who knows how Beethoven wanted that piece to be played ? All interpretations are only interpretations !Gould Kissin Barenboim Horowitz Kempff Perahia ....are all very good but Emil Gilels version is exactly what i want to hear!!!
Completely explodes the myth of EG as "the lyricist." This guy defied every label and flew out of every pigeonhole. That's what artists do, and this one could no more be pinned down than could Beethoven himself. No matter what EG played, he found the unique channel to the very heart of the composition and the composer.
So undeniably perfect. In the fast ascending arpeggios, you can HEAR every single note running up the piano... everything is crystal clear yet ever so blurry and confused... marvelous.
The angry, the raging, the furious tale Beethoven had written through the piano comes across ever so perfectly here.
I don't understand why people think Beethoven must be played without full force to avoid romanticism. We have vastly better dynamics now that can better suit Beethoven's rage, why not use them? If Beethoven, the revolutionary he was, knew that pianists were limiting their fortes and pianos to play in the 'Classical style', he would probably roll over in his grave.
This is exactly how I imagine this should be...scrambling and frantic, like the pianist's grasp on the melody is threatening to disintegrate at any moment.
The other versions are too polite and "affected" for me. caged and tamed and void of power.
I agree. Many people play this piece too "beautifuly", & I feel Beethoven intended it to be as furious & heavy as this marvelous excecution by Gilels. He's truly a master at Beethoven pieces.
Estoy de acuerdo con laonirica. Pero además hay fuego, pasión y control. Realmente suena agitato, como deseaba Beethoven. Gilels demuestra aquí ser un maestro. ¡Bravo!
WONDERFUL !!!
EmiliaGilels 3 weeks ago
who knows how Beethoven wanted that piece to be played ? All interpretations are only interpretations !Gould Kissin Barenboim Horowitz Kempff Perahia ....are all very good but Emil Gilels version is exactly what i want to hear!!!
babifoot 3 weeks ago
La mejor version que he oido en mi vida de esta sonata. Gracias.Impresionante.
Best version ever. Thank you.
baronsol 1 month ago
This, along with Tamas Vasary's version, are the bests. They play it with their hearts and not their fingers
jona4176 2 months ago
I don't know noting about piano music, but this is absolutely amazing. So heart-felt and intense, it really touches you, no, it pierces you.
QueenOfDreamsXxX 2 months ago
@QueenOfDreamsXxX -
Thank you for this comment, Queen---
EvaHartwig 2 months ago
probably the best interpretation of this composition. Gilels plays it with such wonderful dynamic differences. brilliant performance
MrTobiasMusic 6 months ago
Completely explodes the myth of EG as "the lyricist." This guy defied every label and flew out of every pigeonhole. That's what artists do, and this one could no more be pinned down than could Beethoven himself. No matter what EG played, he found the unique channel to the very heart of the composition and the composer.
briandonohue100 8 months ago 2
ladies and gentlemen.....THIS IS BEETHOVEN ! the best ever.....
Mario250666 8 months ago 7
So undeniably perfect. In the fast ascending arpeggios, you can HEAR every single note running up the piano... everything is crystal clear yet ever so blurry and confused... marvelous.
The angry, the raging, the furious tale Beethoven had written through the piano comes across ever so perfectly here.
FrameSticker 9 months ago 5
I don't understand why people think Beethoven must be played without full force to avoid romanticism. We have vastly better dynamics now that can better suit Beethoven's rage, why not use them? If Beethoven, the revolutionary he was, knew that pianists were limiting their fortes and pianos to play in the 'Classical style', he would probably roll over in his grave.
JohnEBPiano 11 months ago 4
watch the version of Mr. Bean, just hilarious.
roggel380 1 year ago 2
я плачу слыша этот шедевр
boospes 1 year ago 4
just no comments...only "wow" ,well,it is awesome, JUST FANTASTIC, THANKS A LOT, MAESTRO !!!
tatispb 1 year ago 4
This is exactly how I imagine this should be...scrambling and frantic, like the pianist's grasp on the melody is threatening to disintegrate at any moment.
The other versions are too polite and "affected" for me. caged and tamed and void of power.
mistakenshyness 1 year ago 37
@mistakenshyness
scrambling and frantic are the true words. my reference for this piece for the future
ATVTbros 11 months ago 4
@mistakenshyness try glenn gould.
ungoliant6666 3 weeks ago in playlist Emil Gilels
Fantastic!!!! Bravo Gilels!!!
Lenochka1107 1 year ago 4
Finally some true rage.
fjonken92 2 years ago 11
Perfect.
novamoda 2 years ago 6
This is very good.
Theonedue 2 years ago 2
This live is even better than the recording...
AndreAx1985 2 years ago 5
the best interpretation i have ever heard!
drshah0 2 years ago 3
take a deep breath while you can ^__^
amazing
farsidepirate 2 years ago 6
Finally I found my favourite interpretation of this wonderful piece. Thank you Emil. :)
JacobRudduck 2 years ago 7
Wonderful!
highskilledsibby 2 years ago
si, Tre`s bien.
takhirviolinest 2 years ago
One of my very favorite piano pieces. Bravo! Full of passion!
BluRondoAlaTurk 2 years ago 3
also I suggest you listen my playing. I'm not good pianist but I play not bad
takhirviolinest 2 years ago
Yeah u r Right, but u wanna listen to MORE passion? Listen to John Lill's version.
Alejandro270193 2 years ago
You are right! John Lill is a great Beethoven interpreter!
aaabbbccc5 2 years ago
Wow... I didn't here about uniquel pianist like E. Gilels. He play very good but I like Horowitz.
takhirviolinest 2 years ago
Emil Gilels
Superior Dynamics.
Splendid (dramatic) interpretation!
ClassicalOJazz 2 years ago 2
Wow! I have heard many versions of this piece. but this is definitely the best of them all.
He has all the passion, which I imagine Beethoven must have had.
Dominicussen 3 years ago 2
I agree. Many people play this piece too "beautifuly", & I feel Beethoven intended it to be as furious & heavy as this marvelous excecution by Gilels. He's truly a master at Beethoven pieces.
00Rotem00 2 years ago 3
Захватывающая музыка и исполнение!
yuravaskov 3 years ago
Это не захватывающе, это гениально. В наше время так легко раздают громкие эпитеты посредственности а подлинных гениев обходят молчанием
musiccritic1910 2 years ago 27
Estoy de acuerdo con laonirica. Pero además hay fuego, pasión y control. Realmente suena agitato, como deseaba Beethoven. Gilels demuestra aquí ser un maestro. ¡Bravo!
sotocarlosf 3 years ago 3
Brilliant.
PeanutJoey 3 years ago 2
Супер!!!
Nataljnka 3 years ago 7
¡¡¡Presición,rítmo y claridad, Impecable!!!Bravo Por Siempre Maestro Emil Gilels !!!- GRACIAS, EvaHartwig, por compartirlo desde YouTube!!!
laonirica 3 years ago 5