiment. A test should be able to withstand the most scrutinous anilization, if it's conducted with integrity.
And it is very ignorant of you to assume what I am or am not capable of.
If "professionals" kick full force all the time and no one dies...Well then, it's THEIR kicks that lack power, not mine.
supremeala 3 years ago
I already knew that pulling somone into my technique (no matter which one it is) will create more force of impact. Anyone with the simiplest understanding of physice knows this. So to me the point of this test was to show how unprofessional and ignorant the guys conducting it are. Just my opinion.
supremeala 3 years ago
No constant, no experiment, no legitimacy.
As I originally said... BULL-SHIT!
supremeala 3 years ago
Ok mr. muai thai I know you want the guy doing YOUR style to legitmatly have the best "kick". But The guys doing the test don't have enough scientific expierence to conduct it properly. There is no constant in the test. It leaves people with a false sense of the truth. Well, stupid people anyway. In my expierence, executing that particular MT move is BULL SHIT. It takes too much time, and for the time it does take, the power derived from it is less than impressive.
supremeala 3 years ago
man the word are too late yo
dyingxmonkey 3 years ago
lol anyanyanya aiish aish aish aish anyanyanyanyanya aiish aish aish aish 2:34 to 2:45
ThugNiggaPimp 3 years ago
It defeated the whole purpose of the test. Ofcourse you wouldn't pull a person into your punch during combat that would defeat the purpose of it. You'd need to take the time to grab first and grabing takes too much time.
In a test of force of impact, Obviously they didn't care if someone ran the dummy into a kick, so why didn't someone run the dummy into his kick while a truck pushes him from behind to create a greater FOI? Total Bull shit!
supremeala 3 years ago
''so why didn't someone run the dummy into his kick while a truck pushes him from behind to create a greater ''
because how realistic is that?
its a part of the technique to pull the opponent into the knee. fighters are doing it all the time
allthough i wouldnt call a knee strike the same as a kick. +im pretty sure the roundhouse middlekick has more power than a knee attack. just watch the episode with an MMA fighter doing a roundhouse kick
MuayThaiViking 3 years ago
How realistic is it to think somone will just stand there and be hit?
I've seem A LOT of fights and in every fight someone is always moving in on the other person. It's not a push but the same physics are applyed, Two opposing forces.
How realistic is it to say a knee has more power if your pushing or pulling the target into the attack, and not doing the same with the other kicks? Remember this is about Force of impact!! Not applicability in combat. Understand the difference?
supremeala 3 years ago
its very realistic. it happens in like EVERY muay thai fight
as i see it, this experiment is only showing how much force of impact each technique has. if the thai dude wasnt allowed to pull the dummy while he delivered the knee, then it would have been the same technique
u can argue if its fair towards the kicks, but thats the way it is
MuayThaiViking 3 years ago
Well I guess we've expierenced very different types of combat. No one has ever stood still, knowing my maximum kick is coming. And I've never stood still in combat, that's asking to get drilled.
"u can argue if its fair towards the kicks, but thats the way it is"
That's what i've been doing, making the arguement that if you were to add the same ammount of opposing force to the dummy during anyone elses kick it would have had just as much FOI. THis is called a CONSTANT, in an exeriment.
supremeala 3 years ago
all the things u say is true. i just dont agree with u thinking this is a 'bullshit test'. as i see it, they test different techniques at full power. a knee delivered from clinch gets some if its power from the push. a kick doesnt
and have u never kicked somebody with full power? never got a lucky kick in, which the opponent didnt see coming? nothing to do with the opponent standing still. watch K-1 with world class athletes. they are still getting hit by full force some times
MuayThaiViking 3 years ago
No, I've never kicked anyone with full power. If I did that, the person would be dead. I use the incoming mass from my opponent to create more FOI so I dont have to use full power or anywhere near it. It's far quicker and more efficent. But the truth is, that this is a B-S experiment, and I've already stated why, NO CONSTANT. No matter what scientist you talk to they'll tell you the only legimate way to conduct scientificly respected test is to have a constant.
supremeala 3 years ago
there are people in K-1 who can probably kick 3 times harder than you. they do it with full force. no people are killed yet. and when its full contact, kicking with full foce IS the most effective. otherwise the proffesionals wouldnt be doing it
and we will never agree about the test. u overanalyze this too much. the test just want to show how much power each technique has when u get hit in real life. it would be bullshit if the thai guy only were allowed to make half of his technique
MuayThaiViking 3 years ago
Sorry dude, now your just talking about shit you don't know. You have no Idea how hard I can kick. I don't need you to belive, in order to know my limits. You're just used to watching all those pussys who fight in competition. LOL, what a joke.
I know what the humanbody is capable of, I've seem people get kicked in half. You wont see that on TV dude, this is real combat I'm talking about, not ring fighting with rules.
And no, full force is not "most effective" SPEED is more important
supremeala 3 years ago
oh man i should have known... im discussion with an idiot kungfu-movie-freak
''all those pussys who fight in competition. LOL, what a joke''
what are REAL martial artists doing then? sitting on a mountain top, meditating to budha all day long?
sorry get back to reality. a 120kg proffesional fighter like jerome le banner can kick harder than a keyboard warrior than you. end of story
and i havnt said that force is more important than speed. u need both
MuayThaiViking 3 years ago 2
Look up the Punch part of this test. No one gets to pull the dummy into their punch. Now, if each martial artist had the dummy pushed into their technique at the same rate or force then that would be a constant, which is necessary to conduct a legitimate test.
Bottom line is that the people conducting this test don't use a CONSTANT system of testing. Thus negating any scientific findings. Total Bull-SHit.
supremeala 3 years ago
I think when it comes down to it, the most practical way to punch someone wouldn't be to pull them to it, that's the point. The most practical Muay Thai Knee happens when being clinched and/or pulled in. That's the point. You only see knees without the pull in movies. The whole pull action is part of the knee technique altogether, whether it seems fair or not. I'm not defending their method, just making sense of it
PuertoRicanTakeOva 3 years ago
What you've said is true. But their measuring force of impact in this vid. So If some one is going to pull a dummy into their kick to acheive a greater FOI then the same physics should be applyed for all kicks and punches for this to be a CONTROLLED test. Which it is obviously isn't. We're not talking about aplicability in combat, or technique. I completely understand the technique and why he pulled the dummy into his knee. But we're talking soly Force Of Impact So it shouldn't have been allowed
supremeala 3 years ago
you also see knees when the person whose kneeing is lunging or flying as well. But very very rarely see a knee without a clinch/pull or without lunging or jumping, it's all apart of it in whole
PuertoRicanTakeOva 3 years ago
lol anyanyanya aiish aish aish aish anyanyanyanyanya aiish aish aish aish
backatchalol 3 years ago
this show's retarded though.... the fighters mass are way too different -_-;;
for taht small chinese guy to generate almost 1000 pound of force with that flying kick is pretty good... as opposed to only 1500 generated by the tae kwon do guy who weighs probably in the 200s -_-;; now that's sad.
HwarangOfFaith 3 years ago
I guess LOGIC has no place here.
If you pull or push the target into the technique (ANY TECHNIQUE) the force of impact will be increased. They teach this in grade school. Opposing forces create greater force of impact. I can't belive the guys doing this test allowed him to pull the dummy into his knee...THEN say he had the most power. BULL SHIT!
LOGIC truely has no place here.
supremeala 3 years ago
dude look at the dummy, he pulls it a little bit to get it at the right angle, no where near enough to influence the outcome much. He delivers more power because he drives all of the energy in his kneecap, which is much smaller than a foot.
Glasscherf 3 years ago
Bc Muay Thai's core is the clinch position where a knew could do the most damage. The most ideal knee in Muay Thai is the one's in the clinch. Only a trained fighter can avoid a good clinch.
PuertoRicanTakeOva 3 years ago
I've seen amatures avoid a clinch. It's called cadence. Move with your opponent, staying just out of his range and just inside yours.
Besides, no one else in the test had the dummy pushed into their technique. Like I said, if you push or pull an object into your technique there will ALWAYS be more force of impact. I'm not saying anything negitive about MT, only the people who are conducting the test.
supremeala 3 years ago
the study does not prove anything...every fighter has a diferent level of skill and power..is imposible to measure anything with so many variables in the experiment
cuevasdecamuy 3 years ago 3
this is fight masters
harmonizethelord9 3 years ago
I find it funny that they use different people for all the kicks and no controls whatsoever. Yeah real good science there sports, lol!
backflash22 3 years ago 2
Watch: fight science - mma . There you can see Bass Rutten how he kicks twice as hard as the Muay Thai Master.
nikkolodien 3 years ago
the muay thai fighter doesnt kick he knees
ch255 3 years ago
yeah Bas is a 205 pound man plus he's also trained in Muay Thai and Menor is like 155 so yeah of course Bas is going to kick harder.
dannielpreto 3 years ago
as if those numbers had anything to do with the art, it always depends on the fighter, not the art, the tkd fighter was like 50pounds more then the kungfu guy, no wonder his kick was harder...
UncleDavid1985 3 years ago
what's the name of this show?
maxiflo 3 years ago
National Geographic channel, they have a youtube subscription thing intresting stuff
Stonio 3 years ago
fight masters
harmonizethelord9 3 years ago
the words r fucking late
dyingxmonkey 3 years ago
its psi.
gameofdeath203 3 years ago
wat tv show is this?
0YuriS0 3 years ago
being hit by a car at 35 miles an hour ok but how many pounds of pressure? i want to know how it compares to the 1500+ lbs delivered by the spinning back kick.
mmmichelle333 3 years ago
Same here.
Xerox20077 3 years ago
ok, if my research is correct, a 35 mph collision delivers about a 50g impact, or roughly 1750 lbs of pressure. The difference is, the spinning back kick basically uses the momentum of the spin to deliver the force of the blow, where as the muay thai knee is generated in a much shorter range of motion, which makes it more devestating.
jalittlejr 3 years ago
He is fighting an English fighter called Chris McDonauld at 3:10.
kieranbehandurante 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shaolin monk will beat up the muay thai ass guy
fireslacker 3 years ago
is he fighting sam stout at 3:10?
thezenbrawler 3 years ago
Bren Foster was in thailand at Fairtex the same time I was and we fought on the same night. He's a really cool guy.
icemountainwillet 3 years ago
do you got footage of that?
sloerie 3 years ago
Not myself but the camp in Thailand has it. I'll see if I can get a copy next month
icemountainwillet 3 years ago
Ok. I will be waiting for you :)
sloerie 3 years ago
glad i have been training thai boxing
sparky303 3 years ago 5
Yeah I agree.
But Melchor Menor is special. Although being a middle weight, he is said to have a kicking power of a heavy weight. In Thailand, he had problem getting matches because he's so good. Except he entered K-1 and lost with a TKO though.
hannibalslaughter 3 years ago
please respond:
bren foster has a kick power "1572" is this in jouls or in kg or pounds ?
melchor menor has a knee power of 1.6 ??? is this in t (tons) ????? or is this equelent to "1600"??????
straiker 3 years ago
it's Al in pounds 1.6 is just a number on some kind of scale with compressing the doll
roxNRG 3 years ago
Thanks.
straiker 3 years ago
no its not its pounds per square inch
charliemurphyslaw 3 years ago
whythehellcantiname - might as well be arrogant, calling me a teenager, but at least he makes some good points... I didn't hear anything that makes sense from you - you just sound like an ass.
augur85 3 years ago
I know, my post is a bit harsh, and you are right, tony jaa is not the best, but he is still good
whythehellcantiname 3 years ago
Oh, don't get too hard on yourself - you just didn't understand what I meant;)
And yeah - Tony's good:) But again - Chuck was the best;)
And the best thing about karate is that even at his 70 years Chuck is in a good shape. As for the muay masters, I suspect they cannot walk without a cane when they hit 35 years:)
augur85 3 years ago
You suspect? Can you give us proof of this...
chonichan 3 years ago
...that muay thai master's are in cane's by the time they are 35..
chonichan 3 years ago 2
Would someone reply to RockyJr17 that he's an idiot, so he can read it:)
augur85 3 years ago
as whythehellcantiname said you're even dumber then me altho you know just as good as i do that tony whould beat chuck he's way to old to match him...<,< (to whythehellcantiname)and augur wikipedia.... what the bloody hell dude only thing that's good for is finding stuff for school not finding anyone's background or whatever related to fights and such.... dumbasses like you just anoy me now shut up watch the clip and stop trying to start pointless arguements.... i rest my case...
RockyJr17 3 years ago
Dumber than you? Oh well at lest you know you're dumb... That says it all - please shut up and don't embarrass yourself anymore.
augur85 3 years ago
you have no respect whatsoever so please just shut up leave it be you're just starting a pointless arguement you pathetic kid... go home...
RockyJr17 3 years ago
Rocky - don't try to think, your head might hurt... I'm not even arguing with you - there's no point.
augur85 3 years ago
Ahhh - I can't post a reply - really:(((
augur85 3 years ago
Ahhh - youtube is bugged - idiot.... was meant for Rocky and the other post is for whythehellcantiname.
augur85 3 years ago
it's not inteded as an insult to augur, but please go see thailand before anymore comments
whythehellcantiname 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
boring data game...every marshal art has it's own structure and attack methods. there is only understanding thing, none of the power's business...
adobeyuyu 3 years ago
this show is Fight Science on National Geographic channel...best fight documentry...covers pretty much all major martial arts including the best weapon
98735il 4 years ago
RockyJr17 - I tell you, a person, sounding more retard than you cannot exist! Chuck Norris - karate champion 6 years. Tony Jaa - film action star. Have you seen Tony in a tournament? Well as you said: think before you say something cause you just made yourself look like a retard o.o
augur85 4 years ago
I agree that Chuck Norris would win, but Tony Jaa did fought in tournaments, people in thailand don't tend to put every vids on the internet
whythehellcantiname 3 years ago
Again - inform yourself before speaking... at least your assumption isn't as idiotic as RockyJr17's.
I have an advise - look it up in wikipedia- even if he did fight in tournaments he didn't win any. It would have been a great advertisement for him in wikipedia, don't you think.
augur85 3 years ago
o, you're even more idiotic than Rocky, wikipedia? o great another teenage boy who thinks the internet is the real deal
dude, I've been to thailand, took muay thai for about 12 years, fought in a tournament, you think they taped it?
no
don't believe things on the internet, get off your fatass and go see the real world, specifically go to thailand and see
whythehellcantiname 3 years ago
and planning on going to thailand next summer^^ been following thai box for quite some time here in belgium and wanna train there for a month and another month just to sightsee allot of thailand:D my bro went there before christmas says it was BEAUTIFULL:o so anyone who wants to go there don't think just go:o it's worth it:D goodluck with training you must be pretty good^^ peace out
RockyJr17 3 years ago
Wow rockyJr17 you are a very dumb-ass person... it's really sad to say your a human. Why don't you go outside and round-house kick yourself in the face for the world? Please!
Kickagnome 3 years ago
I didn't say he hasn't fought - I said that he has never been a champ. They don't film it of course, but the tournaments there are a really important tradition to the thai people - and for sure they keep track of their champions - not filmed but written. There are about 100000 professional fighters there and my point is he's not the best.
augur85 3 years ago
what is this program called ?
hekma 4 years ago
oh... and it was just a joke btw :)
Kickagnome 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Chuck Norris beats both TKD and Muay Thai.
Kickagnome 4 years ago
dude.... tony jaa whould eat chuck noris alive o.o the dude aint worth shit 1. he's old as fuck... 2. he has no bloody rythm nor skill.. and 3. he just sucks dude he's nothing more then a lousy actor...:f think before you say something cause you just made yourself look like a retard o.o
RockyJr17 4 years ago
Chuck would eat u bish :P he owns
Kickagnome 4 years ago
idiot....
augur85 3 years ago
Rocky - you are a moroon.
augur85 3 years ago
Może i kolanko jest silne...ale trzeba złapać...ja uważam osobiście że ten z TKD co kopał jest najlepsze...bo jest dystans...
Barruskb 4 years ago
anyways. i love this video. my parents dont wana instiall scv. sadd.
loveformonkeys 4 years ago
if u notice that the expriment is not done reltively fair in terms of built. if they wana really test on which kick is the best. the only thing that should be change is the style and not the muscle. chnaging 2 term in style and amount of muscle is not fair to determine the outcome for the best kick.
loveformonkeys 4 years ago
it al depends on nothing the taekwondo guy is bigger tan the thai guy and I know from experience and training in taekwondo and muay thai that the power of thai boxing is real the others look good but in the streets it is muay thai or die and for you kung fu and fancy taekwondo fighters find the nearest muay thai gym and do some sparring I dare You
serve1234 4 years ago
it all depends on the fighters, its not wise to compare martial arts. KungFu guy is smaller than the rest of the fighters, this doesnt mean kungfu kicks are weaker than the others
crainsi 4 years ago 2
I think this says noting. The double kick of the kung fu fighter has less damage than the spinning kick, but the kung fu fighter is way smaller en lighter than the taekwondoka. Probably if the taekwondo dude does the double kick it would do much more damage
jecwonch 4 years ago 3
this is fight science
tdd915 4 years ago
wow
fighting against muay thai is a serious deal.
Leogirl786 4 years ago
This is a bad comparison like some of you said as this is a knee and not a kick. I practice muay thai, and in my opinion, it's roundhouse kick is probably one of the most powerful because of the torque. But in karate and tae kwon do, you have the spinning back kick which is really powerful.
enigma562 4 years ago
yes but u gotta spin .. imagine turning your back against a muay thai fighter who can produce untold ammounts of power in a standard strike
bezerka 4 years ago
You do a roundhouse kick and then the back kick so you're less open. I'm a Taekwondo fighter.
Nonrad 4 years ago
yea. u do a roundhouse kick and then the back kick. u said back already.. people who learn muay thai are thought to go in and brutalise. do u think a kick if yours could throw off the balance and give a flashy kick? do u think this is game? in a ring, giving ur back to your opponent is going to heaven. a back kick is too flashy. defeat is only determine when the fighter is down. anytime a flashy move might just end u KID.
loveformonkeys 4 years ago