Gimme Three Steps - Lynyrd Skynyrd Expert Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band

[NeilFraudstrong]

I've watched a few of your videos and I am surprised to see that the charts are nearly identical on a lot of these.

[Maztuhmind]

guitar hero chart is better but the rock band chart still looks like fun.

[dominick477]

Guitar heros chart are fucking horrible!!

ROCK BAND KICK ASS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[DarrenSanch]

Always makes me feel good when i see im linked in one of your description's. lol

<3

[LaZrKaTz4109]

wow the guitar hero version looks so much better

[AsianboyRice]

Overlay the audio, other than that I love these kind of videos!

[bodayoda1]

Wtf was going on in RB's chart during the chorus? Do they realize there's different notes in there???

[CCDaDon15]

@bodayoda1 They charted a different guitar track. there are two in this song. both audible in both of the games.

[DerekMan00]

This is awesome :D

[wwebigman]

Please do more, just dont switch the audio

[OzzyOzrock]

Npaen style, haha.

[hokieman1]

do hangar 18 comparison

[SuperGigaman]

Do people not have a sound system? especially when playing these games??

[v4sh101]

@SuperGigaman I use headphones if that says anything.

[SuperGigaman]

@v4sh101 That's pretty good. what i mean is, on my sound system, there is barely a difference in volume between the games(RB= 15, GH= 18 out of 50 i think). How's it sound with headphones? never tried.

[gordofredito]

at some points it's a bit annoying, appreciate the effort though... do what you want with these type of vids. I liked better the RB chart in some parts, but overall GH chart is better

[32Crayon]

guitar hero 5 is just really really quiet overall. i've always maxed out the volume settings on each game and i usually played at about 20 volume on my tv, but for GH5 i usually play on 30-35 volume. it's just a quiet game for some reason.

[TheWattershed]

Haha. RB compresses the shit out of the song. I prefer turning up the volume and hearing the song as it is supposed to be heard.

[xXForgottenFallXx]

GH just out of personal opinion. I like the chart better.

[CharlieKaneAndSon]

I've noticed two things about GH and RB while watching these comparison videos:

1) On GH, they like to chart lower, and on RB, they like to chart higher.

2) On GH, they like to use index-ring finger chords (GY, RB, YO), and on RB, they like to use index-middle finger chords (GR, RY, YB, BO).

[SuperGigaman]

@CharlieKaneAndSon Are you talking about the "highway"? cuz i think i noticed that too

[CharlieKaneAndSon]

@SuperGigaman Yeah, GH charts are generally more towards the left side of the highway, and RB charts (in comparison) are generally more towards the right side.

[1119Masterchief]

Nice job and more please.

[Monisrocks1995]

GH!!!!

[Whizzer191]

Nice editing! The Guitar Hero audio is really bad. I think Harmonix did the better mixing here.

I also think Rock Band has the more accurate chart. At times, it seems like the Guitar Hero chart is for a different version of the song.

[gordofredito]

@Whizzer191 not before the solo, RB chart fails there

[GoldenJokered]

Someone needs to make a Freebird comparsion when Rock Band 3 comes out. Guitar Hero 2, Guitar Smash Hits, Guitar Hero DLC and Rock Band 3, four different charts, could be interesting :D

[captainjack2781]

@GoldenJokered  The Smash Hits and DLC are the same version if I remember right.

[CharlieKaneAndSon]

@captainjack2781 On Wii, the DLC version has a different chart. I think the 360 and PS3 users accidently got the SH version.

[GoldenJokered]

@captainjack2781 There two different versions, two different recordings.

[CCDaDon15]

@GoldenJokered Nah. There's two guitar tracks. One mimicking the bass track and the other one. GH Charted the one mimicking the Bass and RB charted the other.

[CCDaDon15]

@GoldenJokered oh nevermind I thought you were talking about the chart differences in this song -__-

[tmlguy24]

want more i love them (: g  gh chart looks beter

[accquizzer]

I watch! Put up more! (I persoanlly like Guitar Hero etter for this one)

[aberyf]

more plaz but i prefer rock band though :D

[accquizzer]

I watch! Put up more!

[XxIronManxX1]

I think rockband is more accurate.

[goodboy196]

some parts i like guitar hero on. an some parts i like rb on. solo, ill prefer rb. but i think no one can decide which is better on 3:44. ones doing rhythm an the other is doin lead. but that audio of rb is fuckin amazing

[siddey1]

GH = Better chart.

RB = Better audio.

[MrLordofrock]

GH chart is better.

[FlameClaw]

For the audio things, RB audio always sounds clearer, I don't know why :P Possible just mixed better.

[iammaxhailme]

Which are the ten you have recorded, anyway?

[toymasheenSH]

moar of this

[Tiduspeco]

Definitely prefer the GH5 chart more.

[4lic]

I love comparison videos.. this shows that GH is way more fun.

Bass comparison would be great, as GH have open bass.

would you mind doing a setlist scroll video? I (and others, for sure) wanted to see some imports intensity levels.

[StarDida]

Enjoyed watching! Keep up these kind of videos...

[fudgepuppy91]

I love this kind of videos, they're awesome. :)

[Nattekip]

I like this kind of video :)

[MarutoFighter]

guitar hero looks fun but rickband is louder. i guess theyre both tied.

[Cure3]

I like both charts, but this was before RB2, so there's no HOPO chords on that one.

[awwwscar]

vox on guitar hero are harder than guitar lolwut

[bassist22693]

Rock Band is louder but i have to say i like both games

[Slayerfan7790]

Upload more comparison videos. I always enjoy watching them.

[twa558]

I like the GH chart more.

[nonzz3ro]

If Rock Band had ho/po chords when this came out they'd be about equal.

[JizzleWright1]

But more up I like watching comparisons :D