Absolument génial... quelle merveilleuse technique et quel talent !
J'adore Vierne, je l'ai beaucoup joué, y compris cette pièce, qui est loin d'être facile. C'est parfait, comme sortie. Jehan Alain a dit : "la prière n'est pas un murmure, mais un souffle, qui balaye tout sur son passage..."
@robertgift - to understand Vierne, or any of the great Parisian organists, you must understand Roman Catholicism, and, arguably, be a Catholic yourself. No atheist can fully understand any of them.
@EccentricRichard Incorrect. One can know the myths upon which these compositions are based without being gulliblenough to believe them. Although, the only Vierne I play is Carillon de Westminster. The Westminster Chime melody is incorrect. (With Catholicism, being correct has never been an issue.)
@robertgift - so Vierne misremembered the Westminster chime, and that proves that Christianity is a load of rubbish? Balderdash. There is so much circumstantial evidence from the time of Christ that proved that he existed, and that he did things utterly beyond the abilities of any mere human, that those who call it all a myth are fooling only themselves. Certainly, you cannot understand Dupré, Duruflé, Alain or Messiaen with no Christian faith.
@EccentricRichard Christianity, as all religions, is man-made myth, fairytale and ridiculous laughable rituals, regardless of whether Vierne got the Westminster Chime correct or not. (Did someone write down and give him the melody? Or did he purposely change it for his marvelous composition?)
Certainly an agnostic, atheist or one of another faith can understand these wonderful works. Don't forget Reger!
You might want to know, this piece is not from Vierne's second symphony for organ. It is acutally his Pièces De Fantaisie Op.53 Nos. 1-6 Suite II- Toccata. Much more impressive than symphony 2.!
I play the organ myself and in the church and i HATE it always the people cry or talk so loud!! People always think they've to speak louder than the organ plays!
Why so you think the French school developed the Contrabombarde and Cochereau had the exterior trumpets installed at Notre-Dame? Just to keep the congregation under control!!! (Only joking). Regards, Paul :-)
nice play! but the peopel go away or talk to loud. thats the batch of the organists.
the frensh organ composors said that bach is their big father. does anyone know the march of the night watchman who is like a memorization honour to bach´s "Wachet auf"?
We all love Bach, but those French composers are wicked! Excellent post. Thank you so much for filming how a postlude should go. Too bad you couldn't identify the organist. Vierne and his contemporaries were the men! BRAVO!!!!
"D'accord,mais avec l'exception de Bach bien sur :-). Mais il est aussi mon favorit hors de Bach "
Alors, concernant Bach, nous ne parlons pas de la même époque, ils sont donc incomparables l'un vis à vis de l'autre, et, finalement, nous sommes d'accord. Ce sont les deux plus grands compositeurs de touts les temps !! je suis en train de travailler cette Toccata. C'est un peu technique, mais à jouer... quel pied !!!
stupid how people keep fighting over religion and don't respect other beliefs... beautiful organ and cathedral!
Gabby5471 1 year ago
Absolument génial... quelle merveilleuse technique et quel talent !
J'adore Vierne, je l'ai beaucoup joué, y compris cette pièce, qui est loin d'être facile. C'est parfait, comme sortie. Jehan Alain a dit : "la prière n'est pas un murmure, mais un souffle, qui balaye tout sur son passage..."
Ben voila, excellent exemple...
laclef2007 2 years ago
I love this cathedral, I love this organ!
TR3791 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hope this wasn't played as a postlude for a church service. that would be most inappropriate.
organboi 2 years ago
What is so inappropriate about this piece being a postlude?! Our organist has played it... it's a beautiful and fun piece!!
m30hyper 2 years ago 3
Why, organboi?
Nice ending to the magic show.
What is inappropriate is teaching myth and convincing gullibles that the fairytales are TRVTH.
But it sure is wonderful music.
This piece needs a huge live acoustical environment.
robertgift 2 years ago
@robertgift - to understand Vierne, or any of the great Parisian organists, you must understand Roman Catholicism, and, arguably, be a Catholic yourself. No atheist can fully understand any of them.
EccentricRichard 1 year ago
@EccentricRichard Incorrect. One can know the myths upon which these compositions are based without being gulliblenough to believe them. Although, the only Vierne I play is Carillon de Westminster. The Westminster Chime melody is incorrect. (With Catholicism, being correct has never been an issue.)
robertgift 1 year ago
@robertgift - so Vierne misremembered the Westminster chime, and that proves that Christianity is a load of rubbish? Balderdash. There is so much circumstantial evidence from the time of Christ that proved that he existed, and that he did things utterly beyond the abilities of any mere human, that those who call it all a myth are fooling only themselves. Certainly, you cannot understand Dupré, Duruflé, Alain or Messiaen with no Christian faith.
EccentricRichard 1 year ago
@EccentricRichard Christianity, as all religions, is man-made myth, fairytale and ridiculous laughable rituals, regardless of whether Vierne got the Westminster Chime correct or not. (Did someone write down and give him the melody? Or did he purposely change it for his marvelous composition?)
Certainly an agnostic, atheist or one of another faith can understand these wonderful works. Don't forget Reger!
robertgift 1 year ago 2
You might want to know, this piece is not from Vierne's second symphony for organ. It is acutally his Pièces De Fantaisie Op.53 Nos. 1-6 Suite II- Toccata. Much more impressive than symphony 2.!
ConfederateKentucky 2 years ago
Einfach fantastisch!
PaterEngelbert 3 years ago
Comment removed
tjugofyra 3 years ago
thx for posting this. its one of my favorite pieces.
For me it wouldn't be worth playing such a great piece when people dont care about it! Too Bad!
evilzivil 3 years ago 2
I play the organ myself and in the church and i HATE it always the people cry or talk so loud!! People always think they've to speak louder than the organ plays!
MrWanamaker 4 years ago 8
Lol, that's right ! :)
Tazeruk 4 years ago 5
Think of this: When asked why he never did a postlude, Charles Tournemire replied, "Because when all the stops are out are the ears are as well."
Shenandoah24 3 years ago
You're right... In Italy it happens very often... :(
organimagister 3 years ago
Why so you think the French school developed the Contrabombarde and Cochereau had the exterior trumpets installed at Notre-Dame? Just to keep the congregation under control!!! (Only joking). Regards, Paul :-)
marsvltor2 3 years ago
Ah, ah, ah!!! Yes, you're right!!
Try to speak louder than a Trompette-en-chamade...
:-D
Regards, Lorenzo.
organimagister 3 years ago 2
Get a late Cavaillé-Coll organ and you will not here anyone speak!
Eventually you will not here anything at all...lol:)
Just a little fussy comment!
tjugofyra 3 years ago
nice play! but the peopel go away or talk to loud. thats the batch of the organists.
the frensh organ composors said that bach is their big father. does anyone know the march of the night watchman who is like a memorization honour to bach´s "Wachet auf"?
bastian1608 4 years ago 2
widor is one of the best frensh composers and he called bach "the father of all of us" i know bad translation. wich church is it?
bastian1608 4 years ago 3
Wow! I want to learn this so much but it's so hard to play. :-)
musicmozz 4 years ago 4
Comment removed
tjugofyra 3 years ago
You can say anything you want about the French. But they build the best organs, they play the best and the French Romantic composers are the best.
I've played the largest organ in the world
(Atlantic city with 33,000 pipes) and the best organ in the world (St. Sulpice, Paris). I've done it all !!!!!!
Who was this organist, he/she is brilliant.
tubamaxima 4 years ago
scappano tutti.
maxazi 4 years ago
We all love Bach, but those French composers are wicked! Excellent post. Thank you so much for filming how a postlude should go. Too bad you couldn't identify the organist. Vierne and his contemporaries were the men! BRAVO!!!!
bhigdaddymark 4 years ago 2
Citation :
ufni3p
"D'accord,mais avec l'exception de Bach bien sur :-). Mais il est aussi mon favorit hors de Bach "
Alors, concernant Bach, nous ne parlons pas de la même époque, ils sont donc incomparables l'un vis à vis de l'autre, et, finalement, nous sommes d'accord. Ce sont les deux plus grands compositeurs de touts les temps !! je suis en train de travailler cette Toccata. C'est un peu technique, mais à jouer... quel pied !!!
laclef2007 4 years ago
Wow !!!! VIERNE VIERNE VIERNE ET JUSTE LUI !!!!
Le meilleur compositeur pour orgue qui ait jamais existé... l'organiste est... d'enfer. ^^
laclef2007 4 years ago 2
D'accord,mais avec l'exception de Bach bien sur :-). Mais il est aussi mon favorit hors de Bach
ufni3p 4 years ago
That organ sounds like an artillery barrage, absolutely fantastic and a wonderful player as well. Brilliant.
azmarkus 4 years ago 2
Awesome! Beautiful! This music will rid you of all your demons. Can't get too loud for me.
2468HOTROD 4 years ago 2
What a great sound! Love the raw reed sound.
ufni3p 4 years ago 3