Hahaha, it is a surprise to know that ZXY sings in Indonesian. Listening to the songs, I think that her country of origin is either Indonesia or Malaysia. Because a Singaporean usually can not speak the letter 'r' as Indonesian of Malaysian. How do you think of this. Anyway thanks for posting them.
You're welcome. I agree with you that it's very unlikely ZXY was Singapore-born judging from the way she spoke and sang in all of her Indonesian songs. I believe she must have been born and grew up in Indonesia. My dad told me ZXY was from Makassar, South Sulawesi.
Yeah, after comparing the 2 versions, I understand what you mean. The Indonesian version has extra 2 wind instruments - the trumpet and the clarinet, that the Chinese version doesn't have.
Thanks asianfanofdonny! Yes she sings well in both languages. I espesially love the part when she sings " berani sumpah sungguh mati ". Wow! she sounded so Indonesian.
@mountainmamastudio Watampone, Sulawesi Selatan! Satu daerah sama ZXY dong :-)
ddyprnt777 1 year ago
Hahaha, it is a surprise to know that ZXY sings in Indonesian. Listening to the songs, I think that her country of origin is either Indonesia or Malaysia. Because a Singaporean usually can not speak the letter 'r' as Indonesian of Malaysian. How do you think of this. Anyway thanks for posting them.
jakartahc 2 years ago
You're welcome. I agree with you that it's very unlikely ZXY was Singapore-born judging from the way she spoke and sang in all of her Indonesian songs. I believe she must have been born and grew up in Indonesia. My dad told me ZXY was from Makassar, South Sulawesi.
ddyprnt777 2 years ago
The music in this song is fuller than the Chinese version. The Chinese version seems a little more bland, perhaps less instruments.
I like this better than the Chinese version.
asianfanofdonny 2 years ago
Yeah, after comparing the 2 versions, I understand what you mean. The Indonesian version has extra 2 wind instruments - the trumpet and the clarinet, that the Chinese version doesn't have.
ddyprnt777 2 years ago
Very good job. ZXY sings well both in Chinese and Indonesian/Malay.
She has a very pleasant and sweet voice.
asianfanofdonny 2 years ago
Thanks asianfanofdonny! Yes she sings well in both languages. I espesially love the part when she sings " berani sumpah sungguh mati ". Wow! she sounded so Indonesian.
ddyprnt777 2 years ago