Beyond Reality - American Idol 8 Recap 3/17/09

[ThetseySitders520]

ummm, thats why kris won idiots

[wendygirl123]

you guys are really mean. country music is not that bad. you guys don't have to be brats, taylor hicks sucks anyway.

[LiLobsterCrab]

you people are gay. You gays make fun of People that have more talent then you, you bitch

[ethi0chick]

Anoopp :D

A-freakin-MAZING*

i though Alexis was awesome too.

they should have saved her! :/

[Secretlifecrazy]

Her name is Lil u need to get it straight before u harass Simon

[soccerkid133]

weird...............

[4chonch]

shut up!! what do u know.

[landind]

It's called country week, it doesn't mean that all of them needs to sing county like. They should infuse they're own style on what they are going to sing. They're going to sing country songs but not adapt the whole genre.

I liked Kris Allen's performance and I think he did a good job. Your judgments are pretty shallow and underrated.

[p7879]

ADAM-azing!!!!

[gimmiemycookies111]

don't make fun of my kris

D<

[onehooahwife]

I totally HATED Adam ... "what's that June, you need help turning over?" Sure!

[vickyvicks0]

this is such a though year.. I really don't know who is going home... well last week I knew, but from now on its gon be hard...a lot of good ones this season. anoop is my fave tho! :D

If TOTB don't mess with the votes we will have our first all male top 4. and Im hoping is Anoop/Adam/Matt/Kris.

[COM1292]

is that your mom on the left?

[babiegirl40]

i agree they suck!!! plus country is great

[Reaume09]

U Both SUCK!!!!!

[7913sasa]

Crap...

[hadapurpura]

Hey, did you notice how Ryan totally introduced Adam as "Adam Glambert"? (nothing against the guy, I think he`s great)

[alexloewer2]

I l.o.v.e. Kris Allen!! I hope he makes at least TOP 5!!

I hate Adam Lambert!! He gets on my freakin nerves!!

[eyalgot]

Gosh, you're mean!!!

[iluvmy4blessings]

That was hilarious comment about LSD and so true....it was trippy. But like you said no one can deny he can sing!

[ScottieLowe]

Megan and Scott can't sing AT ALL. If she wasn't blond and he wasn't blind, neither one of them would be in the top 12/13.

Adam is a trainwreck.

[liina000]

ADAM ROCKS MY WORLD.

[xxsummerchica95xx]

adam is the best! and i deff think he should win ! he is sooooooo hot too ! = )

[Saratheinvisible]

ahh, ADAM!...(no comment)

anoop did really good.

lil rounds was amazing!

[dipeza]

wow, i agree with all your comments on the contestants. good observations. Here are my faves in no particular order and in no way sayin one of these will win...but these are my top 4 (in my world LOL) Anoop, Allison, Kris and Matt

[KikiTRS]

Lol does anything Paula says ever make sense?

[scottrsmithjr]

Does anyone remember last year's Dolly Parton week. Brooke also did Jolene and she did a much better job than Alexis and even though she has a much smaller range than Alexis she killed that song where Alexis sang pretty bad.

[l0r3st0]

that song is too country for anyone to put a different, unique spin on; i think it's best left alone. stay away from "jolene!"

[JoshHamric]

Paula told Scott Macintyre that the piano was becoming a crutch (the dude can't sing + he's blind... obviously he needs the crutch, Paula!) He used it last week and we also saw him using it in Hollywood. However, she said absolutely nothing about Matt Giraud using it. He used it last week and also in Hollywood + he's not blind. A bit weird?

[l0r3st0]

i agree, there's nothing wrong with being stuck to the piano, stevie wonder performed that way. scott's blind (legally), he can't be expected to dance around the stage.

[zatinatube]

adam lambert was brilliant

[freethrow7792]

These are 2 complete idiots!!

[NY22Giants22]

THE TOP 4 RUMOR THING IS UNTRUE!! YES!!

[bakatais]

Hmm it was country week, yet what Adam did had nothing to do with country. I really admired lil for actually trying to sing a country song without messing it up.

Anyway my fav. of the night were Matt, Anoop, Kris, Danny, and Allison.

[JamesMlove]

I LOVED Matt!!! He did such a good job along with Danny, Anoop, and Kris. Adam is just too over the top!

[muslimqueen]

I LOVE Anoop w00t anoop

[marysoldt]

ANOOP! his voice was AMAZING!! is AMAZING!! i been liking his voice since..i heard him audition..outta the guys..i think his voice is the best...(to me ADAM just has popularity..but ANOOP has the Voice..especially last night dang..gave me the chills!!

[peacemakerx3]

jboy4493 i loved rock star and

Dilana from rock star was amazing and

adam is just nausiating I hate his act

you cant compare that gay boy to her

get rid of adam now !please!!!!!!

[lonasxandxhepner]

I agree get rid of adam! ugh but you kno if he gets voted off the judges will save him!

[supafreakeyyy]

Adam let me down last night!

[DavidArchuleta94]

I lovee Matt Giraud.

& Megan Corkrey (:

[WhiteBull]

I HATE country. Nothing further.

[epicdweeb]

The grand entrance by the judges is so corny.

[joeyyyy493]

adam lambert & the blind guy need to go. i hate them with sick passions. and carrie is the best thing to come out of this show, im so excited for her performance tonightt.

[jberke]

Adam is amazing... you're crazy

[HEYitsBRIANNAx0]

YES! i agree for michael sarver to go home!!

GO MATTTTTTTT :)

[ihatebsb]

OMG!!!...i saw the same article regarding AI already chosen the final 4...i knoe who they said it will be too...all i can tell u is that the AI producers don't want Alexis and Danny to be the ultimate final 2!!!....

[jboy4493]

If anyone's interested this woman named Dilana performed a very similar version to Adam's Ring of Fire on Rock Star: Supernova a few summers ago. I think the difference is that when Dilana breaks into the choruses she dials back the weirdness however Adam just keeps it going until the bitter end.

[regemo]

lol@ the bear comment at 8:24. That was the only performance I fast forwarded through too.

[regemo]

Hahaha I loved Adam's performance. It was the coolest "??? wth?" moment since Tatiana DelTorro left the show along with her spaztastic episodes.

But the arrangement was cool-fresh-new and his vocals were hot. It's sad that people are sleeping on Matt Geroud

[lemonysnicket234]

I LOVED MATT G!

[NY22Giants22]

american idol has already chosen the top 4!!!! idk how true it is, but it was on the radio this morning and i saw it online. i guess and american idol staff person said that the top 4 has been decided. i wont tell u who it is, cause i was pissed enough when i heard. idk if it true, but we'll have to see

[jberke]

Actually, Alexis Grace was one of the people the "leak" claimed was going to be in the top 4. So I guess it's not true

[punknsmasher]

Anoop was the best!

adam gave me nightmares last night...

[Parody101]

Maybe it's just me, and I admit he sings great but,...I just don't like Danny Gokey :(

He's a good singer, I just...bleh, don't like him for some reason.

[manda5456]

I totally agree with you! I don't really understand the hype with him. I like Matt G, Anoop, and Allison the best. I think Kris will do really well...He'll definetly have the preteen vote lol

[mike1956will]

Adam was horrible and tasteless. You don't take a country classic and do that to it, even if you are a great performer, much less a talentless, efeminate, gay-boy like Adamette....Go away loser!

[alittleguitarlesson]

adam did the best by far imo

no more shallow american idol disney performances

no one is even talking about the other performances that is how big of a deal it is love it or hate it

[RsMark051]

goo allison

[Masterxazer]

I was impressed by how well Megan did while being that sick. But my favorite performance was actually Kris, who I'm beginning to like. Almost.

Adam's performance really was a major WTF-moment. He'll probably still get votes for being Adam, but either way he won't be sent home since the judges will save him. But now I really don't know if I like him or not.

[hurleygirl593]

I LOOOOOOOOOVE KRIS! <3

hes so adorable. i thought this week was good overall. I totally agree with you guys about Adam, good vocals as always, he clearly will go far in this competition...just wasn't a good week for him in my opinion..hey, I still love him :)

YAY ANOOP! FINALLY!

[lymon1500]

i loved matts performanceeeeee

[guyluvsbeauty]

I love these two Mencha's ! It is so much fun to hear their analysis. Props to both of you for a clever review of each show.

[LadyMatsuyama]

adam was like some campy drag queen without the drag. over the top and a mess.

[ldon12345]

and I also loved Adam's performance!

...and Megans!

[ldon12345]

I have to admit that i didnt really like you guys before and thought that you should stop doing recaps but now I always find myself watching your recaps because i like to hear what your opinion is on my favourite shows. Keep up the good job!

[TomCollinsgirl]

When Adam was done, my friend and i looked at each other and went "what the hell was that?"

[ihatebsb]

Let me just yesterday's preformances were really similar in quality yesterday. After much thought. Here's is how i rank the preformances 1) Matt 2) Anoop 3) Kris 4) Alison 5) Megan 6) Danny 7) Alexis 8) Scott 9) Adam 10) Lil 11) Micheal PS: These ranks are only prefomance base...it is not at all based on who i like and not like

[tube4417098]

Freaking funny i love yalls

[bobitsuki]

a solid performance by Anoop! Yes! he is back!....................and I am soooooooooo glad and happy about it!

[vickyvicks0]

anoop was hot!!!

[Arkansas19852003]

KRIS ROCKED!!!

[allweb03]

Adam Lambert is clearly the leader and will win the whole thing. He is a total freak which is what you would expect from American Idol. (got to love that guy-liner stuff too) When you think of "American Idol" Adam Lambert is the definition.

[taylorsvillelove]

Megan got rid of the 'Corkrey" Because it is her EX usbands last name and she doesnt want to get famous with his name.

[chiefsrulebr1]

hey im sorry to say this but u got one part wrong its not megan corkrey it's megan joy now im serious too play it back and everybody called her megan joy, can u figure out y her name is different all of the sudden also if u feel like calling anybody's name just remember i said it first

[Madrosed]

It was always Megan Joy because its Megan Joy Corkrey.

[taylorsvillelove]

Megan got rid of the 'Corkrey" Because it is her EX husbands last name and she doesnt want to get famous with his name.

[Madrosed]

You got it chiefs!

[AboutGetClean]

Tonight belonged to Kris, Anoop and Allison. I usually like Adam and Alexis too...but tonight not so much.

[flipian86]

Hahaha I just subscribed to your recaps.

Doing a great job! I agree to all your comments (we are on the same wave length).

Keep up the good work!

[Lwatson09]

i want allison to get far, but i dont think she will :(

[dollywood48]

Any guesses on who I voted for? LOL. Tough competition this year, excellent talent.

[mike20079]

my favs. this year are Matt and Kris, allison in third. I think they make wayyyy too much outta adam and danny. it annoyed the hell outta me when paula said she saw both of them in the finale. I cheered when simon said matt out sung Danny and when he called adam's performance rubbish.

[stevenash1386]

my faves wee kris anoop dog danny i think mike or ax goes i just tho y no f hill songs

[MrsJasperHale08]

Yay Matt!!!! I definitely thought Matt and Allison did the best and Adam has annoyed the crap out of me since day 1 so I really really really hope he goes home....

<3 Josie

[iHeartY0UTube]

Kara looked like she wearing a super hero outfit.

[tarala2]

"I'm impressed that you remembered all those words, how did you do that?" Really? Just don't say anything to me.