Added: 5 years ago
From: emokid627
Views: 85,568
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (224)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i honestly think that Cantrell should have just taken lead vocals. he's really good.

  • STFU Layne is the best, but face the fact that he died almost 9 years ago. True AIC fans would support them even today, unless you were just Layne Staley fans that don't give a fuck about Starr, Cantrell, Kinney, DuVall, & Inez. If you don't like it, why don't you get off your asses and try to sing Layne's songs, which some of you could, I know there were better choices than William, but get the fuck over it. Scott Weiland declined for the memory of Layne. I'm at least glad they are still here.

  • Why is everyone so fucking negative on DuVall? Layne wouldnt want AIC to just be sad all the time over his death. You "Fans" need to stop talking shit and just start jumping for joy Cause AIC IS FUCKING BACK AND STILL KICKING ASS

  • Just saw AIC recently in Boston, Ma. Truly amazing. I knew Jerry would just crush live...and he did. William, was not only a great performer, but vocally on all the tunes...he just ruled...old and new. I was blown away, seriously. I've been a huge fan and follower of AIC, and Jerry's solo stuff...and this is AIC. Yah, Layne is missed, but William just crushes all the songs. He was amazing. It's nice to see Jerryy so happy on stage. He has always been a huge influence to me. Always will be.

  • Hey we play our own acoustic songs in a little Nirvana/Seether/AIC style.Feel free to check us out.

    Its worth for the non haters :)

    peace

  • i swear, what was wierd bout that nite, was that my bro and i were 26, and we were by far the oldest people there. 90% of em were in their teens it seemed..strange

  • Hey people in the front row... here is Cantrell's package.

  • @MeowChef no shit!! the famous JC log..lmao

  • YES!!!!!! THATS ME!!! Excuse me, im hype lol. at 20 sec, im the guy right up in jerrys crotch, smiling ALOT, with big 4head and really short hair. (im straight, but def gay for jerry LMAO) some dude hit me in back of head at like 30sec lol.......thanks for putting this clip up! that was my 1st time in L.A. and i was seeing AIC! Fuckn HEAVEN! Thanks again

  • cantrell is god!!!!

  • FUCK ALL YOU BITCHES. If You don't like the new line up stop watching their fucking video you trolls. Get off Layne's dick, the guy's been dead for over a decade

  • I don't think that they are trying to replace layne. but move on. I think they sound great!

  • So, your saying that because Layne isn't around anymore that AIC is dead? what about Cantrell? It's sad to see people discredit AIC because Layne isn't around..... Yes he was an amazing singer but he wasn't the only person in the band with talent guys..

  • in my opinion .. aic ..without layne ... is just a piece of shit ... no matter what you people say .. about this new guy .. or how good .. or equal to layne he can sing ... layne ! was the band .. he made it .. and when he died .. the band died with him ..

  • @pilotseason. Did you ever stop to think about who wrote the music that you hear in ALL AIC work? Yeah, that would be Jerry. Jerry also sung almost every single song to complete that distinct tone you recognize. Layne was the voice that screamed and carried their name into the ages, but Jerry was the mastermind behind the scenes. You still have three major elements to Alice in Chains, Sean, Mike, and Jerry. Did you have a problem with the dog album? That was mostly Jerry, Sean, and Mike.

  • @pilotseason hey moron, can u try to picture AIC singing lets say 'your decision' with layne? It would pretty much sound almost identical to Jerry singing, and bill doing the highs like he does.Fuckin wake up and realize that Layne is not coming back and is probably laughing at you morons for even discussing this shit. Listen to it or dont, but shut the fuck up already.Now..who wants lemonade?

  • It's not AIC without Layne, people need to stop pretending it is.

    Just like If it had been Jerry who died. It wouldn't have been the same.

    Layne and Jerry were the heart of the band. Now that there not together, the music has lost it''s power and meaning.

  • lol thats not true, maybe in your opinion but i can see a lot of people disagreeing with you there.

  • AIC is a band not a singer.

  • @Wesson4. No one is pretending it's AIC, it is AIC!!! If Jerry Sean and Mike is not AIC, then I dont know what is. Do you remember Layne playing guitar on every song? Oh wait no, that was Jerry. And still is Jerry. I'm not dogging on Layne, by any means, but you have to know, AIC was Jerry and Seans band that they coaxed Layne into joining eventually. Layne was the most badass singer to ever come out of Seattle, but Jerry is a genious when it comes to Alice's sound. I would rather hear them bro!

  • @PezoCon I would rather hear them without Duvall. Duvall blows. Also stop pretending that Jerry wrote everything, He obvisouly contributed alot. But don't try to down play Layne's contributions.

    FUCKING HELL!!! If it wasn't for Layne who knows even if a Jerry Cantrell emerges. Don't forget Layne was the one who gave him a place to live, and introduced him to Sean.

    Hence why so many people are pissed that there continuing on as AIC.. like Layne was just another dead singer.

  • @PezoCon I don't think a slight name change would be too much to ask for... Fuck call yourselves

    "CHains" or "ALICE"

    But don't try to act like your AIC from the 90's cause your not

  • fuck you layne was cool as hell duvill is just ok, aic ,can go on but its not the same aic but its good as long ass duvill stayes off staleys turf and does his own stuff, so far i love the cd, but i wont go to a concert due to laynes death ,to hard to hear the songs, hands down on the album , id like to see three singers in with them, get travis up their from days of the new

  • You know what I think, I say jeremiahaticf should kill himself worthless fuck head. No respect fuckin dirt bag.

  • I believe Cantrel wrote all or most of the old stuff anyway. Obviously the band wanted the same sound. The album is killer. I hope they rock the ß˙ˆ† out of the music scene.  I don't know about you guys, but I am tired of rock groups that only girls really like and guys are forced to listen to. ;-)

  • @dropnbeatz... not sure why your getting thumbs down, i agree with ur comment

  • Dude, vocalist dies, they get a new vocalist who sounds just like the old one. Who cares? The music still follows the Alice in Chains brand so what's the problem? Dude would still be alive if he didn't party too much anyway so he can't handle his partying and he's dead. New singer, big fuckin deal, it still sounds good doesn't it? I hate it when people are like "Aww it's not him, fuck this!" and don't even give the music a chance just because it's a new person singing. Sounds good to me!!

  • i love layne... but cantrel is a big part of alice in chains... then alice in chains are alice in chains with or without layne!

  • yup.. all i hear is Jerry killing it on the guitar..

    Jerry should a just taken over as lead singer also..

  • YOU are WRONG!!! Atayley was a heroin addicted loser!!! I respect him as a vocalist but despised him as a human. He brought the band down and prevented them from successfully touring.The problem is MOST people can't be objective about anything.

  • No, the problem is that people like you are judge mental morons. Let me guess, your favorite band is Shitallicka!

  • I KNOW that wasn't directed towards me. Let me just add that the fact that I've never been a drug user DOES NOT make me a judgmental person. And the last 5 things I listened to was Kalmah, Iron Maiden, My Dying Bride, Job For A Cowboy and Jerry Cantrell....so NO Metallica is not the icing on MY Metal cake.

  • Seriously? At one point Jerry was handling most of the singing himself and they were at the top of their game. Layne was NOT the group. New stuff kicks ass.

  • @bloodglutton, hell yah dude... glad other people realize this and point this fact out... Jerry doesnt get the credit he deserves from the layne lovers.. (no disrespect to layne)

  • you all are fucking brain damaged. The new singer w/ cantrell sounds identical to layne. Have u heard the new single "check my brain"?? You would do well to follow the titles advice.

  • Fuck this....

    they should change name or something....

    R.I.P Layne

  • They should replace the drummer with an illegal alien and the bassist with a wheelchair-bound transvestite.

  • Is that the same Layne's mom who left her son to rot away? Yeah, I trust her wisdom in this matter.

  • Well the new album has gotten Layne's own mother's stamp of approval...I guess AIC and Layne's mom don't know whats best for the band and it's name...a bunch cyberdorks who spend their lives arguing on YouTube do.

    Hmm...

  • just think

    was layne 100% of AIC's vocals?

    Was there another half of the singing in AIC?

    If you listen to an old AIC song can you actually distinguish the Layne and Jerry's voiced?

    my guess is no

    So in my opinion layne was not the entire band like most of the super AIC fans think

    There were 3 other band members other than layne just because he's gone that doesnt mean they should have to change the name

    Did Metallica change their name when Dave Mustaine or Jason Newstead left or when cliff died?

  • sorry buddy,.,,,,, listen to the guitarist talk about lanes voice

  • While it wasn't 100% of the vocals, it was 100% of what mattered in the vocals. You could replace Jerry Cantrell a lot easier than they are trying to replace Layne.

  • well at least the music is still good...

  • CoonVall blows so many balls, he doesn't even know it.

    His voice already sucks, and now he's trying to get a little cheese element in his voice. What an ass.

    AIC should've broken up after Unplugged, or at least for post-Layne they should've used Scott Weiland or even Corey Taylor (whom I'm not a big fan of). I listened to AIC with both of those guys, and they sounded much better than this crackhead nigfag.

  • u know, calling him a nigfag isnt gonna make him leave aic. theres black fans out there u know, i happen to be one, so just keep those comments to urself.

  • well listen to what he said, but not all the stupid racism. his point is alice in chains should have broken up for good after layne died(which i agree with) or got another singer. they had too great of music, and should have went out on top.

  • have you heard the new single. im not saying that it lives up to the old stuff, but its actually pretty good. duvall impressed me with it.

  • I happen to be a black fan a well, and I loved Layne vocal stylings, but I have accepted the fact that he is dead and whoever Jerry and the rest of the band have selected is who the front man is going to be. No matter who fans say should be the singer or how they express their disdain over it being Duvall.

  • gross comment.

  • I agree.

  • Well i'm glad he doesn't sound exactly like Layne, If sounded just like Layne then everyone would be pissed and call him a poser and shit, they should just be a different band. Just change the name!

    Easy solution. right?

  • Comment removed

  • Hey innocentinnocentx,

    if you'd open your ears (and mind) instead of your mouth you might not sound like such an idiot. It's time you moved out of mommy's basement....

  • get a life u racist pig. layne aint coming back. move on

  • how many bands can scott weiland be in? I don't see what the big deal is. Of course he's not going to sound just like layne, he's not layne and if the guys in alice in chains like him who are we to say anything about him. but that's just my opinion. don't reply and like curse at me and freak out.

  • Everyone talking shit about Layne need to take their heads outta their asses, even being a heroin addict, he was 10 times the person any of you pieces of shit are. If any of you die on heroin tommorow nobody would give a shit. When Layne died the music world took a hit.

  • not rly dude

  • That sounded like shit, they better get back on the Horse! haha.

  • No layne no chains

  • love this band....hope they coome to portland oregon soon

  • I heard Jerry's song on the Twisted Willy comp before he put his first solo one out, I remember thinking, "if he puts out a solo album and it sounds this sincere, I hope the production values and the lyrics are NEW." But I feel the two solo albums are very "inside the box". Not the most corporate things in the world, but it seems more an exercise in telling me how to feel than letting me explore. Re-mystify the experience, guys. And Layne didn't do only ONE record with y'all - change the name.

  • Agree 100%. I don't see any reason other than greed to keep the name.

  • did u guys see hurts online show they did with alice in chains j loren even sang for alice he did great even sounded like alice in chains live they should nogotiate a deal with loren to have him sing for both hurt and alice in chains

  • Call me stupid,an idiot,even moron. But I have always had more compassion for a junkie than a pure azzhole.

  • The words of Sean Kinney:

    "If we found some other dude, I'd love to move on, write some cool tunes and change the name and go on like that. I don't see continuing as Alice and replacing somebodyWe're not trying to replace Layne. We want to play these songs one more time, and if it seems like the right thing to do, it'll happen. I don't know how long it will go or where it will take us. It's kind of a tribute to Layne and our fans, the people who love these songs".

  • I'm sick of seeing you pricks talking shit on Layne... have you ever used heroin? Do you have any fucking idea how difficult it is to break that habit? Of course you don't.

    As for AIC and Duvall? They're mutually exclusive, as far as I'm concerned: they can keep the name, and adopt a new singer, but it won't be enough.

  • this is TOTALLY off subject but I think psychedlic music needs to be brought back band like kay kay and his wethered underground and shit

    ...just sayin

  • MISS YOU LAYNE. Its just not the same. If you ask me Jerry should just sing. Layne is gone but the band is alive.

  • Some of you are insane. You have no say, or right to decide what happens with AIC. No one is replacing Layne as he KILLED himself and left the band hanging. He wasn't removed, so replacing isn't the word you're looking for. They have every right to continue in whatever way they want. It's THEIR music, not YOURS. Listen, or don't.

  • hey everybody! take it from Kronical69420! he has so many cool stoner references in his name! he's probably the type of loser that thought it was better to get a 69 (fail) on a test than a 75. me, well i was always up in the 90's so he can suck my ass. anyway.. you think Layne's big problem was his heroin addiction? i highly doubt he would say that. he was addicted to heroin for one reason: relief. depression is a terrible thing... mix it with drugs and its unbearable. try that for a decade..

  • I miss your Layne Staley

  • As a former heroin addict, it pisses me off that they have William Duvall singing Layne's heart felt songs, when this guy has never done anything other than alcohol, pot, and cocaine. I wouldn't have a problem if they called themselves something else, but they shouldn't still be called AIC because AIC died in 96.

    If they want to call themselves AIC then they shouldn't have one exclusive singer because Layne is irreplaceable. They should have guest singers such as fans and other musicians.

  • congrats! youre a fuckin junkhead! you want a fucking medal?

  • no one said that they were trying to replace layne, they just want to keep on playin dude

  • so lemme get this straight. the new singer has to be a junkie to be in the band?

    thats fucking retarded, how many brain cells did you kill shooting dope?

  • cannabisruderalis, your opinion is irrelevant as you are a junkie. Whilst I appreciate Staley and was a huge fan, he decided to waste it all and end his life. IT WAS NO TRAGEDY, IT WAS NO ACCIDENT. This is what happens when you are a junkie. Once a junkie, always a junkie. Good on AIC for reuniting. Good on Duvall for having the balls to step into Layne's shoes. Can't wait to see 'em next month in Sydney!

  • You have no idea what you're talking about with regards to "once a junkie, always a junkie" people can come back from the disease of addiction. I'm living proof, 3 years clean. The problem with heroin is the withdrawl is worse than the sickness, and some would rather die than go through with it.

  • Congrats man, ive been clean for a year and a half now. It's a tough road...

  • you're a fucking idiot. Why don't you actually LEARN about something before you run your mouth? Have you ever been addicted to heroin? No. Do you know anyone addicted? No. (if you did, you wouldn't sound so pathetically fucking stupid)

  • Jerry Cantrell is a good singer on his own why thea need a new singer just use him fuck the new guy

  • Yeah I agree!

  • All dumbasses.

  • Get him off the stage. The only way I could ever accept this travesty is if this guy has had to battle a heroine addiction for at least a decade . Then he would maybe understand where Layne was coming from. The only person I could ever see singing for this band would be Scott Weiland. That would be sweet.

  • The smartest thing the band could've done was to do a tribute type album in Layne's memory using guest vocalists. By coming out and saying this Duvall person is our one, permanent singer - THEE singer - it comes across as disrespectful, not mention crazy.

  • Yeah...i caught them on their first tour. He sounded exactly like Layne at some parts, but other parts he sounded like himself but not bad. It helped alot that Jerry sang along with him during alot of the songs. It would have sounded so much better if the pulled some guy from an AIC tribute band that sounded like Layne, then went with this guy after

  • guitar sounds a little like Kim Thayil

  • Nice clip, although I couldn't really hear much of the new singer. However I would go to the concert JUST TO HEAR THAT GUITAR!

  • Okay, for one, a TRUE AIC fan would stay TRUE to the ORIGINAL BAND MEMBERS. Jesus H. Christ... How many people are gonna argue over this shnit and why does it make a damn? I firmly believe that Mark Lanegan from The Screaming Trees would have made a better replacement.

  • chester from linkin park are u fucking serous??!! fuckin fag haha r.i.p layne

  • hey it does'nt matter if you like it or dont cause at the end of the day a true AIC fan gives it a FUKKING chance ... you guys are too stuck in the past people are moving foward the fukking future... AIC will always own with me FUKK THE REST :)

  • Your a idiot. Linkin Park sucks btw. Layne won't be replaced. Just like Kurt wouldn't be able to be replaced in nirvana.

    Thats like saying have Chester sing for MetallicA.

  • yeah sure that is totttaly correct but what does that have do with now... they have to have a lead singer to progress .. i dont understand what your arguing about.. it's about singing not linkin park or metallica.. but have a nice day tho :)

  • Kill yourself for even thinking that let alone showing the world.

  • thanks :)

  • BYE the way i show the world what i please !!! :0

  • and thats why no one likes you bitch ass

  • yeah--- change the name. its really disrespectful. its like putting lipstick on a pig. it pisses me off--cont get me wrong, i wanna hear new stuff from the guys-- but not under the AIC name and not covers of the old stuff-- START OVER.

  • Do the respectful thing... change the name of the band... keeping the AIC name is a disgrace. Keep the same guys, play the old tunes, fine, but AIC was Layne.

  • I agree completely aic6702. I look at it the same if nirvana had a new singer. FUCK THAT. Period. AIC will never be the same without Layne.

  • 100% agreed,AIC died with Layne,end of!

  • AIC will release a new album soon and those of you who will buy it, sincerely from my heart, I hope you'll get raped then thrown in front of a bus. Hopefully your skulls smash so there is no way of restoration for the funeral. Close casket case here, man.

  • no one cares shove it in your ass.. i love jerry just as much as layne i wanna here new stuff from the guys... layne wasted ten years of thier lives...i think they deserve to go on and make new music and thier gonna do it no matter what you say so shove it

  • You're a fucking moron.

    It's a band. It's not that serious.

    YES! It fucking sucks that they're going on without Layne and I really wish they would shut the band down, but does that really call for asinine threats on YouTube? Get a life. Please.

    Why don't YOU go kill YOUR dumb, over-reactive self for being such a pretentious moron.

  • "It's not that serious" Have you ever listened to music you ass? Maybe music isn't as important to you as it is to me, but shut up and try to understand me.

    Yes, anyone singing AIC's songs who aren't Layne ought to die for even attempting let alone join the band.

    I'm reactive enough and I'm far from pretentious girlfriend...

  • Oh, I'd agree music is quite serious.

    But worth wishing people death over just for buying an album with members of a band they love? No. They're supporting a group they like. Why should they be faulted for that? I fucking love Alice in Chains and hate the new singer but I'm willing to support my favourite band. It's fine to disagree but when you become hateful about it you just look like an idiot.

    Your comment was a completely rude, frivolous, and intelligence-devoid statement.

  • Buying all the old albums by them is completely the right thing to do, but will you buy their new album? In all of their songs Layne sang at least a small part, but every song. To hear any song by them with DuVall singing would utterly ruin the song, it's not Layne. Say, would you still listen if Cantrell died too,and the band replaced him with some mediocre guitar player? When DuVall sings about some other man's experience that he had nothing to do with, how real does it feel?

  • Yes, I will buy their new album. Why should the rest of the band have to suffer because of an event they had no control over? If they'd simply change the name of the band I probably wouldn't be so angry about it, but oh well. It is what it is.

    All I'm saying is if that's your decision not to buy their album then fine, that's your choice. But it's dumb to put down other people just for wanting to hear a band they enjoy.

    And I like Courtney's voice more than Kurt's anyway. But I get your point.

  • Another reason the new album will suck: Jerry can't write a great song without Layne in the band; Layne was his muse and vice versa, although Layne could write kickass lyrics without Cantrell (Above 1995). I don't think any of Cantrell's solo songs are good, no great riffs, no supreme solos. And all the band members have changed so much now, they are not the same persons they were in the 90s. Final question: Would you still listen to Nirvana with Courtney Love, Grohl and Novoselic?

  • AND WTF?!

    Jerry writes great music by himself.

    So I don't know what the hell you're talking about.

  • i think that the band - the creators of the music (who were friends, partners, & comrades with Layne) - should be able to make their own choices with their own music...

  • And I know DuVall will NEVER come close to Layne. He's fucking annoying and has the worst stage presence ever. I actually hate the new singer. But I just want to hear AIC play ONE more time. Even if Layne isn't going to be taking part of it. Jerry, Sean, and Mike are just as much part of AIC as Layne was.

    And I'm not saying continuing with the band is fucked up. I'm just saying nothing can be done about it, so I'd rather give them a chance before completely writing off my favourite musicians.

  • Typo! I meant to say: And I'm not saying continuing with the band ISN'T fucked up.

  • How can you people wanna see AIC live after the death of Layne? It's not the same. This new singer hasn't had the same experiences as Layne, how the fuck can he sing stuff that Layne wrote? That is no better than stealing someone's identity cause lot of lyrics were written in 1st person singular. If the band now wanna go on without Layne, can't they just change their name and never play old AIC songs again? AIC live in the 21st century is as wrong as it gets. Or instrumental sets perhaps?

  • No Layne....No AIC T_T

  • Agreed. They need to change the fucking name or stop touring. As much as I like Sean, Jerry, and Mike, I will never buy a new album with a new singer if they release one.

  • At least, Jerry should had thought: "Would?"

  • Who the fuck invited fuckin Lenny Kravitz to my favorite band? It's an insult. Jerry should and AIC should do their own job. Don't they understand we died with Layne?

  • GOOD GOD, Duvall, PLEASE put your fucking shirt back on!

    I tried getting used to his voice & watched lots of videos of him singing but he still sucks, in my opinion. His voice breaks every time he tries to tackle their songs. It's awful!

    Maybe on the new stuff he'll do better. I'll buy the album but if it sucks I'm selling it back. I'm sure the music will be amazing, because the band's still there, but Will's voice is too weak and I just don't know how they're going to make it sound good.

  • i was actually at this show and i thought the lead singer was pretty damn good. he sounded like Layne and looked like Lenny nice combo it's all about Jerry anyhow long live Alice.

    THANKS for posting emo.

  • I can understand they want to still play the music, but this guy just doesnt do any justice to layne.

  • layne stanley is sooo waayy better/

    Rip layne.

  • this singer sucks

  • i can definitely say i like the original Alice in Chains Better...Layne's voice cant be replaced when it comes to this band.

  • fuck the new aic i miss layne and yall probly think this is better fuck yall

  • the man it's like lenny kravitz!!!

    That's shit!!

  • i honestly see no resemblance between him and lenny kravitz aside from htem being light skinned black men,hes a great singer I personally think it would be like bringing soundgarden back with another singer,it just cant be done,a band should know when to hang it up

  • its all about Jerry

  • look I still love this band I'm just saying change the name.

    It should be common sense when you lose a part of the original formula.

    Good camera angle by the way.

  • not the same as they once were

  • fuck this new aic bullshit. not the same no mo. maybe they should keep this new singer so that layne can rise from the dead and get on stage and kick duvall in his little balls. maybe then duvall would hit the right notes.

  • layne was the man for alice in chains no one sings like him what a star what a voice the songs last the test of time r i p layne

  • great song. I Love (the band) Hate (the singer) but Love (the band).

    Check my covers of Alice in Chains at my profile

  • I think there's no point arguing about who was the heart and soul of AIC, because it is really the combination. I mean look at Mad Season, it's very good, but not the same thing as AIC. The same goes for Jerry and his solo stuff. Now the both of them together, that was the shit.The same goes for McCarteny and Lennon, the combination was the real thing, I think most bands are about the chemistry between members.

  • nice to hear someone else put it like that

  • The music of alice in chains was and still is amazing. to match two magnificent voices harmonize together like layne and jerry. Unfortunately layne is now dead gone. Look at all of alice in chains accomlishments. they gained respect to so many people. I love there music and am influenced by layne jerry mike and the bass player can't remeber his name but anyway, theres no whos better than who. who wrote more songs, who cares. the org.AIC is dead. but the new alice in chains is beginning. RIPLS

  • Mike is the Bassist, Mike Inez. The Drummer is Sean Kinney.

  • first of all, without JERRY the world would have never known the name Layne Staley. OF COURSE he was the best because people like that will never, ever be again; only imitated. there will never be another Cobain, Hendrix, Lennon, Layne, etc... get over it people, they're DEAD. they were who they were and that is why the world loved them, but they will forever be etched in music history for a reason: NO ONE is like them. i am thankful for that although i am sad that they all are no more...

  • Ugh why even bother

  • odviously layne was better. i saw them in concert in the summer though and they were incredible. AIC is my favorite band Layne was the heart and soul of the band but they are still insane. Gods of Grunge

  • Layne was amazing but Jerry was and still is the heart and soul of Alice in Chains.

  • Without Layne, you wouldn't even know the name Alice in chains. Get a clue.

  • Wrong.

  • Layne was the reason for the name 'AIC' true, but Jerry was the main writing force in the band - I got the damn CDs right in front of me!!

  • The band got better and better as Jerry wrote less and less. Layne, Sean, and the Mikes had their fair share of writing, as well, and the band would not be the same without all four of them.

    The band would not have been the same at all with a different singer, that's for sure.

  • i hate that fucking nigger

  • no; you hate the fact that you don't have the balls of a gay guy to finally come out of the closet, you lunatic ass-pussy joke of a half human. your skank mom should have gone through with the abortion because doing it halfway REALLY fucked you up. LMFAO@U!!!

  • dudes Alice in Chains dosent feel or sounds right...Layne was the soul of the band

  • Jerry, Sean, and Mike have every right to move on and continue as a band with Jerry or someone else on lead vocals. But they should do it under a different name and put AIC to rest along with Layne.

  • can't be arsed to read all the fraff below but i can guess the argument... this guy is in effect just some dude, could be me or you. layne was absolutely unique, u noes it, what's the point of them even touring all the old stuff, i want layne, come home layne.

    unless they come out with some killer new stuff i wouldn't go and see em, would be too depressing, would rather go and se a decent cover band where if you got drunk enough it could seem like the old days.

  • theyre not trying to bring a copy of Layne's voice. Jerry chose DuVall as a replacement not because he sounds like Layne but because he likes his voice. Its the skill that matters not whether you can live up to a martyr in music or not.

    I mean think about it: if DuVall's only goal was to be as close-sounding to Layne, then he certainly wouldnt have been picked. Jerry isn't deaf!

  • I'm sorry but William Duvall only sounds remotely like Layne Staley and I'm being generous. Whats more, if you go listen to Duvall in HIS band, "Comes With the Fall", he sounds a lot different than when he's trying to imitate Layne. To me, he sounds generic and the comment about him sounding like a 9yr. old caroling is a lot more accurate than the comments about him sounding like Layne. Plus he's the clone of Anderson Varejao.

  • you need to see them live...then youll notice that duvall has a great voice and while he is and never will "layne" he is a good replacement. Layne is gone now...they have to move on like so many other bands have had to in the past

  • he aint layne and with out layne there is no AIC cuz no one can match his perfection

  • Saw them in Tampa the other night.DuVall kicked ass!! he was right on the money.All you haters need to grow up and get over it AIC will rise again!

  • saw them last night in tulsa,ok...fukn badass as usual..saw them last year too...best concerts i have ever been2...new guy rocks...jerry cantrell is THE Band...he fukn rocks...still got his head together and plays flawless...

  • I was there that night! That place is a great place to see a show, Cains? is that the name of it? It was the unplugged concert and DuVall is pretty good, you can't replace a Layne Staley but this guy was really good IMO.

  • he's NOT trying to be Layne... they are trying to keep Alice in Chains alive for them and their fans... get the fuck over it!! don't listen to them if you don't like it, millions of other people still will...

  • i gotta say, ive seen em live, and if i closed my eyes, i woulda swore it was layne. no lie.

  • There is no Alice in chains without layne staley

  • This new singer is ok I guess. I think Cantrell could have scouted around and got someone much closer sounding to Layne. You know what? If he didnt want to sound too close to Layne then shame on him! Layne IS ALICE IN CHAINS so get the best of the best to sound like the best of the best! I dont know why Cantrell settled for second best. Its definately not to honour Layne.

  • I respect your opinion however I must say I just saw them last night in Detroit and that new singer carries on the spirit of Layne and the show absolutely rocked..I've been to many concerts and very few rocked like this one..I seen AIC back in the day I am 37yrs old.Cantrell has to settle for second best Layne killed himself with drugs and the new singer was awesome!!!

  • Thanks Im freaking glad somebody said. All the bad shit Ive been hearing just pisses me off. No one is a greater Alice 'n' Chains then I and I agree with southermedic22. Layne was a god but I think Jerry is honoring him by doing what he is doing.

  • It is very sad that Layne Staley died the way that he did, but Jerry wrote the majority of the songs on the album. Jerry was just as much of AIC as was Layne. To put down Jerry and the rest of the crew keeping the music alive for all of the "no telling how many fans" would be a insult to them. I'm not cutting you down inboxj, but I believe that they are just honoring what they have done since the beginning.

  • It makes me sad that Cantrell and the rest of the band is going on without Layne Staley and calling themselves alice in chains,. There is no Alice in chains without Layne Staley, Him and Jerry to me were the best singing combo ever!, If the remaining band wanted to keep going on together why not change their name?. I just find this sad,

  • Couldn't agree with you more man, Jerry just wants to milk the most he can out of Alice in Chains.