Added: 4 years ago
From: beetrue2ufirst
Views: 547,480
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,326)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I was sitting here bawling listening to her- such an intense passionate delivery, you can't fake this depth of soul.You can tell she's lived through something like this. 'Blowing it?'- they must mean the gusty day

  • You better get it with your jaw tension Jennifer!!! I ain't mad at ya lollol

  • @superstar7soso oh well crongratulations to him :) i was sure id seen his face somewhere before :)

  • Comment removed

  • @kidrauhl i checked out your page you're quite good actually you could probably become famous one day if you keep trying good luck :) x

  • @lollipopsweetsx lol kidrauhl is actually Justin Bieber who is one of the most famous celebrities out there.

  • her name is spelled wrong in the video. it's Holiday not Holliday

  • "And I Am Telling You", there has NEVER BEEN nor will there EVER BE anyone who will sing this song like Jennifer Holiday sings it. She OWNS this song.

  • no wonder why they send her to the roof to sing! so nobody could hear hear!!! LOL

  • oh god....her face...

  • search an amazing:

    And I'm Telling You I'm Not Going Cristian e Andrea

  • I saw the pre-boadway run in Boston, she tore the roof off.

    We just expected a sing and dance show, then she started singing...wow.

  • OMG she's too nice! great performance, it definately wasn't as great as the older one's but she's in her 40s here! stop hating cuz nobody on here can sing like that!

  • Breathtaking.

  • wow just awesome!

  • Miss Holiday owns this song, signed sealed and delivered, without a shadow of a doubt - gives me chills each and every time I hear it. A class act!

  • Jennifer was singing not trying to be cute, sexy, not trying to dance, not worrying about diction.........A RAW TRUE TALENT........all the things Americans dont want......a shame!

  • WOW!

    Let me be superficial for a sec. Usually when people are young they are skinny & beautiful. Jennifer was fat & most definitely beautiful. But now her outer beauty and inner beauty is in synch in more ways than one! Look at her. Her smile radiates happiness and LOVE and LIGHT.

    Thank you Jennifer for showing so much positive energy to everyone when you sing.

    You don't get old ... you get better with each year!

    Are you suuuuuuuuuuuuure it's been 25 years since Dreamgirls? ;-)

  • I saw her in the Broadway production a few years back. One of the highlights of the show. She was totally amazing and didn't pull out any stops.

    She is still just as great.

  • this upsets me that they got her on roof c'mon

  • Jennifer Holliday is the truth she is in a class all by herself. Gone girl.

  • @victate Amen!i just hate that the underrated singer's don't get the exposure they need..

  • @victate

    met her a long time ago - she is a beautiful lady and awesome singer....

  • DEAD @ this performance. This was laughable.

  • Hudson is good... but she ain't no Holliday... this role will forever be Holliday's

  • Yes,,,,,,,, I love Hudson so much,,, but it will always be Holiday!!! Perfection is Holiday!!!!!

  • You are 100 percent right. Holiday is touched by the divine. Absolute amazing.

  • this is so fuckin annoyin

  • dont fucking watch it then ya nob!

  • Just going through my favs, and saw this. Still gives me goosebumps.

  • when your first its the best place to be because funnily enough your after. late, behind. she owns this song so i feel sorry for the rest. the truth hurts! end of school!

  • it is a little different seeing her smaller... the crazed singing worked well when she was larger. But regardless... nobody can top her on this song... all they can do is copy. She's the originater of all the oooh's and aaah's and goofy crazed faces! Breath control indeed.

  • Looks and sounds like shit since losing weight!? Are you insane!!?? She looks amazing and so much healthier, I don't know how she lost it but she most certainly does not look "like shit."

  • Completely agree, She has always sounded good but at one time was morbidly obese. She is Healthier and sounds wonderful

  • she wasnt on crack

  • yo mama was on crack=)XD

  • People Jennifer Holiday is the real deal. She sings with such passion and soul it is unbelievable. No one sings this song like her. She is the originator. We are always comparing people instead of accepting people for their own rights and talents. No one is the same. Everyone is different. Thanks for the post.

  • The Original

    The Best

    The OWNER of this song

    Miss Jennifer Holiday.

    Stop the comparison. There are many great talents that perform the song well but Jennifer Holiday puts the soul in it.

  • the acts the song.

    She shows anger and love and strength. Whitney's version is amazing, but Jennifer's is better as she conveys the emotions in to it

  • original

  • Sings very much touching !!!

  • booo jennifer hudsons verison is better than whitneys verison

  • jennifer hudson is not a fake she is FAB-U-LOUS!!!!!!..... hey dude im not saying whitney isnt good to ... infact all in all she is propbably a better singer ... well not better they are actaully quite different but i personally like jennifer hudsons version of this song better then whitneys purely coz of i like the roughness of j-huds voice thats all ... there is no need to call me a stupid kid xx..... have a nice weekend xx

  • I think it is amazing how she can sing with such pure raw passion! What I mean by that is, she does not care what "ANY ONE" think's about her facial expressions! You would never think that the voice would come out of her like it does! AMAZING!

  • jennifer holiday is amazing

  • LOL at the "gospel jaw" comment

  • You people have all completely missed the point of the performance, and the video!

  • yoo she looks maddd crazy :45is mad funnyy

    && wehnn she sayss mehehhehehe

  • Sing it jennifer!!!

    0f c0urse every1 has their 0n opini0n...

    Funnie thing iz they can c0me cl0se 2 ur v0cal talent!!!

    sing 0n mama'z!!

  • what bizarre facial expressions. does she have a medical condition?:S

  • LOL!!!

  • haha yes i think its facial contortion!

  • Oh come on now, Bianca Ryan will be a force to recon with in the near future!!! I have never seen a 11 year old sing the way she does and I believe she will only get better.

  • you guys ever heard of Charice Pempengco from the Philippines? She knocked Bianca's tiny butt out of the game.

  • this is bad.....waa she doin? the firss version was better in the 80s. facial expressions wass that

  • Bianca does a HELL of a lot better than that!!!!!! What's with all the weird noises and faces???

  • Jennifer has extremely annoying mannerisms (and face :D), but you can't even begin to compare voices. Bianca is a kid, sure, props for that, but come on. She overdarkens and only sounds dopey. Very overrated. She will never even come close to being close to Jennifer in regards to pure voice.

  • I dont like this version of the song!

  • I agree with this comment. I didn't even know the song until I saw Bianca Ryan singing it on YouTube, but I find this version very weird and kind of strained and clipped. Maybe good, but very unnatural and really hard work - I'm exhausted just watching it ;-)

  • r u kidding?? who the hell is bianca ryan in comparison to j holliday? as sbn notised that was a bit of sAnging, and it gives me chills..

  • I wasn't comparing - I only said that was the first time I ever heard this song. You must have misunderstood me there. Nor am I disputing that Jennifer Holiday has an excellent voice, but I still find all the grunting and exaggerated grimacing very unnatural and unaesthetic. Just like I can't stand to watch those top notch tennis stars who grunt and pull faces every time they hit the ball - doesn't mean they aren't good players ;-)

  • Cheers)))

  • Comment removed

  • where is my comment

  • omg .. the endings are horrible .. i think theres to much squeakin in it :D .. hahaha horrible .. YOUUUUAAAAAA xD

  • Now THATS some "sangin'"!

  • wow

  • Bravo, Jenifer. Powerful voice, so much energy, feelings and sense

  • It is very special her own style of performance, but actualy IMHO I don't like much grimacing

  • lmao lol cum on now wit dem faces

  • lmao!!!! the expressions are killing nyi nyi nyi omg this is the future!!!! lmoa ha ha

  • i like this song but her facial expressions kinda throw me off...she has such a powerful voice though!!!

  • what genre of music is this?

  • Does it matter? Isn't it just one hell of masterpiece?

  • I think it's "soul"...... if it's wrong then .... anybody knows what genre of music is this?

  • Even though, this version is amazing, i prefer the Jennifer Hudson version myself.

    They both have amazing voices, i could never pull it off. (:

  • OMG

  • best version ever...the song was created for her voice. Her diction of every word is awesome. You can't forget her voice. Listen to the classics first before the renditions.

  • I agree 100% she was the first and is obviously the best! JHud did her thing as well and she brought it but there is no way you can compare these women at all!

  • I hope not to offend anyone....but ummm....I can tell she has an incredible voice, but I really didn't care for this version of the song. I've listened to many other people sing it and this is the first time I've heard her. I am actually very surprised because I've heard a lot about J. Holliday and I was thinking I would be way more impressed than I am. She just seemed to be making noise more than really singing. I want to hear someone belt it out and sing words...not this growl/noise thing.

  • this is the whole idea of the song ... its about pain and crying .... she made the song famous

  • I know...I get that. I don't know, maybe I'm just weird :) I'm sure there are tons of people who really enjoyed this. I guess I just prefer songs I can sing along with and this just isn't one of those (this version anyway). It's just too 'noisy' for me ;) I guess we all have our own likes and dislikes :)

  • i not you....its just this is the original....holiday sang it first...ppl always like the original...u dont hsve to like it

  • this is the way etta should have handled beyonce.

  • i love you jennyfer holliday

    bye

  • Are you friggin kidding me? Bianca Ryan?? I didnt even know who she was. Looked her up here and she is NOT better than anyone who ever even hummed this song! What a joke.

  • Be fair - when you consider that Bianca was only 11 when she sang this on the talent show, I think you have to admit that she has a great voice and tremendous potential. Just because you didn't know who she was doesn't mean she's not good, does it?? And at least she doesn't pull ridiculous faces when she's singing, like someone having an epileptic fit.

  • SO GOOD ! :P

  • be serious no she not honey

  • for those of us lucky enough to have seen Jennifer Holiday live on broadway......there has never been nor ever will be such a performance.....i left the theater a changed man......jennifer hudson did a great tribute to Mrs Holiday but no one will ever belt it out like the way she did in the early 80's.......

  • There's no comparison between Jennifer Holiday and the Hudson girl. The DIVA is Holiday not Hudson. I heard Holiday sing in the early 80s. It left me weak at the knees. Hudson doesn't even come close in voicing. As for the size of the ladies, so they aren't bulimic, big deal. And Holiday looking 'better' today than in 1982, that's just your current perspective. Shoulder pads were 'in fashion' in 82, they are out of fashion now. You can't compare the fashion from then to now. Different times.

  • perfectly said....she is perfection...

  • she looked better when she grew older.. lol weird

  • Wow, she looks so different! Maybe it is a generational thing, but this is, always has been and will continue to be Jennifer Holiday's song, I don't know how anyone can argue with that. When she was introduced all those years ago, it was incredible, I had not ever heard anyone sing like this. Yes, of course Patti and Chaka were there and we know how incredible they are, but Jennifer was just a young girl and she was (and is) an incredible performer. Good to see her again.

  • I think she sing this more emotional than Hudson. But Hudson's version is more beautiful in rhythm.

  • out of all the jennys

    i think she needs jenny craig the most

  • Grow up.....like you could ever match her pipes.....with all the negativity in the world...we don't need more here.

  • where the hell do u see me saying i can match her singing?

  • I think that was a bit inappropriate given how incredible a performer she is and her constantly fluctuating weight. She is absolutely incredible!! =)

  • you think she is good

    1. she has horrible diction

    2. and you notice she was quite till dreamgirls became huge

    3. she has no were near the power and voice of jennifer hudson

  • Wow

  • WOW WHAT WOW are you talking about me or them

  • watch me sing One Night Only, subscribe please, and tell everyone to watch thanks.

  • Jeniffer holiday ugh is the best for the song,ugh but this new version with the ugh ugh does annoy me ugh. is more,less over doing it, ugh she dont have too she sound great, but she does ugh ugh, ah ah aha ah STOP IT NOW JENNY!!!!

  • you albin bitch needz ta shed ta fuck up...cuz she soundz very good...dat's jes her way of singing the song..and it's great...bitch...and da ugh...it stayz!

  • You're the best man -uh, I eva know -ugh.

    I don't wanna be free.....ugh!

  • She the orginal singer for this song, what is wrong with u peps. She the queen! of this song.

  • ... ugh.

  • I love you...ugh. I need you... ugh. I..ugh.

  • its awful...........

    awfully FUNNY!!!!!!! LOL!!!

  • That ugh sound she makes at the end of every note, is not part of emoting, and sounds annoying - it takes away from the great notes that she does sing. It's a singer's affectation that really detracts from the beautiful voice she has. I don't know if it's a Tina Turner thing or what, but because of that, I think Bianca Ryan's version IS better, not just because it's unbelievable that she sings like that at age 11, but because she SINGS the song, makes the notes beautiful even when emoting.

  • It's emoting - hellooooo! You must be too young to remember her role in Dreamgirls. Her song, her role. Jeezus, get widit.

  • is she the same person?

  • at 2:37 she sounds like a guy singing in his falsetto. and so does other parts but this part was the best. she sounds like a guy singing in his falsetto.

  • You're sick.

  • i hate her face! why she have always to look so awful while singing still don't get but she has a beautiful voice just hate the way she express in her face what she sings!

  • coz its all in the emotions. she sings with too much emotions which is good.

  • cause you gotta put on the stank face when you singin somethin like that...

    You cant be cute...you've gotta look like you just took a Laxative and ate every dairy product available.

  • HAHAAHAHA you're right man.

  • My impression is: She must be drunk....?!

    It`s only AWFUL !!

  • lol the 1st line is very vuery lol but her singing is far from uwfull lol

  • I'm amused that someone thinks Bianca Ryan sings this better than original. You're either dumb or deaf. Jennifer Holiday wipes her feet on Bianca's version.

  • bianca ryan sings this better :)

  • i agree!!

  • hell no! no copycat can replace the original i.e. rednecks!

  • Jen has come a long way since the days she was discrimminated against because of her weight. She is beautiful and a truly underated talent. Baby got pipes STILL after 25 years like she has said for Dreamgirls

  • I like Jennifer Hudson's version more than this one

  • dont look at her face, listen to her singing, yes i agree she looks funny singing, this song touches me, it reminds me about my mom who got kicked out by my dad, and got killed. yuh huh , thats my reason,

  • Bianca Ryan is singing this song better!!

  • jennifer hudson is so beautiful and she sings the song so good with passion and her face expressions are out of this world. At 4:01 she does that every time she sings that song and I'm sorry but i can't stop laughing. But nobody can sing the song like she can

  • No one can sing this song better than J-holiday. This song belongs to her. Love u J-holiday.

  • what about bianca ryan?

  • Jennifer Hudson did a great job. But no one will ever do this song with the emotion, soul and depth in which Jennifer Holliday did. She is the original Effie, I saw Dreamgirls on Broadway, when I was 7. To this day I remember her performance, her voice filled that entire theatre, she was majestic, and I was in awe.

  • her face was narley

  • Your the best Jenn !!!!

  • I didn't like this performance and it is also several keys lower than her original performance which I think makes a big difference. However, her performance back in the day is the very best I've seen. It makes me cry every time. She looks weird now though - she must have had so much surgery and she's done something to her teeth too.

  • i dont know how old you are, but could you sing a song like her, at the age of 47, hugh?

  • 47 isn't very old, young actually

  • i remember the soup made fun of this performance saying after all of her bitching, she finally gets a chance to revise her song...alone! with no audience!

  • she make me feeling bad !

    i prefer J Hudson

  • I love Charice so much but.... I think Jennifer Holiday is The best . Charice sing this song very smooth and good but this song Jennifer get it more.

  • power

  • jennifer holiday is the best cause with the facial expessions it is all just so great keep it up beautiful..

  • That was BRILLIANT, no matter what people say, se is and she wil always be the BEST singer who has ever performed this song.

  • Guys, jus cease and enjoy the song. Any1 doesnt like Jen can jus keep the negative comments away.what is the point of making conflicts...

    J. Holiday is magnificent.

  • This performance is FAN BLOODY TASTIC!!! Love ya!! Anyone who can sing THIS song as good as this, deserves recognition!! Sorry, but all you "HATERS" out there, probably can't sing a note!

  • this 'fucking face' is called emotion, she's not only singing she's acting, she's an actress...you are all missinformed...jennifer holiday was the first effie on broadway, she gave effie all her spirit.she made this song famous. hudson did nothing but copying her.

  • "i'm not waking up tomorrow morning...ha ha"

  • What about her face? Well- she sings with passion and deep feelings...sooo...what?

  • wow. let's hear you sing this song.

  • Original and still great.

  • Hey! Nobody has the right to say negative words about Jennifer Holiday, she made this song very famous and her desendants are regine velasquez, jennifer hudson and charice pempengco and a lot more. but Holiday is the original, so thanks to her! at her age she can still her song incredibly great. Go Go Jennifer Holiday

  • mahantachuprah - AMEN! I LOVE Jennifer and yes, this song IS and WILL ALWAYS be HERS! She's often imitated but NEVER duplicated!