Added: 1 year ago
From: spettacolare
Views: 2,038
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (182)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • superb loved it

    

  • I always see Syd as who this song is about.I guess LSD and schzophrenia were his wall.Bob Geldof seemed and looked more like Syd than he did Roger in the 1982 movie

  • Fantastic cover! :) And love the video, again expressions and feeling put in, excellent...

  • @CerebralJam Thank you!! I just saw your videos! beautiful voice !!! fantastic... thanks for watching this video.. and again my compliments to you... :) Greg

  • :O amazing cover bro!! I made one 2 tho its a bit different hehe.. :P can you check it out tell me what you think? again this is great!

  • Speechless Dude Speechless...

  • One words .........awesome !!!

  • Sarà la decima volta che la vedo... :-D

  • @urbania70 E anche grazie a te ... 1000 visite ^_^

  • complimenti ;)

  • @Ambry987 Grazie mille ! ^_^ Benvenuta !

  • I'm stunned..as a musician, I often search out covers..you did a great job on this...BRAVO!

  • @MickMan211 Thank you very much ! ;-)

  • wow guys...very nice job!

    I personally know how hard these vocals are to pull off, and you guys knocked them out of the park!

  • @Spector2112 Thanks a lot !! (Yes, the Hey You vocals are pretty hard ^_^)

  • WOW !!! Wonderful cover !!! Excellent collab !!

    Thank you for sharing :))

    Mélodie

  • @flyingmelody63 Thank you very much Mélodie ! ;-)

  • Awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!! A real passion. Quality cover . Grew up with this song, Waters and Gilmour are genius, this cover does mega justice. Superb vocals, obvious that the 2 guys doing this feel the song in a sincere way

  • @thesixtyninemachine thank you so much for your kind comment.. we truly appreciate it.. ;)

  • @thesixtyninemachine :-) Thank you very very much for the nice words ;-)

  • I love this so much, I listen and watch this one often.......

    what a great song from you both.

    Its so so good..........♥♫

    Jo

  • @JoSieLove2Sing4u thank you so much Jo... It makes it all worth it. I'm so glad you like it. We'll try and do another collaboration soon... ! thanks again!

  • @JoSieLove2Sing4u ^_^ Thank you Jo !!!

  • it is you singing?? O___O i thought it was david gilmour..  perfect.

  • awesome cover!!

    Once again you have passed you the wonder of song. Fabulous video editing as well.

    Alec, what I like most is the passion you put into everything you do, my total admiration for it.

    Greg ... too much talent, especially with the guitar (my handicap, guitar) LoL!

    5/5 and fav!

  • @jarrelana ^_^ Thank you so much jarrelana for your kind words ! Yes, Greg has wagons of talent ... video editing too ! Thanks again !

  • stunishing performance!!!

    thanks for sharing it with me, keep up the good job!

  • @Danoportu Thank you very much !!

  • Thanks

  • @helmusico Thank you !

  • Greatest cover on you tube are Here!!!!

  • @carlosayalapaz Thanks !!

  • As I told Alec, I really enjoy the Greg & Alec Project!! :-)

    Great job and I hope you are able to work together in person soon!

  • @AlanEricFan Let's hope ! ;-) Thanks again Neil !!

  •  Very good charactarization and collaboration!!! Thanks for sharing...

  • @fazil69 Thank you Fazil !! ;-)

  • @modernsebastien Thank you Seb, merci !!!

  • Back here for my daily view of this.. I think one of the keys is the contrast of directing styles: Greg watching often in camera and Alec not, which furnishes the point of view of Pink (Alec). Interestingly in movies actors almost never watch in camera, in TV you must watch in camera, and in videoclips you can do both ways

  • Hi guys! This is a fantastic piece which I belive you' ve played so amazing! It's intense, expressive and full of phatos.. great as the first collaboration!

  • @CodeNamedKara thank you very much for kind comment... :)

  • @CodeNamedKara Grazie !! :-)

  • Quando volete fare On An Island a 3 io ci sono...mi vesto anche da Crosby con la parrucca e i baffoni Bianchi! Bel lavoro ragazzi, propongo di fare presto un'uscita floydiana!

  • @guidopelati grazie Guidy! domani vado a fare On An Island davvero... Sardegna!

  • @guidopelati Grazie mille Guido ! Piacere di conoscerti ! Grazie anche del messaggio sul mio canale e della sottoscrizione dei quali approfitto ora per risponderti ! ;-) Suoni molto bene ! Ci si becca, ciao !

  • Grande qualità, passione e interpretazione per un brano che adoro, sei sempre uno spettacolo my friend..

  • @Ruvidj grazie ! mi fa piacere che ti piace.. :)

  • @Ruvidj Grazie anche da parte mia !

  • Awesome cover!

    Thumbs up for you guys :))

  • @nascream79 Thank you dear... keep rockin' ! ;)

  • @nascream79 ^_^ Thank you Nasreen !!!

  • Great singing and playing!

  • @AngryNinja9000 thanks dude ! :)

  • @AngryNinja9000 Thank you very much !

  • excellent bravo 5*****

  • @vanessathierry Thank You !!

  • @modernsebastien merci ;)

  • bravo...bravíiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii­iiisimo

  • @tavitabayon muchas gracias!

  • @tavitabayon Thank you David !

  • In my comment I forgot to say... great sound.. effects and mix, good job

  • @urbania70 grazie Giorgio.. ;)

  • I keep listening to this, its so amazing. ♫♥

  • @JoSieLove2Sing4u Me too, and doing a lot of sharing, it deserves it.

    4:23 Alec = Roger Waters!

  • @JoSieLove2Sing4u ^_^ So happy for it, really ! Thank you !

  • beautiful and sing beautifully

  • @tvrodri gracias !!!

  • @tvrodri Gracias Rodrigo !!

  • Great collaboration!! Well done to both of you!

  • @AceGallagher thank you ! we appreciate it!

  • @AceGallagher ^_^ Thank you Jill !!!

  • great great cover ragazzi

    your voices are perfect togheter

    your video seems a real professionnal clip

    very good job

  • @joliroi merci !!! :)

  • @joliroi Thank you very much Loris, you're very kind ! :-) I'm very happy you liked this one a lot my friend !!! Merci !

  • You guys are both awesome. Really great!

    Jason

  • @frankzito1 thanks Jason !

  • @frankzito1 Hey Jason ! :-) Thank you very much my friend !!!

  • Awesome¡¡¡ Amazing¡¡

  • @Quiquemusic muchas gracias !!!

  • @Quiquemusic Muchas gracias Enrique ! :-)

  • Awesome work Alec and Greg !!! Is amazing how you did the montage of images and video editing.

    Magnificent voices of the two, good job on keyboards and guitars, and good performance from Alec.

    Make more videos together, please. Congratulations to both and... direct to my favorites !

  • Awesome work Alec and Greg !!! Is amazing how you did the montage of images and video editing.

    Magnificent voices of the two, good job on keyboards and guitars, and good performance from Alec.

    Make more videos together, please. Congratulations to both and... direct to my favorites !

  • @milaraven thank you!! we appreciate all that you've said and there's no doubt about it.. me and Alec will certainly do other songs together.. thanks for watching.

  • @milaraven Gracias Mila !!! :-) So happy you liked it a lot ! Video montage was made by Greg and YES it's great ! We'll surely make other videos together ! ^_^ Thanks again !

  • Awesome...all thumbs up for your and thanks to Giorgio for the share,

    Lilly

  • @LillyC68 Lilly I just saw your piano playing... wow.. i'm on my knees.. thank you very much for commenting.. truly honoured... :)

  • @LillyC68 Thank you Lilly ! :-)

  • very nice and fine video thanks to josexara for sharing

  • @paolitas7 thanks to both of you! josexara for sharing and you for commenting ! thanks! :)

  • @paolitas7 Thank you very much Paolita !

  • Fantastic! Superb! Great job to you both!!! :)

  • @zorapapp thank you !!! we are very happy with all these wonderful comments!

  • @zorapapp ^_^ Thank you so much Zora !!!

  • Really beautiful!!!

    Gaby.

  • @pili2255 Gracias Gaby .. amables palabras que son aún más fuertes cuando se le dijo por artistas como tú

  • @pili2255 Thank you very much Gaby ! :-)

  • #OMG GREAT! Bravissimi ragazzi! I'm going to watch this many times and to share to many floydian contacts!

    Vocals: incredible imitations of Gilmour and Waters vocal timbres, very good

    singing, awesome sync

    Greg: great guit, keys, harmonies

    Alec: your best (so far) acting in a musical video!!

    Very good video work

    Great dramatic effect!

    And a great idea to spread the word about the Wall tour (Monday I'll get the ticket!)

    Giorgio

    PS Funny indeed you did by cyber though you live in same city!

  • @urbania70 grazie Giorgio !!! it's true.. siamo a neanche 20 minuti magari da uno e l'altro ! hehehe it's crazy.. but it's my fault per questioni di tempo. Why am I writing half English e mezzo in italiano ?????

    Anyway.. thank you Giorgio so much for your informative and very very kind comment!

  • @urbania70 THANK YOU ! ^_^ Grazie Giorgio, anche per lo sharing !!! Felicissimi che ti sia piaciuto tanto !

  • Comment removed

  • One of the best collab's I have ever seen/heard!

  • @dohertykaki wow! that certainly makes our day ! thank you so much !

  • @dohertykaki Thank you so much Kate ! :-) And thank you for the nice comment on my channel as well !

  • FANTASTIC JOB guys! Keep on rocking!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @POPARTPRODUCTlONS thanks dude !!

  • @POPARTPRODUCTlONS Thanks Dave ! ;-) I appreciate it !!!

  • WOW!!! This is so great! I love it and you guys rock out so much!  Thanks to Jo for sharing your amazing talent. All the stars and have a great day

  • @SongwriterEricJohn thank you and thanks to Jo for introducing us! much appreciated...

  • @SongwriterEricJohn Thank you very very much ! ;-)

  • Well done guys, nice guitar work, Cheers Billy ;)

  • @bbsb300 cheers Billy !! thanks for the visit !

  • @bbsb300 Thank you a lot Billy ! ^_^

  • Espectacular..¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡..­.....que maravillosa idea.......La interpretación, la voz, la guitarra....gracias.

  • @jetamez muchas gracias !! Gracias por su atención y comentar!

  • @jetamez Gracias Jetamez !!

  • Che bella idea, veramente...Alex, senza che tu te ne abbia a male, per una volta faccio prima i complimenti a Greg. Il suo timbro m'ha ricordato davvero quello di Dave Gilmour per certi tratti (ed anche ottimo suono di chitarra)!

    Fatene altri, è venuto davvero benissimo questo!

  • @mbrellin grazie per i complimenti ! credo che siamo entrambi contenti del risultato di questa collaborazione.. e certamente ne faremo altri insieme... grazie ancora... Greg

  • @mbrellin Fai pure, se li merita tutti ^_^ Grazie !

  • Mi piace, Luca. *****

  • @snorkies1 grazie Luca !

  • @snorkies1 ^_^ Grazie caro Luca !

  • Outstanding...

  • @frankibio gracias !!!

  • @frankibio :-))) Gracias Carlos, my friend !

  • You two are wonderful together. Great singing and mezmerizing guitar. 5 stars for sure. Very good Alec and Greg*******  Linda

  • @pugmom6 Thank you Linda!! we are glad you liked it ! and thank you for leaving a comment... :)

  • @pugmom6 Thank you very much Linda, you're very kind :-)

  • Excellent your cyber collaboration !!

    Very good cover of Pink Floyd :)

    Thank you for the discovery josexara ;-))

  • @ERICBALLAND thanks for watching !

  • @ERICBALLAND cheers.. we very much appreciate it... ! thanks for visiting and commenting ! ;)

  • @ERICBALLAND Thanks a lot !!

  • Vraiment superbe ***** merci Jos pour ce partage , Bravo à vous deux ....

  • @rebel750v4 merci merci !! :)

  • @rebel750v4 Merci beaucoup !!!

  • Brilliant - outstanding collaboration and well put together

  • @icebluehorizon thank you!

  • @icebluehorizon Thank you Mike !! ;-)

  • Perfect rendition! thumbs UP :)

  • @bungalowbill969 cheers !!!

  • @bungalowbill969 Grazie amico ! :-)

  • Great!

  • @jreichbart thanks!

  • @jreichbart Thank you very much dear Jake ! ;-)

  • Hey guys, I've enjoyed your vid a lot !!

    Hope to see more stuff from you in the next future...

  • @TheMaxprs thanks so much for visiting. I certainly think that we shall collaborate in the near future.. absolutely..

  • @TheMaxprs Grazie Max ! :-) Happy you liked it and ... yes ... we both want to do more ^_^

  • Quelle magnifique reprise !

  • @monsieurgontrand merci monsieur !!

  • @monsieurgontrand Merci ! :-)

  • great job !!! To the both of you well balanced great performances

  • @linktronics thank you !! we are both very greatful for all these wonderful comments... thanks!

  • @linktronics Thanks Kurt, I'm very happy you liked it ! :-)

  • bravo !!wonderful music !love !

  • @cogermax91 merci madamoiselle !!!

  • @cogermax91 Merci !!!

  • excellente reprise !!!!! super !!!!excellente voix et guitare!!!

  • @franckbrin merci !! J'ai vraiment l'apprécier

  • @franckbrin Merci beaucoup !!

  • This is absolutely wonderful you guys. Great collaboration. Love it. james:)

  • @ignitionfive cheers James.. glad you liked it !!! thanks for watcing

  • @ignitionfive Hey James ! Thank you very much my friend !

  • Fantastique *****

  • @XblueMarieX merci... :)

  • @XblueMarieX Merci !! :-)

  • QUE DIRE A PART SUBLIME 5*********

  • @josexara Je suis sans mots ... merci :)

  • @josexara Merci beaucoup Jose ... pour le commentaire dans le canal également ! :-)

  • Génial, bravo.

  • @gmonier1 merci !!!!! ;)

  • @gmonier1 Merci !!

  • ottimo!! ;)

  • @lo7angus Grazie !!

  • stupendo!!!!!!!

    grandi!!!!!!!!!

  • @albetazza1983 grazie !!

  • @albetazza1983 Ma grazie !!! ^_^

  • First of all, Greg, nice to meet you: AleC has talked me a few times about you!

    It's amazing how many parts you can play and sing: you just did a great job!!!

    And just the same I can say (as usual!) about you, AleC... not only: in this song I especially see you get rocking and wild... the whole thing results quite emotional!

    Thank you guys for sharing such a pearl (and that's referred to both the original and your version! :-D) with all of us!