You know what else would have been funnier?? Erik magically pulls out a hidden immunity idol and blindsided Parvati, but that, obviously, did not happen. :(
You know what's funny?? If Cirie and Natalie actually went with Erik and voted out Parvati, they could've actually won the game..... Erik would've then gone on to beat Amanda at the next immunity challenge, and the final 3 would've been Erik, Natalie and Cirie.
But nooooo. Cirie just had to stick to her alliance even though she knew that she was on the bottom of it. And Natalie only cared about 'the sentimental value of beating all of the men....'
Why won't they give it up? He said he's sorry, he can't do anything to change what he did. Get over it. Why did they keep beating a dead horse? He did the honorable thing by forfitting.
yes its a dumb move, if I were on the show I would never give up my immunity, but he wouldnt have won the season unless he won two more challenges... so if the girls DID keep their word (which we knew wasnt going to happen becuase natalie is a huge bitch with a stick up her ass) he might have gained some jury votes out of it, and surely would have won. but wake up people...THE MOST DESERVING PLAYER HARDLY EVER WINS THE GAME.
@631Whatsgood Parvati played better than russell. I think he deserved 19 but not 20. I also think Twila deserved it more than Chris in Vanuatu. I also think people only deserve to win if they are in the finals, otherwise i would say Ami deserved to win Vanuatu.
@004Daniel Chris was the only male left with about 6 females, I think he showed great game playing skills by being able to turn the women agaisnt each other, plus Twila had no honor or integrity compared to Chris, not saying you have to have honor to deserve to win but if you're being pitted agaisnt somebody who played the game just as well, but with honesty you should lose.
also I disagree, Terry on Panama played the best game that season, yet he didnt make the finals.
@631Whatsgood Twila and scout were really the ones that started turning on the girls. Chris didn't make them turn on each other, he just made sure they wouldn't turn back to each other. Twila and scout gunned for eliza and when Ami finally agreed they went and told eliza it was all Ami's idea with Leanne. Twila got eliza, who hated her, to vote against the one person that cared about eliza. I still think you have to make your plea to the jury to deserve to win. Cirie's social>Terry's
@004Daniel true but I dont think its always about who has the best social game, for Terry to win 5 immunity challenges in a row, to me thats huge. He played the best game in my eyes just based on his sheer determination and perseverance. They wanted his torch snuffed since the merge, and they couldnt ever do it until the end.
Maybe I'm just a fan of playing the most honest game you can, although it seems to me like the honest ones never win.
@631Whatsgood Yeah. I mean they were the best players of their season, but you have to make it to the end to deserve to win. I agree social shouldn't matter at the final tribal, but if he had better social game he would have swayed numbers in his favor. Also, you said Russell should have won, but he was not honest at all. Just saying...
@004Daniel You're right, but then again Russell controlled that game like a puppetmaster, AND made it to the end.. he deserved that game over the two tag alongs he brought to the end, nobody played with a strategic mind at all that season. Now lets say he made it to the end with a player like Cirie or a Twila (had players like that been in the season) then thats a different story.
@631Whatsgood Are you talking about s19 or s20? Parvati and sandra weren't tag alongs at all, but natalie and mick definitely were. Parvati controlled russell in 20 and she won the most immunities when she needed to. She played honorably, staying true to the villains all the way and staying true to danielle and russell, her alliance from day 1.
@004Daniel I was talking out s19.... in s20 I believe either Parvati or Russell should have won, Sandra was just dead weight being kept around for whatever reason.
But to be honest, I give Russell the most credit for s20 becuase he was taretted by Boston Rob in the very begining so for him to get that far was pretty impressive, I think Russell not having won either one of those seasons is bull
@631Whatsgood Him not winning s19 was insane. Him not winning s20 was understandable since Parvati outplayed him, but I expected it to be close between them instead of Sandra wiping them both out for nothing. I just found out Candice and Sandra were friends cause they lived near each other and rupert was her friend from pearl islands. Plus, amanda couldn't get over the fact Parvati beat her. JT and Colby shocked me since they were the physical beasts of their season yet didn't award Parv for it.
parvati was the most luckiest bitch to ever win a season, 3 quits, people giving up, dumb players. UGH Look at JT and Tom, they totally deserve to win their season
@zimdelinvasor ikr he knew he was the only guy left he knew they wanted him otu ke knew he wast he next to go i lvoe james line ivel sot my ring as dummest survivor ever
this is the dumbest fucking move in this game besides ozzy and jason not playing their hidden immunity idols and they knew they were targets but they still never played their idols bur this is a pretty fucking awesome perfomance by natalie
without a doubt, the DUMBEST move in Survivor history...I don't know how JT's move was dumber than this cause he (along with all the other members of season 20) didn't know Russell and his gameplay, etc. He only handed him an idol and not the necklace, but then again, still a dumb move just like Marty handing Sash his immunity idol
yep, and tell me again how these "fans" were supposed "hard core fans of SURVIVOR".
100% that these "fans" were cast because they were weak willed and would do whatever the vets told them to do no matter how it went against their own best interests.
Yeah, he is kind of dumb. I don't believe money is better than companionship, but you don't come on this show to make friends with other people. Most likely he won't be seeing any of these people again. That's probably for the best too.
@DanielsKDJ I never understood how cirie was a heroe. I guess since amanda made it to the end twice? I think since cirie was an inspiration to people that watch the show and then try out, she was a heroe to someone. Idk, I think they just wanted Parvati alone on a tribe and the fan favorites; cirie, amanda, and james all together.
this will ALWAYS be the dumbest move ever... JT's move may have earned the "official" title, but it was a legitimately respectable move based on a perfectly logical assumption. i'm not a JT fan, but i hate when people attack him for a ballsy-ass move... to win the game, you have to be willing to make giant moves. what JT did was ballsy. erik, on the other hand... come on. really?
@zimdelinvasor JT's move was not ballsy. It was reckless. Do not assume because you will make an ASS out of U and ME. He is a villain and they don't know who he is. You can't trust your friends in the game, let alone strangers on a different tribe. Erik had been coerced by the girls going crazy on him all day and at tribal, which lasts about two hours. He still had to win two more immunity challenges. This move was stupid, but JT's was worse.
@hipstermi Lol that's because the girls teamed up together to manipulate him into giving up the immunity cause they wanted an all women final four. You don't have to have muscles to win survivor...just gotta know how to play the game and how to play people!
Lesson that was learned from this tribal council: if they are trying to get you to give up immunity, then they are basically telling you that they want you gone (I was almost sure that Randy from Survivor Nicaragua was going to be voted out because of this)
@ParvatiisAwesome Oh wow, I am so stupid, lol. Yes, I mean Marty from Nicaragua. Eventually, not keeing the Hidden Immunity Idol did cost Marty, now that that season is over.
this was my favorite survivior EVER. I love Parv. she has always been my favorite. she was too funny in in this season. hell when this happened half the girls were like at a lose for words. LOL you were so played dude.
@gavinweaver13 That said, Erik was a student of the game. It's definetely safe to say noone else studied the game more than him, so he really should have known better.
Wow. And here I thought Jason was the most gullible, wet behind the ears, schnook to ever partake in Survivor but Erik with a move like that he has to take the cake. That has to be officially the dumbest move ever on the entire history of Survivor!
@nmv262 Colby was pretty stupid with his final 2 move as well...he cost himself 1 million dollars by taking Tina to the end instead of Keith...had he taken Keith, that check would've been his
The votes speeches are just hilarious. All of then!
Erik: "Oh God!"
Natalie: "...but thank you."
Amanda: "you know..." (the best!)
Cirie: the mom's quote
Parvati: "Ever!"
Best blindside of the history. Amanda and Cirie were on fire! Parv went to Exile so Erik couldn't get the idol. And Natalie was the one that he thought he could trust. Just perfect!
Man... block by block, brick by brick the girls really built, as a team, the ground work for Erik to hang himself by handing over the immunity ... but you have to hand it to Cirie for cementing that final "glue" into place for kicking Erik over the edge and making this ridiculous $1million dollar dumbass move
@toptenguy1 ... Amanda to me has always been one of the most beautiful (if not THE most beautiful - much more so than "Poverty") of all Survivor women - but to answer you question - I think she out did everything on the last "Heroes vs. Villains" when she came on as a Jury member for the first time after being voted off. Look it up on here or on CBS ...absolutely sweet and beautiful and "bring her home to meet Mom" in every bit of her smile and walk and persona.
Cirie claims girls can always beat guys with using your brain. Note she she "always" sounds rather sexist... Hmm she is a hypocrite I seem to recall a time in survivor heros vs villains when Tom used the Hidden immunity idol and got enough people to vote out Cirie! So Cirie it'd be rather wise to say "you can almost always beat them with "these" (refers to brain). You can outsmart peons but against the best your just a one trick pony. Perhaps you needed a new game plan a third time around huh?
@Eskara0 Tom didn't beat Cirie. That was JT because he flipped. JT destroyed the heroes by voting out Stephenie, Tom and Cirie when Colby, Rupert and James were weaker physically and mentally. By doing that he made Candice feel isolated, that's why she flipped and he took out the only people that would have told him, "Keep the fucking idol, you moron."
@josevazquez1987 Jason had that beat...Randy's fake idol was pretty similar to the real one...Jason on the other hand, believed that a stick with eyes and a mouth was the real thing
Close call. Natalie and Cirie the dumbest move in Survivor history or Erik. The result Parvati winner and Amanda the runner up. Just what his move was aimed to prevent if only Natalie and Cirie had looked futher than top 4 and the stupid girl vs guys agenda.
How is this NOT the dumbest move in Survivor history? (In the S20 reunion show, J.T.'s giving Russell the idol was deemed the dumbest, but THIS, IMO, CREAMS it.)
AMANDA'S BLINDSIDE ON ALEXIS WAS THE BEST MOVE EVER, THIS WAS BY FAR THE DUMBEST MOVE EVER, BOTH THE SMARTEST AND DUMBEST MOVE IN THE SAME SEASON AND BACK TO BACK TOO
Don't see how JT's move is dumer then this. Sure its dumer from a viewing stand point but they never saw russles season and they never new what was going on at camp and it was a smart move if it worked. but Erik was just brain dead.
Look at them all smiling and leaning on each other as he's voted out "HA HA WHAT A DUMBASS HE TRUSTED US." And voting out the person who gave you immunity? What a bunch of bitches.
Let this be a lesson to everyone who watches this: Women love money more than kindness, and any amount of effort or act of love you put toward them.
@TopOfTheScoreboard I'm a girl and I don't love money more than kindness. I think the lesson here is that you should *never* allow people to manipulate your feelings so much that you give up the one thing that makes you safe. It's one thing to do so as a strategic move, it's *another* to do it because your emotions got the best of you.
@TopOfTheScoreboard Wow, looking back at my own comment, I was being really hateful. I've changed my opinion on this since I've had a good female friend enter my life. Back when I wrote this I was really bitter and feeling kind of alone in my life. Not only is my previous comment childish and immature, it is written badly and thoughtlessly too. I'm glad I'm a changed man.
Erik should have won the Dumbest Survivor Ever award. This was far more stupid than James not playing his idol, Tyson accidentally voting himself out, and JT giving his idol to Russell. There was logic behind the risks that James, Tyson, and JT took (and Russell took a huge risk by giving his idol to Parvati, because if Tyson didn't vote for her, Russell would've been the idiot). But there was no logic whatsoever behind Erik's move.
He would have won if he progressed esp when I saw the final immunity challenges. Cirie was awesome but Amanda was a horrible player. Why did they bring her back even once. Eliza,Alexis and Ozzy were all more memorable IMO.
@abcdefg3451 Or Courtney or Sandra...aside from snarky comments, none of those two was evil enough to be a villain...everyone else on the tribe deserved their spots
I don't care if JT won the award at the reunion, Erik is still the dumbest Survivor ever. He only won because of short-term memory by the audience. I even consider what Tyson did dumber than JT's move.
@LTomlinson31 i know right. JT didn't know the situation in the villains tribe and russel was the wild card...nobody knows how he played the game in samoa, and he needed russel for votes in a merge. Erik was in a minority in this group and he gave immunity to someone in the majority. Definitely the dumbest move!
@LTomlinson31, I agree 100%. I say anyone with short-term memory loss should not have the right to vote. This move by Erik far surpasses any other dumb moment in Survivor history. J.T.'s move was a lot more risky in dumb. There's no way he could have known it wasn't a woman's alliance on the Villains tribe.
@jwdogfst What I find the biggest difference too: if J.T's move was successful, greatest move in Survivor history, you think? But because it doesn't work out, its all of the sudden the dumbest? If Erik's move worked out, no one would consider it even a bit smart. Same with Tyson's. And it was very easy to believe an all-woman's alliance was praying on the men. Erik's move...... no logic whatsoever, unlike J.T's.
@LTomlinson31 I totally agree -- at least about the fact that Erik still made the dumbest move ever. J.T.'s move was reasonable from his point of view -- he just misread the situation. Erik -- he was played by four very smart women and he was in the minority! Idiot.
@NYChica23 To me, what made him look even more stupid was how he laughed at Jamie for using a fake idol, which looked almost exactly like the real one and she realized was probably fake, but might as well take the chance and then he got voted off with two of them.
@indigo12ash Yeah, it was almost as hilarious seeing the women trying to hide their "Holy mackeral, he actually did it" look as it was seeing Erik get voted out for his troubles. But the funniest part was seeing the reactions of the jury members -- especially James! I loved seeing him laugh out loud after Erik gave Immunity to Natalie. He didn't even *try* to hide his reaction!
It rfeally wasnt that dumb considering he had no shot to win the game. No one on the jury was going to vote for him. He said im gonna give this immunity up and take the risk of getting voted off. If they didnt vote him off he would have gained respect from the jury and won the game. It seems like a really dumb move..but whats the point of making the final 3 and getting no votes, take a risk.
@waytoomany10 It was dumb, you have to consider that there was 4 woman, and the won the 3 last immunity challenge. He was the biggest .. "danger"( idk the word in english), and they even told him at the tribal council before that.
You know what else would have been funnier?? Erik magically pulls out a hidden immunity idol and blindsided Parvati, but that, obviously, did not happen. :(
dayborne35 2 days ago
I'm wondering if Brandon from South Pacific watched this season, lol
byranntherockstar1 1 week ago
Ohhhhhhh, I felt so sad when Erik started to run after having his torch snuffed. He's probaby never going to trust a woman the same way ever again.
MrBen51309 1 month ago
Enjoying the quality.
2Funny4YouMan 1 month ago
Hes trying to get a million dollar date what a fool.
Tex200950 2 months ago
History has been repeated
MummyGaGa 2 months ago
You know what's funny?? If Cirie and Natalie actually went with Erik and voted out Parvati, they could've actually won the game..... Erik would've then gone on to beat Amanda at the next immunity challenge, and the final 3 would've been Erik, Natalie and Cirie.
But nooooo. Cirie just had to stick to her alliance even though she knew that she was on the bottom of it. And Natalie only cared about 'the sentimental value of beating all of the men....'
MrBen51309 3 months ago
@MrBen51309 That is why Cirie did not deserve to win. She couldn't look at the big picutre
zt1053 2 months ago
i wonder if this guy knows just how fuckin dumb that really was?
penske13 4 months ago
240p... we meet again at last!
handello 4 months ago
@handello hahahahahaaa. i wonder if anyone else will understand that.
penske13 4 months ago
so naive, it is a GAME, should not give a damn for so-called respect!
benaparis 4 months ago
Erich would have fit in perfectly with all the retards that were on Survivor Redemption Island
adheckle 4 months ago
I think it's funny how no one other than Amanda got the joke about James being the dumbest player...well unless I guess he told them about it.
ipodnano4334 5 months ago
@ipodnano4334 I think the jury knew. Eliza seemed to get it.
004Daniel 2 months ago
HAHA james ive lsot my ring as dumemst survivor ever i was laughing when eric lsot
calicofan998 5 months ago
00:54 haha, Amanda is so funny
gule1990 6 months ago
James laughing. Sorry but we know you James
MrKadirbey 7 months ago
Why won't they give it up? He said he's sorry, he can't do anything to change what he did. Get over it. Why did they keep beating a dead horse? He did the honorable thing by forfitting.
Onefleshabiding16 8 months ago
they are all asswholes i no he was stupid but really? Get a soul
vitalsemtex 8 months ago
Best part is that Eric still betrayed them, as he was supposed to vote for Amanda.
JohnBigOz 8 months ago
yes its a dumb move, if I were on the show I would never give up my immunity, but he wouldnt have won the season unless he won two more challenges... so if the girls DID keep their word (which we knew wasnt going to happen becuase natalie is a huge bitch with a stick up her ass) he might have gained some jury votes out of it, and surely would have won. but wake up people...THE MOST DESERVING PLAYER HARDLY EVER WINS THE GAME.
631Whatsgood 9 months ago
@631Whatsgood
Instances where most deserving player didnt win...we could be here forever
season 2- tina wins. colby most deserving by far
season 3- ethan wins..lex most deserving
season 6- jenna wins (really?) rob c most deserving by far
season 11- danni wins... Rafe most deserving by far
season 12- aras wins..wow.. Terry dominated this game
season 13 is a toss up..ozzy and yul both played great and it was a close vote
season 20- russell owned this game..totaly garbage he didnt win.
fml
631Whatsgood 9 months ago
@631Whatsgood season 11 stephenie was most deserving to win by farrrrr! she played an awesome gameeee
agujeroagujero 9 months ago
@631Whatsgood Parvati played better than russell. I think he deserved 19 but not 20. I also think Twila deserved it more than Chris in Vanuatu. I also think people only deserve to win if they are in the finals, otherwise i would say Ami deserved to win Vanuatu.
004Daniel 2 months ago
@004Daniel Chris was the only male left with about 6 females, I think he showed great game playing skills by being able to turn the women agaisnt each other, plus Twila had no honor or integrity compared to Chris, not saying you have to have honor to deserve to win but if you're being pitted agaisnt somebody who played the game just as well, but with honesty you should lose.
also I disagree, Terry on Panama played the best game that season, yet he didnt make the finals.
631Whatsgood 2 months ago
@631Whatsgood Twila and scout were really the ones that started turning on the girls. Chris didn't make them turn on each other, he just made sure they wouldn't turn back to each other. Twila and scout gunned for eliza and when Ami finally agreed they went and told eliza it was all Ami's idea with Leanne. Twila got eliza, who hated her, to vote against the one person that cared about eliza. I still think you have to make your plea to the jury to deserve to win. Cirie's social>Terry's
004Daniel 2 months ago
@004Daniel true but I dont think its always about who has the best social game, for Terry to win 5 immunity challenges in a row, to me thats huge. He played the best game in my eyes just based on his sheer determination and perseverance. They wanted his torch snuffed since the merge, and they couldnt ever do it until the end.
Maybe I'm just a fan of playing the most honest game you can, although it seems to me like the honest ones never win.
631Whatsgood 2 months ago
@631Whatsgood Yeah. I mean they were the best players of their season, but you have to make it to the end to deserve to win. I agree social shouldn't matter at the final tribal, but if he had better social game he would have swayed numbers in his favor. Also, you said Russell should have won, but he was not honest at all. Just saying...
004Daniel 2 months ago
@004Daniel You're right, but then again Russell controlled that game like a puppetmaster, AND made it to the end.. he deserved that game over the two tag alongs he brought to the end, nobody played with a strategic mind at all that season. Now lets say he made it to the end with a player like Cirie or a Twila (had players like that been in the season) then thats a different story.
631Whatsgood 2 months ago
@631Whatsgood Are you talking about s19 or s20? Parvati and sandra weren't tag alongs at all, but natalie and mick definitely were. Parvati controlled russell in 20 and she won the most immunities when she needed to. She played honorably, staying true to the villains all the way and staying true to danielle and russell, her alliance from day 1.
004Daniel 2 months ago
@004Daniel I was talking out s19.... in s20 I believe either Parvati or Russell should have won, Sandra was just dead weight being kept around for whatever reason.
But to be honest, I give Russell the most credit for s20 becuase he was taretted by Boston Rob in the very begining so for him to get that far was pretty impressive, I think Russell not having won either one of those seasons is bull
631Whatsgood 2 months ago
@631Whatsgood Him not winning s19 was insane. Him not winning s20 was understandable since Parvati outplayed him, but I expected it to be close between them instead of Sandra wiping them both out for nothing. I just found out Candice and Sandra were friends cause they lived near each other and rupert was her friend from pearl islands. Plus, amanda couldn't get over the fact Parvati beat her. JT and Colby shocked me since they were the physical beasts of their season yet didn't award Parv for it.
004Daniel 2 months ago
@631Whatsgood Also, yeah Russell was targeted by Boston Bob, but Parv was targeted by every single player on BOTH tribes even before the game began.
004Daniel 2 months ago
@631Whatsgood Wait your saying Russell deserved to win?
TheGothicEmpress 2 weeks ago
You know you're dumb when JASON is shaking his head at you.
AndyRantz 9 months ago
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHA THIS IS FRIKKEN HILARIOUS!! giving up ur idol just to gain respect like really?!
kyo0teboo 9 months ago
parvati was the most luckiest bitch to ever win a season, 3 quits, people giving up, dumb players. UGH Look at JT and Tom, they totally deserve to win their season
isyutd159 10 months ago
THE PRICE IS WRONG!!!
SurvivorPoison 10 months ago
Stupid
SiHanGooner 10 months ago
this is hard to watch if your a guy, erik would of for sure won it, unbeleivably ridiculous move
gregmacfd3 10 months ago
what a guy
longfootbuddy 11 months ago
wasn't erik suppose to vote for Amanda instead of Parvati?
JohnBigOz 11 months ago
this never stops being funny. i love erik but... come on, man
zimdelinvasor 11 months ago 18
@zimdelinvasor ikr he knew he was the only guy left he knew they wanted him otu ke knew he wast he next to go i lvoe james line ivel sot my ring as dummest survivor ever
calicofan998 5 months ago
hahaha ozzy is like fuckin idiot
zinchukk 11 months ago
Erik is the biggest idiot in survivor history! He could have won this season...
88Leinad 11 months ago
lol at james laughing
hbkpower 11 months ago
LMAO!!!! Funniest thing ever.
realitytvfreak 1 year ago
this is the dumbest fucking move in this game besides ozzy and jason not playing their hidden immunity idols and they knew they were targets but they still never played their idols bur this is a pretty fucking awesome perfomance by natalie
1montrealfan 1 year ago 2
without a doubt, the DUMBEST move in Survivor history...I don't know how JT's move was dumber than this cause he (along with all the other members of season 20) didn't know Russell and his gameplay, etc. He only handed him an idol and not the necklace, but then again, still a dumb move just like Marty handing Sash his immunity idol
AroundWDW4Free 1 year ago 2
yep, and tell me again how these "fans" were supposed "hard core fans of SURVIVOR".
100% that these "fans" were cast because they were weak willed and would do whatever the vets told them to do no matter how it went against their own best interests.
XChupacabras 1 year ago
Such a dumb ass:
Ozzy just laughed and shook his head
TerraDangerJonas 1 year ago 2
HAHA! James is no longer the dumbest Survivor!
*Recall Survivor China*
MinahBelohz 1 year ago
in the words of red forman......DUMBASS!
drunkenpimphand 1 year ago 2
Yeah, he is kind of dumb. I don't believe money is better than companionship, but you don't come on this show to make friends with other people. Most likely he won't be seeing any of these people again. That's probably for the best too.
TopOfTheScoreboard 1 year ago
Comment removed
TopOfTheScoreboard 1 year ago
pure stupidity...
TestY0urMight 1 year ago
So this is the reason Cirie and Amanda were brought back as heroes. For screwing over a great guy like Eric.
DanielsKDJ 1 year ago
@DanielsKDJ I never understood how cirie was a heroe. I guess since amanda made it to the end twice? I think since cirie was an inspiration to people that watch the show and then try out, she was a heroe to someone. Idk, I think they just wanted Parvati alone on a tribe and the fan favorites; cirie, amanda, and james all together.
004Daniel 2 months ago
You know what is the funniest thing? That Erik still voted for Parvati instead of Amanda as he would've been told.
JohnBigOz 1 year ago
dumbest player ever. i love jeffs line thats what you call a life lesson. that may be the best final 4 ever. that and yuls final four.
movieman104 1 year ago
this will ALWAYS be the dumbest move ever... JT's move may have earned the "official" title, but it was a legitimately respectable move based on a perfectly logical assumption. i'm not a JT fan, but i hate when people attack him for a ballsy-ass move... to win the game, you have to be willing to make giant moves. what JT did was ballsy. erik, on the other hand... come on. really?
zimdelinvasor 1 year ago 3
@zimdelinvasor JT's move was not ballsy. It was reckless. Do not assume because you will make an ASS out of U and ME. He is a villain and they don't know who he is. You can't trust your friends in the game, let alone strangers on a different tribe. Erik had been coerced by the girls going crazy on him all day and at tribal, which lasts about two hours. He still had to win two more immunity challenges. This move was stupid, but JT's was worse.
004Daniel 2 months ago
Dumbest. Move. Ever.
NorthStar20121 1 year ago
anyone who discredited cirie is senseless. FACT
nooriskandar 1 year ago
i love this season. cirie was rocking this game
nooriskandar 1 year ago
I find it so mean that they voted for Erik. He was so nice. I felt sorry for him T-T
msmaple 1 year ago
I loved how Eric had a face of disbelief and shock...when he should have seen that coming from 1 lightyear away.
MeBomb1 1 year ago
That was stupid of him...but that dumb bitch he gave the idol even voted against him!
Stupid ass...he was "stranded" on this island and thought he would get something off the hot chicks.
hipstermi 1 year ago
@hipstermi Lol that's because the girls teamed up together to manipulate him into giving up the immunity cause they wanted an all women final four. You don't have to have muscles to win survivor...just gotta know how to play the game and how to play people!
cutiepatootie120 1 year ago 6
LOL watching how he runs in the end was priceless. If I was him I would run until I die. Someone that stupid doesn't even deserve to live.
cc22ful 1 year ago
4:00 i love her expressions lol
gule1990 1 year ago
If Eric had the hidden immunity Idol and he gave his idol to Natalie, he would have won Survivor.
MrSamXxXxXx 1 year ago
Im gald they didnt, but i think it would rock if Natalie and Cire accualy DID vote Parvatis name. It would be the best blindside EVER.
gavinweaver13 1 year ago
Omg I bet he lost sleep over that. :P
TheDustinBroke 1 year ago
In a way this made Cirie not win Survivor..
ramdomisfunny 1 year ago
@ramdomisfunny huh, why so?
nooriskandar 1 year ago
I ADORE PARVATI AND CIRIE
nole122 1 year ago 22
@nole122 i adore amanda and paravti!!!!!
STARWEB912 9 months ago
Lesson that was learned from this tribal council: if they are trying to get you to give up immunity, then they are basically telling you that they want you gone (I was almost sure that Randy from Survivor Nicaragua was going to be voted out because of this)
byranntherockstar1 1 year ago
@byranntherockstar1 You mean Marty. Randy was apart of Gabon.
ParvatiisAwesome 1 year ago
@ParvatiisAwesome Oh wow, I am so stupid, lol. Yes, I mean Marty from Nicaragua. Eventually, not keeing the Hidden Immunity Idol did cost Marty, now that that season is over.
byranntherockstar1 1 year ago
He is like FABIO
TheFillyPhan 1 year ago 4
this was my favorite survivior EVER. I love Parv. she has always been my favorite. she was too funny in in this season. hell when this happened half the girls were like at a lose for words. LOL you were so played dude.
StarbucksAwesome 1 year ago
Whats that tune at 4:00?
EAOAFG 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Bitches! They are all bitches!
MrSantaClaws1001 1 year ago
poor eric
TheZeddyboy 1 year ago
OMG this was just too easy for those girls... like taking a candy from a 2 year old LMAO
eswolf84 1 year ago
I think JT was dumber. I mean Erik was played by Parvati, Amanda, Cire and Natalie, all GREAT players. JT had a guess
gavinweaver13 1 year ago
@gavinweaver13 That said, Erik was a student of the game. It's definetely safe to say noone else studied the game more than him, so he really should have known better.
haytrav3 1 year ago
@gavinweaver13 You are so right.
004Daniel 2 months ago
Wow. And here I thought Jason was the most gullible, wet behind the ears, schnook to ever partake in Survivor but Erik with a move like that he has to take the cake. That has to be officially the dumbest move ever on the entire history of Survivor!
nmv262 1 year ago 2
@nmv262 Colby was pretty stupid with his final 2 move as well...he cost himself 1 million dollars by taking Tina to the end instead of Keith...had he taken Keith, that check would've been his
NYChica23 1 year ago
@badger5079..........LOL. I would have pulled out my dick and pissed all over those biatches faces.
nmv262 1 year ago
LOL! What a DUMBASS!
Ilzaza2 1 year ago
Black Widow Brigade - best aliance ever! Ever!
The votes speeaches are just awesome! Especially Amanda's "you know..." Lol!
dbalesteros 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The votes speeches are just hilarious. All of then!
Erik: "Oh God!"
Natalie: "...but thank you."
Amanda: "you know..." (the best!)
Cirie: the mom's quote
Parvati: "Ever!"
Best blindside of the history. Amanda and Cirie were on fire! Parv went to Exile so Erik couldn't get the idol. And Natalie was the one that he thought he could trust. Just perfect!
dbalesteros 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
dbalesteros 1 year ago
a little random but wtf is ozzy wearing?????
greekchic1 1 year ago 2
@greekchic1 Looks like some sort of poncho
NYChica23 1 year ago
How JT got the worst move in survivor history is beyond me... this was wayyyyyyyy worse.
TheAndybeale 1 year ago
Man... block by block, brick by brick the girls really built, as a team, the ground work for Erik to hang himself by handing over the immunity ... but you have to hand it to Cirie for cementing that final "glue" into place for kicking Erik over the edge and making this ridiculous $1million dollar dumbass move
anonyms404 1 year ago
Comment removed
anonyms404 1 year ago
Best thing about this is James laughing.
Blaiwnez 1 year ago 35
@Blaiwnez Not to mention Eliza's facial expressions...those alone crack me up
NYChica23 1 year ago
Can Amanda possibly be more beautiful than right there?
toptenguy1 1 year ago
@toptenguy1 ... Amanda to me has always been one of the most beautiful (if not THE most beautiful - much more so than "Poverty") of all Survivor women - but to answer you question - I think she out did everything on the last "Heroes vs. Villains" when she came on as a Jury member for the first time after being voted off. Look it up on here or on CBS ...absolutely sweet and beautiful and "bring her home to meet Mom" in every bit of her smile and walk and persona.
anonyms404 1 year ago
all women are bitches. this is the proof.
rajithaify 1 year ago
Cirie claims girls can always beat guys with using your brain. Note she she "always" sounds rather sexist... Hmm she is a hypocrite I seem to recall a time in survivor heros vs villains when Tom used the Hidden immunity idol and got enough people to vote out Cirie! So Cirie it'd be rather wise to say "you can almost always beat them with "these" (refers to brain). You can outsmart peons but against the best your just a one trick pony. Perhaps you needed a new game plan a third time around huh?
Eskara0 1 year ago
@Eskara0 I agree. We all know Cirie is extremely irrational. I laughed when she lost :').
Shame Erik will probably never trust a woman in his entire life anymore.
Perhaps he'll get over it. It's a shame it always has to come down to gender on the later shows. Atleast most of them.
Mythically 1 year ago
@Eskara0 Tom didn't beat Cirie. That was JT because he flipped. JT destroyed the heroes by voting out Stephenie, Tom and Cirie when Colby, Rupert and James were weaker physically and mentally. By doing that he made Candice feel isolated, that's why she flipped and he took out the only people that would have told him, "Keep the fucking idol, you moron."
004Daniel 2 months ago
Comment removed
Eskara0 1 year ago
Comment removed
Eskara0 1 year ago
what about randy from gabon he used a fake immunity idol thinking that it was real and everyone was laughing at him
josevazquez1987 1 year ago
@josevazquez1987 Jason had that beat...Randy's fake idol was pretty similar to the real one...Jason on the other hand, believed that a stick with eyes and a mouth was the real thing
NYChica23 1 year ago
Close call. Natalie and Cirie the dumbest move in Survivor history or Erik. The result Parvati winner and Amanda the runner up. Just what his move was aimed to prevent if only Natalie and Cirie had looked futher than top 4 and the stupid girl vs guys agenda.
efcpl 1 year ago
This is preety bad the idea isn't too bad, he couldn't win anways, and he attepted to get a chance it it just failed.
yyy279 1 year ago
How is this NOT the dumbest move in Survivor history? (In the S20 reunion show, J.T.'s giving Russell the idol was deemed the dumbest, but THIS, IMO, CREAMS it.)
loopyallie1 1 year ago
This is a case of...these women are crafty, but Erik is also insanely dumb!!!!
PhoenixMarco5 1 year ago
Erik is the most georgous golden blond since Leif Garrett. Beautiful wavy locks, a hot sleek body with just enough muscle. WOW. He is the man.
Andygarrett357 1 year ago 4
Cirie is badass, this was all her doing
MrJpman2 1 year ago
AMANDA'S BLINDSIDE ON ALEXIS WAS THE BEST MOVE EVER, THIS WAS BY FAR THE DUMBEST MOVE EVER, BOTH THE SMARTEST AND DUMBEST MOVE IN THE SAME SEASON AND BACK TO BACK TOO
MrPoison4Life 1 year ago
Don't see how JT's move is dumer then this. Sure its dumer from a viewing stand point but they never saw russles season and they never new what was going on at camp and it was a smart move if it worked. but Erik was just brain dead.
ecwecwecw1 1 year ago 4
It would have been funny If Erik pulled out a hidden immunity idol at the last minute....or maybe his dick.
badger5079 1 year ago 30
@badger5079 I would love to suck his dick.
Andygarrett357 1 year ago 2
Look at them all smiling and leaning on each other as he's voted out "HA HA WHAT A DUMBASS HE TRUSTED US." And voting out the person who gave you immunity? What a bunch of bitches.
Let this be a lesson to everyone who watches this: Women love money more than kindness, and any amount of effort or act of love you put toward them.
TopOfTheScoreboard 1 year ago
@TopOfTheScoreboard I'm a girl and I don't love money more than kindness. I think the lesson here is that you should *never* allow people to manipulate your feelings so much that you give up the one thing that makes you safe. It's one thing to do so as a strategic move, it's *another* to do it because your emotions got the best of you.
BelleBook 1 year ago
@TopOfTheScoreboard Wow, looking back at my own comment, I was being really hateful. I've changed my opinion on this since I've had a good female friend enter my life. Back when I wrote this I was really bitter and feeling kind of alone in my life. Not only is my previous comment childish and immature, it is written badly and thoughtlessly too. I'm glad I'm a changed man.
TopOfTheScoreboard 1 year ago
Comment removed
TopOfTheScoreboard 1 year ago
Just goes to show, you can't trust women.
TopOfTheScoreboard 1 year ago 2
@TopOfTheScoreboard I think Russell did a fine job of proving that men can be as dirty as women when it comes to Survivor
NYChica23 1 year ago
Erik should have won the Dumbest Survivor Ever award. This was far more stupid than James not playing his idol, Tyson accidentally voting himself out, and JT giving his idol to Russell. There was logic behind the risks that James, Tyson, and JT took (and Russell took a huge risk by giving his idol to Parvati, because if Tyson didn't vote for her, Russell would've been the idiot). But there was no logic whatsoever behind Erik's move.
kcg921 1 year ago 3
He would have won if he progressed esp when I saw the final immunity challenges. Cirie was awesome but Amanda was a horrible player. Why did they bring her back even once. Eliza,Alexis and Ozzy were all more memorable IMO.
deltron121 1 year ago
BLACK WIDOW BRIGADE all the way.Parvati is just out of space bad and great.But,Cirie is the one who realized how dumb can eric be.Cirie is badass.
CroBlondie 1 year ago
erick is dumb natales mean parvs mean
brettstewartrocks 1 year ago 2
I feel really bad for him, but his idiocy balances out what pity I DID have for him ...
NewMadrid01 1 year ago
omg bad video quality
RyanWed18 1 year ago
Natalie definitely deserved to be a villain on heroes vs villains........
she deserved the spot much more than Danielle did
abcdefg3451 1 year ago
@abcdefg3451
Heroes vs Villians been so cool with both her and Courtney do you reakon?.
Homeandawayguy 1 year ago
@abcdefg3451 Or Courtney or Sandra...aside from snarky comments, none of those two was evil enough to be a villain...everyone else on the tribe deserved their spots
NYChica23 1 year ago
wut a dumbass ewww!
KingRussell101 1 year ago
I don't care if JT won the award at the reunion, Erik is still the dumbest Survivor ever. He only won because of short-term memory by the audience. I even consider what Tyson did dumber than JT's move.
LTomlinson31 1 year ago 2
@LTomlinson31 i know right. JT didn't know the situation in the villains tribe and russel was the wild card...nobody knows how he played the game in samoa, and he needed russel for votes in a merge. Erik was in a minority in this group and he gave immunity to someone in the majority. Definitely the dumbest move!
Rhapthorne3 1 year ago
@LTomlinson31, I agree 100%. I say anyone with short-term memory loss should not have the right to vote. This move by Erik far surpasses any other dumb moment in Survivor history. J.T.'s move was a lot more risky in dumb. There's no way he could have known it wasn't a woman's alliance on the Villains tribe.
jwdogfst 1 year ago
@jwdogfst What I find the biggest difference too: if J.T's move was successful, greatest move in Survivor history, you think? But because it doesn't work out, its all of the sudden the dumbest? If Erik's move worked out, no one would consider it even a bit smart. Same with Tyson's. And it was very easy to believe an all-woman's alliance was praying on the men. Erik's move...... no logic whatsoever, unlike J.T's.
LTomlinson31 1 year ago
@LTomlinson31 I totally agree -- at least about the fact that Erik still made the dumbest move ever. J.T.'s move was reasonable from his point of view -- he just misread the situation. Erik -- he was played by four very smart women and he was in the minority! Idiot.
BelleBook 1 year ago 2
@BelleBook James was pretty stupid too in China...he had both idols in his pockets when he went to tribal and still got voted off without using them
NYChica23 1 year ago
@NYChica23 To me, what made him look even more stupid was how he laughed at Jamie for using a fake idol, which looked almost exactly like the real one and she realized was probably fake, but might as well take the chance and then he got voted off with two of them.
004Daniel 2 months ago
lmao what the hell is ozzy wearing
viggy71691 1 year ago
oh boy... talk about being gullible.
cirie totally owned erik. lol
YukiYuriChan 1 year ago
so stupid does he even want to be a millionare
heath3933 1 year ago
What an idiot ...
NewMadrid01 1 year ago
i would of gave amanda or parvati the immunity because of how gourgeous they r.
STARWEB912 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The best strategy:
1. Do everything that Erik did here (this will prompt everyone to vote against you)
2. DRAW OUT THE HIDDEN IMMUNITY IDOL!!!!!
...and voila!!! best blindside
iankevinsevilla 1 year ago
The best strategy:
1. Do everything that Erik did here (this will prompt everyone to vote against you)
2. DRAW OUT THE HIDDEN IMMUNITY IDOL!!!!!
...and voila!!! best blindside
iankevinsevilla 1 year ago
@iankevinsevilla I've always wanted to see a blindside like that. It would be hilarious, especially if the audience had no idea they had the idol.
LTomlinson31 1 year ago
that's eric's kodak moment
ronnie9345 1 year ago
6:54-6:56 priceless!
Eskara0 1 year ago
ROFLMFAO when the women are trying to hide their "Holy-shit-he-actually-did-it" look. Remember, breasts rank above dicks. WOMEN ARE IN CHARGE!!!
indigo12ash 1 year ago
@indigo12ash Yeah, it was almost as hilarious seeing the women trying to hide their "Holy mackeral, he actually did it" look as it was seeing Erik get voted out for his troubles. But the funniest part was seeing the reactions of the jury members -- especially James! I loved seeing him laugh out loud after Erik gave Immunity to Natalie. He didn't even *try* to hide his reaction!
BelleBook 1 year ago
@BelleBook Eliza didn't either...her facial expressions were priceless...lol
NYChica23 1 year ago 2
Natalie was such an ugly cunt.
smitty01209 1 year ago
He knew he wouldnt win. So why stay?
dodopoptart 1 year ago
He wouldn't have won anyway he might as well have just given it away.
watermelonygoodness 1 year ago
lol, poor guy.
flapflapflap4 1 year ago
It rfeally wasnt that dumb considering he had no shot to win the game. No one on the jury was going to vote for him. He said im gonna give this immunity up and take the risk of getting voted off. If they didnt vote him off he would have gained respect from the jury and won the game. It seems like a really dumb move..but whats the point of making the final 3 and getting no votes, take a risk.
waytoomany10 1 year ago
@waytoomany10 It was dumb, you have to consider that there was 4 woman, and the won the 3 last immunity challenge. He was the biggest .. "danger"( idk the word in english), and they even told him at the tribal council before that.
He did a mistake, that's all.
shadowranger123 1 year ago
I think thats what u call a dumbass
MetalGearPablo9 1 year ago
I love the sound effects "youve told her youve told her youve told her" :)
Hammotastic 1 year ago