Float On - GHWT vs RB2 - X Guitar

[jOnIcksS]

GHwT

[carlosmenciaROX]

Wanna know what's charted more accurately?

A real guitar tab.

[BlueMoonz55]

@carlosmenciaROX RB has that option now.



[Tiwaking]

It would be interesting to see the Rock Band 3 Pro Guitar chart vs Guitar Hero chart since, you know, the Pro Guitar is an actual guitar.

[python935]

Rb wins da day lik always sory gh but u lose:)!

[mistermeekl12]

lego rockband vs. gh5 song 2

gh5 wins by over 9000%

[MrBball0]

The fuck wiff what

[ElBeatlemaniatico123]

This The Beatles Rock band

[MrBball0]

nahh chill rock band it awsome its wayyy better than guitar hero

Guitar Hero: was made in the 80's n they kept makin jus better names of it. its like gettin a yankee hat wit the same sin n different color

Rock Band : was made in 2007

[ImSoAwesome45]

@MrBball0 Guitar Hero was made in the 80's? The fuck?

[Dankscarver]

@MrBball0 da Fuck? I think you're mixing up Rock's the 80's with it actually being in the 80's.

That or your mixing up two different games.

[NightmareSnake]

GH wins the day.

[Ozzmaster2112]

GH:WT has a better chart.

[rawrxitsxrachael]

i like rock band better because of the way the songs are set up, and guitar hero makes it confusing... plus the guitar buttons are too close together for guitar hero, and the guitar is smaller...so the rb guitars are easier to use...

[gordodefuego]

i like RB2 better

[damaged776]

You can convert this or any youtube video to an mp3 at audiogetnow..com

[ShaydeRogers]

Guitar Hero killed it xDDD I still rep my WT ;D

[accquizzer]

Guitar Hero for being more challenges and more on track

[fingadude]

i vote ghwt

[freakout389]

i think rb2 in more in tune for fun :D and gh is hard

[mensager110]

gh harder if u disagree fk off

[CrimsonDIEnamo101]

@mensager110 yeah it is harder lol

[AnAverageAzn]

I see so many people arguing over which is harder. If anything the only thing that should be compared in this video is how loyal both GH:WT and RB2 remain to the original song. You've got to understand, this song is EXTREMELY easy to play even on the REAL guitar.

[Ozzmaster2112]

@AnAverageAzn

Yeah i agree i'm taking guitar lessons (just started today! =D) and i learned to play "Iron Man". It's even easier than the GH1 version!

[superlukko]

RB2 the best

[LightSwitchToTheMind]

Personally, I like Guitar Hero better. And WoR is going to kick-ass. Not saying RB3's going to be bad (keyboard's look freakin' awesome), but I'd rather reserve WoR than RB3. But, to each to their own, I guess.

[favorflavor101]

the reason RB is easier is because it's slightly slower and GH keeps their notes closer to the actual song, which i like better. it gives people a challange

[BFMVLieven]

If you ask me , RB is too easy :)

[markmark111]

@BFMVLieven so you've totally Gold Starred what a horrible night to have a curse on drums, and the same for painkiller, panic attack, and the Yngwie Malmsteem DLC?

[BFMVLieven]

@markmark111 No i think the guitar is too easy on RB the guitar is harder on GH

[markmark111]

@BFMVLieven the note window is smaller.

[tanklimuel]

I don't like Rock Band because at times when I play it at my friends house there's no difficulty with the songs. Everything is way to easy to play so it really gets borin' after a while. Second everybody talks about how many songs Rock Band has for downloads which if u think about how much money u waist just to download a bunch of songs, for example, my friend has nearly 90 songs as downloads on tht game now add up how much money he waisted on those.

[SuperChuckMe]

@tanklimuel Maybe Uour Freind Was Nice And Did It On Easy For You.

U Moron.

[tanklimuel]

@SuperChuckMe Boy I play Guitar, Bass, and Drums on Expert and Expert + on drums. So I don't know what u play on but when i play the two rock band is usually the easier of the two.

[TheDescent]

@tanklimuel Can't really say how people still say that rock band is easier. Guitar Hero is easier for me because of timing window, and rock band got a lot of DEATH METAL for DLC that you can't even imagine. What a horrible night to have a curse and This is Exile are harder than any song on the guitar hero platform, for each instrument. Also, look at some rbn song, you'll see yourself how complicated they are.

[markmark111]

@tanklimuel

wasting money is a matter of opinion.

[InsideOutGaming]

Rockband wins,in opinion. More instruments,thousands of songs,and more choices. Character creation,etc. GH Fail.

[GotParody]

Both games by harmonix. So please shutup.

[holyelectricalsocket]

lol for the single notes in this song theyre the same except they're one lower on GH.

rock band FAIL.

[greenorange75]

Rock Band is gonna have keyboards! In your face, Guitar Hero! :-P

[InsideOutGaming]

@greenorange75 Thats right! Can I get a Holla?

[greenorange75]

@InsideOutGaming HOLLA!

[MrGibbonz]

From playing both games at a high standard i can safely say the rockband tabs are much easier. HOWEVER, guitar hero guitars and the fact the notes are greyed out for tapping make GH much easier. For example many of the harder songs on rockband would be much easier for me if they were the same notes just on the GH platform. Also hard GH tabs (eg the solo on in "one- metallica" would just seem impossible on rockband although i can do it on GH3 :S.

[noviski10]

Rock bands better because rock band notes are square not circle.

[Ikebixcezare]

guitar hero is much harder

[AZRangerJr]

I think rb is so much better than guitar hero.

[blahblahblaha1a2a3]

is this same difficulty setting and same instrument?

[greenorange75]

I HATE those overlapping notes on Guitar Hero's side on 0:55. I had nightmares about them before they existed. Now they do! Aaaah!

[laughablemania]

i dont see a difference exept guitar hero has O shaped notes and rock band has [] shaped ones

[wiccan31576]

if i can remember correctly isint float on like, one of the hardest songs on ghwt? i mean its up there on the list

a bit misleading a harmonix?

[DAVO0621]

To theguywho1 you are a fag

RB:The Beatles and RB:2 bot topped gh metallica, aerosmith, and wt do your research

RB rocks and will be remembered longer than gh!

[XxSoulxSteelersxX37]

how can you compare two different game with each because of one song. Comparing one songs doesn't mean anything.

[TheRecessedOne]

Fuck gh rb2 is better by all perameters

[UFC813CHRIS]

I like guitar hero better, and theGUYwho1 has a good poing, without guitar hero there wouldn't be a rock band, at least not yet.

[theGUYwho1]

the fact of the matter is with out gh their is no rock band, another fact is rb sales tanked hence the gh metallica& van halen, aerosmith. i know their are rb fans out their but you people dont have to get mad that people who play gh are more skilled and made the better choice. people with iq make the right choices, followers just go to the rb and rb2. but when everything is said and done gh will be the game remebered for way longer and rb will be long forgoten. p.s. fags play rb lol

[jester5637]

Jimmybshaw: I understand you alot games are pointless but what will happen if makers stopped making them do u know how much chaos will b out n I prefer rb2 gh are bitters n people say rb was an experiment plus ghwt wasn't charted right with the notes they did add extra n people say rb was an experiment who ever like gh over rock band is ohnestly a loser I'm sorry if it has to turn out like that but it's the truth and the truth hurts: I'm out

[theGUYwho1]

actually the truth is rock band was a failed experiment, and the sad truth is rock band fans are fags no one likes rock band & never will hence why theirs gh contests and no rb contest, mind you idiots like you will get together with your friends and have contests but that doesnt count lol people like you need to get the chip off your back just cuz someone who plays gh took your woman from ya doesnt mean ya have to take it out on the world. if ya have to just kill yourself the world will love it

[XxSoulxSteelersxX37]

i just wanna make a point if you get your woman taken from you over a video game means your a fag. and just because guitar hero makes more games doesn't mean anything the released like 6 games this year. It doesn't mean they are the better game. and stop talking about gh like you are in love with it they are both games and that's it deal with it.

[jester5637]

I think I'm my opinion to rb2 rocks no matter what. What I did is went a lil further n did my reasearch on rb n gh n saw it was the same creator

[AldySy]

in my opinion.. all guitar hero does is add in random notes to make it harder... i think rock band 2 is better charted... no im not a fanboy

[peaceout895]

guitar heros harder

[XxSoulxSteelersxX37]

i'm sorry but guitar hero is easier

[xxsghnrbfanxxs]

rb2 drums and vocals awsome ghwt bass and GUITAR awsome ghwt hard songs are great and rb2 graphics are great

if u put them together u will get an amazing game i shuld kno i own both games

[GuItArHeRo9002]

are they like different? like on is bass and one is guiatr?

[peaceout895]

no they are just from different video games

[mrwii52]

rb2 is so awsome. but guitar hero's guitars are better but rock band drums are way better then guitar hero's. and rock band is a better game over all.

[DietCokeWitDrPepper]

I like rock band is better

[acezospad3s]

rb because the verse chords are just too fucked up to be charted right and the chorus was spammed too hard by activision to premote their new gh features (sustained+singles)

[Raflan1257]

@acezospad3s not neccisaryaly . Lol if ur the kind of person who likes older music then ghero is cool but rock band has newer songs .

[acezospad3s]

uh guitar hero doesnt have many oldies. rock band has like 16 grateful dead songs, like 10 who songs, like 3 jethro toll songs, among many others. yeah rock band has new stuff like a7x and chinese democracy but it also has its old classics too

[Raflan1257]

well true but if u own the new ghero world tour there is only 3 new songs rest are old and i used to have rock band but the gitars broke on me and i took great care of it o.o i still like g hero lol

[FriendOfSorrow]

Rb is better cause it goes alone with the music better, Gh is more flashy which is stupid and besides the guitars for Gh suck.

[Au4Ob08]

1:52 shows that the GH chart is better.

[pilipali100]

hey rb2 is lot of times better the any gh trust me i know i have rb2,gh 3,gh wt and gh gh(greatest hits)

[TheSpeedfreak14]

@pilipali100 ha not true at all man. i own rb2, gh2,3, areosmith, gh wt, smash hits and metallica. gh takes it.

[pilipali100]

well that is your assesment(or what that word is)

sorry of my bad english :P

[TimeForShitpickel]

through most of the song i would say rb but at that point i definently can see that gh did a better job representing that section

[fallenleaves32]

rb2 no contsest

[MrFaelon]

Guitar Hero is just too Orginal !

[mycoolgoodvideos]

rock band 2 wins...GH just charts rhythm only...Rb charts rhythm and lead ...which makes it more fun

[UnoOfTng]

GH is more realistic! GH, ftw! I do admit that Rockband has a lot of good songs though

[newmanjordan1]

both games are really fun. the good thing about gh:wt are the instruments, like the drums are a little more realistic, but rb2 has better songs. but i think gh:wt is better barely just cuz da instruments

[AznJerk510]

Rb2 cause its faster

[bloodvein3]

funner to play on ghwt

[Kaokidx10]

GH 4TW!! OK every one is P'Oed that GH copies RB but think if they didnt who would by it? besides because they did we have 2 awesome series(plural spelling?) so stop bagging on GH its an aesome game

[666HeinekenBeer666]

GH:WT = WIN

RB2 = EPIC FAIL

[pengeneral]

so y did ghwt copy from rb2? the orginal makers of gh made rb but sold it to activision. and then they made the band game. and then ghwt came with the copied drum and singing ideas. rb2 win.

[Sinlexs]

With some GH songs its the lead guitar and RB its rythem or opposite. Probably what happened with this song. They are honestly about the same

[mycoolgoodvideos]

rb is charted more accurately

[grimmyrlz118]

@mycoolgoodvideos Agreed but i think guitar hero is better because its charted worse makes it more fun ;)

[lstealbikes]

Guitar Hero had a lot better feel and more of a realistic touch to playing the song. If you listen closely you can see Rock Band switches in between main guitar and 2nd guitar. In my opinion thats bullshit.

[callofduty2100]

rb sux

[pengeneral]

rb2 winz

[JimmyBshaw]

In my opinion.

Its a game.. and a song.

some perfer rock band, some perfer guitar hero. i use to be a rock band person, but im done with these games..

they become pointless, im a guitarist, not a plastic player. so i choose to play a real instrument.

in my opinion, this song is so much funner to play with a real guitar then these plastic guitars.

but still, play your games if it makes you happy.

[ReagleBeagle101]

Almost the same lolz.

[ashleyashleyishot]

rock band is the best, the hammer ons are easier to see,and the chart is almost perfect, but on guitar hero the chart is way off and they add extra notes, or take out notes , and the hammerons are hard to see

[AlbinoJedi]

hammer-ons are way easier to see on guitar hero since they actually look different by having glowing white tops and no black ring on top. the rock band hammer ons are just a tad smaller than normal notes so its hard to tell.

[jonasbrothers491]

i'm used to playing it on guitar hero if i played it on rock band it might mess me up idk

[rockfan856]

i think gh wt chart is better

[bloodvein3]

agreed

[360galore]

Get a room you queers.

[spideyzul]

seems like GHWT's mnore challenging

[artemaus10]

woah guys! I just gave my opinion on it and you guys got all freaked out alright! There is clearly no need for you guys to get all bitchy on me!

[VansMaster12]

rock bands frets looks realistic but guitar hero is more to straight but have patterns ts cool

guitar hero 78 percent

rock band 98

[RequiemSoup]

Everyone knows that GH pwns RB, and I know I'm gonna probably get shit for this, but fck it I'm just stating my opinion.

But I guess if I had to explain myself (which I really don't need to do) I choose GH because I'm the kinda dude that enjoys a challange in a game, GH does that such thing, where, to me, RB does not provide..

[Pitzhakepab]

So you say songs like Painkiller, Green Grass And High Tides, Constant Motion or Thrasher don't provide enough challenge?

[RequiemSoup]

No I didn't not say that those songs didn't provide any challange at all. I didn't even list any song names.

And sure Rockband may seem more realistic but most of its song patterns aren't to tricky as GH's.

[pengeneral]

can someone help me at the hospital? i coud not survive painkiller *drums* expert. go rb2!

[tyklug2013]

bcuz they intentionally make the notes harder

[RequiemSoup]

And thats what I enjoy about it. The intention to make the game harder.

[tyklug2013]

i guess we all hav opinions

[RequiemSoup]

exactly :)

[tyklug2013]

Finally some1 on the internet that i dont know personally that isn't a dick. :)

[RequiemSoup]

haha isn't it wonderful?

lol :)

[artemaus10]

Rock Band FTW GH just copied them! RB BEATLES!!

[sithwalrus]

they came from the same company. guitar hero was first, rock band split off around GH3, so RB was the copy. yes, they had full band first, but are you really going to call that a big innovation? "if we can sell a game for 50, controllers for another 50, then why should we just stick with two? lets get them to buy a whole set." it was just a matter of time.

aside from that, there have never really been any innovations in these games. there is nothing worth copying.

[diehardpatriotfan]

Guitar hero came way before rockband

and it's made by the same people

what the fuck are you idiots babling about?

[pengeneral]

becuz the original makers of gh made rb.

[mattforget12]

depends what you are judging by the note chart or just how u play or just idk there's so many categories

[VampireGirl961]

Guitar hero is WAY better than stupid rock band.

[Pitzhakepab]

What exactly makes it stupid?

[VampireGirl961]

Well Rock Band copied Guitar Hero and Rock Band is toooo easy Guitar Hero is more challenging

[Pitzhakepab]

Actually Rock Band is made by Harmonix, which also created Guitar Hero, so they didn't copy anything, at least not from Guitar Hero. It was Guitar Hero that copied RB by adding mic and drums.

[12Saintsrow]

Guitar Hero was made by Harmonix who created Rock Band. So they really didn't copy anything!! But to be honest, GHWT copied the drum idea which is stupid.

[inevitabledoom44]

dude you just said that there both made by the same thing, so GHWT didn't copy crap from RB, they simply added it as a feature.

[JimmyBshaw]

no because harmonix sold guitar hero once they made rock band. so the new owners copied rock band

[bloodvein3]

the drums for rb suck tho. they dont have noise cancelling like the ghwt drums do i swear im using rockband drums and u could hear the sticks hitting the pads from the other side of my house, it that fucking loud

[linkinpawkrules]

@12Saintsrow oh yeah? well if guitar hero cant copy rock band for the drums, then rock band cant cops guitar hero for the gem colours and stuff

[12Saintsrow]

u think rock band us 2 easy. have u played painkiller on rock band 2? wow

[VampireGirl961]

Yeah, wasnt that hard but i admit it was a challenge (:

[LittleLucky777]

Here's the thing, notice how the notes are the same. People still don't understand that Harmonix is still with Guitar Hero and Neversoft just took most of it while Red-Octane own the other part. so pretty much RB and GH are together.

[ABCproductionsBFF]

i dont like guitar hero because when you use star power all the notes turn blue. in rock band the the note thingy has blames and the notes stay the same. overall i like rock band 2 the best

[dasebilbao]

rock band is the best always

[toontown234]

Guitar hero wins rockband has a fat ass

[austingetzthesmall1]

yup

[al41al]

gh wins but i can play expert on gh but i play hard in RB2

[pieceopaper]

guitar hero pwns rock bands ass

[tma112]

I like both

[zewund]

i think that gh capurted the movement of the hands better than rockband but there both not close to the real thing

[NonZeroPossibility08]

rock band is more realistic. guitar hero makes songs more difficult than they are if you just pick up a guitar and play them. guitar hero also adds unnecessary notes, as evident in Blink 182's Dammit off of World Tour and Silversun Pickups' Lazy Eye.

[bryanisweird1298]

ghwt wins rockband is too easy

[axuzu]

but they are both still fun plus rock band started the full band thing so guitar hero is kind of stealing their idea.

[GuitarHeroGeek3]

Guitar hero WT is an ecxellent thing to start on because it is like 20 thousand times more difficult than RB2, RB2 they made too easy, its more recreational in the end tho because you get the glory of saying you played it on expert. GH WT is an excellent way to waste 7 hours like i did when i first got the game and a great way to get carpal tunnel much sooner than rockband games. they are all equal in the end and GH did kinda steal the idea but i think they made it a little better.

[axuzu]

Well in the end it comes down to which one has more songs you like, but like I said earlier I enjoy them both.

[tiagojeff123]

GHWT , definitly

[MajiinFreddy]

rb2 ftw.

Gh sucks

[NeonMite]

GHWT is better

[Dragonstermant]

Wt is fucking bullshit. if you like it your a stupid fucking cunt. WT came out of an asshole, made by one, and played by one

[9keogh]

i prefer Rock Band 2 but gh is more accurate

[pengeneral]

they both contain pieces that can't be charted at the same time. both are partially accurate.

[jakejackjoe]

GH More accurate.

I'm glad I found Float On on GHWT, great song

[ItachiUchiha50999]

RB is easier so GH all the way i luvs me a good challenge xD! thumbs up if u agreee if u thumbs down then u obviously dont kno a good game wen u see 1 eh?

[cmitch419]

This song may be easier on RB but RB requires more precision for hits so GHWT looks impressive but the tolerances are so high, it's hella easy to play.

[joel99268]

do u even own rock band, the song list in rb is way harder then guitar hero's. the songs that are put in both games look harder on guitar hero but rb has harder songs. still i love both games though :)

[GuitarHeroGeek3]

what you just said didnt make too much sence, but i never had a though to prefer one over the other so good for you. why is everyone killing each other over what game is better? Dragonstermant has some major problems. if he hates the game and thinks "it came out of an asshole" then what makes him think that the rest of us care about HIS particular opinion at THIS paticular moment anyways. i clicked on this video out of curiosity, not to start World War III.

[DylonDaPwner]

You're an idiot.

[freand80]

Guitar Heros one is harder.

This song is great :)

[ArmisticeOfFire]

RB has the hardest songs between the two, though. They're putting up the hardest songs now

[kurtdied4outsins]

isnt float on in rb1?

[NelsonCrush]

yeahhh rock band is the original

[danielberven701]

that shits easy

[jakylpops]

did you download this song on GHWT? or do you unlock it?

[armyalex11]

I could do that....

Easy much?

[dragonsyth10]

lol yeah its pretty damn easy but its a fun one to play

[kurtdied4outsins]

it looks like the guitar hero chart is lead guitar and the rockband is rythem.

[djb103]

its kinda lame rockband dont have sustaint notes and slider notes.

if they did that before guitar hero world tour did, no one would buy gh:wt except for the songs. thats the only reason they might buy it

[WHiiSPERINTHEWIND]

GH IS WAY BETTER

[brightmatt2]

i nvr realized how stupid these games wer until i actually learned how to play guitar

[MattaTatta92]

guitar hero looks harder. like th eintro riff is harder cos you have chords that you have to strum, whereas RB has a mix of chorsds and single notes to pull off and hammer on. That makes it easier

[guitarsrock92]

gh may be more challenging on guitar, but rb has better drums and vocals

so overall, gh is good if its only you playing, rb is better if you have friends and want to start a band

[lucywoof08]

GH RULES!!

[123spiker123]

I never really liked the RB chart for this one. WT is the better chart, IMO.

[superrootbeer197]

gutiar hero rulz!!!!!!!!!!!!

[HockeyFreak102]

guitar hero. looks more challenging. =/

[monokuropoo]

somewhat. guitar hero is harder and more notes. but rb2, its harder to hit the notes. personally i like guitar hero better

[Drihscol]

rockbands just looks more fun...

[MJLaneTV]

GH Looks SOOOO much better IMO

[gizmofreak789]

Guitar hero looks better