I don't know about sounding like Coltrane in this vid, it's pretty hard to imitate the sheets of sound style he patented. That being said, I enjoy these solos a hell of a lot. Now the alto player....I think his solo was cool, even if it was a little too Coltrane-esque.
Envy is a bitch... How can a great, fun version of Giant Steps, with tight and smokin ensemble playing and amazing solos get 'dislikes' and disrespectful comments?
@JazzTrumpetBlues I wasnt talking about the dudes in the vid. They did pretty good. But still, they didnt develop their phrases enough. What i mean is their are are alot of runs, but no motiv development, melodic development, repetion or imitaion (which ever term, they are all the same.) The sax at the start did it. check it this is what i want more of: 1:16-1:22
@greati9 No motif development? Have you ever tried to play Giant Steps? I have to admit that when I first heard the 'Big Band' of this arrangement I was put off, I grew up with the 4 - 6 member jazz groups, but once I got past that & listened to the solos I wasn't so negative. But to return to my motif and develop it a tiny bit: GIANT STEPS is seriously difficult! I mean, if one is trying to improvise across 3 key changes & n+ cord changes all at Mach 1, good luck!
@Cohnmiester the song isnt that hard. its only 12 bars. Anyone who practices enough can play medically over it. Your stopping urself by saying u can't do it. U can probably do a better job than some of these guys! I play over giant steps for fun, cuz i just like the sound. Pro hint: the 2-5-1's from the keys of Eb to G to B are good points to develop melodically. look at the melody.
Well it seems to swing enough. Just remember that Coltranes shoes are hard to fill. This is a big band arrangment so obviously it's going to be turned down a step.
Great version of Giant Steps--check out Chris Hunter on George Gruntz's Concert Jazz Band--most recent CD is Tiger by the Tail, but earlier CDs are great too--most feature Chris Hunter.
P.S when i said lame i was bein sarcastic get it, get it, yeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaahhhhhhh the computor is hard to convey sarcasm so i had to make extra sure
... i don't why youtube allow you to respond to individual comments if they're not going to be threaded so other users can see the context. the comment below is in response to the idiot way down the list who saw colour as relevant in commenting on this video.
there are actually quite a few tuning problems...other than that they are great! and studying with Frank Elmo must be a blast....especially if your a sax player lol
Dear God. I'm sorry to insult people, but this is horrible. It's like a parody -- Giant Steps with no soul. Don't these poeple know that Giant Steps is a beautiful piece of music, not just a forum for horn players to show off machizmo? Totally sterile.
Haha, Giant Steps... Incredible Peice and well Frank had some trouble taking Trane's signature Giant Steps licks that he plays throughout the peice... Frank, That was very nice and I haven't heard some originality like that at the end in a little while.
I am sure you can but I am not all too failiar with diffrent ligs on Links.. Uhh I put a runyon on eon mine but Honestly I just use the Normal Otto Link Lig
Wow! I'm amazed. Frank Elmo is tooooo good. If you can could you ask him what type of mouthpice and size reed he uses. Nice arrangement too....how'd u cum up with this?
many people use a 7* but that would be a question for Frank Elmo himself. I personally use one with a 9 opening with reeds ranging from strength 2 to 3, really depends what i need to play. Also, probably 85%+ of link users play on rico royal reeds, as they seem to harmonize well with the mouthpiece.
That Tenor player is fucking nuts, and props to that trumpet player! I've only ever know two other trumpet players, play over Giant Steps and one of them is Tom Harrel. Sweet Arrangement
it makes me sad that this band hasn't hit it big, this was very good, and u guys deserve better than the 20 ppl (that it sounded like) in the audience. good work!
tight arrangement and interesting solos for the most part, the the rhythm section and dynamics leave somthing to be desired, the somthing thing lacks energy. the piano and drums aren't resonding and listening, but the cadenza is cooking.
right now I don't have a publisher and I'm not looking to sell the chart. I'm working on a recording for this band and possibly after the recording is released I will publish the chart. Thanks so much for your interest--Willy Dalton
Lol I play tenor so of course Frank Elmo :D
That118Guy 4 weeks ago
Frank Elmo the Hierophant.
zwazi09 1 month ago
@zwazi09 You are most kind!
54tommy 1 month ago
Or Chris Hunter...
EmphaticItalic 4 months ago
I'm an alto player so naturally my favorite was Chris Huner. :)
EmphaticItalic 5 months ago
lmao made me jump when it played lol...... still hot song :D!
fuut10 9 months ago
Chris Hunter...the best of this band
GrilloNoGRAZIE 10 months ago
I don't know about sounding like Coltrane in this vid, it's pretty hard to imitate the sheets of sound style he patented. That being said, I enjoy these solos a hell of a lot. Now the alto player....I think his solo was cool, even if it was a little too Coltrane-esque.
mtownboy13 11 months ago
wow this sax player was amazing definitely sounds in the same bebop style
franciscorosado22 11 months ago
Envy is a bitch... How can a great, fun version of Giant Steps, with tight and smokin ensemble playing and amazing solos get 'dislikes' and disrespectful comments?
Human beings are weirdly funny animals...
giopagoda 1 year ago
i h8 that everyone who plays this tune tries to improvise like coltrane... where is the originality?
greati9 1 year ago
@greati9 Originality? Wtf are you talking about? This man did just a good a solo as any and your going to criticize him after an amazing solo?
JazzTrumpetBlues 1 year ago
@JazzTrumpetBlues I wasnt talking about the dudes in the vid. They did pretty good. But still, they didnt develop their phrases enough. What i mean is their are are alot of runs, but no motiv development, melodic development, repetion or imitaion (which ever term, they are all the same.) The sax at the start did it. check it this is what i want more of: 1:16-1:22
greati9 1 year ago
@greati9 No motif development? Have you ever tried to play Giant Steps? I have to admit that when I first heard the 'Big Band' of this arrangement I was put off, I grew up with the 4 - 6 member jazz groups, but once I got past that & listened to the solos I wasn't so negative. But to return to my motif and develop it a tiny bit: GIANT STEPS is seriously difficult! I mean, if one is trying to improvise across 3 key changes & n+ cord changes all at Mach 1, good luck!
Cohnmiester 7 months ago in playlist Listen up!
@Cohnmiester the song isnt that hard. its only 12 bars. Anyone who practices enough can play medically over it. Your stopping urself by saying u can't do it. U can probably do a better job than some of these guys! I play over giant steps for fun, cuz i just like the sound. Pro hint: the 2-5-1's from the keys of Eb to G to B are good points to develop melodically. look at the melody.
danieljones013 7 months ago
@danieljones013 please count the bars again, there are 16!
alexbarmann 1 month ago
Frank Elmo is my music teacher...
Aman184 1 year ago
12 People can't improvise over Giant Steps
sweederlander 1 year ago 3
k, so the tenor player... looks like he's using a Francois Luis ligature.... any idea what mouthpiece he's using?
efitzpat2011 1 year ago
OMFG!!!!!!!!! GOOSEBUMPS!!!! Lover this.....
addeex1 1 year ago
What beautiful sax section sound,,, that lead alto is really bright
sadizes 1 year ago
This is pretty cool!
musicrebel 1 year ago
holy crap this soung should be in circd du cilla
hondacr85r2008 1 year ago
wow frank elmo is pretty amazing hes also a really good band teacher :)
coolcv112 1 year ago
faster would be better
FabioSaxAlto 1 year ago
The most difficult composition. i love giant steps.
sandrovaro 1 year ago
Frank Elmo… WOW!
bob4247 1 year ago
wow.That solo was just effortless....whish I could do that >:-/ oh well either way it's a great tenor solo
bariel617 1 year ago
one of the reasons i am gonna start playing the sax !
nonameformetodaypf 1 year ago
truly amazing!!!
grejon1 1 year ago
DRUMMER IS MY TEACHER
bobdina 1 year ago
thats a good jazz band
NicChambers93 1 year ago
Awesome Tenor Sax Solo! I Just Learned Coltrane's Solo In Giant Steps Today By Ear! It Was Really Hard But It's Awesome!
marleyisman22 1 year ago
killin tpt solo!
thepeople1325 1 year ago
this is freaking awesome! :)
HjalmarGuitarMaster 1 year ago
au Banan, Frank Almo ist ein Tier !
Great Sound !
WalkersParadise 1 year ago
That's Big Band Sound, great.....What a Tenor Saxophone,amazing..
Saxolinaful 1 year ago
Excellent!!! Killer solos but that Tenor player my God, set it off!!! Phenomenal outro!!!
krayon04 2 years ago
Nice Tenor...
MasterBlasterMusic 2 years ago
sweet!!!!
hottencliff 2 years ago
sax lick 3:43 amazing
SatchisthebestX7 2 years ago
The drummer is awesome!!
snorhyveln 2 years ago
That fat sax guy to the left is fucking great!!!
Kjutte1 2 years ago
yea that guy on tenor sax is great. Love the sound.
Link is so hard to get a good sound on these days.
petersalisbury108 2 years ago
man that tenor player has a great sound.
copedogg888 2 years ago
That guy knows how to play a link
crs251 2 years ago
Well done!
SanneMeems 2 years ago
omg... what an insanely awesome version of this crazy piece. frank elmo ftw!
thepianoman89 2 years ago
Where would modern tenor sax players be without Coltrane? His sound is found in almost everyone.
Kobashi81 2 years ago
WOW!
EmphaticItalic 2 years ago
good arrangement and soloists
could i get my hands on it?
oober349 2 years ago
Frank Elmo is my band teacher. whooo
hellopeople225 2 years ago
USED TO BE!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LOL!
ChessnutStudios 2 years ago
Luckyyyyyy
RainMan137 2 years ago
frank elmo with that biiggg nasty tone wheww ya you right
estoufflet 2 years ago
hehe i have the same mouthpiece as mr. elmo, freaking beast
dipstick555 2 years ago
I love the intro
maskone 2 years ago
Frank Elmo is freakin killing that sax solo.
mrallpurpose 2 years ago
Excellent version of the classic. Although very hard to improvise for an orchestra. This is more than satisfactory, it is excellent. Good job guys.
blurkreg 3 years ago
this arrangement kicks ass
upT3mpo 3 years ago
I like this arrangement a lot :)
bigbenhillman07 3 years ago
ié ! :)
bizelli07 3 years ago
Nice Job...
RCV1963 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is so sad to watch, this kind of big band sound ruins what Coltrane did and averything he stood for
kolwood 3 years ago
I had a nightmare......I had to improvise over Giant Steps.....
imbatman333 3 years ago 35
Rofl.
LackOfAWittyName 3 years ago 2
@imbatman333 oooh thats scary lol, i sure as heck cant do it
pistok2 1 year ago
Oh. It's none other than curleysloth. The forever reigning judge of who and what is "capable but not tasteful."
You are obnoxious, curleysloth. Get a life.
quitbullshittingme 3 years ago 4
I really LOVE that last tone Frank plays. Wonderful!
sweederlander 3 years ago 2
wow i teacher is frank elmo and proud to call him my teacher=p he works at ridgefield park high and hes a great teacher/musician
korean4arch 3 years ago
band teacher???
Saxmaster1230 3 years ago
yep
korean4arch 3 years ago
it was just great. Frank Elmo all honors for you.
damianoitaliano89 3 years ago 11
Good job, but not my favorite way to hear this song --- swing band. Still, I have to respect the arranger and the players.
iwanttowatchsomethin 3 years ago 2
Anyone know what Sax Frank Elmo is playing on?? maybe a Mark 6?
RainMan137 3 years ago
Yeah
XxSaxCannon921xX 3 years ago
who ever calls this silly really does not understand Jazz....
RainMan137 3 years ago 4
hmmmmm- -- I like it. Nice job guys!!
williamsinn 3 years ago
when i wrote that i didnt realize the solos would be good!
joeljjison 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
when i wrote that i didnt realize the solos would be good!
joeljjison 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
very silly, but kinda cool in a hmmmm kinda way
joeljjison 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
very silly, but kinda cool in a hmmmm kinda way
joeljjison 3 years ago
I'd love to play this!!!
Piechickenman 3 years ago
man im so happy they play here in New Jersey alot. I gotta check these guys out at trumpets
morales664 3 years ago
Frank Elmo is the fucking shit...
saxgroovez 3 years ago 2
that tenor soloist at the beginning has an incredible tone...wish i knew what mouthpiece he's using..
saxgroovez 3 years ago
looks like otto link
aShot74 3 years ago
jody jazz dv
jmm1714 3 years ago
Dat whole codenza is hot but dat part startin @ 3:44 all the way to the end is soooo sexy no homo lol
maestrochild 3 years ago
I'll let him know about it. hahha
XxSaxCannon921xX 3 years ago
Oh neva mind lol
maestrochild 4 years ago
Yo dis is a nice arrangement. N E one kno who its from????????
maestrochild 4 years ago
"John Coltrane's "Giant Steps" arranged by Willy Dalton." It says it in the description of the video.
XxSaxCannon921xX 4 years ago
I kno dats y i said neva mind rite afta i posted dat comment
maestrochild 3 years ago
I didn't see that comment haha
My apologies. :P
XxSaxCannon921xX 3 years ago
oh no problem i guess its easy to miss things on this site lol
maestrochild 3 years ago
Yeah; it happened with both of us. hahaha
XxSaxCannon921xX 3 years ago
That was EXCELLENT! I loved that cadenza at the end!!
AdamDallas 4 years ago
nice , mo foes nice.
spyderman57 4 years ago
yeah no matter how good it will never fill coltranes shoes. John Coltrane is a legend
longrunnings 4 years ago
yeah he was. i love it when people circular breathe while soloing- wynton does that a lot. very cool
jaguarjoe91 4 years ago
How can you tell he was doing circular breathing? He took an actual breathe in between in the end a couple times....
Krusenik 4 years ago
THAT GUY WAS SICK!
calebhixon 4 years ago
the old dude on tenor kicks ASS. nice big band arrangement, still kept that manic coltrane vibe intact.
axolotl84 4 years ago
great sound elmo, lovin the tone
LedRocker11 4 years ago
frank elmo does a fantastic job
longrunnings 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This does not swing at all.
decus69 4 years ago
Well it seems to swing enough. Just remember that Coltranes shoes are hard to fill. This is a big band arrangment so obviously it's going to be turned down a step.
chinesefoodskrip 4 years ago
Sure it does. Have you actually listened to it?
bboy2388 4 years ago
its not a swing song, its a bebop song.
tylerdrum07 4 years ago
So.. Bebop cant swing? You der brain.
decus69 4 years ago
well yeah it can, but some dude said that it doesnt "swing" enough. Its not really made to sound like swing.
tylerdrum07 4 years ago
he means the 8ths dont swing enough, not that this is a swing era song.
renixe 4 years ago
The faster the song gets, the less you can swing hard and not sound hokey. If this were half-speed, i'll bet they could swing the crap out of it.
jazzmanpianer 4 years ago
These guys hit this one rigt out of the ball park with this song.PERFECTTTTTT.
acela2120 4 years ago
Drums and all the solo players did really great especially the tenor sax at the end that was mad good.
Supaboy000 4 years ago
Nice alto sound, what piece does chris hunter use? Beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
dvdcracker 4 years ago
Great version of Giant Steps--check out Chris Hunter on George Gruntz's Concert Jazz Band--most recent CD is Tiger by the Tail, but earlier CDs are great too--most feature Chris Hunter.
harrysmallenburg 4 years ago
pff i love it ,
daveconex 4 years ago
I just cant get enough of this arrangememnt.
any idea where i can get it?
musikid2 4 years ago
I Play a 5* Otto Link
Jazzman303 4 years ago
to saxcannon that is so lame im so jealous
P.S when i said lame i was bein sarcastic get it, get it, yeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaahhhhhhh the computor is hard to convey sarcasm so i had to make extra sure
altosaxbeboper09 4 years ago
... i don't why youtube allow you to respond to individual comments if they're not going to be threaded so other users can see the context. the comment below is in response to the idiot way down the list who saw colour as relevant in commenting on this video.
sjtg 4 years ago
Is Frank Elmo Playing on a Link? It looks like one and sounds sooo nice
sicksaxman 4 years ago
He's playing a Jody Jazz DV mpc
TenorSaxBreed 4 years ago
yeah its an older model of the link i play on that model also nd i believe that trane played on the type of link its kool
vnizzle13 4 years ago
I like this. Sure, John Coltraine's version will always be the best, but this comes close.
DifferentGamer 4 years ago
They should make a band version of Countdown. That would be awesome!!!!
TenorSaxBreed 4 years ago
i never thought that giant steps could be a big band arrangement. this is a good arrangment and frank elmo is bad...
p.s. when i mean bad i mean like very good
sonnystitt123 4 years ago
cruel teachers are the best, you will get better
mynameismudd33 4 years ago
hes a decent teacher but he can be a little... a... cruel sumtimes
JForcE777 4 years ago
there are actually quite a few tuning problems...other than that they are great! and studying with Frank Elmo must be a blast....especially if your a sax player lol
SaxyManny 4 years ago
i dont kno what your talking about curly. they play it beautifuly for an all white band
theMissARose 4 years ago
what sort of ignorant comment is that?
sjtg 4 years ago
Dear God. I'm sorry to insult people, but this is horrible. It's like a parody -- Giant Steps with no soul. Don't these poeple know that Giant Steps is a beautiful piece of music, not just a forum for horn players to show off machizmo? Totally sterile.
curleysloth 4 years ago
What????? This is a great arrangement. It is totally cool. And these are very musical and soulful musicains. Trane's tune is in very capable hands.
davens99 4 years ago
Comment removed
shwizzy 2 years ago
hmm frank elmo (sax) is actually my music teacher at my school
JForcE777 4 years ago
AGH!!! LUCKY! wow, so what's it like?
laumeister 4 years ago
Frank is great, he's my sax teacher
XxSaxCannon921xX 4 years ago
so what is his mpc setup?
FarmerTed75 4 years ago
Jody Jazz DV...Rigotti 3 1/2 I believe
TenorSaxBreed 4 years ago
Haha, Giant Steps... Incredible Peice and well Frank had some trouble taking Trane's signature Giant Steps licks that he plays throughout the peice... Frank, That was very nice and I haven't heard some originality like that at the end in a little while.
I play a Otto Link 5 (Trane Played a 5)
Jazzman303 4 years ago
finally ive come across someone who plays a 5 its an incredible mouthpiece isnt it i was wondering can u put a ultimate ligature on a 5??
vnizzle13 4 years ago
I am sure you can but I am not all too failiar with diffrent ligs on Links.. Uhh I put a runyon on eon mine but Honestly I just use the Normal Otto Link Lig
Jazzman303 4 years ago
well i use the normal link lig right now also but ive been looking for new ligs jus to experiment wit my sound
vnizzle13 4 years ago
i use an eddie daniels rovner on my otto 7...pretty good. 6 different tones u can get
TenorSaxBreed 4 years ago
I think that's actually a guardala mouthpiece that elmo is using. He is using it with the "Ultimate Ligature" by Francois Louis
joelspan 4 years ago
Actually I think you're both wrong, I believe he is using a Jody Jazz DV mouthpiece in this video.
XxSaxCannon921xX 4 years ago
Very nice!! props!
prsguru 4 years ago
That's a great interpretation of Giant Steps. I love it.
Seán
stpd1957 4 years ago
Great arrangement, solos and sound! 5 stars!
Lot2learn 4 years ago
this is probably my favorite jazz piece..and a great arrangement btw...and frank elmo is INSANE
Harmonicdelusions 4 years ago
Cool arrangment i like it!
Cerpa05 4 years ago
perfect! 5/5
maskone 4 years ago
Wow! I'm amazed. Frank Elmo is tooooo good. If you can could you ask him what type of mouthpice and size reed he uses. Nice arrangement too....how'd u cum up with this?
TenorSaxBreed 4 years ago
It looks like a Otto Link "Super Tone Master"
many people use a 7* but that would be a question for Frank Elmo himself. I personally use one with a 9 opening with reeds ranging from strength 2 to 3, really depends what i need to play. Also, probably 85%+ of link users play on rico royal reeds, as they seem to harmonize well with the mouthpiece.
Props to the arranger, i really like it :)
subbieee 4 years ago
Who arranged this tune? Where can I find it for my band?
hhm478 4 years ago
This is my arrangement--check the text. Right now I don't have a publisher and I'm not looking to sell the arrangement until I record it.
youtubeuserwilly 4 years ago
You did a great job on this..you are a great musician.
jgpanta 4 years ago
Great music, well done. If you ever record a cd of your music do please let me know.
Seán
stpd1957 4 years ago
alto articulates just like parker
shappenfit 4 years ago
OMG this is sick
sjtg 4 years ago
got to love frank elmo's playing!! great solos by trumpet and alto too.
jamminmercedes 4 years ago
AwesOME!!!
IhaveaCstring 4 years ago
Outstanding!!!
calebl75 5 years ago
I'M PLAYING A JODY JAZZ DV!! .Frank Elmo
54tommy 5 years ago
That Tenor player is fucking nuts, and props to that trumpet player! I've only ever know two other trumpet players, play over Giant Steps and one of them is Tom Harrel. Sweet Arrangement
mattroberts66 5 years ago
Coltrane would be proud . . excellent job !
flag400 5 years ago
Bravo Gentelmen.
bahoss 5 years ago
it makes me sad that this band hasn't hit it big, this was very good, and u guys deserve better than the 20 ppl (that it sounded like) in the audience. good work!
jkillu 5 years ago
Show 'em how it's done, gentlemen.
mctroublepants 5 years ago
how long did it take u to come up with this song. and what kind of moutpiece do u use, metal or hard rubber, or plastic
betterthancoltrane 5 years ago
I'm the arranger and guitar player so I can't help with the saxophone questions. The arrangement took several hours.
youtubeuserwilly 5 years ago
What sax player are you talking about?
XxSaxCannon921xX 5 years ago
Left to right: Metal, Hard Rubber, Metal, and it looks like a Jody Jazz Hard Rubber metal look a like.
XxSaxCannon921xX 5 years ago
Metal, Rubber, Metal, Metal, Rubber looking like metal*
XxSaxCannon921xX 5 years ago
Wow, that Tenor player was tiiiiiiiight. Excellent arrangement!
acesxhigh26 5 years ago
nice alto solo
justinnico 5 years ago
I like ur arrangements dude!
VanKoopman 5 years ago
tight arrangement and interesting solos for the most part, the the rhythm section and dynamics leave somthing to be desired, the somthing thing lacks energy. the piano and drums aren't resonding and listening, but the cadenza is cooking.
Chaser834 5 years ago
I'd love to buy this chart, where do I go about purchasing this arrangement?
shwizzy 5 years ago
i think it was arranged by Willy Dalton, the guy who posted this video.
XxSaxCannon921xX 5 years ago
right now I don't have a publisher and I'm not looking to sell the chart. I'm working on a recording for this band and possibly after the recording is released I will publish the chart. Thanks so much for your interest--Willy Dalton
youtubeuserwilly 5 years ago