henry is the killer he brings everybody 2 the island he knew where everybody was gon to stand at the wedding he the only one who had the paper about that he knew trish exboyfriend was there so he killed him cause member on the boat when the ex got killed henry uncle marty gun and money was still there when danny them found him and took the money and he keep trying to save abby not trish but he keep stoping abby from killing wakefield and plus henry and jimmy go at it and somebody on the docks
I REALLY dont want to believe Henry or Jimmy would do anything to hurt Abby by killing her dad. Maybe its Sully or maybe that one black dude, no ones said anything about him.
Well.......EXCUSE ME! Just wonderin why no one speculated about DANNY. I still hope its not Henry but your right it could be him. I just dont want JW's helper to be Jimmy or Henry bc they're my fave characters, well guy characters.
P.S. I wonder why Henry would sabotage his own wedding, doesnt make sense, but whatever you say.
Right now they're pointing at Jimmy. Everytime they've pointed at someone it has been a deadend. What if it's Abby? Wouldn't that blow everyone's mind. The murders did start when she came home, and when JD died he said it's all about her. I'm calling my shot right now! Abby is teaming up with John Wakefield because they're father and daughter.
no. she would never team up with wakefield. when he killed her father he came to her and she screamed at him and she went to go shoot him. when it was JUST the two of them. its either henry or jimmy. and cant decide!!!
it can be henry cause he might want to call off the wedding, & maybe go to abby? but i dont think its jimmy- way too obvious. & the wedding is what bought abby back to island, so why jimmy want to send her away, again?
I thought it was Jimmy all along but now they are so obviously pointing at him, that it's not him. I think it's Henry because maybe he had some beef with his uncle and started killing people close to him and then Wakefield just started to kill as well so whatever, but I don't just think it's Wakefield.
at the begining is trish in her wedding dress? why? i dont think annyone is helping wakefield, i think he's doing it by himself, cant wait for the next episode!
Finally someone else thinks it might be Shea! I'm not sure who I suspect, but I'm leaning towards her. Or Abby - they could pull an Agatha Christie on us. Or maybe just no one at al.
My theory was blown last week. All season I thought it was the sheriff. I believed that the sheriff committed the murders 7 years ago and pinned them on Wakefield. I guess I can't be right all the time.
I'd have to agree with you. The next episodes are titled 'Gasp' and 'Sigh', respectively. I think that Trish will be chased by Wakefield, and then runs into Henry. She thinks she is safe, then gasps as Henry kills her. The ultimate betrayal.
That's really good. But why would Henry kill his Uncle? Also why Would Henry kill Abby's dad since they are bffs. I think it's the dude who likes Abby. (I forget his name)
I think what muffins6789 was trying to say is that Henry is like Abby's older brother. He's been lookin out for her all season, even when all the evidence said that Abby was JW's child. He wouldnt do anything to hurt her.
Jimmy is " the dude who likes Abby" and a lot can change in 7 years. But they belong together and there is a part of me that still believes he's innocent, but you never know.
I know. I was just saying it sounded weird. And jasmeetsidhu if you see this I already knew but you're still a one of the jerks who likes to ruin everything for everyone. Have fun doing that.
Comment removed
RawrtoSpeak 2 years ago
HE LOVES ABBY
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
i bet you jimmy is the second killer...thats what me and my sister thought the whole time.
nbbforever009 2 years ago
u r wrong HENRY is the killer
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
oh, ok? it was just my opinion...
nbbforever009 2 years ago
I BET U 5 DOLLARS HENRY IS THE KILLER
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
um...no?
nbbforever009 2 years ago
my guess is henry is wakefeilds child/the other killer
Courtney943 2 years ago
The 2nd killer will be Wakefield's kid with Abby's mom. It can't be Danny, he's black.
kthevsd 2 years ago
Comment removed
muffins6789 2 years ago
Well, I'm sure Danny is Wakefield and Abby's mom's kid. He just got a major tan, that's all.
savieandkay 2 years ago
henry is the killer he brings everybody 2 the island he knew where everybody was gon to stand at the wedding he the only one who had the paper about that he knew trish exboyfriend was there so he killed him cause member on the boat when the ex got killed henry uncle marty gun and money was still there when danny them found him and took the money and he keep trying to save abby not trish but he keep stoping abby from killing wakefield and plus henry and jimmy go at it and somebody on the docks
1g45 2 years ago
it is definatly sully, he is killing, and wakefeilds son. and trish is in her wedding dress because she ran out of clean clothes...
anniebannani93 2 years ago
or maybe its not any of them and it's just wakefield i mean think about it they tried to trick us before
chachamidnight 2 years ago
I REALLY dont want to believe Henry or Jimmy would do anything to hurt Abby by killing her dad. Maybe its Sully or maybe that one black dude, no ones said anything about him.
Twilighter1495 2 years ago
no one said anythin about DANNY bc he is goin to die and HENRY is the killer not jImmy
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
Well.......EXCUSE ME! Just wonderin why no one speculated about DANNY. I still hope its not Henry but your right it could be him. I just dont want JW's helper to be Jimmy or Henry bc they're my fave characters, well guy characters.
P.S. I wonder why Henry would sabotage his own wedding, doesnt make sense, but whatever you say.
Twilighter1495 2 years ago
okay afterseeing some videos like these i must admit i kinda thing its henry now teehee
xxtwilight2nightxx 2 years ago
Henry and Wakefield are the killers, and Madison's involved somehow.
Frieza1500 2 years ago
Henry has become the sexy pick. Two of the victims have been related to him; JD and Uncle Marty. Maybe the one everyone is overlooking is Madison.
Tigerhawk1978 2 years ago
Right now they're pointing at Jimmy. Everytime they've pointed at someone it has been a deadend. What if it's Abby? Wouldn't that blow everyone's mind. The murders did start when she came home, and when JD died he said it's all about her. I'm calling my shot right now! Abby is teaming up with John Wakefield because they're father and daughter.
Tigerhawk1978 2 years ago
Comment removed
Twilighter1495 2 years ago
no. she would never team up with wakefield. when he killed her father he came to her and she screamed at him and she went to go shoot him. when it was JUST the two of them. its either henry or jimmy. and cant decide!!!
xxtwilight2nightxx 2 years ago
it can be henry cause he might want to call off the wedding, & maybe go to abby? but i dont think its jimmy- way too obvious. & the wedding is what bought abby back to island, so why jimmy want to send her away, again?
xPankti 2 years ago
I thought it was Jimmy all along but now they are so obviously pointing at him, that it's not him. I think it's Henry because maybe he had some beef with his uncle and started killing people close to him and then Wakefield just started to kill as well so whatever, but I don't just think it's Wakefield.
seaweedgravy 2 years ago
it is HENRY that is the killer and Jimmy will tell Abby that he loves her and everything he has been holding back for her for so long!
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
i agree with that. and then when trish is running shes in her wedding dress. mabey hes mentally psyhco
xxtwilight2nightxx 2 years ago
Jeez, you couldn't have stopped yourself from trying to spoil everyone could you? >_>
sparkleytangerine 2 years ago
sorry i couldnt help ittt
jasmeetsidhu1234 2 years ago
at the begining is trish in her wedding dress? why? i dont think annyone is helping wakefield, i think he's doing it by himself, cant wait for the next episode!
kevy293 2 years ago
Comment removed
Twilighter1495 2 years ago
it was confirmed that shes in a wedding dress, VOLUNTARILY,
kevy293 2 years ago
Yes she is. Maybe she was thinking about how beautiful her wedding could have (should have) been.
Twilighter1495 2 years ago
I think it's Shea, Trish's sister! No one is even suspecting her. OR Sully. So two options for me: Shea or Sully for the killer.
greenleo111 2 years ago
Finally someone else thinks it might be Shea! I'm not sure who I suspect, but I'm leaning towards her. Or Abby - they could pull an Agatha Christie on us. Or maybe just no one at al.
savieandkay 2 years ago
good point...and then there were none is a great book.
nbbforever009 2 years ago
My theory was blown last week. All season I thought it was the sheriff. I believed that the sheriff committed the murders 7 years ago and pinned them on Wakefield. I guess I can't be right all the time.
Tigerhawk1978 2 years ago
^^^^^^^^^( I agree)
Maybe it is Henry, Jimmy, or just Wakefield. I still think it's Jimmy and Wakefield but, will see on the 9th or on the 11th.
muffins6789 2 years ago
i think its henry who is the killer
arrshika 2 years ago
I'd have to agree with you. The next episodes are titled 'Gasp' and 'Sigh', respectively. I think that Trish will be chased by Wakefield, and then runs into Henry. She thinks she is safe, then gasps as Henry kills her. The ultimate betrayal.
LupisNero 2 years ago
That's really good. But why would Henry kill his Uncle? Also why Would Henry kill Abby's dad since they are bffs. I think it's the dude who likes Abby. (I forget his name)
muffins6789 2 years ago
Maybe his Uncle wasn't really his Uncle...
And I think you're confusing Henry with Jimmy. Jimmy was the one who was friends with Abby's dad/
LupisNero 2 years ago
No I'm not. I'm saying why would Henry kill Abby's dad if Henery and Abby are bffs.
muffins6789 2 years ago
I think what muffins6789 was trying to say is that Henry is like Abby's older brother. He's been lookin out for her all season, even when all the evidence said that Abby was JW's child. He wouldnt do anything to hurt her.
Jimmy is " the dude who likes Abby" and a lot can change in 7 years. But they belong together and there is a part of me that still believes he's innocent, but you never know.
Twilighter1495 2 years ago
finally someone understood me! lmao.
muffins6789 2 years ago
'Gasp' and 'Sigh'? I'm sorry, that just sounds...weird.
savieandkay 2 years ago
That's what it said on IMDb. *Shrugs*
LupisNero 2 years ago
It's the sound the two people who die in those episodes make when they die.
sparkleytangerine 2 years ago
I know. I was just saying it sounded weird. And jasmeetsidhu if you see this I already knew but you're still a one of the jerks who likes to ruin everything for everyone. Have fun doing that.
savieandkay 2 years ago