I agree, the recorded version is way better for me. I think Will Oldham sounds awful live most of the time but his recordings are exquisite. So much of the appeal in his songs depends on creaking out the perfect notes, something he can't really do well live. That is just my opinion.
@immolation333 - Totally on the same page as you are. He tries to take his songs too far off track live. Part of the charm is hearing a song the way you know it (or even close), but this is wayyyy different.
this is not a cover, is is an original song based on the folk song.
aeofjrabenojb 1 year ago
Ha ha...this is terrible!
Thank you Will for introducing some Americans to the Loch tay Boat song...but seriously...this is terrible!
JCMcGee 2 years ago
Terrible?? Are you high??
infernus44 2 years ago
Nope....go listen to the original....this is laughingly bad "cover"
JCMcGee 2 years ago
@JCMcGee
I agree, the recorded version is way better for me. I think Will Oldham sounds awful live most of the time but his recordings are exquisite. So much of the appeal in his songs depends on creaking out the perfect notes, something he can't really do well live. That is just my opinion.
immolation333 1 year ago
@immolation333 - Totally on the same page as you are. He tries to take his songs too far off track live. Part of the charm is hearing a song the way you know it (or even close), but this is wayyyy different.
TheGrandOleHopry1 1 year ago
This was a fabulous show. Well worth the drive from Michigan.
The sound engineer was asleep on the job, so some tunes had to be entirely acoustic.
I hope he keeps playing with The Picket Line.
RedDetroit 3 years ago