There is absolutely nothing wrong with her middle part - as children (as I would know from when I played at that age) it is sometimes necessary for us to play at that speed. She will develop as suits be, but as it is there is nothing wrong with her performance, relative to her stage of pianist developement.
One final thought, Marin. The accompanimental chords in a Chopin must, as a general rule, be very soft and light so that the nuanced singing quality of the melody in the right hand can be appreciated. All the best in your music studies, Marin. Thanks again, Enzo, for putting up on your channel the performances of your musical colleagues.
Please, Marin, do not take my previous comment in an unintended way. They are meant as my personal ideas and are given in a spirit of constructiveness. It takes considerable courage for a person to get up on stage and present their music, from memory before an audience.
I know nearly everyone zooms away in the second section. My recollection of the Henle urtext edition is that Chopin gave no direction to speed up. At the very least, therfore, this cannot be regarded as obligatory. I definitely don't like the accelerando approach. ... The pedal should go through the semiquaver rests in the theme, as clearly marked by the composer at least on the first occasion. I know that virtually no-one does this though.
You guys feel really good about talking about "piu mosso" and shit BUT I DON'T THINK YOU FOLLOWED IT WHEN YOU WERE EFING NINE!!!! YEAH!!! I'M TALKING ABOUT YOU MsMikiliki!! SHUT THE HELL UP!!!
she's amazing for a nine year old, but on the full scale of pianists, she isn't that great. Technically she isn't at a level which anyone should really desire, and you can tell from her piece that she has very limited musical sense. The notes have been hammered into her head and she has been taught the way it should sound, but notice the mechanic-like way she plays, it shows you that no matter how hard she works, she will never truly become an elite pianist like a Barenboim etc.
Absolutely amazing! Marin is remarkably talented, and like hamilton, I remember her from the Concert in the Park. Thanks for sharing this with us, Enzo!
I bet she has been playing the piano for 9 years when this video was uploaded
CupcakeKebab739 1 month ago
she is SUPER good!!! how long has she been playing piano?
skylar50 2 months ago
There is absolutely nothing wrong with her middle part - as children (as I would know from when I played at that age) it is sometimes necessary for us to play at that speed. She will develop as suits be, but as it is there is nothing wrong with her performance, relative to her stage of pianist developement.
100flobby 9 months ago
It's amazing how much a child can grasp at an early age.
I kinda wish my parents would've beaten the fuck out of me till I could do something productive like this when I was her age.
Maxero5 1 year ago
Awesome!
skylar50 1 year ago
oops "in a Chopin waltz"
gerardbedecarter 2 years ago
One final thought, Marin. The accompanimental chords in a Chopin must, as a general rule, be very soft and light so that the nuanced singing quality of the melody in the right hand can be appreciated. All the best in your music studies, Marin. Thanks again, Enzo, for putting up on your channel the performances of your musical colleagues.
gerardbedecarter 2 years ago
Please, Marin, do not take my previous comment in an unintended way. They are meant as my personal ideas and are given in a spirit of constructiveness. It takes considerable courage for a person to get up on stage and present their music, from memory before an audience.
gerardbedecarter 2 years ago
I know nearly everyone zooms away in the second section. My recollection of the Henle urtext edition is that Chopin gave no direction to speed up. At the very least, therfore, this cannot be regarded as obligatory. I definitely don't like the accelerando approach. ... The pedal should go through the semiquaver rests in the theme, as clearly marked by the composer at least on the first occasion. I know that virtually no-one does this though.
gerardbedecarter 2 years ago
You guys feel really good about talking about "piu mosso" and shit BUT I DON'T THINK YOU FOLLOWED IT WHEN YOU WERE EFING NINE!!!! YEAH!!! I'M TALKING ABOUT YOU MsMikiliki!! SHUT THE HELL UP!!!
pianoboypagsi 2 years ago 2
absolutely amazing for a nine year old to be able to do this. (:
worryrokspaz325 2 years ago
i think when she did the part with piu mosso, she sped up too fast. It should not be so sudden. the speeding up should stretch for a few bars.
jasvagas 2 years ago
there are so many talented that i dont know who is talented
verygacon 2 years ago
why does everyone always rush the middle part, and makes it sounds like shit.
PsychoSuo9000 2 years ago 5
the middle part has a piu' mosso tempo which means more movement/faster...
miguellouieiii 2 years ago 5
You're so right. I barely heard it here. It doesn't NEED to be that fast.
danpianoman1 2 years ago
She's ok only. She does not have any expressions! Enzo, you are way better than that!
girlypink08 3 years ago 2
girl08, she's only NINE! You're jealous because she can whiz through this, and if you tried to, you'd eff it up. lmao!
PianoCriticsKilller 2 years ago
she's amazing for a nine year old, but on the full scale of pianists, she isn't that great. Technically she isn't at a level which anyone should really desire, and you can tell from her piece that she has very limited musical sense. The notes have been hammered into her head and she has been taught the way it should sound, but notice the mechanic-like way she plays, it shows you that no matter how hard she works, she will never truly become an elite pianist like a Barenboim etc.
309058659 3 years ago 3
i can not believe how many negative comments i am reading here. she is 9! i think she did great!
yiyiku 2 years ago
What a waste, she could be an AWESOME candidate for CMC
agentcoolcat 3 years ago
Did she travel from Japan for this competition ? She is excellent.
brian777999 3 years ago
she's really good!
pianoangel12 3 years ago 2
Fabulous! She is very talented!
pianogirl98 3 years ago
Absolutely amazing! Marin is remarkably talented, and like hamilton, I remember her from the Concert in the Park. Thanks for sharing this with us, Enzo!
Moosie
anmoose 3 years ago 2
She's super! I hope you'll add more videos of her soon. Or better still, why not a channel of her very own? She deserves one!
MusicDoLove 3 years ago
Wow she's awesome ! Does she have her own channel?
koubache 3 years ago
オメデトウ ( ^ _ ^)∠☆PAN！
Awesome work!
TheIshter 3 years ago
What a talent !! I am a fan of hers !
blueyoyi 3 years ago