the only reason i watched this movie was b/c of donnie yen but man he would have been better suited for liu bei. Well, there is a speculation that liu bei must have been pretty good warrior since he could wield dual blade on horse.
@WeNeedSomeGolfShoes 'Your dumb ass' .. is that proper english? LOL.. whos the retard here.. plus, im the top comment here so majority agrees with me.. hush up you moron.
Just watched i, it was quite a bad movie. Fight scenes, choreography and acting were good, but I totally didn't know who played liu bei. The character and storyline development was weak. If you watch it without reading any online summaries or wikipedia, you will be quite lost until mid movie, so it was sorta like watching pointless fight scenes. The introduction was very weak. Don't recommend this movie for the story line, but the fight scenes were fine.
@jiyefuuu This movie is so freaking shit that my father smashed his head on the seat and went sleeping. It seriously sucked as it changes the original content by A LOT. The movie made Cao Cao potrayed as though he was the hero in the Three Kingdoms, but in fact he is a tyrant. The movie was too based on the part '过五关,斩六将' , which means killing six generals while passing 5 gates. And Donnie Yen was too short. And the freak fact is that THE EMPORER ACTUALLY WENT TO FARM????!!!!!!
@mrandmrsscouse yes i do know the ENTIRE 3 kingdoms history, that is, the true history and not the romance of three kingdoms. well of course u can disagree. u're entitled to ur own opinion
5 Articles, from online newspaper, and local newspaper giving high ratings and praises. While you are sitting there alone, complaining about the movie.
You watch the movie online? What a fan. Utterly disappointed. Some movies have to be seen in the big screen, such as this one, i was at the GALA premiere and the response was awesome.
Why can't i laugh at you? Saying that the best movie in the genre sucks is laughable.
Yes, based on 3 guo zhi, not san guo yan yi. i have evidence also.
Yup, and planning to watch it again. =) I think that you are probably a bigger nerd than me, seeing that your social circle is so puny that you have to come here and try and spread bad stuff about the movie, instead of such telling your friends. =)
You want to bet? I can show you at least 5 reviews, from various asian countries which are saying that this is the BEST Romance of the 3 kingdoms movie up till now. Want to dare me? Bring my 5 articles saying it sucks.
Lol, i guess a 5 year old kid has much better english than you. Let alone Movie taste. You watch movie every day? HAHA. You mean you watch online or something?
It is BASED on the Romance of the 3 Kingdoms HISTORICAL TEXT, not Romance of the 3 Kingdoms NOVEL! LOL. Do you know that Guan Yu is not sworn brothers with liu bei? Do you know he's not taller than average? Do you know he doesn't have red face? These are all from the novel! The Movie is based on San Guo Zhi, not San Guo Yan Yi
i watched it twice already, in Singapore. It is amazing! Better than Red Cliff 1 and 2, add together! Much more exciting action scenes and the plot is so much more realistic and deeper. Only weird teenagers who only goes in to see PURE action will be disappointed, because this film is about the plot + fighting scenes together, and they compliment each other and made this the best ROTK movie as of today. =)
@glentaker: agree! I like Don's movie when he played as cop or brucelee, but to play as Lord Guan, I feel like he's too small for legendary 2meter warrior
@DooKNo1 the novel definitely did not portray Guan Yu godlike, he was a strong and capable general and known for his loyalty, but the book did point out many of his flaws, like his arrogance and his poor judgement that lead to his death. And most Chinese don't view Guan Yu godlike (unless in religion), even in regular Chinese mind if you ask them what do you know about Guan Yu, most likely you will get an answer of "loyalty" or "righteousness"...but won't get a "Godlike" answer
@QinWang87 dookNo1 lol mebbe thats why guan is loved in the west our gods are more like humans they are jealous arrogant and at times bloodthirsty look at zues athena wotan or thunor i dont think his judgement was poor given communications at the time and the fact that he needed to take and hold what do you call it now xiang yang in the time of the kings it was hsienyang he did what he thought nescessary paid with his life but if your a monarchist and legalist like me you can appreciate it
@lvcivs11 well technically to be exact, in legends Guan was made into a God after his death and was glorified after the Jin Dynasty. In fiction and in history never mentioned his religion for Buddhism was not widely practiced during the Han but instead in the Tang. And no, Guan Yu did not take a risk, he was too arrogant and overconfident which led to his death. If he just stayed put in Jing Province like he was ordered, he would not have died for his army stationed is too big to be messed with
@kaninas well, Chinese people don't worship him because of his arrogance, regular citizens, cops and organized crime alike worship him because he's loyal and righteousness
even in death, he had a choice to live or die, he chose to die instead of turn-coating, a lot of people like that
Don't get me wrong @DooKNo1, I love Donnie Yen and will probably end up loving this movie, but since this is a movie, it will far be historically correct...and no disrespect to you
@DooKNo1 no it is not a realistic portrayal of Guan Yu, Juustbeopen2010 is right, the style you see in the trailer is all wushu and not the actual fighting style back in the day, the spinning of the Guan Dao in the movie is purely for eye-candy, to look good on screen
Guan Yu is said to be 9 span (equivalent to be around 6'8" +/- 2 inches), beard was at least 4 spans long.
hey your channel is cool :) please come to visit my webseries WE ARE GUARDIANS , is very similar to an asian style movie ;)
davidekyoproduzioni 2 weeks ago in playlist Uploaded videos
there is the guy i took an arrow to knee from :/ il kill him ----- ("shiinng") says the sword
johnn2122a 2 weeks ago
1:08 troll
xtimina 1 month ago
DYNASTY WARRIORS :) !
aw23aw23 1 month ago
big fan of donnie yen, but yh, completely not right character for guan yu
theSPREDATOR 1 month ago
ip man guy
ALveeQ6r 3 months ago
dynasty warriors
rovernio 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is gonna be Epic!
ErickDamon 4 months ago
muyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy bueno!!!!!!
robert76807 6 months ago
the beard is too small , and the sword should have a dragon figure around the sword
ilovethreekingdoms 6 months ago
Guan Yu................and his beard
HamaguriSensei 7 months ago
GUAN YU!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Kvgrn1 8 months ago
Guan Yu styled Yunchang. Guan Yunchang if you want to say the whole thing!
arrivederciliebe32 8 months ago
the only reason i watched this movie was b/c of donnie yen but man he would have been better suited for liu bei. Well, there is a speculation that liu bei must have been pretty good warrior since he could wield dual blade on horse.
PhenomKBR 8 months ago
@WeNeedSomeGolfShoes no, let me teach you. its spelled 'You're a Dumb Ass'.. do not insult others when you yourself cannot spell properly..
jiyefuuu 8 months ago
@WeNeedSomeGolfShoes 'Your dumb ass' .. is that proper english? LOL.. whos the retard here.. plus, im the top comment here so majority agrees with me.. hush up you moron.
jiyefuuu 8 months ago
donnie yen can be any man he wants to be lol btw red cliff casting was beast
MaLuEiD 9 months ago
Only Donnie Yen can show the traditional Green Dragon Kwan Dao 2011!!
marg189 9 months ago
Just watched i, it was quite a bad movie. Fight scenes, choreography and acting were good, but I totally didn't know who played liu bei. The character and storyline development was weak. If you watch it without reading any online summaries or wikipedia, you will be quite lost until mid movie, so it was sorta like watching pointless fight scenes. The introduction was very weak. Don't recommend this movie for the story line, but the fight scenes were fine.
rsmod123 9 months ago
蠢电影, 甄子丹怎配演我大汉战神关云长?
简直是笑话!!
什么破电影!!!!
Shaolinkungfucat 10 months ago
Guan Yu Chang?
What?
The name is Guan Yun Chang.
Shaolinkungfucat 10 months ago
Blasphemy! Guan Yu should have a much longer beard.
papalolita 10 months ago
its so shit.. story sux, casting sux.. outfit SUX
donnie yen should never be guan yu.. hes way too small
jiyefuuu 10 months ago 27
@jiyefuuu I 2nd this, Guan Yu was described as a man who towered above others...
niharasan1 10 months ago
@jiyefuuu This movie is so freaking shit that my father smashed his head on the seat and went sleeping. It seriously sucked as it changes the original content by A LOT. The movie made Cao Cao potrayed as though he was the hero in the Three Kingdoms, but in fact he is a tyrant. The movie was too based on the part '过五关,斩六将' , which means killing six generals while passing 5 gates. And Donnie Yen was too short. And the freak fact is that THE EMPORER ACTUALLY WENT TO FARM????!!!!!!
chengwen010 9 months ago
Comment removed
Tax3000 9 months ago
@jiyefuuu at least the movie was funny. u need to know cantonese to get the jokes XD
applecheer276 8 months ago
@jiyefuuu I completely disagree, do you even know the history behind the story??
mrandmrsscouse 8 months ago
@mrandmrsscouse yes i do know the ENTIRE 3 kingdoms history, that is, the true history and not the romance of three kingdoms. well of course u can disagree. u're entitled to ur own opinion
jiyefuuu 8 months ago
@jiyefuuu Indeed I am.
mrandmrsscouse 8 months ago
@jiyefuuu couldn't agree more.
MetaIhead89 6 months ago
@jiyefuuu yeah, it really suck, and when you look at the end, at 1:21 , the graphics suck so much for something in 2011
Simon777v 1 month ago
@wilsonlk
5 Articles, from online newspaper, and local newspaper giving high ratings and praises. While you are sitting there alone, complaining about the movie.
You watch the movie online? What a fan. Utterly disappointed. Some movies have to be seen in the big screen, such as this one, i was at the GALA premiere and the response was awesome.
Why can't i laugh at you? Saying that the best movie in the genre sucks is laughable.
Yes, based on 3 guo zhi, not san guo yan yi. i have evidence also.
PTigris7 10 months ago
@wilsonlk
Yup, and planning to watch it again. =) I think that you are probably a bigger nerd than me, seeing that your social circle is so puny that you have to come here and try and spread bad stuff about the movie, instead of such telling your friends. =)
You want to bet? I can show you at least 5 reviews, from various asian countries which are saying that this is the BEST Romance of the 3 kingdoms movie up till now. Want to dare me? Bring my 5 articles saying it sucks.
PTigris7 10 months ago
@wilsonlk
Lol, i guess a 5 year old kid has much better english than you. Let alone Movie taste. You watch movie every day? HAHA. You mean you watch online or something?
It is BASED on the Romance of the 3 Kingdoms HISTORICAL TEXT, not Romance of the 3 Kingdoms NOVEL! LOL. Do you know that Guan Yu is not sworn brothers with liu bei? Do you know he's not taller than average? Do you know he doesn't have red face? These are all from the novel! The Movie is based on San Guo Zhi, not San Guo Yan Yi
PTigris7 10 months ago
@wilsonlk
i watched it twice already, in Singapore. It is amazing! Better than Red Cliff 1 and 2, add together! Much more exciting action scenes and the plot is so much more realistic and deeper. Only weird teenagers who only goes in to see PURE action will be disappointed, because this film is about the plot + fighting scenes together, and they compliment each other and made this the best ROTK movie as of today. =)
PTigris7 10 months ago
I dont understand why they call it the lost blademan....
kaninas 10 months ago
On red hare.
kinkasuka 10 months ago
GOD of War is backkkk :D
sanadaHIRO 10 months ago
too thin for Guan Yu
glentaker 10 months ago
@glentaker: agree! I like Don's movie when he played as cop or brucelee, but to play as Lord Guan, I feel like he's too small for legendary 2meter warrior
briansuck 10 months ago
@DooKNo1 the novel definitely did not portray Guan Yu godlike, he was a strong and capable general and known for his loyalty, but the book did point out many of his flaws, like his arrogance and his poor judgement that lead to his death. And most Chinese don't view Guan Yu godlike (unless in religion), even in regular Chinese mind if you ask them what do you know about Guan Yu, most likely you will get an answer of "loyalty" or "righteousness"...but won't get a "Godlike" answer
QinWang87 10 months ago
@QinWang87 dookNo1 lol mebbe thats why guan is loved in the west our gods are more like humans they are jealous arrogant and at times bloodthirsty look at zues athena wotan or thunor i dont think his judgement was poor given communications at the time and the fact that he needed to take and hold what do you call it now xiang yang in the time of the kings it was hsienyang he did what he thought nescessary paid with his life but if your a monarchist and legalist like me you can appreciate it
lvcivs11 10 months ago
@lvcivs11 well technically to be exact, in legends Guan was made into a God after his death and was glorified after the Jin Dynasty. In fiction and in history never mentioned his religion for Buddhism was not widely practiced during the Han but instead in the Tang. And no, Guan Yu did not take a risk, he was too arrogant and overconfident which led to his death. If he just stayed put in Jing Province like he was ordered, he would not have died for his army stationed is too big to be messed with
QinWang87 10 months ago
@QinWang87 Agreed... we should not worship arrogance....
kaninas 10 months ago
@kaninas well, Chinese people don't worship him because of his arrogance, regular citizens, cops and organized crime alike worship him because he's loyal and righteousness
even in death, he had a choice to live or die, he chose to die instead of turn-coating, a lot of people like that
QinWang87 10 months ago
Don't get me wrong @DooKNo1, I love Donnie Yen and will probably end up loving this movie, but since this is a movie, it will far be historically correct...and no disrespect to you
QinWang87 10 months ago
@DooKNo1 no it is not a realistic portrayal of Guan Yu, Juustbeopen2010 is right, the style you see in the trailer is all wushu and not the actual fighting style back in the day, the spinning of the Guan Dao in the movie is purely for eye-candy, to look good on screen
Guan Yu is said to be 9 span (equivalent to be around 6'8" +/- 2 inches), beard was at least 4 spans long.
QinWang87 10 months ago
Guan Yu is the Best!
Hellsing0454 11 months ago
Dayum Donnie Yen is GUan Yu!!!
HanmaHayes 11 months ago
he is a good actor but sadly too short for Lord Guan Yu....
lonewolf037 1 year ago
that horse got fucked up
mastergradeone 1 year ago
He have the martial skills and acting skills to pull it off....but he is a shorty.
Which means we will be seeing an awesome MINI Guan Yun Chang.
PrimeChaosVC 1 year ago
Dynasty Warriors!!! Guan Yu. The God of War!
INYOURFACE5625 1 year ago
Donnie Yen, a great martial artist!
apachemk4 1 year ago
cool~~~~
terrystephanie1 1 year ago
this movie is good n bad at the same time.
Good : starred DY, modern fighting style n settings about the great GY
Bad : starred DY - he just not that much resemble the huge physic of GY, not the old style combat, consist of too much acrobatic like a monkey.
justbeopen2010 1 year ago
Comment removed
SaphiraPorter 1 year ago
Looks good, I hope this doesn't disappoint like Legend of the Fist.
Donnie Yen was making better stuff before he made it big with Ip Man in my opinion.
martialbro5 1 year ago
@martialbro5 Ip 1 was good Ip 2 kinda go downhill ever since...
ivanUtube 1 year ago
Stunning :)
EternalMoonScent 1 year ago 2
@EternalMoonScent yeah, looks good, cant wait for it...:)
loveasianfilm 1 year ago
@loveasianfilm me too. but the actor used should be higher... but ok in the rest its very good!!
Tax3000 9 months ago