IJS: Glaring Misconceptions & Omissions... By Muslims

[IslamNederland]

Keep up your dawah aghi ! I liked your libya/democratie intervieuws, nice arguments.

Wasalem aleikum from cold europe, the Netherlands

[dawahworks]

@IslamNederland Shukran!



[IslamNederland]

On the niqab isue , fatima was a young age

al of the sahabayat wearned niqab

if we look at the tafsier they said the hijab is a scarf from the top over the head al the way down and then the imam wrapped the scarf over his head with only his eyes uncovered !

[dawahworks]

@IslamNederland Fatimah was nearly 20 when she marriaed Ali (ra). & 30+ when Muhammad (saw) passed. I dont understand the "young woman" logic.

[IslamNederland]

@dawahworks how old was the prophet peace and blessings upon him when he died? And then still we got the tafsier which speaks of niqab and the fact (for I have read) that the sahabayat wearn niqab.

[dawahworks]

@IslamNederland 63. Yes they were known to wear niqab, but how & when? Also is was not obligatory except for the women of His (saw) household,.

[IslamNederland]

@dawahworks the argument of Fatimah I didnt heard. I think her age 20 doesnt fit the timeline. But the scholars have 2 opinions on niqab: 1.Obligatory 2.Very recommended . But Allah knows best, Keep going on with your dawah!

[IslamNederland]

@dawahworks the argument of Fatimah I didnt heard. I think her age 20 doesnt fit the timeline. But the scholars have 2 opinions on niqab: 1.Obligatory 2.Very recommended . But Allah knows best, Keep going on with your dawah!

[IslamNederland]

@dawahworks how old was the prophet peace and blessings upon him  when he died? And then still we got the tafsier which speaks of niqab and the fact (for I have read) that the sahabayat wearn niqab.

[XAbdr]

Is Ijtihad a source of Sharia? Is marijuana halaal or haram? You get it from Qiyas, I know. But analogy infers a thought process connecting two events. Ijtihad is simplly the jurist solving an issue where no qiyas exists. Are you saying that ijtihad is not a source of Islamic law?

[THAT1UMMAH]

Hiajab is head covering I thought.

Burka is a full covering, right?

I could be wrong, I'll go check it out, Akhi.

Sallam.

[dawahworks]

@THAT1UMMAH No. You are mistaken. Burka is traditional Afghanistani dress which is specifically (by name & style) theirs.

[TheFridayCake]

MashaAllah (Niice)

[THAT1UMMAH]

Are you trying to say that women shouldn't cover?

You need to cool your jets, bro.

[dawahworks]

@THAT1UMMAH The subject was An-Niqab (face veil) not Hijab (full body cover) or Khimar (head covering).

[THAT1UMMAH]

I like you, bro.

LOL, you crack me up!

What you say is true.

[iraqiguy]

Just a question bro, where do you get your information from ? It seems to be copycatted from somewhere judging from the mistakes you make. No disrespect

[dawahworks]

@iraqiguy Yea thats me: "Copycat". As if any knowledge is original.

[iraqiguy]

@dawahworks I would beg to differ bro, knowledge is constantly built upon, even shar' wise, I refer you to the hadith

عن أبي هريرة ـ رضي الله عنه ـ قال : قال رسول الله ـ صلى الله عليه وسلم " إن الله يبعث لهذه الأمة على رأس كل مائة سنة من يجدد لها دينها " (1).

But going back to my question, it seems your level of Arabic (however formidable) is quite weak with some very basic errors. hence I wonder where you get your knowledge from.

Again no disrespect, JazakAllahu khairan for your videos

[dawahworks]

@iraqiguy All knowledge is from Allah (awj). Bring Deen back to its original is REnewing. Not making new. & yes my Arabiyyah is horrible. I look fortward to bros like you to take the lead in the Dawah.

[iraqiguy]

@dawahworks Thank you continuing this convo with me. I am inshallah involved in the Dawa in Australia. Though I have a face for radio, lol.

In regards to knowledge, I feel this is going into a more philosophical arena so it's all good.

One quick correction, it's Ma'sum not Mas'um.

The reason I ask is not unto itself because mashallah you are doing great work. I do however ask because you see to hold an authority that rejects other valid opinions on this issue, is this my misunderstanding ? 

[dawahworks]

@iraqiguy Shukran for the correction. I tend to slip up that way due to an all english environment.

In present the opinion that I adopt. I dont feel obligated to present everyones opinion. This is even a criticism of Fiqh us Sunnah that it leaves you guessing which opinion is correct. However it is impracticle to practice all opinions simultaniously.

[iraqiguy]

@dawahworks I'm not asking that you present all opinions because that would be impractical, just to acknowledge during the video presentation that there are other *valid* opinions as well. Even the four Imams when giving their verdicts would always acknowledge other possible opinions and even demand their students follow other opinions if the latter saw more fit. So have different opinions on non-crucial matters is part of Islamic Fiqh.

Wallahu A3lam.

[snowc3ed]

@iraqiguy

I have checked your channel and no videos were uploaded by your part. I can guess that it's safe to say that your English is not that good or you're afraid to post  videos.

Why are you trying to bring a brother down, he's doing his best. You can give him a hand instead. He even search the Hadith and explained it to you and you are the ARABIC SPEAKER.

I really like what he's trying tp do so just let the brother do what he can and do what you can.

[iraqiguy]

@snowc3ed on the contrary, I would hate to be seen as bringing the brother down. I commend his work and efforts of course. However I feel I can advise the brother in a friendly manner of any mistakes or issues he should make notes of. It's up to him whether he takes them or not.

Allahu a3lam how good my english is, though I have a number of accounts I work from, my other account is nasserkat which you may find what little work I have.

Jazaks brother.

[sube3]

السلام عليكم اخي

ممكن تخصص حلقة عن السروريين

شكراً

[MuslimVlogGuy]

Assalamu Alaikum, I know that wearing a thaub doesn't give you extra sunnah "Blessings" or anything like that. And I know the Prophet Sallalahu alayhi wasalaam wore the clothes of his societies. But my question is what if I do wear one to jummah? or I wear one in the streets of America. I am American, and I know America accepts all cultures and beliefs (you can wear whatever you want.) if I like the clothing of the thaub, is there any harm??

[dawahworks]

@MuslimVlogGuy There is absolutely NOTHING wrong with wearing a thawb ... even in Alaska.

[MuslimVlogGuy]

@dawahworks

Jazakh Allaah khair. Because I know Yasir Qadhi (whom I usually don't take from) has this teaching encouraging Muslims not to wear thaubs in the west.