hollyleaf IS still alive. proof: blossomfall and ivypool were helped by a mysterious black cat in the tunnels, and she was scented by a dead squirrel. also, when jayfeather visited starclan, hollyleaf wasnt there.
love hollyleaf!!! she seems evil to some people, but that insane stage she went through, and how she is now qualified as evil it just makes her character that more interesting, i know she's alive, and i know she's comeing back. she's comeing back to thunderclan better then ever! :D
SHE IS STILL ALIVE ERIN HUNTER CONFIRMED IT!! :D in the next book to be released (the forgotten warrior) she is the forgotten warrior. :) :) :) huzzahh
she killed because she thought she was doing the right thing!!! NOT BECUZ SHE WANTED TO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -fur rises up in anger- Besides, -smoothes chest fur down- Ashfur kinda deserves it. He tried to kill firestar and he almost killed holleyleaf, jayfeather, and Lionblaze. HOLLEYLEAF IS NOT AN ASSASSIN!!! -fur flies up again- -unsheathes claws- SHE WAS ADDICTED TO THE WARRIOR CODE AND THE NEXT THING SHE KNEW SHE WAS BRAKING IT WITH EVERY OUNCE OF BREATH SHE HAD!!!
If you ask me, Hollyleaf's evil now. But not that boring I hate you evil, that awesome Azula-traped-inside-her-mind evil. I really have no idea why but ever since sunrise (or sunset? I'm not sure) I've been reminded of Azula from Avatar The Last Airbender.
SPOLIER ALERT!! i knoww shes alive and im soo excited!! i loved her and i think it would make a suprising twist to the newest series if jayfeather and lionblaze found out she was alive . i forgot what book, but doesnt anyone remember when jayfeather found a mysterious herb and no one admits to getting it? i believe that its hollyleaf because this herb was the first herb hollyleaf got!
Yup. She's alive. It was Fallen Leaves and Hollyleaf - I believe it was different times. I don't remember right now. Anyway, I'm so glad I'm not the only warrior freak on here! :)
Spoilers!!! dont read this if you dont want to see!! ~ Hollyleaf is the main character in the next omen of the stars book, The Forgotten Warrior, it was said by the author
@jayfeather11000 actually . . there were two cats who helped ivypool and blossomfall. the first one was fallen leaves , the second one had to be hollyleaf . but thats just my opinion. :)
Hollyleaf is alive the shadowy cat was fallen leaves not hollyleaf but I hope hollyleaf does come back that would be great and why would she live with sol she hates him
ON AUGUST 20 WE WILL ALL WATCH DEMI'S MUSIC VIDEO SKYSCRAPER IN HONOR OF HER BIRTHDAY. THIS IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL SONG SHE HAS MADE. SO LET'S GIVE HER THE BEST BIRTHDAY PRESENT EVER: THE HIGHEST VIEWED VIDEO ON YOUTUBE! WE NEED TO GIVE HER WHAT SHE TRULY DESERVES! COPY AND PASTE TO ALL DEMI VIDEOS TO GET THIS NOTICED!
Alive, Erin wouldn't be so vague. It is confirmed she chases firestar and they both die. Bramble claw gets blinded and all. But the supplies found at the opening to there camp was the only thin hollyleaf remembered from being a medicine cat the tuft if fur was her. The cats m
ITS CONFIRMED SHE IS ALIVE just in, like JUST if Erin didn't care she would be dead the reins are being vague because they are making a surprise, and it's true that she is going to come back in the forgotten warrior and her an forester dies. Bramble claw gets blinded by a rabbit. But she is Alivr
i belive HollyLeaf is alive and so not with Sol i think she is a rouge or somehow managed to find the tribes or maybe anotehr clan to be with becasue the warrior code did mean alot to her
Shes not living with sol people they dont like each other sol is not living in tunnles to be with her sol may come back (doubt it) but he wont be with hollyleaf!
I hate spoiling things , but EVERYONE is right. Hollyleaf is not dead. In one of the books, it clearly states that Hollyleaf survived. And she is possibly living with Sol.
graymist45 ibeleive hollyleafs is not dead because jayfeather can't see that make seens . if you where reading the story it tells you that jayfeather sees in his dreams.
I'm just writing a story bout how she got out of the tunnels, centimeters in front of the last sharp stone, and then wandered around, confused and... well, the same she left ThunderClan.
It's called "Hollyleaf's journey" and will be seen on dA =D
She's definently still alve. She isn't seen in Starclan or the Dark forest, plus, i'm pretty sure Erin Hunter is going to make her a big part of the plot later on.
@maxpro42 Because Killing Ashfur was too much for her to handle and she told everyone the truth about their parents. She wanted to get away so she ran into the tunnels and they collapsed. I believe shes alive though.
It would be SOOOOO cool if all the sudden Jayfeather was wandering through the forest and heard moaning and he thought of digging through the tunnel (and he did) and he found Hollyleaf struggling there covered in blood and was almost dead and she screamed to Jayfeather "HELP ME IM ALIVE "
I LOOOVE ASHFUR TOO! if i hate any one its stupid squirel flight cuz she chose brambleclaw and woopty doo look what happens he dosent love her any more!! i mean now squireleflight has no mate and its all her fault for lying AND not choosing ashfur.
well if someone kin of fire star was evil wouldn't it be ivypaw? i mean she was training with dark forest cats. and what about that vision jayfeather saw where all of thunder clan except ivypaw died?i mean thats who i think but i agree i hope hollyleaf is alive
She has no power.... The proficy is Jayfeather Lionblaze and Dovepaw, not Hollyleaf... My friend's friend instant chats with erin hunter.... SPOILER: Hollyleaf comes out as villan and drives Firestar off cliff and they both die in book 6 of Omen Of The Stars....
Erin Hunter said one of the three kin would be evil. Could it be Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, or Jaypaw? I think it could be Lionblaze, considering he seems very ambitious and is trained by Tigerstar and Hawkfrost. I don't think it will be Jaypaw, considering he has done nothing wrong that hints he is evil. I don't think it will be Hollyleaf, either- she has done nothing wrong, but her power is not yet known- this power could lead her into evilness. Your opinion? It is definetly Hollyleaf... She has n
Well, I subscribed, I rated and I liked, and now I'm commenting. You happy? And I LOVE Hollyleaf!!!! Ashfur threatened to take away what she believed in, so she responded by fighting for what she thought was right. But, she then realized how mistreated they had been, and the secret was driving her crazy. She couldn't help but tell everyone, it was driving her insane. In my opinion, if Ashfur had it coming, and I hate him because I believe he drove her insane....
why does everyone think of murder and blood when they think of hollyleaf?she only killed one cat, unlike tigerstar.stop being so hard on her! please. i sympathize her. she was just so confused,you know?it was like she was addicted to the warrior code, and when ashfur threatened to take that away,she killed him.took away the threat.no, i don't think if she was human she shouldn't get away with it,but she was just really confused,and they're cats,in the wild,with evil humans.they die all the time.
@Swiftflower Me too! I still love Holleyleaf and she can't help that her heart was broken to pieces! Her heart is pure warrior, but it was torn. That's all. She's nothing compared to the cats of the Dark forest.
@Swiftflower i know right!? It wasnt her fault her life was full of lies! Also i didnt like ashfur, also about the warrior code, she just wanted to be a loyal warrior but, i mean really. I would go crazy too if i was in her postition!!
@Swiftflower She may have killed another after she disappeared since she is still alive for all we know she could have killed more. We have to wait till the next book to find out.
YAYZIES THIS IS GOOD hollyleaf is SO ALIVE i think she's been half-driven to insanity from having been shrunken and having to live with flies for 60 moons and in the huge war: WHICH SIDE WOULD SHE CHOOSE?!?! EVIL VS. GOOD!!!!! MWAH HA HA HA HA HA HA HA I LUV ERIN HUNTERS FOR CREATING MOST AWESOME BOOK SERIES
I hate the fact that people LOVED Hollyleaf in the beginning of the books, and then started just HATEING her when she killed Ashfur. I'm glad I know people in this world who like Hollyleaf. Like me. And like you. XD
@ILoveHawkFroat No,he Only saw the tunnel collapse.But that doesn't mean that Hollyleaf is dead.She couldv'e dug her way out or get out before the tunnel collapsed on her,She should appear back in ThunderClan.Soon,I hope.
@thelime95 Hollyleaf is alive it says in Sign of the Moon when Jayfeather and Lionblaze finally decide to investegte where the rocks fell. And all they found was a tuft of fur no Hollyleaf. And then Bloosomfall and Ivypool meet her without knowing when they accidentaly get lost in the tunnels. It dosnt say its her but I just know it is oh and they also meet Fallen Leaves. So its not him, cause it said it was a different cat.
@thelime95 hollyleaf is alive because in the new books jayfeather and lionblaze go into the hole after another cat falls in. They find a tuft of black fur and pawprints
@thelime95 She isn't dead ~~ <3 I only know is that all they found was a tuft of fur, but not her body. They believe she became a rouge, but then they think about how much the Warrior Code meant to her...
@JBANK29 yeah but Fallen Leaves died in the tunnel and his soul was lost down there so maybe that happened to Hollyleaf. She could possibly still be alive thought and if she is Erin hunter will make a dramatatic reappearance for her xD
@JBANK29 I beleive she ran away with Sol in the tunnel. . . . .and she is living well. During Night Whispers, when Jayfeather finds a tuft of her fur, she just needed a medicine. I also beleive she has many kits .3.
@JBANK29 She's not in the tunnels 'cause Jayfeather and Lionblaze checked there. They also found her fur in the rocks, proving she wasn't crushed, but the fur scent was stale.
the first like thirty seconds or so until it says beatin like a hammer it sounds like it's from the movie Suckerpunch..
great video too i love it
Candie123450 3 days ago
:D i like it! who ever dislike ARE DUMB!
bakerbunchsc 5 days ago
i luvs hollyleaf but i also luvs ashfur...
bluekat321 4 weeks ago
hollyleaf IS still alive. proof: blossomfall and ivypool were helped by a mysterious black cat in the tunnels, and she was scented by a dead squirrel. also, when jayfeather visited starclan, hollyleaf wasnt there.
TieDyeGirl41 1 month ago
@TieDyeGirl41 I would say she maybe went to the dark forest, but then she would be training and ivypaw would've seen her
TheMorningCloud 1 week ago
this song is a perfect theme song for lana from the gone series cuz she cant die and she keeps healing herself and talking coyotes are chasing her.
bluekat321 1 month ago
I love this song. Which picture did you draw? I LOVE HOLLYLEAF, CROWFEATHER, JAYFEATHER, AND ASHFUR.
Wildfur454545 1 month ago
@TNTrocksTNT who is cinderstar
sarahshepard1000 1 month ago
its because he....well i dont really know i just hate him... oh... because he almost ruined the clans.
sarahshepard1000 1 month ago
bitch's she's alive! just read the forgotten warrior!
LoveErica2Hot4u 2 months ago
hollyleaf doe survive, lives in the tunnels and is there when dark forest attack starclan and the other clan cat. Curse u sol!!!
XxMaltraayaWolvesxX 2 months ago
Wait Hollyleaf is alive
Yay, but wy the only girl from the three(Jay, Lion, and Holly) go insane
she was my favorite and I can't belive that Erin Hunter had her kill Ashfur and try to kill Leafpool just why?
Rainstar49 2 months ago in playlist Hollyleaf
i love this song <3
SadleProductionz 2 months ago
Spoiler alert-Hollyleaf does come back from the tunnels in forgotten warrior.And Sol apso comes back, seeking revenge.
Hollyleaf235 2 months ago
@Hollyleaf235 OMG i HATE sol
sarahshepard1000 2 months ago
@sarahshepard1000 why?
Affectionatequeen13 1 month ago
yayyyyyy, i finished the forgotten warrior book and shes alive ;)
cksl516 3 months ago
@cksl516 Don't spoil the book for everyone.
DragonPowaify 2 months ago
@DragonPowaify o sorry! D:
cksl516 2 months ago
@cksl516 That's fine XD
DragonPowaify 2 months ago
Cant Wait!!!! i am so tired of reading the same books over and over though theyre the best series ever :)
silverstar383 3 months ago
even if erin didnt confirm it hollyleaf helped ivypool and blossomfall out of the tunnels after falllen leaves tried to
silverstar383 3 months ago
Yesh! new book comes out on the 22nd! Finally ill have something to read instead of playing xbox and getting fat!
sandstar576 3 months ago
lawlz ashfur and crowfeather made acounts to dislike!
ecipoe 3 months ago 8
@ecipoe oh now nightcloud has as well who knew cats used youtube? XD
littleponypet 2 months ago
@ecipoe
And Nightcloud!Don't forget Nightcloud!
badgerstarful 2 months ago
@ecipoe Ashfur, Crowfeather and Squirrelflight!
aep1a 1 month ago
the 1 dislike was ashfur
Hawktalon18 4 months ago 2
@summersweetie159 i forget what book to but the kits also found a squirrel
jayfeather11000 4 months ago 2
@summersweetie159 your right read it over
Must have read it wrong first sorry :)
jayfeather11000 4 months ago 2
That was awesome!!
firepelt222 5 months ago
love hollyleaf!!! she seems evil to some people, but that insane stage she went through, and how she is now qualified as evil it just makes her character that more interesting, i know she's alive, and i know she's comeing back. she's comeing back to thunderclan better then ever! :D
WolfFreaxx200 5 months ago
i love hollyleaf.
SHE IS STILL ALIVE ERIN HUNTER CONFIRMED IT!! :D in the next book to be released (the forgotten warrior) she is the forgotten warrior. :) :) :) huzzahh
ToontownLavender 5 months ago 19
@ToontownLavender rly?
or r u just trolling?
hamsterlover577 2 months ago
@hamsterlover577 naw bitch i just read the book she's back! :D
LoveErica2Hot4u 2 months ago
@ToontownLavender Nope! Just Chuck Testa!
NyraArtist 1 month ago
i think she was just confused and didn't know what do do. she couldn't think correctly and killed ashfur, then told everyone the secret.
mousestar2 5 months ago
love this song danced to it in talent show yah
monstermall66 5 months ago
Hollyleaf is alive! I just know it! The Erin Hunters even said it was so!
CresentDawn1 5 months ago in playlist Hollyleaf
@catwarriorfoxtail *uses tail to smooth your fur* we know. And its not like she's gone...
SayinWarriorCat 5 months ago
she killed because she thought she was doing the right thing!!! NOT BECUZ SHE WANTED TO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -fur rises up in anger- Besides, -smoothes chest fur down- Ashfur kinda deserves it. He tried to kill firestar and he almost killed holleyleaf, jayfeather, and Lionblaze. HOLLEYLEAF IS NOT AN ASSASSIN!!! -fur flies up again- -unsheathes claws- SHE WAS ADDICTED TO THE WARRIOR CODE AND THE NEXT THING SHE KNEW SHE WAS BRAKING IT WITH EVERY OUNCE OF BREATH SHE HAD!!!
catwarriorfoxtail 6 months ago
@catwarriorfoxtail IT'S NOT HER FAULT!
catwarriorfoxtail 6 months ago
i just made a video about hollyleaf about an hour ago....did u get pictures from internet too? some are same as mine xD
TheRavenclawgal 6 months ago
If you ask me, Hollyleaf's evil now. But not that boring I hate you evil, that awesome Azula-traped-inside-her-mind evil. I really have no idea why but ever since sunrise (or sunset? I'm not sure) I've been reminded of Azula from Avatar The Last Airbender.
violetisinventing 6 months ago
shes alive, we all know it right? shes probably the fourth cat that must join with the three. :P...
Jaymelody500 6 months ago
SPOLIER ALERT!! i knoww shes alive and im soo excited!! i loved her and i think it would make a suprising twist to the newest series if jayfeather and lionblaze found out she was alive . i forgot what book, but doesnt anyone remember when jayfeather found a mysterious herb and no one admits to getting it? i believe that its hollyleaf because this herb was the first herb hollyleaf got!
summersweetie159 6 months ago
Yup. She's alive. It was Fallen Leaves and Hollyleaf - I believe it was different times. I don't remember right now. Anyway, I'm so glad I'm not the only warrior freak on here! :)
lauraandjamesjo4 6 months ago
Spoilers!!! dont read this if you dont want to see!! ~ Hollyleaf is the main character in the next omen of the stars book, The Forgotten Warrior, it was said by the author
megapwenr3000 7 months ago
@katiecandy7
It was not hollyleaf that helped ivypool and
Blossomfall out of the tunnel it was fallen leaves because it said Ginger Tom and it said HE smelled of rock and earth
So it must have been fallen leaves cause rock is gray an hollyleaf is black so it can't be rock or hollyleaf it has to be fallen leaves
jayfeather11000 7 months ago
@jayfeather11000 actually . . there were two cats who helped ivypool and blossomfall. the first one was fallen leaves , the second one had to be hollyleaf . but thats just my opinion. :)
summersweetie159 6 months ago
Hollyleaf is alive the shadowy cat was fallen leaves not hollyleaf but I hope hollyleaf does come back that would be great and why would she live with sol she hates him
jayfeather11000 7 months ago
wow this is my favorite seires. my favorite song. and my favorite book THANKK YOU
spazkitten1 7 months ago
They found a tuft of fur....but no body......and when they went deeper into the tunnels, they said that they felt as if they wer "not alone"
Justo1237 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ON AUGUST 20 WE WILL ALL WATCH DEMI'S MUSIC VIDEO SKYSCRAPER IN HONOR OF HER BIRTHDAY. THIS IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL SONG SHE HAS MADE. SO LET'S GIVE HER THE BEST BIRTHDAY PRESENT EVER: THE HIGHEST VIEWED VIDEO ON YOUTUBE! WE NEED TO GIVE HER WHAT SHE TRULY DESERVES! COPY AND PASTE TO ALL DEMI VIDEOS TO GET THIS NOTICED!
sweetpaw72 7 months ago
the new lost warriors i read a review at books a million.com and its about sasha WTF!!
brat0502 7 months ago
Also a strange scent was found near camp and a dead squirrel with a scent jay feather thought was hollyleafs
katiecandy7 7 months ago
@katiecandy7 Ive read the books out I dont remember a dead squirrel can u refresh my memory?
SwagKing212 7 months ago
Who were lost dovewing... And I forget um they were led out by a dark colored cat. And that cat had said there were others that had been down there
katiecandy7 7 months ago
Alive, Erin wouldn't be so vague. It is confirmed she chases firestar and they both die. Bramble claw gets blinded and all. But the supplies found at the opening to there camp was the only thin hollyleaf remembered from being a medicine cat the tuft if fur was her. The cats m
katiecandy7 7 months ago
ITS CONFIRMED SHE IS ALIVE just in, like JUST if Erin didn't care she would be dead the reins are being vague because they are making a surprise, and it's true that she is going to come back in the forgotten warrior and her an forester dies. Bramble claw gets blinded by a rabbit. But she is Alivr
katiecandy7 7 months ago
hollyleaf isnt dead =P
tigerfang2017 7 months ago
hollyleaf is awsome and i know shes not dead she will probally come back in the next book
Warriorsrock129 8 months ago
i belive HollyLeaf is alive and so not with Sol i think she is a rouge or somehow managed to find the tribes or maybe anotehr clan to be with becasue the warrior code did mean alot to her
rtsbts01 8 months ago
well...Hollyleaf is actuly alive did you know or did you gess?
nightpool23 8 months ago
Shes not living with sol people they dont like each other sol is not living in tunnles to be with her sol may come back (doubt it) but he wont be with hollyleaf!
12Icepelt 8 months ago
She is alvie XD
Cariea122 8 months ago
im so happy hollyleaf is alive and most likely either living with sol of in the tunnels :D
yugvf 8 months ago
According to what Lionblaze and Jayfeather discovered in Omen of the Stars Book 5, Hollyleaf is probably still alive.
406maisy 8 months ago
This song really fits hollyleaf
HollyxSol foreva
Echosong24WolfGirl 8 months ago
I hate spoiling things , but EVERYONE is right. Hollyleaf is not dead. In one of the books, it clearly states that Hollyleaf survived. And she is possibly living with Sol.
dovepawXtigerheart 9 months ago
graymist45 ibeleive hollyleafs is not dead because jayfeather can't see that make seens . if you where reading the story it tells you that jayfeather sees in his dreams.
srs23dcx 9 months ago
I'm just writing a story bout how she got out of the tunnels, centimeters in front of the last sharp stone, and then wandered around, confused and... well, the same she left ThunderClan.
It's called "Hollyleaf's journey" and will be seen on dA =D
Todavia99 9 months ago
She's definently still alve. She isn't seen in Starclan or the Dark forest, plus, i'm pretty sure Erin Hunter is going to make her a big part of the plot later on.
BUT WE'LL SEE!!!!♪♫
IAteChildren 10 months ago
im reading the newist book sigh of the moon and lionblaze and jayfeather were in the cave and only found a tuff of her fur so she's alive!!!!
sorry 4 spoilers :)
thunderstone1234 10 months ago
Comment removed
WebkinzLuver413 10 months ago
Comment removed
silverfan4ever 11 months ago
good new erin hunter comfirmed she was alive but didnt say wich book she would come back in i think in book 5 forgoten warrior
runezabber02 11 months ago
why'd she go in the tunne in the first place?!
maxpro42 11 months ago
@maxpro42 Because Killing Ashfur was too much for her to handle and she told everyone the truth about their parents. She wanted to get away so she ran into the tunnels and they collapsed. I believe shes alive though.
ShadAmy4Eva1 11 months ago
Hollyleaf and Scourge....... hmmmmmmmmm. That would... could make a good pair... sort of.
embarandshadowlegend 11 months ago
It would be SOOOOO cool if all the sudden Jayfeather was wandering through the forest and heard moaning and he thought of digging through the tunnel (and he did) and he found Hollyleaf struggling there covered in blood and was almost dead and she screamed to Jayfeather "HELP ME IM ALIVE "
turk6177 11 months ago
I LOOOVE ASHFUR TOO! if i hate any one its stupid squirel flight cuz she chose brambleclaw and woopty doo look what happens he dosent love her any more!! i mean now squireleflight has no mate and its all her fault for lying AND not choosing ashfur.
srjohnson100 11 months ago
well if someone kin of fire star was evil wouldn't it be ivypaw? i mean she was training with dark forest cats. and what about that vision jayfeather saw where all of thunder clan except ivypaw died?i mean thats who i think but i agree i hope hollyleaf is alive
srjohnson100 11 months ago
I am making a vid with this song and charcteer! cuz it fits, btu I'm not tryin to steal the idea, just letting you guys know. :D
LATabbytail 1 year ago
She has no power.... The proficy is Jayfeather Lionblaze and Dovepaw, not Hollyleaf... My friend's friend instant chats with erin hunter.... SPOILER: Hollyleaf comes out as villan and drives Firestar off cliff and they both die in book 6 of Omen Of The Stars....
Shapeshifteroflight 1 year ago
@Shapeshifteroflight YAY FIRESTAR DIES SOON~
warriorsvlog 1 year ago
@warriorsvlog NO THAT IS NOT YAY... because i know part of me will die when he dies or i will cry
darksparlescar 1 year ago
@warriorsvlog Finally the reign of useless pacifism will be over! Pity hawkfrost is dead..
pteriforever 11 months ago
@Shapeshifteroflight :O im close to that..im reading rising storm, firestars quest and omen of the stars, 1st book.
123applezz 1 year ago
Erin Hunter said one of the three kin would be evil. Could it be Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, or Jaypaw? I think it could be Lionblaze, considering he seems very ambitious and is trained by Tigerstar and Hawkfrost. I don't think it will be Jaypaw, considering he has done nothing wrong that hints he is evil. I don't think it will be Hollyleaf, either- she has done nothing wrong, but her power is not yet known- this power could lead her into evilness. Your opinion? It is definetly Hollyleaf... She has n
Shapeshifteroflight 1 year ago
I hope she's still alive ;-;
Shapeshifteroflight 1 year ago
Well, I subscribed, I rated and I liked, and now I'm commenting. You happy? And I LOVE Hollyleaf!!!! Ashfur threatened to take away what she believed in, so she responded by fighting for what she thought was right. But, she then realized how mistreated they had been, and the secret was driving her crazy. She couldn't help but tell everyone, it was driving her insane. In my opinion, if Ashfur had it coming, and I hate him because I believe he drove her insane....
SuperBolt101 1 year ago
why does everyone think of murder and blood when they think of hollyleaf?she only killed one cat, unlike tigerstar.stop being so hard on her! please. i sympathize her. she was just so confused,you know?it was like she was addicted to the warrior code, and when ashfur threatened to take that away,she killed him.took away the threat.no, i don't think if she was human she shouldn't get away with it,but she was just really confused,and they're cats,in the wild,with evil humans.they die all the time.
Swiftflower 1 year ago 22
@Swiftflower Me too! I still love Holleyleaf and she can't help that her heart was broken to pieces! Her heart is pure warrior, but it was torn. That's all. She's nothing compared to the cats of the Dark forest.
Undertakerzgurl 1 year ago
@Undertakerzgurl it's not like she was REALLY evil. lionblaze trained with dark forsest dudes. that's beyond anything. EVIL BEEPIN' CATS!!!! GRRRRRR
Swiftflower 1 year ago
@Swiftflower i know right!? It wasnt her fault her life was full of lies! Also i didnt like ashfur, also about the warrior code, she just wanted to be a loyal warrior but, i mean really. I would go crazy too if i was in her postition!!
angelgirl0403 1 year ago
@Swiftflower She may have killed another after she disappeared since she is still alive for all we know she could have killed more. We have to wait till the next book to find out.
Ino45599 4 months ago
@Swiftflower i know right! most of the videos ive seen have pictures of her with blood on her paws with a grin
animalcrossingRaiyna 4 months ago 4
Comment removed
Swiftflower 1 year ago
YAYZIES THIS IS GOOD hollyleaf is SO ALIVE i think she's been half-driven to insanity from having been shrunken and having to live with flies for 60 moons and in the huge war: WHICH SIDE WOULD SHE CHOOSE?!?! EVIL VS. GOOD!!!!! MWAH HA HA HA HA HA HA HA I LUV ERIN HUNTERS FOR CREATING MOST AWESOME BOOK SERIES
Swiftflower 1 year ago
Comment removed
Swiftflower 1 year ago
Well I personally like Hollyleaf and I'm happy she killed Ashfur because I didn't like him at all! Well this is just my opinion so ya
BlueStarDaLeader 1 year ago
Mal also means bad in French!
xHimeka 1 year ago
I love Hollyleaf so much, even if she did kill Ashfur and all that stuff. She's just so... I dunno, interesting!
I really hope that she's alive. I absolutely love it when cats go insane, so fun... so fun :D
DarkiOmnom 1 year ago 10
@DarkiOmnom Erin Hunter said she was still living!!! ^-^
annekeazureheart 5 months ago
I lovez Hollyleaf. ^^
I don't know if she should be alive or not. Hollyleaf could be the one who will truly convert Ivypaw to the dark side. =O
TheCrazedSkittles 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
4:31 thats Yellowfang and Brokenstar
RavenstarxJayfeather 1 year ago
4:31 thats Yellowfang and Brokenstar
RavenstarxJayfeather 1 year ago
@RavenstarxJayfeather Actually I think that's Hollyleaf when she was trying to get Leafpool to eat deathberries :/
zeitgeistermann 1 year ago
Great video!!! :D Nice song too;)
MEOW677 1 year ago
I have that same feeling. Maybe she'll be seen one day. More drama! :D
BlueMew919 1 year ago
I hate the fact that people LOVED Hollyleaf in the beginning of the books, and then started just HATEING her when she killed Ashfur. I'm glad I know people in this world who like Hollyleaf. Like me. And like you. XD
Spottedheart98464 1 year ago
@Spottedheart98464
I hate that too,
But I'm one of those people who never even liked her when she was first in the series.
I was sad she killed ashfur, but i do hope she's alive.
I dunno, it's confusing...
xX13blackcatXx 1 year ago
@Spottedheart98464 not me.. she bad kitty xD
SuperShaz100 1 year ago
@SuperShaz100 LOL
Spottedheart98464 1 year ago
im not mad but sehs still hollykit for me i think im on dawn,
1996annabeth 1 year ago
I love this song and Hollyleaf <3
I KNOW she is still alive! I really know! =^.^=
VioletteEstrella 1 year ago
this is really good.
:)
i truely believe that hollyleaf is alive. cuz shes not seen in the dark forest and not seen in starclan. so... is she living in the tunnel?
JBANK29 1 year ago 50
@JBANK29 thank you! and I beleive hollyleaf is still alive, cause jayfeather diddnt 'see' hollyleaf die.. if that makes sense
thelime95 1 year ago 45
@thelime95 yes, but lion blaize did.
ILoveHawkFroat 1 year ago
@ILoveHawkFroat No,he Only saw the tunnel collapse.But that doesn't mean that Hollyleaf is dead.She couldv'e dug her way out or get out before the tunnel collapsed on her,She should appear back in ThunderClan.Soon,I hope.
Twilightfrost89 1 year ago
@thelime95 I don't see how she could possibly be alive though, because, just think. She'd have starved or something by now.
But, ya'll got a point. She wasn't seen in StarClan or the Dark Forest. *shudders* That's scary. D:
RinKagamine4Ever 1 year ago
@thelime95 They also didn't find her body!
LunaMoonRise 11 months ago
@thelime95 Hollyleaf is alive it says in Sign of the Moon when Jayfeather and Lionblaze finally decide to investegte where the rocks fell. And all they found was a tuft of fur no Hollyleaf. And then Bloosomfall and Ivypool meet her without knowing when they accidentaly get lost in the tunnels. It dosnt say its her but I just know it is oh and they also meet Fallen Leaves. So its not him, cause it said it was a different cat.
crystle4103 10 months ago
@crystle4103 I so agree!
AllyVeal 10 months ago
@thelime95 hollyleaf is alive because in the new books jayfeather and lionblaze go into the hole after another cat falls in. They find a tuft of black fur and pawprints
MegaWolflover12 10 months ago
@thelime95 i bet you in a upcoming book shes gonna be found and she was in the tunnel for her life :D
tigerclawyourownface 8 months ago
@thelime95 She isn't dead ~~ <3 I only know is that all they found was a tuft of fur, but not her body. They believe she became a rouge, but then they think about how much the Warrior Code meant to her...
Silverpetalfur 8 months ago
@thelime95 read the newest book and you'll get your answer! =)
featherwingy 8 months ago
@featherwingy what new book? CrookedStar or 4 Book of th Series?
coolbluestar1 8 months ago
@coolbluestar1 the fourth book of the series the fourth apprentice.
featherwingy 8 months ago
@thelime95 in fading echos jayfeather/lionblaze scented a dead squirrel with her scent on it
brat0502 7 months ago
@brat0502 no it had no sent on it but most people asume it's her
12Icepelt 7 months ago
@thelime95 thats true.he saw rocks fall on her but that was it
StarTheWolfPuppy 7 months ago
@thelime95 exactly plus she's seen in sign of the moon helping IceCloud and DoveWing out of the tunnels with her ginger friend......
SwagKing212 7 months ago
@thelime95 And in the fourth book (?) Blossomfall and Ivypool go in the tunnels and see a "Shadowy cat" whom helps them get out.
rainclawwarriorcat 7 months ago
@thelime95 plus...they didnt see any blood. it woulda leaked out of teh rock, right?
thunderclanliveson1 6 months ago
@JBANK29
Correct! Instead of them saying "she died" they say "gone" so she must be alive :D
VioletteEstrella 1 year ago
@JBANK29 i heard rumors shes gonna appear in next book and she IS alive the erins revealed it on the chat :D
JAMMZKATZ1O1 1 year ago
@JBANK29 i like the song..it goes good with the pics X3
dovepawXtigerheart 11 months ago
@JBANK29 : if u read fading echos they think they have a animal (or prey) with her scent on it
brat0502 11 months ago
@JBANK29 yeah but Fallen Leaves died in the tunnel and his soul was lost down there so maybe that happened to Hollyleaf. She could possibly still be alive thought and if she is Erin hunter will make a dramatatic reappearance for her xD
WebkinzLuver413 10 months ago
@JBANK29 in signs of the moon it is confirmed that she is still alive
ospreytalon5 10 months ago
@JBANK29 yupperzzz
epikhampster 9 months ago
@JBANK29 I beleive she ran away with Sol in the tunnel. . . . .and she is living well. During Night Whispers, when Jayfeather finds a tuft of her fur, she just needed a medicine. I also beleive she has many kits .3.
soulofRiverclan 8 months ago
@JBANK29 Read the newest book. :D
Viperclan2 7 months ago
@JBANK29 hollyleaf IS alive. it says that >.<
littleseezer 7 months ago
@JBANK29 She's not in the tunnels 'cause Jayfeather and Lionblaze checked there. They also found her fur in the rocks, proving she wasn't crushed, but the fur scent was stale.
TheWolves67 2 months ago
nice job :3
Shadowtiger50 1 year ago