Hilary Duff and Joel Madden

[tinklove87]

they were the cutest couple ever. I dont see why they broke up. He looked so much like he loved her. I bet he thinks of her alot. I think Nicole is ugly she is way prettier and should have joel. Nicole you suck. Hilary is better. Love ya biotch. Muah

[Kemang21]

My opinion about this couple is " They were really great couple,but i think da reason Y Hillary leave Joel its bcoz Hillary is a grace women and soft hearted plus she have a normal life,so its kinda unmatch with joel that have a rock life style....... that we know its lil' bit wild,so i think its about they Ego who's doesn't really match and they diffrent lifestyle..." What do u think guys...?

[clarildinha]

esse cara é um merda ele é mt feio

[lunalila320]

i love tht song does somebody now who sing it??

[maryduff19]

The Cramberries-Kiss Me

[laurima24]

they looked so cute togheter :(

[TheeCookie]

They're SO cute!

[myownsummershoveit]

i think the video is very well done and veeery cute but the song definatley doesn't fit, i'm sorry. still great though!

[avvrill]

lol not!!!

i dont like hilary at all..

she's so jealous on Nicole!!

i mean..

Look at Joel, Nicole and Harlow they are family..

and hilary is still hilary.. lol

dont get me wrong but ... i just dont like her.. at all

[elinapple]

he cheated in Nicole cause he did not happy and he misses Hilary!!they should go back together.they are 2 parts of heart who separate from each other

[eline55]

i feel just the same!

[ybutterfly99]

this is a good video. i never wanted them together, i was so mad. i needed them to break up, cuz hilary need to date a pop star dude, like jesse mcartney. now it doesn't make any sense that joel is now with nicole richie. or pete wentz with ashlee simpson and worst of all benji with paris hilton. that world is differnt in hollywood. eww

[mychemfan102]

i think pete and ashley suit each other, and so does nicole with joel, i watched an interveiw and she got a lot more mature, but im not sure about paris and benji

[ghostlsdori]

I'm not sad about it, Hilary deserve SO much better.

Joel makes me sick !

[avvrill]

you FUCKIN FAT ASS!!!!

DONT EVER TALK BAD BAD THINGS ABOUT MY BABY!!!!!!!!!! NEVER OKAY

Hilary deserves a piec of shit and nothing SO MUCH BETTER!!

[ghostlsdori]

are you insane?

Talk to my hand xD

[avvrill]

you know what... if Joel makes you sick..

YOU MAKE ME SICK!

leave him alone ! <3

[009wonderful]

thy are soo cute in 1.58

[MissGanGsta4eva]

i think they were a great couple...i dont think i have seen joel smilin since he's with that skelleton nicole...

[Mathlize]

Yeah I would say that too..

[aznchic209]

Yeps, I agree. Ever since Joel and Hilary broke up, Joel has never been the same. He has tattoos all over his body now! GRR! I liked him better when he was with Hilary...I really thought they were gonna make it!

[mychemfan102]

whats wrong with tatoo's, the tatoo's on his arm are of jesus!

[edyeq89]

btw..i'm talking about what ferber14 said..hurm..bout hilary n joel..they really look cute together..n suits for each other..

[mterostation01]

I'm not much of a big fan of hilary duff...I use to be like a biggest fan ever...i use to have a lot of posters of her,,,nobody else but her on my wall. But They look so cute together...this is so sad..they were all cuddly towards each other :(

[smellyhippy93]

aw man so cute... miss jilary.. :(

[xXxRubySohoxXx]

What was the real reason why Joel and Hilary broke up?

[donna695]

viva nicooooooooooole!!!

[Pinnaccle]

This is really good! Matched really well

[troyana306]

mil veces prefiero ahilary k a nicole buuu ..

[so91940]

Ils allaient bien ensemble dommage que ce soit fini pour eux deux mais bon , chacun vit bien sa vie maintenant , belle vidéo ...

[NeonSk8teboarder]

Beautiful video :-)

[PiNKiSLOVE5521]

She must have been heartbroken when she found out that Nicole and Joel were going to have a baby :"( Hilary is such a sweetie. But they were never meant for each other. He was way too old for her.

xx

[firebrigade999]

How old was Joel?. Is Hilary aged 20?.

[PiNKiSLOVE5521]

..I think so I am not to sure

[firebrigade999]

Why is that?.

[Pinnaccle]

He was older than Hilary I think like 28 not really sure!

[firebrigade999]

How old was Joel?. Is Hilary aged 20?.

[anar101]

they are the cutest couple ever well were... they would of had a great family if they were still together...

[firebrigade999]

Joel and Hilary should of had a baby together.

[ferber14]

dude she said she wouldnt even get laid by joel until they got married apperantly he couldnt wait that long but comon what guy could wait that long

[edyeq89]

really?..wow..really rspect her..bcoz that's my principe too..but my bf still waiting for me until we get married..thnk god~

[MercieBoco]

the cutest! they belong together! :) nicole and him doesen't. but i think that joel is good for nicole.

[BloodyValentine16]

they really love each other ..its so sad that they broke up ..now joel is not the same ;(i miss them...and the worse thing is that benji is doing the same mistakes..he and sophie broke up and he is dateing with Paris Hilton..She is not for him ..Benji is too good for her..but it doesn't metter what they'll do i'll always love them ...

[eline55]

i totaly agree with you!! i love hilary and joel and i miss them , and benji is to good for paris!!!!but i always will love hilary,joel and benji!!

[syazmore]

they were so cute together

[ickythump55]

i dont like him

[babybirl009]

she shoulda had his baby...instead of nichole

[eline55]

yea

[Tabitha1029]

I wish they would get back together  :-(

[eline55]

i wish that to!

[benniskjaldbaka]

I think he was way too cool for her...:S

I love GC and I really don't like Hilary's stuff! ..wahtever

[eline55]

i love your video so much

[ag07811]

nicoles IS a ugly whore!!!

[yellow2]

hell yea she is!!

[ag07811]

glad someone agrees

[kliasder9]

they were a good cople then nicole richie

came in the story!!!!!

[eline55]

yea but i'm not sure that it is because nicole that they split up... but i miss jilary every day!!

[dolliey]

JOEL N HILARY WERE SO GD TOGETHER!

[eline55]

i miss jilary to

joel and hilary were perfect togheter hilary is so much beter for joel then nicole

[robloweissexy123]

I Hate Jilary!!! Nicoles way better for him plus theyre having a baby together

[michelletatosian]

I miss Jilary Joel deserves better than Nicole my boyfriend thinks so to

[YouAREsoDUNZO]

this video is absolutely adorable! i miss Jilary..Nicole and Joel arent a horrible pair but i just liked joel and hilary better! Can you tell me where you got the pic at 2:21-2:22..its so cute!

[LaceylovesJonasBros]

They were so cute together

they made a great couple...he is the rocker and she is the former disney star it's like they brought to worlds together and the 8 year age difference...big deal I mean look at ashton kutcher and demi moore they have a 15 year age difference and are doing great.

Too bad they can't get back together since Nicole is having a baby...hmmmm how do we know it's his?...just kidding...they were great together.

[casseychazzzzzzzzzzz]

when hilary hug joel look so sweet...y!!!y they broke up!!!

[xwalsh14x]

i agree i think they were a cut couple and what do you me he changed her she actually died here hair for a film rle

[madbad01]

It's dyed.

[KayteeSmith17]

Hilary and Joel were such a cute couple! I can't believe they broke up! I just don't like the fact that not even a month after they broke up, Joel moved on to be with the biggest skank in Hollywood, Nicole Richie! I hope he gets Aides from her!

[theblacksalviulos]

uhh that "picture" that Joel was throwing away was a card!!! and they weren't even going out thenn!!! Anyways, they were such a cute couple while they lasted!!!!

[123iluvmiley]

WRONG!!!! they were not a cute couple!!! do u people even know that he changed her? he is the reason that she had black, oh, and brown hair. ever since their breakup, she has had BLONDE hair!

[eline55]

is it all becuse of joel that she had brown and black hair?

[maddenduff545]

what's song name?

[okhilaryduff]

Kiss me

[liliroxx54]

they made such a cute

couple...!!

how could they have moved on soo fast?

dat sux..!!

[jujufunes]

they look so happy!

[oulion21]

Yeah, it's a shame they broke up...

[Juggalette4ever55]

how cute! ...im jealousss

[70sBuff]

once u loove somebody then ur always gonna nd if u try to go out nd find better then ur gonna end up losing wut u had nd missing out on wut u could have had!

[juicyduff]

at 2.37 - 2.44 it shows joel chucking away a photo of hilary.. is that from a music video they have done? if so waht one please ? xx

[hottiehat09]

yeah it's from good charlotte's first cd... i think the song name is motivation proclamation... something like that

[soyotelo]

nice video

[hannahlovers333]

i really likeed hilary and joel

and i wish they would get backk together

i like nicole richie but i dont like joel and nicole together

shes already pregnant..-.-

[bhotpepper]

where'd you get the clip at 1:37???

[DieCoonDiesBitch]

I think he still loves Hillary!

[xPrincessxBright]

wow that was a really dream couple

[BillyMartinfan]

aw.. they are so cute together it's crazy :D

[linalalinde]

ps el de nicole richie y el...

[linalalinde]

nooo ps, casi casi lloro...asi super en seriooo!! q vuelvaaaaaaaaan! pero el problema es....el bebecito este q van a tener! q se podria hacer con el haber... mmmm jajaja

[GCSahara]

mh...nice video.....its a pitty....hilary was better than nicole...and they matched better.....mh...but ok....this are their lifes....mh... :(

[soniaxt]

i hate nicole..

[pinkoxo]

its so annoying how celebritys move on so quick after they declare there luv 2 someone an then next minute there goin out with her friend they just all pass there boyfriends round it quite gross an nicole richie is pregnant already an him an hilary only just split so he didnt waste any time.

[benjimaddenrox12]

oh and by the way its a very nice video i luvv it!

[benjimaddenrox12]

If Joel didnt want to settle down and Hilary didn't want to party basicly im saying that if there wasnt such a big age difference...THEN...they would have split up. they made a nice couple though! I LUVVV BENJI! and i hope everything goes well with Nicoles baby's birth!

[purearab]

Joel + Hilary was not meant to be. Hilary should go out with Jesse McCartney.

[marianlee1411]

they wer the best...why are they shatterd?? why?? and why nicole joel?? WHY THE FUCK IS IT DAT BITCH NICOLE??

[9sujata]

thnx 4 the post! i miss them! r they really history now?

[greendayobsesser]

omg they only went out for like a week!

[pinkoxo]

cant believe they split up they seemed really happy an cute its a shame an in the part were he is on the phone in a phonebox is that a music video they were in together.

[IdeeFixe09]

The one he was in was Predictable and she in Coming Clean, seperate videos for their seperate careers. But it blended nicely, didn't it?

[missjodie1234]

WOW!! the best hil/joel vid i ever seen, well done!! but the split at the end makes me sad, even though im a huge fan of nicole richie, you can just tellthat them two are so much better together :'(

[pinkspinker]

man, they made the cutest couple ever. they really loved each other, you can tell.

[princessperfectbaby]

aww snap u made da cutest love video in history muah kissses i LOVE YOU AND YOUR VIDEO!!!!!!!!!

[Princessxblonde]

i heard hilary was the one to break.. and the words she said bout nicole and joel in her interview to "seventeen" were nasty! it was so mean of her..

[IdeeFixe09]

I've got that magazine and what she said wasn't mean. She said she felt disrespected by Joel for moving on so quickly to Nicole [who she didn't even mention by name].

[Princessxblonde]

and what bout "rebound" and that joel has changed so much bla bla? i'm not against hilary i like her but she shows HER disrespect by saying such words in the interview.

[kvelasquez3]

casi me pongo a chillar!

porque terminaron?!! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!

[PeachyVelvet]

2 bad they're not togethaaah anymooWe .... !

[okhilaryduff]

Gracias por los comentarios =)

Thanks for the comments =)

[BeaStorm]

un video genial, muy bien hecho!

[L0velyCharMing]

I'm sooo jealous!! I love Joel, he's my hero!

[sodin0926]

wow so many hugging and kissing.Hilary is so damn lucky man haha!!wonder why joel love her cuz joel's so rock and hilary so erm..sweet??haha dont know how to say..anyway they're not together already??how come??!!

[bettyGH]

i like your vidoe so cute vidoe:) i like when they dating

they so cute

[stringrose]

Oh my god they was just so perfect together...Now he's with Nicole...pffff

[caiofirmino]

what music is that?

I love it!!

*-*

[JoelandHilaryfanKH12]

so cute!! i loved them together so much. i can't believe he's dating nicole richie aka nicole bitchie now!! hil is so much prettier and nicer (i think) i hope joel dumpes the skank and gets back w/ Hilary

[emogrl987]

that was sad. they were the cutest couple. notice how happy joel was and now he's like not as happy. i almost cried :(

[4thS]

Watching this video with the pictures make me wanna put the broken heart back together :'()

[Sk8terERICA]

holy crqap,i loved it! i loved the way you put them talking on the phone with there video clips,that was mazing,favorites,5/5 loved it!!

[maddy246]

beautiful vid =] nice video clips of them together!!

[stracciatella91]

I know, I don't know her, so I can't judge her

but she looks like a sweet dolly bird ;/

[adriadriaa]

Yep..HE cared about HER alot...when she was on the Tyra Banks show she said that she needed "space" to be a regular 19 yr old..

[bahamas411]

lilhis vid is better

[lwyte]

fuck you justin, you yeasty little bastard

[BasketLady]

he´s like a perfect boyfriend.. but i think joel and nicole are better and cuter together than joel and hilary...

[poculum]

it`s sooooooo cute!!! =)

[musicalmarina]

great job dude!

[grrr1991]

they where very cute together i really though he was very gentil with here and very carefully so cute!!!

[shaleena21]

aww this is so cute. It looks like he cared about her ALOT

[itmustsucktobeyou]

R.I.P Jilary ='[

I saw this on Myspace a while back.

<3

[Shiyomi]

FUCK NICOLE RICHIE!!!!!!

[lwyte]

hilary is a goddamn fucking retard that should get a life

[justinbiblion]

you are a retard that should get a life. You should get an old fation country ___ whippin'! (Ya, I'm a Trace Adkins fan too)

[lwyte]

wow, don't even have enough courage to cuss, how dissapointing...

[horrorshowsneety]

aw cuute, i didn't even like them together but i still loved the video. nice job!

[joymaryhilary]

they were sooooo cute!! Richie sucks :(

[prash0330]

look its hil's decision. we r no one to interfereor to gv our opinions

[asli345]

they are so sweet it is so bad they broke up ı love hilary but ı wish they didint broke up and tharks for the video

[14xoxohsmxoxo14]

WOW... if anythings depressing its this video, hats off to you, this video is amazing

[Schoolaholic]

they made such a cute couple!!!

[greendayfreak55]

shutup i dont want my mom to die!!!

[arlidogs]

i agree nicole is dirty as and way too discustingly skinny and boring. yukkk

[Melly2214]

if you hate them don't post them

[jickis]

What is this song...I love it! (Good video too!)

[jickis]

I love them together. Wish it could've lasted longer.

[racthelynn]

aww sweet i miss them sniff

[randumgirl]

its all been said so i cant really say anything,lol

[cemeterydrive24]

Nicole is a rebound chick for joel

[oth00]

i completely agree! that better be all she is. he can do so much better

[corres13]

I miss them, honestly..  I think he should get back together with her. Nicole is disgusting, and she obviously has problems!

[hdrocks]

i absolutely loved jilary, but can i just say hilary dumped joel and i dont think she will get back with him but i really hope she does

[maddenduff545]

fuck Nicole (bitch)Richie!!!!

[outtathisworld051094]

i hate nicole richie, what happened to them? and why nicole out of 1000 girls in the world? I thik he should get back with hilary, you can really see the love between them, when they kiss, hug, hold hands, hug, smile, look at each other, they belong together... i hate nicole richie, she should talk to him about getting back with hilary, Joel _ Hilary=never ending love

[merkamoon123]

nicole richie is a skinny skank, *sigh* wish they hadn't broken up. hilary and joel were so cute together! besides, nicole is just a temporary replacement for hilary, the relationship with nicole and joel ain't gonna last

[roguexxxroguexxx]

I Don't like Nicole Richie :|

Idiot.

[angel48]

ditto. she is a skank like parasite. you rock hilary.

[calebmw]

gacelduff i think this is his new one because his other account got suspened

[kerencr1291]

Amo el video!!! Me enkanta!! 4/5 WOW!! FElicidades!!

[gacelduff]

wowowow increhible edgar cudiate vales mil bestfriends xD salu2

[okhilaryduff]

Thank you very much for your opinion aneva123, your opinion will help me to improve my creations in a future =)

[gallardo5500]

ohhh spare me

[aneva123]

This was so cute but I think near the end when you show that they're broken up with the split pictures and suff the song didn't match but still good 4/5 stars.