Seriously man. Hes right up there with The Beatles...without people like Bowie music would not have gotten this far (although to be honest music these days is quite shit)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This song is at the end of the movie 'The Cove' it's a movie about killing dolphins in Japan. It's a very serious issue and we all shoul know something about killing dolphins, mercury in fishmeat and the provacy of that all. You have to see that movie.
This is the greatest love song of all time. David Bowie, while recording this album in the Studio By The Wall in Berlin watched 2 lovers meet by The Berlin Wall to kiss. It inspired him to write this song. The fact that 2 lovers, 1 from East Berlin, and the other from West would risk their own lives in the name of love is amazing.
Autonomy87 - your story is romantic but if you ever saw the Berlin wall before 1989, you know that this is pure fiction. The only way to get near the wall, was in West. And nobody from East was allowed to go to West. As simple as that!
On the album Heroes he started with the line about "I, I will be king" yet in other versions I started with the dolphins stanza, I've also heard versions where he starts off with the "you can be mean" line. Anyone have any insight on this?
Been a Bowie fan for a long time and I always wondered.
I'm not sure about the "you can be mean" line. I believe he used that during his Serious Moonlight Tour in 1983. Also, the single version of this song starts cuts the first stanza off and goes directly to the third stanza. This version is the full 6:00 album version from his "Heroes" album in 1977
I would have thought the dolphins stanza start was the radio edit because six minutes would be too long, while three and a half minutes is about standard. There are many songs which I have the full album version but get bits cut out for the radio.
One good example of song editing for radio is Yes' Roundabout originally around 7 or so minutes.
Funny but I think Hey Jude might be the only long song that was never cut for top 40. If so, well, we are talking about The Beatles. Another song on top 40 radio that, I think, was never cut was McArthur Park.
Stairway to Heaven was never cut too but it was a staple of FM radio, so that doesn't count.
I think you may be thinking of the film Moulin Rouge... There is a medley of a bunch of different love songs in it. The words are different though. In the film is "you, you will be mean."
@eatmorenachos the single version (the old 45 rpm) started with I wish you can swim and ends before "we're nothing etc.". No wonder that it wasn't a big hit...the short version is complete nonsense. THIS is the original and BEST version of this WONDERFUL song
@eatmorenachos I bought this album the day it came out and fell for this song. When the single came out I was so bummed that they edited it to cut the first two verses, they set up the whole song. Since the single was popular, I suppose that's why David usually did the "single" version live. Would much rather have heard the song as is (actually could have done without the "dolphins" verse rather than the first, made no sense to me).
Thank you! I'd wondered about that for a long time. It was always one of my favorite songs but it seems strange not to hear it in the original (and better) form.
@eatmorenachos there is a german version of this too. Bowie sings german the third line (i dont remember exactly). This version i mentioned is on the album "Christiane F." a soundtrack from "Wir Kinder vom Bahnhof ZOO" film.
Really? I only hear Fripps filtered Les Paul fingering and Eno's synth additions. The Theremin really has no action signature and as such is an instrument that is totally unique. I am, of course, referring to hands on instrument action. The theremin is not touched at all. But please point to the sound you heard. Let me know.
I'm somwhat new to David Bowie; however I've heard the majority of "Aladdin Sane", "Ziggy Stardust" and "Low" (in it's entirety). Truthfully I don't know what to think of Bowie, but I did love "Low".
on the back of the vinyl record case it says recorded by david bowie in berlin by the wall
so in the song the mention of it is refering to the berlin wall because one of his band members went to meet his lover and bowie saw them kissing by the wall under a gun turet
I agree is an absolutely excellent record. The instrumentals are more interesting than those on "Low". I think that "Low" achieved more on an artistic level so from that perspective it is probably the best. But after listening to the entire 'Berlin Trilogy' over again I think I had more fun listening to "Heroes" it is a great record indeed.
The thing about Heroes is that it is more Poppy and more accesible to the masses. And that is why I give it my regards as Bowies best album. It is not that it is this eclectic mess of thigns and odd recording techniques.
It took the sounds developed and misused on Low and propelled them to a straight ahead, jaunty, poppy, rock and roll, groove.
Rather than the Art Rock minimalistic mess that was side two of Low.
The description of this video is absolutely spot on. I could not agree with nesplayer94 more. Low is a life-changing record to the right people, and Heroes is a great album, but nothing like Low. But the title track, "Heroes"....my god. It is literally my favorite song ever. If it ever comes on, I turn it up, and everybody shuts up, and everybody feels good. Incredible song...absolutely incredible.
I like Moss Gardens. I like the whole album in fact, but Moss Gardens is a really beautiful, atmospheric track. But then, I spose that's because aswell as loving Bowie, I love Brian Eno.
That is my favorite instrumental on the entire album, it's absolutely incredible. It really gives off a calming atmosphere, haunting almost. It's tracks like that which make Bowie's 'Berlin Trilogy' my favorite among his other work.
I agree the single version doesn't give you the same kind of impact the album version does. As for the rest of the album being ehh... it's still fantastic isn't it? =D
This song's pedigree is legendary. Produced by Brian Eno, and guitar work by Robert Fripp... Oh, my god... Pure musical bliss. I love this album!!! :)
Produced by Tony Visconti, Bowie was helped by Brian Eno. That is a common misconception Although Eno's presence is felt in the song, it isn't him who produced it.
Christiane F. Wir kinder wom bahnhof zoo.. havent seen that? Whatch it!!! 10 times!! its old but, well to good to miss!, ofcource depends of which childhood you come from maybe...
i don't know why this version is so hard to come by, most versions are the three minut versions that start on the third verse of this-nothing about "i'll drink all the time"
heard the german version for the first time y'day-very strange
i have a 12" vinyl promo copy of this...my prized record!
vazmo14850 1 week ago
i agree...low is absolute balls out Genius!!!
vazmo14850 1 week ago
One of the most beautiful songs ever written
montereypopfestiva67 2 weeks ago
Bowie's best album.
tanpiltanpil 3 weeks ago
whats the synthesisers voice?
124norge124 1 month ago
MASTERPIECE!
SKOTP69 2 months ago
I'm inspired by David Bowie, and I love his songs
meilfreak1 7 months ago
Seriously man. Hes right up there with The Beatles...without people like Bowie music would not have gotten this far (although to be honest music these days is quite shit)
splinter360 1 year ago
my alltime fav song!! so powerful.
agnessmash 2 years ago
his best song
walredhead 2 years ago
the last 2 verses make me proud to be gay!
fazzie12345 2 years ago 2
that bass line is sick!
TheFirstJedi 2 years ago
He outdid Sinatra"s "My Way" with his "Life on Mars" and outdid the Beatles "Hey Jude" with "Heroes"
sazerac1 2 years ago 3
@sazerac1 im sorry but nothing out does Hey Jude
IAmTheMan217 2 years ago
The synthesizer sound effect used in this song is what makes it amazing.
nirvanawg 2 years ago
changes or rebel rebel arguably better
Oberwoot 2 years ago
@Oberwoot or just different
Yosh997 2 years ago
This is Bowie's best song and nothing else is even close.
zacatecas2002 2 years ago 13
@zacatecas2002 Ha! "Fame" blows it away.
kipperfeast 3 weeks ago
jacob dylan and the wallflowers did a cover of this on the godzilla movie soundtrack
chubbykitty29 2 years ago
I don't think anyone here on this video cares about that.
UnsereLuftwaffe 2 years ago 4
lmao!!!
ekul85 2 years ago
and it was shit!
pinheadsen 2 years ago
Someone did a cover of this song, anyone know who it was?
tinsane73 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Best love song ever. EVER.
AFirmKickInThePants 2 years ago
Today's the twentieth anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall DB is referring to in this song!!
panera88 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song is at the end of the movie 'The Cove' it's a movie about killing dolphins in Japan. It's a very serious issue and we all shoul know something about killing dolphins, mercury in fishmeat and the provacy of that all. You have to see that movie.
LamboGallardoSL 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dolphins are gay Lambo the Japanese are doing us a favor.
IamDayoldHate 2 years ago
I have this album cover as a poster, it is my favorite!
drummerhere 2 years ago
WOW..amazing huh?
David Bowie is a genius.!!!!!!
seriously.a brilliant man!!!!!!!!!
KuanYin2424 2 years ago 2
What a song
cannibaljuice 2 years ago
This is the greatest love song of all time. David Bowie, while recording this album in the Studio By The Wall in Berlin watched 2 lovers meet by The Berlin Wall to kiss. It inspired him to write this song. The fact that 2 lovers, 1 from East Berlin, and the other from West would risk their own lives in the name of love is amazing.
Autonomy87 2 years ago 7
Autonomy87 - your story is romantic but if you ever saw the Berlin wall before 1989, you know that this is pure fiction. The only way to get near the wall, was in West. And nobody from East was allowed to go to West. As simple as that!
Tablemaker59 2 years ago
I read that in a biography of Bowie.
coronerchic 2 years ago
excellent song. I hate when they shorten a great song like this.
MrLukestardust 2 years ago 6
One of his best.
theendofconfusion 2 years ago 6
Woo simpsons Montage FTW!!!!!
GekiRinTouja 2 years ago
I love this song.
On the album Heroes he started with the line about "I, I will be king" yet in other versions I started with the dolphins stanza, I've also heard versions where he starts off with the "you can be mean" line. Anyone have any insight on this?
Been a Bowie fan for a long time and I always wondered.
eatmorenachos 2 years ago
I'm not sure about the "you can be mean" line. I believe he used that during his Serious Moonlight Tour in 1983. Also, the single version of this song starts cuts the first stanza off and goes directly to the third stanza. This version is the full 6:00 album version from his "Heroes" album in 1977
nesplayer94 2 years ago
I would have thought the dolphins stanza start was the radio edit because six minutes would be too long, while three and a half minutes is about standard. There are many songs which I have the full album version but get bits cut out for the radio.
thomrook10 2 years ago
One good example of song editing for radio is Yes' Roundabout originally around 7 or so minutes.
Funny but I think Hey Jude might be the only long song that was never cut for top 40. If so, well, we are talking about The Beatles. Another song on top 40 radio that, I think, was never cut was McArthur Park.
Stairway to Heaven was never cut too but it was a staple of FM radio, so that doesn't count.
mus1cat 2 years ago
I think you may be thinking of the film Moulin Rouge... There is a medley of a bunch of different love songs in it. The words are different though. In the film is "you, you will be mean."
Ami806 2 years ago
@eatmorenachos the single version (the old 45 rpm) started with I wish you can swim and ends before "we're nothing etc.". No wonder that it wasn't a big hit...the short version is complete nonsense. THIS is the original and BEST version of this WONDERFUL song
walbianco 1 year ago
@eatmorenachos I bought this album the day it came out and fell for this song. When the single came out I was so bummed that they edited it to cut the first two verses, they set up the whole song. Since the single was popular, I suppose that's why David usually did the "single" version live. Would much rather have heard the song as is (actually could have done without the "dolphins" verse rather than the first, made no sense to me).
Babaziba 1 year ago 4
@Babaziba ,
Thank you! I'd wondered about that for a long time. It was always one of my favorite songs but it seems strange not to hear it in the original (and better) form.
eatmorenachos 1 year ago
@eatmorenachos yeh, he has been singing this song for so many years he just forgets or likes a change like Lemmy with Ace of Spades
redqueensghost 7 months ago
@eatmorenachos there is a german version of this too. Bowie sings german the third line (i dont remember exactly). This version i mentioned is on the album "Christiane F." a soundtrack from "Wir Kinder vom Bahnhof ZOO" film.
sedlmayr 7 months ago
Call me crazy, but I'd say a lot of David Bowie's later stuff sounds a lot like the Velvet Underground.
ClassicRockSovereign 2 years ago
No, I feel you, actually.
I was listening, and an inner riff sounds a little like I'm Waiting for My Man.
argentofan123 2 years ago
The Berlin era was heavily inspired by Kraftwerk. Side 2 on LOW for instance.
pinheadsen 2 years ago
Sounds like they used a theremin
blackaggie 2 years ago
Really? I only hear Fripps filtered Les Paul fingering and Eno's synth additions. The Theremin really has no action signature and as such is an instrument that is totally unique. I am, of course, referring to hands on instrument action. The theremin is not touched at all. But please point to the sound you heard. Let me know.
joh3 2 years ago
I love that picture of him.
KaleidoscopeKidd 2 years ago
I'm somwhat new to David Bowie; however I've heard the majority of "Aladdin Sane", "Ziggy Stardust" and "Low" (in it's entirety). Truthfully I don't know what to think of Bowie, but I did love "Low".
JesusCristo2002 2 years ago
on the back of the vinyl record case it says recorded by david bowie in berlin by the wall
so in the song the mention of it is refering to the berlin wall because one of his band members went to meet his lover and bowie saw them kissing by the wall under a gun turet
samfrosty2k8 2 years ago
David Bowie+Robert Fripp+Brian Eno=Me knocked out on the ground with cartoon stars spinning around my head... :-)
SeifervsQuistis 2 years ago
I concur.
bartleby2007 2 years ago
This is the song that made me a bowie fan its 10/10
MegaBear1990 2 years ago 3
brill video
iggyziggy 2 years ago
The German version is excellent, he puts so much passion into the bridge section.
Heroes was a pure German product, pure Berlin in fact. The studio looked out onto the wall. Naturally to sing in German gives it lots of atmosphere.
paddy9i99 2 years ago
thanx for the tip, paddy! do u like 7 yrs in tibet mandarin version (this zig thinks it = killer)
zigCARNIVOROUS 2 years ago
I haven't heard 7 years in tibet Mandarin, are you being serious?!
paddy9i99 2 years ago
don't be dissin' low and lodger.
eno fripp phil collins and pete townsend amongst others made these three albums along with scary monsters amongst his best.
i still like his early goofy folk stuff best though like the laughing gnome.
bartleby2007 2 years ago
Bollocks.
'Heroes' is a great record, the only album of the trilogy, recorded, mixd and engineered in Berlin. Low wasn't and Lodger was just plain shit.
paddy9i99 2 years ago
I agree is an absolutely excellent record. The instrumentals are more interesting than those on "Low". I think that "Low" achieved more on an artistic level so from that perspective it is probably the best. But after listening to the entire 'Berlin Trilogy' over again I think I had more fun listening to "Heroes" it is a great record indeed.
nesplayer94 2 years ago
I have stood in the room in which the song was recorded, Studio 2 at Hansa.
Great feelings, great memories, great music.
Thanks for the video man.
This was a fascinating period in the artistic life of David Bowie.
paddy9i99 2 years ago
Classic song, simply brilliant!
retrodude01 2 years ago
Besides being very romantic, this song also ROCKS.
gus4u2c 2 years ago
Great bowie song classic!!!
APPLE6314 2 years ago
The thing about Heroes is that it is more Poppy and more accesible to the masses. And that is why I give it my regards as Bowies best album. It is not that it is this eclectic mess of thigns and odd recording techniques.
It took the sounds developed and misused on Low and propelled them to a straight ahead, jaunty, poppy, rock and roll, groove.
Rather than the Art Rock minimalistic mess that was side two of Low.
End transmission
Seifer267 2 years ago
The description of this video is absolutely spot on. I could not agree with nesplayer94 more. Low is a life-changing record to the right people, and Heroes is a great album, but nothing like Low. But the title track, "Heroes"....my god. It is literally my favorite song ever. If it ever comes on, I turn it up, and everybody shuts up, and everybody feels good. Incredible song...absolutely incredible.
Albeleo 2 years ago
Robert Fripp, Brian Eno, Bowie.... simply the best, an all time favorite
sa65cn1 2 years ago 5
absolutely sublime, some of the best vocals put to any song
eliotness4 2 years ago
kills me that most people only know the truncated version of this....
the first three songs; beauty and the beast, joe the lion, heroes...perfection.
the rest of the lp...ehh...but those songs were among the best bowie ever.
beautiful
TheCosmicFluke 2 years ago
I like Moss Gardens. I like the whole album in fact, but Moss Gardens is a really beautiful, atmospheric track. But then, I spose that's because aswell as loving Bowie, I love Brian Eno.
Nekhben1 2 years ago
That is my favorite instrumental on the entire album, it's absolutely incredible. It really gives off a calming atmosphere, haunting almost. It's tracks like that which make Bowie's 'Berlin Trilogy' my favorite among his other work.
nesplayer94 2 years ago
@Nekhben1 Can't agree more! Moss Garden is beyond words! I absolutely love that song!
doubleder 4 months ago
@Nekhben1 Brian Eno and Bowie. What a magnificent musical marriage!
Salineddi 2 weeks ago
I agree the single version doesn't give you the same kind of impact the album version does. As for the rest of the album being ehh... it's still fantastic isn't it? =D
nesplayer94 2 years ago
good song!
MyPepsiCola 2 years ago 2
Godlike song, end of.
GriefTourist 2 years ago
Didn't even know about this original version for a long time but that serves me right for not searching for any non-spiders from mars bowie
metrosfan 2 years ago 3
This song's pedigree is legendary. Produced by Brian Eno, and guitar work by Robert Fripp... Oh, my god... Pure musical bliss. I love this album!!! :)
picklejuicepj 2 years ago 5
Produced by Tony Visconti, Bowie was helped by Brian Eno. That is a common misconception Although Eno's presence is felt in the song, it isn't him who produced it.
JiggersGenius 2 years ago 2
Christiane F. Wir kinder wom bahnhof zoo.. havent seen that? Whatch it!!! 10 times!! its old but, well to good to miss!, ofcource depends of which childhood you come from maybe...
OxygenePanic 3 years ago
The album version is the BEST.... we can beat the just for one day!
midlifecrisis1968 3 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Absolutely brilliant. The Wallflowers also do a really good version of this song in my opinion :)
Ekulssorc 3 years ago
I think the Walflowers version strips it of it's originality, makes it bland imho.
bresmith 2 years ago 4
it sucks ass
fleamarket3000 2 years ago
i heard this song again in the movie 'christiane f'
it fits perfectly
BazzTheBoss 3 years ago
It almost sounds 90's ish or even from today, crazy.
and when he says 'heros' it sounds like 'hey joe' from jimi hendrix for like 2 seconds:)
xpurity666 3 years ago
Words cannot express how amazing this song is... it almost brings tears to my eyes...amazing
crocodilewerewolf 3 years ago 2
Kultur
OxygenePanic 3 years ago
thank you very much for have posted the long version!!
keith25658 3 years ago 5
How the f--k did he go from this kind of majesty to Modern Love in just 5+ years....i wonder if he regrets it now!
stev1963hit 3 years ago
The money in his account says otherwise!
PompadourSamurai 3 years ago
The full 6-minute version rules over the shortened single. Personally, I think shortening THIS song is uncool.
bobbyiscool1992 3 years ago
i don't know why this version is so hard to come by, most versions are the three minut versions that start on the third verse of this-nothing about "i'll drink all the time"
heard the german version for the first time y'day-very strange
cheapy2006 3 years ago 3
Thanks for posting my hero.Have you heard the english german version it's my fave.
cockaleekieman 3 years ago
yes I have and it is a very good version
nesplayer94 3 years ago