The problem was not so much Curly's lack of energy, because he turned in a decent performance conisdering it was after his initial stroke. The problem was that he could not remember any of his lines. Moe coached him line by line; at 6:43, Moe nudges Curly's left elbow to remind him of his line. It is really sad, but all the more reason to credit Curly for pushing himself beyond his means.
while I agree Curly doesn't look well in this short I thought this short was well written and well directed and I thought this and "Three Little Pirates" were the two best shorts of 1946
Doctor: "First thing to discuss is your diet. We will be cutting out sugars, starches, protiens, and carbohydrates." Curly: "What will we eat?" Doctor: "Vitamins and calories" Curly: "Oh boy, with cream gravy!"
As ANDRES161166 said, this is the first appearance of most-recurring (I think) Shemp-era villain actor Kenneth MacDonald. (Said commentor doesn't hafta keep shouting, though.)
The would-be schedule with all that wood-chopping, roadwork, and what-have-you sounds promising. It just needs legitimate minds backing it.
Kenneth MacDonald had a long career as a character actor. Late in his career he was a semi-regular on the classic TV drama "Perry Mason" as a courtroom judge. And he was even in the classic late-40's RKO film noir "Crossfire"!
Along with Bud Jamison and Philip Van Zandt, Kenneth MacDonald was one of the Stooges' most frequent foils, often playing a greasy conman or two-bit thief. Although he carries his scenes well, it doesn't hide the fact that Curly was sluggish and hoarse all through filming.
Curly's wasn't the only one in this stooge episode that was having health problems at the time. Cy Schindell, who played Clarence, one of the nurses, was suffering from terminal cancer which he caught while he was serving in the Marines in the Pacific during World War 2.
At this time Curly had problems memorizing his lines. It was so bad Moe had to coach Curly his lines and if you look closely at 6:43/6:44 around there you can see Moe nudging Curly to say the line "I know: a nice big bowl of milk." Wikipedia confirms it aswell.
I could tell Curly was really sick. He wasn't getting slapped in the face, only on the head. He didn't get shocked like Moe did while touching the electric wires cuz he was in no condition of shaking. And he was talking really soft.
"Moe pleaded with Harry Cohn to allow Howard some time off upon discharge to regain his strength. Cohn would not halt the production of his profitable Stooge shorts and flatly refused Moe's request. Author Michael Fleming stated that "...it was a disastrous course of action."
Why on every late Stooge video, someone has to bring up Curly's poor health? We know he is sick, you can tell, but leave his life out of it, and enjoy the great films he was able to produce.
This short is a great example that the late Curly shorts produced/directed Hugh McCollum/Edward Bernds are much better than the late Curly shorts directed by Jules White, while Curly appeared really sick and unhealthy at least Curly isn't pushed to the background as often like he was in shorts like "Uncivil War Birds", "Three Loan Wolves" and "GI Wanna Home"
It's sad knowing that this was Curly's last short. You can tell he wasn't as able to do the physical stuff. Even when he speaks, he seems somewhat tentative. What a shame.
@acfreak55 Unfortunately the opposite is true. His condition during the production of this one was so bad Moe had to sometimes coach Curly his lines. You can see it at 6:42 where Moe nudges Curly.
@acfreak55 It was a combo of Moe's coaching and the director shooting in such a way so as to help Curly look good. The result was a very good short, even Curly wise. But he wasn't in good health.
The problem was not so much Curly's lack of energy, because he turned in a decent performance conisdering it was after his initial stroke. The problem was that he could not remember any of his lines. Moe coached him line by line; at 6:43, Moe nudges Curly's left elbow to remind him of his line. It is really sad, but all the more reason to credit Curly for pushing himself beyond his means.
daffylatke 7 hours ago
"You idiot! Why don't you watch what you're doing?!"
"I only climbed up seven steps!"
"The ladder had six!"
LMFAO!!!! Classic!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AnakinAhsokaGeek18 1 week ago in playlist The Three Stooges 1946
@AnakinAhsokaGeek18 L.M.F.A.O.!!!!
AmazingOnes45 1 day ago
First debut of Kenneth McDonnall, who is famous for playing bad guys in several Shemp episodes
AnakinAhsokaGeek18 3 weeks ago 4
Funny...I set my clock for 5:06 today.
terminat1 3 weeks ago
5.00 O clock thats the time you get shot at sunrise .
ducklandwikeno 2 months ago
The doc's a quak .
ducklandwikeno 2 months ago
while I agree Curly doesn't look well in this short I thought this short was well written and well directed and I thought this and "Three Little Pirates" were the two best shorts of 1946
Doobie1975 2 months ago
"Gimme a hand!"
"Which one?"
Some lines never get old (LOL!)
rayandreina 2 months ago 2
the nurse is absolutely stunning
bLuDcLoT06 2 months ago
6:41 Moe nudges Curly to say his line.
legofreaktwin 3 months ago
"Gentlemen"
"Who came in?"
That line never gets old
"Gentlemen"
"He means us!"
320k 3 months ago
give me a hand
which one?
samurai9845 4 months ago
Moe: Why don't you e careful when ya climb a latter
Curly: I Only climbed 7 steps
Moe: That latter had 6
pmahunik 5 months ago
Doctor: "First thing to discuss is your diet. We will be cutting out sugars, starches, protiens, and carbohydrates." Curly: "What will we eat?" Doctor: "Vitamins and calories" Curly: "Oh boy, with cream gravy!"
MrJetstreamjesus 5 months ago
I always knew he was a groundhog!
MiChJeSu22 5 months ago
As ANDRES161166 said, this is the first appearance of most-recurring (I think) Shemp-era villain actor Kenneth MacDonald. (Said commentor doesn't hafta keep shouting, though.)
The would-be schedule with all that wood-chopping, roadwork, and what-have-you sounds promising. It just needs legitimate minds backing it.
Undetermined1986 5 months ago
@Undetermined1986
Kenneth MacDonald had a long career as a character actor. Late in his career he was a semi-regular on the classic TV drama "Perry Mason" as a courtroom judge. And he was even in the classic late-40's RKO film noir "Crossfire"!
JubalCalif 4 months ago
Along with Bud Jamison and Philip Van Zandt, Kenneth MacDonald was one of the Stooges' most frequent foils, often playing a greasy conman or two-bit thief. Although he carries his scenes well, it doesn't hide the fact that Curly was sluggish and hoarse all through filming.
HaggisMcCrablice 1 month ago
4:44 that's for hitting Curly u dumbell lame brains!!
DanNZ4 6 months ago
can somebody decode those roman numerals at the opening sequence?
relimes 7 months ago
"I only climbed up seven steps!"
"The ladder has six!!"
LOL
JohnSilverfan01 7 months ago 2
Curly's wasn't the only one in this stooge episode that was having health problems at the time. Cy Schindell, who played Clarence, one of the nurses, was suffering from terminal cancer which he caught while he was serving in the Marines in the Pacific during World War 2.
NDW85 7 months ago
At this time Curly had problems memorizing his lines. It was so bad Moe had to coach Curly his lines and if you look closely at 6:43/6:44 around there you can see Moe nudging Curly to say the line "I know: a nice big bowl of milk." Wikipedia confirms it aswell.
PUNISHERWarzone87 8 months ago
I could tell Curly was really sick. He wasn't getting slapped in the face, only on the head. He didn't get shocked like Moe did while touching the electric wires cuz he was in no condition of shaking. And he was talking really soft.
TimeForFunGuy 8 months ago
5:39 I bet if I tried to charm a pretty girl she would do that to me.
wiisalute 8 months ago
2:05 - 2:55
LMAO!!! Ever
trannon1 8 months ago
"Moe pleaded with Harry Cohn to allow Howard some time off upon discharge to regain his strength. Cohn would not halt the production of his profitable Stooge shorts and flatly refused Moe's request. Author Michael Fleming stated that "...it was a disastrous course of action."
jameskoolkat 9 months ago
Every time I think about Cohn, I think I hate him more and more.
Undetermined1986 5 months ago
Moe actually had a photographic memory and memorized every line to every short and had to help Curly on every one in this short!
12gianna 9 months ago
Moe actually had a photographic memory and memorized every line to every short and had to help curly on every one in this sort!
12gianna 9 months ago
@osprey1993
*looks around my midsection* Where?
LuigiGodzillaGirl 9 months ago
Why on every late Stooge video, someone has to bring up Curly's poor health? We know he is sick, you can tell, but leave his life out of it, and enjoy the great films he was able to produce.
vrimmy78 10 months ago
Well they deserve the punches anyway
DanNZ4 10 months ago
4:35
Now wait just a dog gone minute i think Curly should get back at them for hitting him and they should apologize to him the dopes
DanNZ4 10 months ago
2:00 I love the way Curly yells "Ow Ow Ow Ow!"
MichaelD8393 10 months ago
@FUNNIEBONE21 i agree.
MichaelD8393 10 months ago
This short is a great example that the late Curly shorts produced/directed Hugh McCollum/Edward Bernds are much better than the late Curly shorts directed by Jules White, while Curly appeared really sick and unhealthy at least Curly isn't pushed to the background as often like he was in shorts like "Uncivil War Birds", "Three Loan Wolves" and "GI Wanna Home"
Doobie1975 10 months ago
Magan:"Iwant juoce and I want it right now!"
Curly:*Innocently*"Here ya are"*Holds up a live wire.*
*Magan receives electric shock.*
LMAO :D
DodgyMan12 10 months ago
It's sad knowing that this was Curly's last short. You can tell he wasn't as able to do the physical stuff. Even when he speaks, he seems somewhat tentative. What a shame.
sneezepal 11 months ago
@sneezepal This Is Not Curly's Last Short His Last Short Was Half-Wits Hoiliday
69789Darius 11 months ago 14
Perfect activity for recovering from the work week: sitting in my jammys watchin' the stooges on youtube!
unholyimage 11 months ago
Cy Schindell: "What do ya think your doin'?!
Moe: "We're breathin'"!
Cy Schindell: "Well cut it out, it aint on the schedule!!"
Moogaar1 1 year ago 2
@Moogaar1 "Well cut it out, it ain't on the schedule" is my favorite line on this episode. Love that guy who says it. Always plays a bad guy
beani24329 8 months ago 2
curly actually doesent look too sick in this 1. Long live the stooges!
acfreak55 1 year ago 9
@acfreak55 Unfortunately the opposite is true. His condition during the production of this one was so bad Moe had to sometimes coach Curly his lines. You can see it at 6:42 where Moe nudges Curly.
toddles822 1 year ago
@acfreak55
He certainly was though. Moe had to coach him line by line. The filming was grueling.. The director was exceptional though. He covered it up well.
jella11 10 months ago
@acfreak55 It was a combo of Moe's coaching and the director shooting in such a way so as to help Curly look good. The result was a very good short, even Curly wise. But he wasn't in good health.
fjccommish 7 months ago
"I only climbed up seven steps!" "The ladder had six!" ROTFLMFAO
AnakinAhsokaGeek18 1 year ago 2
boy that boss guy needs a chill pill
MrDiablolord 1 year ago
Miss Shapley !!! I love nurses !!!
slonamu 1 year ago 2
@slonamu Nice! Miss Shapely!
unholyimage 11 months ago
@ANDRES161166 This was 1946
Murderdoll13 1 year ago