He's not doing anything to denigrate the piece, the style is just a little too foreign to the scene and although the cat's got chops, he just lacks the subtleness I'm used to. He's playing it very straight and very safe. But I don't blame him, takes guts play with a band with Buddy's style and tenacity ingrained on it.
I prefer Dave Weckl's version, Phil is playing it too safe and not showing what he is really capable of doing. Phi Collins is a great drummer and I wish more drummers would do what he is doing here. Wouldn't it be great to see a prime time tribute to Buddy Rich like this on television as opposed to the usual crap that is out there right now????
stop being downers for god sake there's ppl who couldn't cover a phil or michael jackson song if their lives dependent on it and phils playing tribute to one of his jazz/drummer heroe damn get a life personally he's got great instrumentals of his own right can't stand narrow minded ppl
stop being downers for god sake there's ppl who couldn't cover a phil or michael jackson song if their lives dependent on it and phils playing tribute to one of his jazz/drummer heroe damn get a life
@simpkal He's not trying to replace Buddy Rich. He's paying tribute Buddy. Because he 's not playing like Buddy does not mean that his playing is sad.
We just got given this in our school big band. I've never been so happy in my life :D
Benedictwesson 1 month ago
@Benedictwesson Yes Ben!!
JakeBulldogz 1 month ago
The older tenor rips! hes so hip!
wyattcooper123 5 months ago
He's not doing anything to denigrate the piece, the style is just a little too foreign to the scene and although the cat's got chops, he just lacks the subtleness I'm used to. He's playing it very straight and very safe. But I don't blame him, takes guts play with a band with Buddy's style and tenacity ingrained on it.
Gazcarter111 6 months ago
Steve looks a little old to be playing that strong. Not as good as old times though... But still great!
MrJazzSaxophonist 7 months ago
It just doesn't sound right with Phil's drumming style.
1WFE3 1 year ago
I prefer Dave Weckl's version, Phil is playing it too safe and not showing what he is really capable of doing. Phi Collins is a great drummer and I wish more drummers would do what he is doing here. Wouldn't it be great to see a prime time tribute to Buddy Rich like this on television as opposed to the usual crap that is out there right now????
203marcos 1 year ago
Lets not forget the Dave Weckl performance that set the bill for this number!
adentee 1 year ago
stop being downers for god sake there's ppl who couldn't cover a phil or michael jackson song if their lives dependent on it and phils playing tribute to one of his jazz/drummer heroe damn get a life personally he's got great instrumentals of his own right can't stand narrow minded ppl
45wolfer 1 year ago
stop being downers for god sake there's ppl who couldn't cover a phil or michael jackson song if their lives dependent on it and phils playing tribute to one of his jazz/drummer heroe damn get a life
45wolfer 1 year ago
he's good,, the best way to learn jazz is playin' jazz, maybe he plays too many rock, and he forgot how to play jazz
frnndogoal 1 year ago
personally, i think it's sad that phil collins tried to take buddy rich's spot. nobody can fill his shoes. but great song and band!!
simpkal 1 year ago
@simpkal He's not trying to replace Buddy Rich. He's paying tribute Buddy. Because he 's not playing like Buddy does not mean that his playing is sad.
Phil is being Phil not Buddy!...
ceetee21 1 year ago 9
@ceetee21
yeah you're right. my comment came across a little harsh. goes to show how much i miss buddy haha
simpkal 1 year ago
@simpkal It's all good!
ceetee21 1 year ago 2
IS that steve marcus?? :)
rduffy338 1 year ago
Phil collins is a good drummer... but still nothing could beat the buddy version!!
rduffy338 1 year ago
They could have gotten a drummer a million times better than phil collins to do this.
Stratosteven 1 year ago
Really? Yes there are better drummers but not a million times better.
ceetee21 1 year ago 7
@Stratosteven watch the version with dave weckl, it's soooo good
ryanmooney92 1 year ago
@Stratosteven You mean: a drummer...
ZeBurck 6 months ago