Added: 3 years ago
From: breckbone
Views: 53,304
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (224)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Don't do that again.

  • Who taught you..?

  • HAHAHAHAHHAHAHA this is just wonderful ! Fantastic Job !

  • And to make things worse -- it is an octave too low!

  • ...... teach me please

  • wonderful tone, great dynamic and phrasing!

  • Maurice Ravel just turned in his grave...., and I think she popped something with all that pressure..........

  • lowut

  • The only thing worse then I bad musician is a bad musician that doesn't know he/she is bad.

  • @joeVARADI And what's worse than that? An ignorant jerk that can't recognize a joke when it's right in front of him. Do a little research bro, think before you speak/type. It'll prevent future embarrassment.

  • @thelbronius lol I get it now! ha ha ha ha! funny joke ;)

  • Normally, I give words of encouragment when I hear a fellow trombonist struggling with a peice. Well...

  • Well at least her embouchure was ok

  • I see now, you actually stink.

  • OMGGGG I"M CRYINGG HAHAHA i laughed sooo hardddddd!!! Bad trombone playing is one of the funniest things EVER!!

  • I always believed that the hardest aspect of this excerpt isn't actually the "high notes", but keeping a great sense of internal pulse down to the 16th note. Bravo - flawless time!

  • Amazing!

  • That was painful to hear......

  • On second thought I take tht back.. It was actually pretty funny, but sometimes people are trying to hear how the song/piece actually sounds... There's nothing wrong with making a parody, but some people just wanna get an idea of how it reall sounds

  • Oh....this...is just ABUSE......

  • .............

  • Oh god. This is disguisting. A little part of me died on the inside :'(

  • gay joke lame and gay

  • just discasting...horrible....

    

  • poor trombone...

  • i am going to walk around with my trombone and feel good about myself

  • the musicallity is amazing, pure stroke of genious to play an octave lower! The melody really comes to light then :)

  • HAHA! I LOVE THIS! It made me giggle uncontrollably!

    Before posting a comment please consider the following. Is this supposed to be taken seriously? Will I look like a jackass for critiquing something that is obviously meant to be funny?

    Several people have already confirmed that they are lacking in social skills, please, please...PLEASE!! don't add to it.

    p.s. To both Mulcahys, thanks! p.s. I read a few good articles Holly wrote, many thanks.

  • What a dreadful noise how on earth can anyone listen to this, out of tune / about the worst I have ever heard total crap.!

  • sou bad !!

  • This has to be a joke you're not even getting your slide right in this video. I couldn't even watch it for more than 15 seconds lol.

  • Failblog needs to visit here and title "Trombone Fail"

  • Dear Mr. Mulcahy (if I am correct in my assumption that you are indeed Craig Mulcahy): the video is awesome. the comments are even better!

  • Fail. LOL

  • Man, everyone realizes that this is comedy, right...?

    Whatever, I dig it. I'm tired of being expected to play this 20 times in a row without making a mistake.

  • thumbs up if you used this guys fingerings to play it

  • Time for tips. Open up. Use almost no pressure from you mouth and mouth piece, looks like your pressing to hard. DO LIPSLURES... I can't stress how important Thoes are. As far as tone goes it will take time. Play middle F to B flat going down in half note and returning to F. This will help tone.

  • Comment removed

  • trop nul, j'aurais honte de me mettre sur youtube avec un son pareil

  • STOOOOOOOOOP POOOOOOOSTIIIIIIIIIIIIIING THIIIIIIIS SHIIIIIIIIT.

  • Is that a Shires Eastman????!!!!!

  • go girl... love it, so funny! would love to see you play in a section of similar standard players playing by numbers! tannhauser or ride of the valkyries!

  • YOU FUCKING SUCK

  • damn I get the joke but lol thats disgraceful

  • man i just started playing trombone and i even sound better :/

  • Proof that you can actually find funny videos on youtube.

  • I just wanted to trow a rock to his head to get that trombone and play that shit!

    Jesus what a disgrace...

  • she like trombone, have a nice ear, and is very fresh (at all practicing) il like it

  • horrible vaya mierdaaaaaaa

  • ひどいな

  • this sucked

  • WTF u doin lady? Jus Letting go of the slide at the end. That's a good way to damage a good instrument.

  • @Danktank091293 Come on you've got to have a sense of humor. It sucks big time but it's funny. She's obviouly not a trombone player!

  • Absolutely stunning!  I cried listening to this!

  • what's a shame

  • ouch lol

  • ouch lol 

  • I like how when people are just honest and straightforward and can realize that this is most likely a joke, you come back with the harsh replies. Grow up and stop being a hypocrite. We get it, you're trying to be funny with this video and your responses by acting serious, but it's not! You're just embarrassing yourself and wasting people's time. Congratulations. I look forward to a great, classic response with tons of good points about how I am such a terrible person.

  • ... this reminds me of the worste french horn player video. lol I'm not sure if this is an insult or what... but it made me laugh.

  • Comment removed

  • I hope to dear God that you are not actually being fucking serious....

  • I was hoping that you would attempt to play it in the appropriate octave, that would have been amusing.

  • I applaud you for having the guts to play an instrument that's not your primary instrument, especially one in a completely different family! You sound way better than I could sound on trombone. It's quite entertaining :)

  • lolz i love how everyone hates this. if shes just begining then u were no better than her once so just leave people alone ffs

  • I love it.

  • what the heck!!

  • I haven't played my trombone in two years and I could play it better than this...

  • Joke or not, please go play another instrument before insulting ours. Trumpet?

  • Best thing ever.

  • You truly suck! LOL

  • yo breckbone...im pretty sure i messaged you a while back but i have a few questions for you. 1 how long have you been playing? 2. Is this your principle instrument? 3. whos trombone is that and what type looks like a back 42 bo which is what i play.4. what are u recording on? Im assuming this is for a college class or something. either way if you are new to the trombone id like for you to keep playing its a great pasttime and im sure you'd enjoy it....keep posting vid's of your improvement!!!

  • First I want to apologize on behalf of the vast majority of my fellow trombonists. Trombonists for the most part are very much elitists and judgmental and hate anyone who so "disgraces" their sacred instrument.

    I do hold a genuine respect for the Trombone, myself, but I am far from holding it "sacred". I have a Bible for that. I do however respect that the trombone is almost the epitome of the evolutionary peak of wind instruments.

    I thought it was funny, myself, with the intro and whatnot : D

  • uhm u play tormbone?

  • que esterco

  • no se puede tokar peor

  • My friend told me she is a violinist and if she is then she's awsome at trombone for not ever having used her lips to play any instrument lol

  • At least you didn't quit. ??

  • Wow... What the hell was that? I would write more, but I see you have another video. Let's hope it's better. Talk to you soon!

  • k asco por dios!!!!

  • Honestly, I'm offended. You should post a formal video with your apology and announcement that you'll never touch a trombone again. 

  • ma'am ive been playing trombone 70% of my life. I know good trombone playing when i hear it. I don't see your video as being real impressive. I would put money on me being able to sight read this excerpt. Not demanding at all. I suggest finding another hobby.

  • She is a string player. Relax guys. It is musicians having fun. It is funny. :) thanks for the humor. :)

  • Damn that tree line in the rocky mountains must smell like shit,That was just horrible.I respect the effort though

  • I'm 12 and what is this?

  • Maybe embarrass yourself in the privacy of your home instead of online where thousands of people can say "Dumbasses"

  • @CrazyRobotsRock7

    Way to pluralize "dumbass", dumbass.

  • @breckbone because there is more than one dumbass? DEH

  • @CrazyRobotsRock7 MICHAEL Mulcahy is the trombonist in the chicago symphony, This is like his sister or his niece or something. She's a violinist. Its supposed to be funny.

  • haha xD im sorry lol, you havent played trombone for a long time have you :P thats ok, this is a really hard solo. you just have to take it up another octive and take out the pauses

  • question, do u know when ur making a good sound, or r u just plain deaf

  • u have still to praktice

  • You go, girl!!

  • Dude this girl sucks

  • im in seventh grade and im better than u

  • a demonstration of one of the most demanding trombone excerpts in the orchestral repertoire <------ jajajajajajaja! ese titulo

  • i'm sorry, that is horrible though.

  • Bravo!!! I think I have seen that horn before:-P Trombone playing must run in your family.

  • why would she do this?!

  • ummm are you serious? is this a joke? this has to be.

  • ima beginner trombone and i no this was really bad try again

  • you poor thing. i have been playing bone for a year and a half now. i am first chair. i am sorry. but that was bad

  • jus terrible favorite part when it was ova

  • This is very good. You are ready for the circus.

  • HAHAHA fantastic

  • @rock27863 Hahaha best joke ive heard today. that was a good one XD

  • whos horn are you borrowing?

  • I am sorry but you should stick with violin. P.S. learn your notes; don't mark every single note because you wont know how high the pitch is. I would go on and on but I don't want to be even more rude.

  • 何ですかこれwwwwwwwwww

    馬路ないわ、ノイズもやばいしw((爆

    これを吹く前に基礎練習しなさい^^

    あと、テンポ落とせwww

    馬路、びびったwwwww

  • Dear friend, your remarks make me laugh very hard... ^_^

  • Yay, I think Mike should have played the snare drum part. Then it would be complete. Just remember, if you start to pass out.... save the horn!

  • Your playing is magical to me, I would love for you to join our symphony. This is the sweetest sounding, most beautiful music I've heard in 10 years.

  • Comment removed

  • All of you are acting like that was legit. Obviously it was meant as a joke, get off your high rods. Is that the wife or daughter of Michael Mulcahy? He's the second trombone with the Chicago Symphony.

  • Comment removed

  • Lighten up folks. Have some fun in life.

  • For those who don't know she is a violinist with the Chicago symphony!!!

  • U diagrace the trombone name

  • @hi4242

    You disgrace the English language.

  • @breckbone Ma'am, I think English is the only thing that you can do normally.

  • I was expecting something awesome after that announcement and then.....my ears started bleeding.

  • did she have to write the positions out? im in 7th grade and... well.. thats sorta pathetic

  • @phebster878787 i am in 7th grade too and i agree with you

  • @phebster878787 i play better than you though

  • Comment removed

  • @ TheJazzyTrombone uh excuse me? how the helllll would you know how i play? u need to get a life and quit being so full of yourself! jeezz ! THINK BEFORE YOU TYPE!

  • @phebster878787 sorry!

  • anda hijaaa!! dedicate a otra cosaaa =SS

  • Bravo!

  • Clearly, one of the best renditions availalbe on YouTube. Benchmark quality!

  • Holly, you and Miranda should do a duet! Or at least have her open your videos with "Haters, back off!" ;)

  • what the heck is wrong with this player...... just hurts my ears...

  • LOL.

  • I'm sorry. But being a trombonist myself this is nearly pathetic. You shouldn't try music of this difficulty until you can make a good sound. This was truely awful...

  • You're an idiot...... We don't need any Debbie Downers or Negative Nancys. Get a life.

  • I'm sorry but it's true. Tone quality is no where near where it should be to play a piece of such difficulty.

  • garoher clearly doesnt speak english

  • that sounds like crap! i play trumpet way better than she plays her trombone,by the way i hate trombones.

  • Spoken like a true trumpet player aubdog9

  • Will you marry me ?

    i play trumpet almost as well as you play trombone.

  • no suban idioteses suban algo k valga la pena!!!

  • do u speak english?

  • get a sense of humour some of you!... funniest thing I've seen for a long time!! Brilliant!

  • you're awesome, good job!

  • what the hell, that's an insult to the trombone

  • @70mile You can't possibly take this video seriously. If there's one thing I've learned from spending half of my life around trombonists its that those who only care about the trombone and nothing else have no sense of humor, or a very distorted one in the least.

  • you hurt the music a lot

  • DAAAAAAAAAAAAMMMMMMMMMMMNNNNNN­NNNNNN! Go to Europe to take some lessons, well worth it

  • You must be relaxed to play!

  • You've to study!

  • agggggggggggg!

  • hahaha this is sooo fugly!! But I 5* you because you really made me laugh!!!

  • wow......not good

  • Where she learnt to play the trombone like this. It's horrible!

  • i so hope that this is a joke.....this is absolutely horrible......she is going to musical hell for this...ravel is turning in his grave as i type

  • Mulcahy would be pissed. haha

  • which Mulcahy?

  • Which Mulcahy?

  • Hold on while i go cut myself.

  • i did not know i could be moved in this way by someone playing a trombone until tonight

  • wow part of me just died on the inside....

  • I think this is some funny S***! You've got to have a sense of humor, for crying out loud!!

  • le sale muy mal , pero al menos lo intenta y si sigue practicando lo va a lograr , eso va para los que solo critican y no saben nada de musica y perseverancia

  • You stupid dumbasses, this is obviously a joke. To all the trombone "players" who took this seriously, it is time to get your stupid ass out of the practice room, comb your hair, start using deodorant, and learn to socialize a bit. The fact that you thought this was serious PROVES you are a RETARDED TROMBONE PLAYER!

  • Typical trumpet player that you are. LOL

  • You either think your the shit or your just trying to make fun of the trombone.

  • You're obviously not a trombonist. This is an example of top-notch orchestral trombone playing. Perhaps you're just not used to hearing it without the music?

  • Lmao, this is hilarious. Good job ;)

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @breckbone Nah, you just can't play this. 

  • where can i find this sheet music for trombone? I want to play it but mine will sound more like Joseph Alessi!