This is one of the best songs I have EVER heard. Illinoise is one of the most interesting records of the decade. However. This version is VERY disapointing
His album, "Come On Feel the Illinoise" is very polished, professional and densely-layered. So it would be too much for his live performances to match up.
That being said, I have watched several videos of Sufjan Steven's live performances and have come to the conclusion he is a very poor performer. And he has surrounded himself with some very amateurish backup musicians.
Come on, you have to admit this is a dreadful performance. It sounds like a hastily rehearsed high school talent show.
In an interview Sufjan said that he "likes to think of his performances as sounding like a grade six band." His courage to not have "polished" performances highlights something very unique about him. Don't watch the video, just listen to it. His voice is still very amazing.
wooooooo go sufjan i live in j-town thats Joliet illinois for you non-illini folk. and yes modell naming alot of small times like that means he did do his homework very impressive
Having lived in Illinois all my life, I'm quite impressed on how a non-native like Stevens seems to know a lot more about the state than I do...he's certainly done his homework!
I love the song, but I don't think the instruments mingle well in this live version. The acoustics are really bad at this venue, or it's just the camera
Why can't I like this more than once?
XmissXalyssX 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sufjan's performance on Austin City Limits is amazing. If you think he a bad performer, watch those.
TheSamuelGui 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheSamuelGui 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheSamuelGui 1 year ago
This is one of the best songs I have EVER heard. Illinoise is one of the most interesting records of the decade. However. This version is VERY disapointing
santiromerosaco 2 years ago 3
His album, "Come On Feel the Illinoise" is very polished, professional and densely-layered. So it would be too much for his live performances to match up.
That being said, I have watched several videos of Sufjan Steven's live performances and have come to the conclusion he is a very poor performer. And he has surrounded himself with some very amateurish backup musicians.
Come on, you have to admit this is a dreadful performance. It sounds like a hastily rehearsed high school talent show.
DFDalton1962 2 years ago
the trumpet has obviously been drinking, because he's fucking up even the simplest lines.
I think Sufjan is a fine performer. You have to remember you're judging this based on a cam taken from the crowd.
Check out his performance on austin city limits, it's pretty good IMO.
coldwind777 2 years ago
In an interview Sufjan said that he "likes to think of his performances as sounding like a grade six band." His courage to not have "polished" performances highlights something very unique about him. Don't watch the video, just listen to it. His voice is still very amazing.
MissAlexanderina 2 years ago
@DFDalton1962 my highschool band was the winner of many awards, so I'd say thats a good thing to sound like.
bitmap 1 year ago
bien décevante je trouve cette version live..
la chanson perd tout son coté posée tranquille..
tenshu74 2 years ago
EXCELLENT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
peppermintlemon 2 years ago
"of having been at last forgoooooot"
omg sufjan if u are out there, i'm yours!!!
another1shortdaymore 2 years ago
You have to get past me, first!!!
CinnCity78 2 years ago
*small towns*
alexpw12 3 years ago
wooooooo go sufjan i live in j-town thats Joliet illinois for you non-illini folk. and yes modell naming alot of small times like that means he did do his homework very impressive
alexpw12 3 years ago
Having lived in Illinois all my life, I'm quite impressed on how a non-native like Stevens seems to know a lot more about the state than I do...he's certainly done his homework!
And go Illini!! :)
modell588 3 years ago 2
LUCKY.
you live in illinois.
ilovemutemath 3 years ago
this song is strange, i live in kankaee >_<
not really a ghost town...
lol
but its cool none the less, the song has a haunting melody too it. :D
foblovesme 4 years ago
Good song, but I don't think they mixed it very well...
DarknessHowls 5 years ago
this is really good video. love the song.
jrtrobotdance 5 years ago
who is the girl? any relative to sufjan?
campfirestring 5 years ago
Katrina Kerns. She used to be a ford model, might still be. I think she has an album out too. Gorgeous creature.
bluesrunthegame 3 years ago
I love the song, but I don't think the instruments mingle well in this live version. The acoustics are really bad at this venue, or it's just the camera
MyNameIsNickKreider 5 years ago
Illini shirts!!
paulietchka 5 years ago
He sounded way better in Stockholm this wednesday. Unfortunately he never sung this song.
osmark86 5 years ago
That trumpet player is terrible.
Blackhawkphil 5 years ago
don't ever bash craig, he's better than your mother
sssllloooaaannn 5 years ago
Not at trumpet.
Blackhawkphil 5 years ago
this craig fellow is really botching(sp) most of his parts, the trombone player wasn't much better.
youzwan 5 years ago
Funky as all fuck. I was hoping for the three-part-harmony action at the end, but I guess that's kind of hard to replicate live.
chs
thenotfallingman 5 years ago
i love this song!
xthenaysayerx 5 years ago
Great video!
NoagKennedy 5 years ago