Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (47)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • just because we have an opinion dosent mean it cant be the same as other peoples. okay....you have to be making this up...you have to be....this cant be real, what im watching. i cant comprehend. youre just a troll. very funny. thats cool. great sarcasm. but if youre serious im going to find you and kill you.

  • the point of the phantom menace is to make money and make lucas feel good about himself. midiclorians is fucked up.  YOU ARE SO RETARDED IT MAKES ME SO ANGRY. THATS WHAT FANS IS SHORT FOR YOU IDIOT. FANS - FAN-ANTICS. YOU ARE SUCH A TWAT. I CANT ACTUALLY BELEIVE WHAT IM WATCHING. JAR JAR BINKS....... REALLY??? THIS VIDEO HAS GOT TO BE FAKE. ARE U REALLY SERIOUS? GO WATCH GI JOE RISE OF COBRA OR SOMETHING. HOW ABOUT YOU GET A BRAIN

  • star wars changed the world....i love blade runner. and every version of blade runner is availiable on one set....not star wars. also. blade runner is one film ( so far ), not three that were ruined by another 3. YOU are being an idiot.

  • WE are being selfish? who brought Lucas up to being a billionaire? The fans and the audience! Lucas himself thought that when Star Wars came out in 1977, it would be a big failure. Its the people who are putting millions of dollars in his pocket. It may be his franchise, but he owes it to us.

  • The fanatics with mental issues... You talking about you right? Using 45 minutes to "defend" the prequels and George Lucas. You know? That's pretty messed up, man!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Oh, and RedLetterMedia has released an independent film, Feeding Frenzy... and its not a person, its a filmmaking group... and Star Wars was not their first major review... and your also a hypocrite... and the prequels were bad movies... and if these reviews are bringing entertainment to people aren't they contributing something positive?

  • really? your example of a serious and heavy and not-fun movie is the lord of the rings? ok

  • Whats wrong with your FACE!!!!!!

    

  • I don't think this man has ever seen a tampon.

  • You're embarrassing yourself.

  • This is a joke reactionary piece, right? Is he trying to prove just how good a job Redlettermedia did with their reviews by showing how incredibly bad they could have been?

  • Close encounters also has multiple versions. However, you can watch all three versions in one dvd/blu-ray combo pack. Hell, even Spielberg as humble as he was actually said it was a mistake to show the inside of the mother ship. I don't think some of you fans understand that art is important and it should not be altered because just like Mona Lisa, Starry Night, etc, art belongs to more than just the artist... it belongs to the world.

  • 8:25 and unward is pretty much just trash talk and non-sensical insults toward redlettermedia. You sure proved why he sucked with all these insults.

  • Comment removed

  • Yeah, and Bladerunner's different versions suck too.

  • 14:21 UH, STUTTER! STUTTER!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • 09:57 - 10:20 You shouldn't talk that way about yourself.

  • @kamdan2011 haha yeah thats true.

  • Maybe we like Red Letter Media, because we share the same opinions about how shitty those films were and it's satisfying to know that we weren't the only ones. It's also entertaining if people can make those opinions interesting to listen to, rather than your technique of just pointing a camera at yourself and start bitching into it.

  • So, you're saying that it's okay to have an opinion, but not to express it? At least when Red Letter Media reviews the films, it's done in an entertaining and informative fashion. You're just a boring talking head.

  • The theatical cut WAS released in the 5-disc Blade Runner Blu-ray set! You only got the Final Cut two-disc version. Scott respected that fans liked that version of the film, while Lucas does not.

  • "I'm trying not to use bad language but this guy is a PIECE OF SHIT!"

  • RedLetterMedia has more a brain than this moron.

  • The whole saga sucks.

  • George hasn't released the original trilogy untouched since 1995. He wants to make changes? Fine. But he isn't giving anyone a choice. Some people want to see the original the way they were released in theaters. I for one would like to see the original with the scene of the Tie-fighter getting its wings shot off, & the pod floating aimlessly in space, which was the inspiration of the toy's ability to pop the wings off in battle.

  • I completely agree with your opinion regarding the fanatics, but the critisicm to Redlettermedia I feel is unwarranted. You adress the work as Mr.Plinkett is just nitpicking minor details, which to me is part of the joke in the reviews, he adresses valid flaws just aswell as mentioning minor unwarranted details, some of it holds true to the construction of narratives, bu some of it is isn't because of false representation. And Redlettermedia has for the record produced feature length films afaik

  • Well said. Haters are nothing but nerdy fanatics that give the rest of the fans a bad name. Here I disagree with you in some points: I prefered puppet Yoda, I thought Obi-Wan was the main character in TPM and I have watched RLM reviews and got a kick out of them (I disagree with his views of course), but that doesn't mean that all of the sudden I hate your guts because we have different views. That's the problem with the fanatics, they take things too seriously.

  • You said "If you guys hate new Star Wars stuff so much, why are you still talking about it?" Same back at you, man. If you LOVE the rereleases & the prequels so much, then WHY BOTHER responding to haters? Because it's a free country, & we can express our opinion any way we want & you can't stop us, & I think what frustrates you the most is the sheer amount of flawless logic that shatters the dream image you had of Lucas. I once praised him, too. Turns out, he's just another money hungry asshole.

  • tehe

  • Since you brought up Blade Runner, the difference there is, they're all available to be viewed/purchased in the best format out there. It's a 5-disc set. You know this right? And for Superman II, theatrical cut is available too right alongside the Donner Cut. THAT'S NOT THE CASE WITH STAR WARS. That's why people are complaining. How hard is it to understand that really?

  • Not trying to put down what you like. That's your opinion. I have no issue with that and more power to you. However, the prequels are 100%...dogshit. No one complains about newer versions of Blade Runner or Superman II because their impact on the overall cinematic structure in Hollywood and how they influenced movies to this day was minsecule. Star Wars changed everything literally over night, and defined a generation. It's not the fact that he's changing things in the original trilogy that pi

  • the prequels are bad movies. Redletter Media is perhaps a nerd but he is right about the prequels!

  • I think the reason no one complains about alternate versions of other films is because the original versions are also available in the same quality as the new version.

  • damn you...you are starting to convince me.

  • Redlettermedia is a moron! In his reviews he sounds like a retard... I hate how they make fun of the prequels!

  • I think I'm aware only one authorized director's cut would be made for those movies. Any other cut that's made for Blade Runner weren't overseen by the director. That said, the original trilogy, having another special edition down the line for the other two, will be the most director's cuts with control from the director himself.

    And by the way, the character in the RedLetterMedia reviews is fictional. You really take those BlairWitch style intercuts with him interrogating that girl seriously?

  • well said buddy!!!... im a big star wars fan and appreciate all versions.. i must admit the yoda change is better on ep1 of blue ray....

  • You are my hero. :D

  • I love you, TheLuminous777! :-)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more