Handel, Bach & sons, Brahms, Beathoven, Mozart and Wagner....Germany has definitely contributed dispropotionately to the European classical tradition. They're a clever bunch and no mistake.
LIES! lol I am a black violinist. listen to the harlem string quartet. The first person to play Beethoven's Kruetzer Sonata was african. The Saint Louis Symphony has 3 black people in it. . Oh and i am not offended at all.
Although music is supposedly universal, when dealing with specifics, it tends to segregate as do all things in the world. Which comes back to personal preference. I for one love to see people enjoy one another's culture as long as no one has to get hurt :)
Perhaps it's a culytural difference. Black people tend to be more in to rhythmn then melody. I acknowledge that there should be exceptions as we do find white people playing blues music etc. Pehaps black people might explain why this is. Interesting.
I know a lot of people that play classical music,one being myself,the only reason that you dont see many black classical music players is that they are not part of a famous orchestra...also the way you said it offended me alittel :(
But I have seen many orchestras. I seen Japenese players, chinese players but not one a black player. Even in famous orchestras I never seen one black person. In all these years would would surely expect to come across one.
Don't see why you should be even sligthtly offended. I have even heard many black people saying that that culturally they tend to prefer rhythm. Take this onboard, even when I went to see orchestas in Birmingham UK which has a large black community, very few black people went to classical music concerts. When I seen classical music on TV there are very few black people in the audience. Yet I have gone to blues and jazz clubs and found just as many white people as black people.
This is an interesting topic of conversation. I disagree with the conclusion that simply because black people are not visible en masse at classical music concerts or playing classical instruments that 'they' as a racial group inherently prefer rhythm to melody (which seems a somewhat odd distinction to draw between classical and mainstream music). There are undoubltably complex sociological mechanisms at work which determine how individuals of varying social groupings engage with music.
Remember my comments are not racists comments as some people imply.They are observations. It could be that classical music was at one time for middle class and upper class people only. The poor classes tended to make their own entertainment and music e.g. folk music, blues music, jazz,etc. It would be intersting sociological study to see how many black people throughout the world attend or listen to classical music. BTW I'm not suggesting that there aren't any black people like classical music.
I accept your observations, & I hope I didn't seem to be accusing you of racism. Conducting a quantitative study to find out how many among a certain demographic engage in a particular behaviour does nothing to explain why. If it is true that only a small minority of black people engage in the production/consumption of classical music, I would be more interested to know the factors which effect the relationship between classical music & a given social group. Anyway, thank you for posting this.
Hmmmm. I see what you guys are saying, but I'm not so sure it can be applied to classical, or for that matter any type of exceptional music. Personally I definitely don't believe that one race would be disposed to like one type of music over an other, though there are clearly genetic differences between races they are almost all cosmetic of highly integrated with cultural exposure.
I think that was why people were getting annoyed. They mistook your statements about culture as a statement saying 'black people are genetically less capable of enjoying classical music', which isn't true, and which I don't think you ere saying anyway.
@DrMontague I think your comments are racist but not negative, in the sense that racism is a distinction between races, however racism is not synonym of negative
Haha I love how comments on here stray so far from the actual subject of the video. How did we get on the topic of Karl Marx from a video of a Mozart violin concerto? I'm not complaining; people are just funny sometimes. But don't you think the conductor looks a little like Ian Mckellan?
lol i only care about music. I agree there are lots of great asian musician. I'm a guitarist and three of my favorite guitarists are Yamashita Kazuhito, Wang Yameng and John Williams (1/8 asian).
China has a population of around 1.3 billion and europe .7 billion. The chinese have been writing music for over 2000 years and the europeans less than 1000.
Much as traditional chinese music is often beautiful, colorful virtuosic and evocative they hardly made it past the pentatonic scale!
My ex gf played her first concert at 5 and was rated no.6 out of 110 by the Rachmaninov society of America for her 17yo recording of Rac 3. She could do this because (like a lot of asian parents) her mum was very strict. She made her run for 8 kms and practice for an hour before she was allowed breakfast in the morning since she was about 7. She is Spanish (and also speaks Russian).
It's always controversial issue how children should be educated. Perhaps this the reason many Asians sound very robotic in their playing. Paganini practised 10 hours a day because he wanted to. His father was also very strict. Even though Paganini willingly practised for hours his father would sometime refuse to let him have supper if he didn't think he had made enough progress in his playing.
The reason people think Asians sound robotic is due to hard working kids being taught by average and unmusical teachers. This was often the case when western art music first took of in Asia. Not all the teachers were bad but a lot. This has changed to some extent recently, though the big universities in China and also the USA often teach a very robotic style of playing which sounds especially bad when interpreting 19th century music.
asian languages use pitch instead of syllables or wording, thats why most certainly asians will form either relative or perfect pitch.
the robotic playing is due to functioning on rules and what is, rather than what can be.
same as asian pianists, very few have good rubato.
as for paginini, he wasnt really forced to practice, he was a man who didnt like being told he couldnt do, so whenever a challenge was presented he took it on.
his technique and compositions are the finest because of this
Many people go to see a soloist perform in reality listen to the concerto with their eyes not their ears, meaning they rely on the performer's physical movements to relate to the emotion of the peice rather than it's actual musical elements. A soloist who doesn't sway with the music may look robotic, but that certainly doesn't make his/her playing automatically dry and flat.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Midori, Sarah Chang, Kyung Wah Chung and Anne Akiko Myers, all Asians, are much, much better than her, a Caucasian. There's **absolutely** no question that Asians are way, way superior to Caucasians!! Caucasians are savages - they have Neanderthal genes in them.
i haven't even listened to this yet but your comments are hilarious, lol you are a moron. This piece was written by a Caucasian! In my experience the best Mozart interpreters have studied at the Schola Cantorum Basiliensis in Switzerland or the Italians from the academia ottocento. I'm Australian/English/Russian. Also the last i heard of Sarah Chang was a boring pop song the likes of Vanessa Mae!
That only means that these Asian musicians are kicking your ass at your own game! And it's not only in music where they are beating the crap out of you whites - in math, science, biology/medicine, engineering, even law - all the top graduates & professionals are Asians. To me it is *very clear* that you whites are way, way inferior to Asians. Even in looks, they are cuter and more attractive than you pale-skinned Caucasoids! BTW I'm neither Asian nor white, so I'm being quite objective here.
From your comments I would guess you know very little about music and musicality. I have a question for you. Would you mind commenting on one of your favorite performers in detail and telling me what is musical about their performance, in comparison to someone you don't like playing the same piece? With some detail. I don't think you can!
well now i see why there is no peace in this world:D i mean c'mon Asians are cool and Caucasians are great also...we r all humans and there are many many great exemples about people who were serieusly unrated still they become history(not only music i mean in everything it can happens:) ) thats so beautifull in beeing a human that we have millions and millions of chances deep in us...in my opinion everybody is the Best and nobody is Less...sorry for bad english...from Belgium:)))))
If you want to understand the reason we have hate in the world I recommend that you read the works of philosopher Karl Marx esp. his writings on class struggle. There is nothing wrong with constructive criticism it raises standards.
i heard about Marx and thanx for tryin to help but u know im only 16 and im still in the world of Gabriel Garcia Marquez trying to smile every day and say peace to everyone im deffenetly goin to read Marx and Engels but not now...maybe later..
We establish a youth orchestra me and Awg Sumadi Sukaimi who was my boss in Brunei. That's a children's orchestra. That was 1988, I don't know what happened to it after I left Beunei in 1990. It was under Kementerian Kebudayaan Belia dan Sukan. I would like to go back there someday and make your dream come true. I'm a Filipino now living in Canada.
It is always easier to criticize than to actually be creative and perform. Janine Jansen is beautiful and talented. Itzhak Perlman is talented as well, but it is Janine Jansen who is performing in this video.
It is a real joy to see and hear Janine Jansen. She must have been sent by God.
naruto00000000. I don't allow insults against the musician in any of the videos I upload. This is why I have removed your comment. By all means Criticise and compare performances, but please refrain from usinginsulting language.
She.. IS... AWWESOME!!
brofenix 1 month ago
BEAUTIFUL T_T
Irmaj2009 2 months ago
:D
alexryuzaki 5 months ago
Feel lile a sir!
dedefh23 5 months ago
BEAUTIFUL CONCERTO. BEAUTIFUL PERFORMANCE. VERY BEAUTIFUL WOMAN
1122KLAUS1 8 months ago
11 people likes justin bieber
rafaelcenteio 8 months ago
no m. rabin :P No passion is like he had
pettymolly 10 months ago
Look at the conductor at 0:42 hahahahah what a weird body movement
makedonas86 10 months ago
Realmente maravillosa al violín.
V. Lecha.
lechanavarro 1 year ago
Mozart is without doubt better than Justin Bieber! :)
Rahetor2 1 year ago 5
@Rahetor2 how dare you to even compare?
rafaelcenteio 8 months ago
@rafaelcenteio Sarcasm - do you know what that strange word means? :)
Rahetor2 7 months ago
why are musicians always so good looking?
gradius55 1 year ago 5
@gradius55 cause this was a video, not radio lol
donkim1 9 months ago
Handel, Bach & sons, Brahms, Beathoven, Mozart and Wagner....Germany has definitely contributed dispropotionately to the European classical tradition. They're a clever bunch and no mistake.
smrndoff 1 year ago
@smrndoff Very true, but the modern German music is incredible bad and sad!
I dont understand what went wrong with German music.
Drsboppe1 1 year ago 2
Mozart is not German, he is austrian.
oskvgp 1 year ago
So beautiful. :')
StradAmatiViolin 1 year ago
elegant lady makes poetry voice in the air.
waiiawluis 1 year ago
@waiiawluis couldn't have said it better myself
Xyotoo 1 year ago
LIES! lol I am a black violinist. listen to the harlem string quartet. The first person to play Beethoven's Kruetzer Sonata was african. The Saint Louis Symphony has 3 black people in it. . Oh and i am not offended at all.
deronwlsn 1 year ago 3
The Germans make strudels. The Italians make pasta. The Chinese make ramen noodles.
You take your pick on what you want to eat at the time. The world is your dinner table.
It's all about sharing ourselves with each other's food and culture. The World would go crazy without coffee.
Sushi anyone?
albierte 2 years ago
@albierte Ramen's Japanese.
AdvocateToTheAccuser 1 year ago 4
@albierte lol
fardisghomeshi 1 year ago
@albierte ramen noodles are japanese LOL and don't you go saying chinese and japanese are the same, because they are NOT.
Clutchmaster91 1 year ago
@Clutchmaster91 i'm korean, and i say you all look the same to me
donkim1 9 months ago
@donkim1 You are a bigoted racist assfuc*k
QueerOldDean 7 months ago
Mr. Ashkenazy knows everything about Mozart, brilliant pianist!
buscapleitosNo1 2 years ago
the orchestra is remarkable
I seldom hear orchestra playng this piece in such a "mozart" manner, excellent!
lch830lcc 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
One ridiculous again!!!!!!!!!
What the hell is happening??
What is she doing with her violin?? Gym or music?!?!?!?!? Just incredible...
I have the feeling the juries are getting blind by all these clown violinists...They can't see clearly and it's a shame...
And the music?? Nothing special, again, who's who!!?!?!?
TheVerity93 2 years ago
Although music is supposedly universal, when dealing with specifics, it tends to segregate as do all things in the world. Which comes back to personal preference. I for one love to see people enjoy one another's culture as long as no one has to get hurt :)
adt43 2 years ago 15
check out Mozart quartet no 2 in D major
TheSnailSugar 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hahahah the conductor was like oboe??????? you want oboe????lol.....
vlhere 2 years ago
yeah, this sounds A LOT like Mozart...lol
davlor86 2 years ago 16
It's so nice to see real English in youtube text comment areas. I guess that's what I get for looking up LOL cat. =)
AnthraxBird 2 years ago
Sorry for an idiot question,
does the conductor looks like magneto??
maskscraper 3 years ago 4
the conductor is vladimir ashkenazy
farzadvengerov 3 years ago
maskScraper looks like magneto
nakedBison69 3 years ago
janine is dutch idol, i mean world idol
joosangbai 3 years ago
ummmm...yeah, what the hell is gray supposed to be?
shihuiguan 3 years ago
Gray?
ShinigamiShiro 3 years ago
just wondering why there are not any black people playing classical music ?
by the way i not black i am grey.
all u tube classical stuff does not contain a single black player
as to a conductor i did not dare to think or question
alilapointe1 3 years ago
Perhaps it's a culytural difference. Black people tend to be more in to rhythmn then melody. I acknowledge that there should be exceptions as we do find white people playing blues music etc. Pehaps black people might explain why this is. Interesting.
DrMontague 3 years ago
I know a lot of people that play classical music,one being myself,the only reason that you dont see many black classical music players is that they are not part of a famous orchestra...also the way you said it offended me alittel :(
Kimmimaru1 3 years ago
But I have seen many orchestras. I seen Japenese players, chinese players but not one a black player. Even in famous orchestras I never seen one black person. In all these years would would surely expect to come across one.
DrMontague 3 years ago
Don't see why you should be even sligthtly offended. I have even heard many black people saying that that culturally they tend to prefer rhythm. Take this onboard, even when I went to see orchestas in Birmingham UK which has a large black community, very few black people went to classical music concerts. When I seen classical music on TV there are very few black people in the audience. Yet I have gone to blues and jazz clubs and found just as many white people as black people.
DrMontague 3 years ago
This is an interesting topic of conversation. I disagree with the conclusion that simply because black people are not visible en masse at classical music concerts or playing classical instruments that 'they' as a racial group inherently prefer rhythm to melody (which seems a somewhat odd distinction to draw between classical and mainstream music). There are undoubltably complex sociological mechanisms at work which determine how individuals of varying social groupings engage with music.
HerzogsShoe 3 years ago
Remember my comments are not racists comments as some people imply.They are observations. It could be that classical music was at one time for middle class and upper class people only. The poor classes tended to make their own entertainment and music e.g. folk music, blues music, jazz,etc. It would be intersting sociological study to see how many black people throughout the world attend or listen to classical music. BTW I'm not suggesting that there aren't any black people like classical music.
DrMontague 3 years ago
I accept your observations, & I hope I didn't seem to be accusing you of racism. Conducting a quantitative study to find out how many among a certain demographic engage in a particular behaviour does nothing to explain why. If it is true that only a small minority of black people engage in the production/consumption of classical music, I would be more interested to know the factors which effect the relationship between classical music & a given social group. Anyway, thank you for posting this.
HerzogsShoe 3 years ago
Hmmmm. I see what you guys are saying, but I'm not so sure it can be applied to classical, or for that matter any type of exceptional music. Personally I definitely don't believe that one race would be disposed to like one type of music over an other, though there are clearly genetic differences between races they are almost all cosmetic of highly integrated with cultural exposure.
Surells 2 years ago 2
I think that was why people were getting annoyed. They mistook your statements about culture as a statement saying 'black people are genetically less capable of enjoying classical music', which isn't true, and which I don't think you ere saying anyway.
Surells 2 years ago 2
@DrMontague I think your comments are racist but not negative, in the sense that racism is a distinction between races, however racism is not synonym of negative
frunmasterx 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
RACIST!!
leastigotachicken 3 years ago
Dick head
DrMontague 3 years ago
ok??
leastigotachicken 3 years ago
What the heck are you doing here? Who are you calling racist? Can't you just let people enjoy the music and keep your hate to yourself? Egads!
trustbaby7 3 years ago
Passionate hatred can give meaning and purpose to an empty life.
sisterspure 2 years ago
try wynton marsalis strings, wynton marsalis is an african-american who grew up in new orleans.
huffrya0 3 years ago
I'm getting this sheet music
musictranscription 3 years ago
what do you expect?
Richardtheincredible 3 years ago
Haha I love how comments on here stray so far from the actual subject of the video. How did we get on the topic of Karl Marx from a video of a Mozart violin concerto? I'm not complaining; people are just funny sometimes. But don't you think the conductor looks a little like Ian Mckellan?
HannahXIV 3 years ago
marry me Janine!!
:´(
<3
zhenitdon17 3 years ago 2
okay.
Richardtheincredible 3 years ago
search " Anton Polezhayev " he is amazing too
mynameiZroma 3 years ago
All of the best players in the world have huge european influences (Except for late 20th century music)
tomward8 3 years ago 3
@
tomward8
Europe cannot possibly have a population of 7 billion since the population of the world is 6 bil 671 mil....
The population of Europe is aprox. 728 mil which is about 11% of the entire world population.
qubix2008 3 years ago
I said .7 Billion (Point 7)
tomward8 3 years ago
By the way r u half Korean?
tomward8 3 years ago
lol i only care about music. I agree there are lots of great asian musician. I'm a guitarist and three of my favorite guitarists are Yamashita Kazuhito, Wang Yameng and John Williams (1/8 asian).
tomward8 3 years ago
China has a population of around 1.3 billion and europe .7 billion. The chinese have been writing music for over 2000 years and the europeans less than 1000.
Much as traditional chinese music is often beautiful, colorful virtuosic and evocative they hardly made it past the pentatonic scale!
tomward8 3 years ago
My ex gf played her first concert at 5 and was rated no.6 out of 110 by the Rachmaninov society of America for her 17yo recording of Rac 3. She could do this because (like a lot of asian parents) her mum was very strict. She made her run for 8 kms and practice for an hour before she was allowed breakfast in the morning since she was about 7. She is Spanish (and also speaks Russian).
tomward8 3 years ago
It's always controversial issue how children should be educated. Perhaps this the reason many Asians sound very robotic in their playing. Paganini practised 10 hours a day because he wanted to. His father was also very strict. Even though Paganini willingly practised for hours his father would sometime refuse to let him have supper if he didn't think he had made enough progress in his playing.
DrMontague 3 years ago
The reason people think Asians sound robotic is due to hard working kids being taught by average and unmusical teachers. This was often the case when western art music first took of in Asia. Not all the teachers were bad but a lot. This has changed to some extent recently, though the big universities in China and also the USA often teach a very robotic style of playing which sounds especially bad when interpreting 19th century music.
tomward8 3 years ago
asian languages use pitch instead of syllables or wording, thats why most certainly asians will form either relative or perfect pitch.
the robotic playing is due to functioning on rules and what is, rather than what can be.
same as asian pianists, very few have good rubato.
as for paginini, he wasnt really forced to practice, he was a man who didnt like being told he couldnt do, so whenever a challenge was presented he took it on.
his technique and compositions are the finest because of this
Loudsilence84 3 years ago
Many people go to see a soloist perform in reality listen to the concerto with their eyes not their ears, meaning they rely on the performer's physical movements to relate to the emotion of the peice rather than it's actual musical elements. A soloist who doesn't sway with the music may look robotic, but that certainly doesn't make his/her playing automatically dry and flat.
HannahXIV 3 years ago
Agreed, though when you have heard this song so many times. The emotion, of the players does make them that much better.
When I listened to this, I didn't need the volume to know what it sounded like. I've heard this hundreds upon hundreds of times.
It is also what sets talented amateurs apart from passionate professionals.
jordan8199 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Midori, Sarah Chang, Kyung Wah Chung and Anne Akiko Myers, all Asians, are much, much better than her, a Caucasian. There's **absolutely** no question that Asians are way, way superior to Caucasians!! Caucasians are savages - they have Neanderthal genes in them.
sterlingtaste01 3 years ago
i haven't even listened to this yet but your comments are hilarious, lol you are a moron. This piece was written by a Caucasian! In my experience the best Mozart interpreters have studied at the Schola Cantorum Basiliensis in Switzerland or the Italians from the academia ottocento. I'm Australian/English/Russian. Also the last i heard of Sarah Chang was a boring pop song the likes of Vanessa Mae!
tomward8 3 years ago 2
Excellent counter argument.
DrMontague 3 years ago
That only means that these Asian musicians are kicking your ass at your own game! And it's not only in music where they are beating the crap out of you whites - in math, science, biology/medicine, engineering, even law - all the top graduates & professionals are Asians. To me it is *very clear* that you whites are way, way inferior to Asians. Even in looks, they are cuter and more attractive than you pale-skinned Caucasoids! BTW I'm neither Asian nor white, so I'm being quite objective here.
sterlingtaste01 3 years ago
From your comments I would guess you know very little about music and musicality. I have a question for you. Would you mind commenting on one of your favorite performers in detail and telling me what is musical about their performance, in comparison to someone you don't like playing the same piece? With some detail. I don't think you can!
tomward8 3 years ago
well now i see why there is no peace in this world:D i mean c'mon Asians are cool and Caucasians are great also...we r all humans and there are many many great exemples about people who were serieusly unrated still they become history(not only music i mean in everything it can happens:) ) thats so beautifull in beeing a human that we have millions and millions of chances deep in us...in my opinion everybody is the Best and nobody is Less...sorry for bad english...from Belgium:)))))
KicsiRamy 3 years ago 4
If you want to understand the reason we have hate in the world I recommend that you read the works of philosopher Karl Marx esp. his writings on class struggle. There is nothing wrong with constructive criticism it raises standards.
DrMontague 3 years ago
i heard about Marx and thanx for tryin to help but u know im only 16 and im still in the world of Gabriel Garcia Marquez trying to smile every day and say peace to everyone im deffenetly goin to read Marx and Engels but not now...maybe later..
KicsiRamy 3 years ago
Janine Janseni is really a great violinst
DartanianQ8 3 years ago
The orchestra is fantastic, I must say!
morindhe 4 years ago 3
Very talented indeed....
helmsdeep84 4 years ago
OK, I don't know whether you agree or not: Vladimir Ashkenazy looks kind of like Leonard Bernstein, doesn't he?
hdunik 4 years ago 2
Agree. Only, Ashkenazy is a Cossack while Bernstein is a cowboy. :)
Dogaradodia 4 years ago 2
Hahaha, He does look like Bernstein!!!
MACEDONIANHELLINISM 3 years ago
2006? This looks like mid 1990s...
ThaSchwab 4 years ago
wow... the orchestra sounds so good and professional! i wish my country (brunei) had a youth orchestra...
egg59 4 years ago
We establish a youth orchestra me and Awg Sumadi Sukaimi who was my boss in Brunei. That's a children's orchestra. That was 1988, I don't know what happened to it after I left Beunei in 1990. It was under Kementerian Kebudayaan Belia dan Sukan. I would like to go back there someday and make your dream come true. I'm a Filipino now living in Canada.
junevi2000 3 years ago
Best of luck to you. This music was meant to be appreciated by the world. It transcends borders and races.
trustbaby7 3 years ago
did you know that a 'janine jansen appreciation society' group exists on facebook ?
jetsetjason 4 years ago
It is always easier to criticize than to actually be creative and perform. Janine Jansen is beautiful and talented. Itzhak Perlman is talented as well, but it is Janine Jansen who is performing in this video.
It is a real joy to see and hear Janine Jansen. She must have been sent by God.
TimeSum21 4 years ago
naruto00000000. I don't allow insults against the musician in any of the videos I upload. This is why I have removed your comment. By all means Criticise and compare performances, but please refrain from usinginsulting language.
DrMontague 4 years ago
holy crap...the orchestra sounds amazing for a youth.
georgiehenley 4 years ago
Ohhhh to be good enough to play in the Youth Orchestra :( hehehe
thelightisahead 4 years ago
Private message me the address please.
DrMontague 4 years ago
gosh, the orchestra is so good. it's rare to find young orchestras play that well. janine is good too.
violinbentley1 4 years ago
she's hot! great performance
bitchass888 4 years ago
The strad society lent her a violin... nuff said
jetsetjason 4 years ago
oh yes she is !
jetsetjason 5 years ago
in that case, all i can say is, i am sorry for you if you think so.
angelia81 4 years ago
the best violin player alive today !
jetsetjason 5 years ago
OH - MY - GOD. WAKE UP!!! SHE'S NOT!!
angelia81 5 years ago
you are right!
JohnSuChristine 5 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
are you serious? what ever happened to itzhak pearlman? did he just suddenly become succeeded by this over-rated whore?
thecritiquevirtuoso 4 years ago
We can only conclude that your choice of words cannot but reflect your personal development: pretty low level, I would say.
mangye 4 years ago 2
oooooooooo janine sighhhh
jetsetjason 5 years ago