@HoennMaster Well,if he/she didn't see pther videos,it's normal that (S)he didn't know that. Geri wasn't in this performance because Geri had left when they released this song,but she is in the tour! :D
One of the things that surely got me all excited was hearing rumours about Geri having a part in Holler, a bit of Mel B's part, wud have sound excellent and it wud have erased time as if Geri never left, sadly it never happened but Id kill to see Geri dancing to this r&b vibe!
i love how geri just disappears into the smoke. viva forever is so symbolic because this was the last song geri sang with the girls before running out on them in 1998.
i think it is not right for Geri to sing this song.... because she was already gone and the girls already move on with her when this song release... although she deserves to sing the track "goodbye." because she co-wrote the song with the girls and also "Viva FOrever." since she sings in the track... but I really like her and victoria. and i am glad she is in the tour with the girls...
Geri didn't perform 'Holler' on the tour because it was written and released after she left the band. But also, the next song on the setlist on this tour was her solo of 'Its Raining Men', so while the other four are singing this, she does backstage for a costume change
it's not that Geri doesn't deserve to perform this song. It was a time of the Spice Girls' life as a foursome...without Geri, and I'm sure she respected that. She even said in her 2nd book that one of the reason she left was because the 4 girls wanted to take the next Spice Girls album (3rd) to a more R&B sounding style. Which Geri supported them on it, but she was more of a pop style singer.
I was at this concert. I had loads of fun. No, Geri should not have stayed for this number, it was an era of the Spice Girls where it was just the 4 of them.
deberion sacar a la negra cochina de mel b y dejar a geri que cante sus lineas de esa cancion , ahi hubiera salido perfecto todo .... mel b sucks .....GERI is the best foreverrr
The Spice Girls made more than enough money during the hey day for Mel to be a gold digger for anyone. Eddie should be glad she even looked at him, let alone bore him a gorgeous child. The money he is being forced to pay, is going into a trust for Angel, not Mel's pocket!!! FYI
Support our DVD campaign! Spread the link to anyone you can so we can get the video on Youtube's front page. Be sure to e-mail to the address provided in the video.
Add watch?v=fU0Bi1yIAMA to the end of the Youtube URL, or simply look up Spice Girls - 2009 DVD Campaign for the video!
Copy/paste this message and send it to everyone you can!
Geri didn't hel on the writting process for Holler and LLLTW, but she and Emma Wrote GoodBye (wellthey started it)Goodbye was meant for the fans, then once they found out Geri had left the band, Mel B. turned it into a song about Geri. that's why Geri only sings GoodBye with the Girls.
THEy ROCK!! iT WOULD HAVE BEEN COOL iF THEy iNCLUDED GERi.....LiKE GiVE HER A PART TO SiNG SO iT CAN SEEM AS iF SHE NEVER LEFT =) BUT i LOVE THE SPiCE GiRLz!!
Why would you thumbs down a question on where Geri is? There are far too sensitive and stupid people on these threads who will write anything that comes into their heads and then misunderstand and take personal offence to the comments from someone else. Fucking weirdos!
well two years after goodbye waz released they made another album without her (she wanted to be a solo artist) so holler was the first single from forever (not goodbye, goodbye didnt even hav an album title yet) so when she waz leveled at the end of viva forever it waz saying she left the group when that song waz a hit (actually she left befor the song became a hit) so all the songs that had 4 then only 4 girls sang...each songs tells a story
Was anyone else absolutely in LOVE with those funky comic pics in the background showing the girls fighting in a futuristic war type thing with those glam outfit???
ombre... no esta mal, pero no abra DVD, asike dificil lo veo ke aya sido extraido de el... y si lo ubiera no pondrian imagenes grabadas por el publico... pondrian algo con mas calidad.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
lets make the headlines,now is true,we wanna show to world what miracles money do..if you lost one show we sure we ve done and the tickts and cds please dont live us alone,cos just really matter is have money near
yes i've heard in a mel b interview, she said that i live dvd will be released in the end of october 2008. the New York City Concert in Madison Square Garden was filmed.
Victoria OWNED that stage.
rachellecamilla 1 day ago
POR FAVOR REGRESEN LAS AMO DEMASIADO!
rudoltnt3320 3 weeks ago
baby=Emma, posh=Victoria, scary=Mel B.,ginger=Gari, sporty=Mel C. The Spice Girls!!!!
hyphywifey777 6 months ago
Emma was singing VICTORIA'S part :S
BSGGEJ 10 months ago
@BSGGEJ um do you know which is victoria's parts because no she wasn't. Victoria was singing her own parts.
LeoGonWild 9 months ago
they should of done it with geri
pauldrewery 1 year ago
I wish there was a Forever tour . :(
replayj86 1 year ago
was ginger on this tour?
lookinfresh2010 1 year ago
@lookinfresh2010 yes
weenerwallet 1 year ago
@lookinfresh2010 You watched this video and you don't know that?
HoennMaster 1 year ago
@HoennMaster Well,if he/she didn't see pther videos,it's normal that (S)he didn't know that. Geri wasn't in this performance because Geri had left when they released this song,but she is in the tour! :D
Paterbubi 11 months ago
@lookinfresh2010 Yes she was
tamecka100 1 year ago
One of the things that surely got me all excited was hearing rumours about Geri having a part in Holler, a bit of Mel B's part, wud have sound excellent and it wud have erased time as if Geri never left, sadly it never happened but Id kill to see Geri dancing to this r&b vibe!
slolove06 1 year ago
@slolove06
Felt the same
Geri in Holler would be fucking fierce
smck2009 1 year ago 4
@smck2009 =)
slolove06 1 year ago
AS MUCH AS I LOVED THE SPICE GIRL....WOW....NOT SO GOOD VOICES!!!! STILL LOVE THEM THOUGH XX
candiecorinne 1 year ago
whoo they sound good when they actually sing
garlogan2 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I really love them.
But Melanie c's voice is amazing!!!
NoellePL 1 year ago
I really love them.
But Melanie c's voice is amazing!!
NoellePL 1 year ago 3
i love how geri just disappears into the smoke. viva forever is so symbolic because this was the last song geri sang with the girls before running out on them in 1998.
love this video! :D
Jarrod323 1 year ago
I JUST LOOOOOOOOOOVE THEY ! They're soooooo awesome! <333
annielynk3 1 year ago
i think it is not right for Geri to sing this song.... because she was already gone and the girls already move on with her when this song release... although she deserves to sing the track "goodbye." because she co-wrote the song with the girls and also "Viva FOrever." since she sings in the track... but I really like her and victoria. and i am glad she is in the tour with the girls...
makiaphrodite 1 year ago
Is there an actuall DVD for this tour?
homie480 1 year ago
@homie480 no..and it's such a shame.
Didnt get to see the show live ( it sold out! ) but atleast YouTube has some great clips.
likewhateva1 1 year ago 2
wheres gary ? '_'?
mfc1184 2 years ago
Geri doesn't appear in the performances of some songs after her departure from the band (such as Holler and Let Love Lead The Way).
etreduardo 2 years ago
melc rocks
Fancie1982 2 years ago 6
@Fancie1982 I agree.Mel C is such an great singer
NoellePL 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@Fancie1982 I agree.Mel C is such an great singer!!!
NoellePL 1 year ago
Geri didn't perform 'Holler' on the tour because it was written and released after she left the band. But also, the next song on the setlist on this tour was her solo of 'Its Raining Men', so while the other four are singing this, she does backstage for a costume change
spider23000 2 years ago 7
Since Geri performed Goodbye with them and she wasnt in the group than she should of got to perform this song,She would of looked great.
spiceforlife81 2 years ago
Horrible photographer
omgitsmadonna 2 years ago
it's not that Geri doesn't deserve to perform this song. It was a time of the Spice Girls' life as a foursome...without Geri, and I'm sure she respected that. She even said in her 2nd book that one of the reason she left was because the 4 girls wanted to take the next Spice Girls album (3rd) to a more R&B sounding style. Which Geri supported them on it, but she was more of a pop style singer.
sassysarsi 2 years ago 2
I think Geri coul sing the chorus in this song
PamelaElizabeth 2 years ago
geri not even on the stage
DanMarie96 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
yeah and I don't like that
PamelaElizabeth 2 years ago
she had left the group when this album came out. SHe was in the beginning of the video. She goes under the stage. pay attention
bettedavisfan1 2 years ago
I was at this concert. I had loads of fun. No, Geri should not have stayed for this number, it was an era of the Spice Girls where it was just the 4 of them.
sassysarsi 2 years ago
Geri should have been in that performance.
NadiaLFCullen 2 years ago 3
I wish I could've went to the concert, I was almost crying when I heard they were returning.
WOWitude 2 years ago 2
I actually cried :P and I am 25 xD
AnetteOlzonItalia 2 years ago 3
Oh i did too honey, don't worry!
hangshimkim 2 years ago
deberion sacar a la negra cochina de mel b y dejar a geri que cante sus lineas de esa cancion , ahi hubiera salido perfecto todo .... mel b sucks .....GERI is the best foreverrr
murderwarner19 2 years ago
Perfect Girls... Wherever they are... And Forever... caus' nobody will be the same!
They're eternal!
Pirilim195 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
mel b is a gold digger i don't like her thats my opinion,
alihussain309 3 years ago
thats not true, eddy is an idiot for leaving her. she's hot
willc2k 2 years ago 28
@willc2k what i don't understand is how she even let him hit that...he isn't even attractive what the hell was was she thinkin!!!
thalialuvmx 1 year ago
@willc2k leaving who
SummerS1998 9 months ago
@SummerS1998 mel b
willc2k 9 months ago
@willc2k who eddy why he leaving her
SummerS1998 9 months ago
@SummerS1998 they were dating, she got pregnant, denied the child was his, then split from her
willc2k 9 months ago
The Spice Girls made more than enough money during the hey day for Mel to be a gold digger for anyone. Eddie should be glad she even looked at him, let alone bore him a gorgeous child. The money he is being forced to pay, is going into a trust for Angel, not Mel's pocket!!! FYI
Khere00 2 years ago 4
3:00, Mel C really knows how to move her body!
bday121 3 years ago
hot! LOL!
willc2k 2 years ago
gostaria de ver a geri a cantar holler .....seria maraviloso
rosamenti 3 years ago
Is there a DVD for realese? or does anyone know when??!!
HELP!!
natalieoneillbennett 3 years ago
No, it's never going to be released...
We are HOPING it LEAKS... Or at least screen scenes.
But that's quite impossible once ANY of the Spice Girls (as a group) really leak.
pierre00 3 years ago
I love the old choreograhpy they did back in 2000 more than this one. Yet this one is hot too.
Tum2185 3 years ago 3
Support our DVD campaign! Spread the link to anyone you can so we can get the video on Youtube's front page. Be sure to e-mail to the address provided in the video.
Add watch?v=fU0Bi1yIAMA to the end of the Youtube URL, or simply look up Spice Girls - 2009 DVD Campaign for the video!
Copy/paste this message and send it to everyone you can!
LegendsBuiltToLast 3 years ago 3
Isn't there a performance of them singing Holler with Geri??
jj85585 3 years ago
no there isn't.
capcom23 3 years ago
Geri didn't hel on the writting process for Holler and LLLTW, but she and Emma Wrote GoodBye (wellthey started it)Goodbye was meant for the fans, then once they found out Geri had left the band, Mel B. turned it into a song about Geri. that's why Geri only sings GoodBye with the Girls.
chavitanoguez 3 years ago
I so much love to see them back together. When they were... Love the girls. Best (girl)band ever and will always be! <3
MelanieCFan88 3 years ago
Melanie, what a nice fetish boots!!!
kukuzice 3 years ago
what we gotta do to get a spice girls tour dvd x
wayneyeo12 3 years ago
TOUR DVD PLEASE X
wayneyeo12 3 years ago
lovge the spicess
Rich87 3 years ago
THEy ROCK!! iT WOULD HAVE BEEN COOL iF THEy iNCLUDED GERi.....LiKE GiVE HER A PART TO SiNG SO iT CAN SEEM AS iF SHE NEVER LEFT =) BUT i LOVE THE SPiCE GiRLz!!
KLIFF55 3 years ago
yo creo que geri deberia haber cantado esta cancion!..al fin y al cabo es una cancion del grupo y ella regreso al grupo...
rockangelwing 3 years ago
es que esta canción era del grupo cuando eran 4 y Geri no tiene participación vocal en la misma
saintabbaspice 3 years ago
sigo pensando que la cancion es del grupo y da = las chicas que esten en el grupo como si estuvieran otras, geri tenia que haber cantando ....
rockangelwing 3 years ago
Pienso lo mismo que tú, hubiera sido interesante ver a Geri bailando la coreografía de Holler ¿No?
LordFalcon2007 3 years ago
Why would you thumbs down a question on where Geri is? There are far too sensitive and stupid people on these threads who will write anything that comes into their heads and then misunderstand and take personal offence to the comments from someone else. Fucking weirdos!
blueecto 3 years ago 3
victoria sang great in that video!
Arkh9 3 years ago 2
agreed she does the Holler Holler bit better in the recording, abit more powerful than here!
walkaway221 3 years ago
where the hell is Geri???
StevieNicksFan 3 years ago
I don't see why my question was given a thumbs down, asshole
I simply asked were Geri was, and then I found out this song was after she left backn in '98
so fuck you, and a thumbs down for you too bitch
StevieNicksFan 3 years ago
well two years after goodbye waz released they made another album without her (she wanted to be a solo artist) so holler was the first single from forever (not goodbye, goodbye didnt even hav an album title yet) so when she waz leveled at the end of viva forever it waz saying she left the group when that song waz a hit (actually she left befor the song became a hit) so all the songs that had 4 then only 4 girls sang...each songs tells a story
navarronbret15 3 years ago 2
They performed Viva Forever right before this song. At the end of Viva Geri was lowered from the stage, and they did this song without her.
MaruLovesCats 3 years ago
Bai-bai Geri!
gtey 3 years ago
Mel b is a hot dancer :)
grrrdaaa 3 years ago 6
MEL B = la meilleure, the BEST
servin85 3 years ago
lol their awesome victoria sang really well here and so did melanie c ugh LUV THEM!
EmoPhobiaMaster07 3 years ago 4
Mel B voice in this song are like her.. fantastic
pepiflor 3 years ago
ELLE SONT TROP SEXY SURTOUT MEL B
juleromain 3 years ago
This is hot, I love it when the guys are crawling and they're on leashes the girls are holding lol.
SuperstarKED 3 years ago
Was anyone else absolutely in LOVE with those funky comic pics in the background showing the girls fighting in a futuristic war type thing with those glam outfit???
Loved it
aurykl 3 years ago 13
PLEASE RELEASE A DVD!!!!
aurykl 3 years ago 3
Very clear. Thankx
willc2k 3 years ago
ombre... no esta mal, pero no abra DVD, asike dificil lo veo ke aya sido extraido de el... y si lo ubiera no pondrian imagenes grabadas por el publico... pondrian algo con mas calidad.
pero aun asi me enkantan y t pongo 5 estrellas
leonelygeri 3 years ago
Si..y people u are!! The one who recorded it at the concert edited as dvd and then it sounds much better,clear from dvd means that
mccbcn77 3 years ago
No dvd will be preoduced i dont know why this says clear from dvd because the Spice Girls aid there will be no Dvd
dodgeboy17 3 years ago
thats so right...really dumb to call the video its from a dvd!!!
TheReturnOfMusic 3 years ago
cuz its the best your gonna get form this tour
richieboyland 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lets make the headlines,now is true,we wanna show to world what miracles money do..if you lost one show we sure we ve done and the tickts and cds please dont live us alone,cos just really matter is have money near
rosamenti 3 years ago
I was wondering how they would do this if.....geri was there...haha
Lexikool94 4 years ago 3
will a dvd be realeased?????? please someone tell me!!!!
ldla2002 4 years ago 3
yes i've heard in a mel b interview, she said that i live dvd will be released in the end of october 2008. the New York City Concert in Madison Square Garden was filmed.
GoldeneyeJam 3 years ago
can u post the interview, please? :) :P
ArenAvril 3 years ago
the dvd comes out before the end of the year and it was filmed at madison square garden in new york
Badboyofcourse 4 years ago
Dvd..where did you get it?
MIGHTYSKRIBZ 4 years ago
This was recorded from the stands. It's not an official DVD.
GreatCanadianGamer 4 years ago 2
These are all from spicegirlsexpeirience
wat a fake..
czarinaluvshakop 3 years ago 3
Are they puting out a DVD of their live show?/
candymoo81 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
victoria had totally lost her voice °_°
shiningball 4 years ago