Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (390)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • An absolutely stellar performance by both performers.

  • delivery wise i'll go with this little girl! she's so cute with a thunderous vocal range!

  • ok.... both are truely amazing! and they have their own style of singing thats why they are amazing! and stop comparing them!

  • I go for Charice.

  • a Queen is a queen but a princess will be queen on her own someday. and that goes for Beyonce and Charice.

  • Theres no need to compare coz Beyonce is already a legend...

    and to Charice im proud of her...shes amazing...she has her own songs of course...

  • charice is the best!

  • Beyonce is the queen and we all know what to expect from her!

    Charice also has such powerful voice too bad she doesn't have her own songs to sing.

  • who gets a standing ovation at the oscars??? um charice they don't give 2 shits about music on the show beyonce performed there how many times and ppl are lookin like okay why are u here?

  • すげー

    

  • Beyonce and very good ... and however amazing that Charice powerful voice! clean! BRASIL.

  • Beyonce e muito boa... porem Charice e incrivel que voz poderosa! limpa!

  • beyonce, she have a soul.... charice, she just screaming

  • no question, charice is d best!..

  • charice is just the loudest,beyonce is the best

  • beyonce sucks

  • LOVE IT TO THE FULLEST.

  • @cesbayron fantastic duet charice & beyonce..so amazing

  • WOW and absolutely it's

    Charice rendition.

    love it

  • what if they will sing in a stage together and lets see the difference how they sung...

  • Goosebumps for Charice's performance...everytime!

  • Absolutely, Charice!!!! Bravo!!!

  • CHARICE!! definently!! 

  • สุดยอดมากๆค่ะ ชอบมากๆเลย

  • charice is an amazing talent, and a lot better than beyonce.. sorry,,,its my personal opinion

  • CHARICE ROCKS!!!!!!!!

    BEYONCE' VERSION WAS GOOD BUT SHE SANG IT SOMETHING IN A SAFE MODE.

    CHARICE BELTED THE SONG VERY POWERFUL! SHE'S A RISK TAKER!

  • Comment removed

  • Beyonce's voice is more dynamic and has more depth, better quality, Beyonce no doubt is the better singer . Ang layo ng agwat, magaling naman talaga si Charice pero di hamak na mas maganda ang boses at mas classy ang style ni Beyonce, IMO..

  • they're both WONDERFUL, I really like them so much!!

  • wow!

    

  • wowwww!!! I have no word to say just...

  • yah same awesome singer but charice is the bst.

  • she has a powerful voice

  • nakakaiyak performance ni charice... nakaka proud...

  • THat Guys Hand Was Liikee o.o

    WOAH WHATS THAT LMAoo xD

  • they both r good but no offence charice is better :)

  • charice pitch is higher...

  • @superguko and does it maker her better? NO

  • I've always watching charice's muzic video.. I'm crazy for her when I'm starting to watch her...I felt I'm hungry to listen and watch all her muzic video everyday...I'm already addicted to watch her muzic video everyday...I don't feel asleep if I'm watching her singing with feelings...She's amazing and extraordinary charice...That in my heart she's only the great star. The great star is born in the Philippines....No one can replace her...

  • XD OMG HAHAHHAHAHAHAH 1:35 hahah beyonce's face soo Freaking funny

    Btw i love both of th3m so much

  • This song tells the very story of charice while starting as a singer,and now her dream come true.she deserve all this great acomplishments in her carrer.

  • I think that Charice is the better singer of the two, and oh my God she is just starting keep it going Charice. I've seen Charice sing I will survive and all by myself, wow she sings the hell out of those songs...Charice is GREAT !! LOOK OUT WORLD A SUPERSTAR IS BORN. from the Philippines.

  • io non riesco accogliere la differenza tra le due bravissime......

  • amazing

  • charice has the voice of an angel.. beyonce does too. except beyonces clothes are much better than charices haha

  • Beyonce is amazing, but in my opinion Charice is a notch ahead of her. However, the fact that so many are having this debate is a wonderful testament to both of them. They are both the best at what they do.

  • She looks possessed at 2:35

  • yo do you hear the guy at the end of charice's performance.. damn that's me right now. GO CHARICE! and damn same goes out to beyonce. they're both fantastic, and unbelievably talented musicians

  • wow!amazing charice..

  • i love them both...

  • -Both are great singer!!!.,, but Honestly...Charice is the best...

  • see people?? next time always listen before you regret the biggest mistake you will ever make. SO LISTEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HAHAHA xD

  • beyonce is OVER-USING vibrato in this performance.

  • Which concert did Charice perform this? 

  • my vote goes to charice....beyonce is my favorite singer but in this song "listen" i can tell that charice version is the best than beyonce version :)

  • 2 morons didn't listen carefully!

  • The two videos that gave me shivers out of the four was charice, THAT SAYS IT ALL !!!! :P

  • wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ooowwwwwwwwwww idol charice,,,, always stay away in ice cream,,,,,im so proud of my kababayan,,,stay as what you are and who you are...god bless

  • ..Both Beyonce and Chaisse are great singers! love them! ^^

  • Charice Pempengco~!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • love u both

  • I love Beyonce but wow to charice to belt such a powerful voice for a little person is amazing.. and i know for i am also short in stature..big heart and powerful personalities! =-)

  • KInda wish Beyonce would just sing instead of all the extra's in her singing.

  • i remember pilita's bending style in beyonce

  • Charice rendetion of this song is far better than Beyonce's. Charice version is full of real feelings and more explosive. Her version will really stick to your mind for quiet a while. Remarkable version.

  • good god she is just absolutely amazing. its unreal.

  • my hands automatically clap everytime i watch this especially beyonce's rendition in this video. :))

  • beyonce still the best.she can deliver notes as good as she can be.n the other han, charice is a cery good singer love her voice

  • @everisangkol Too late...the girl's famous.

  • @everisangkol : she may not have her own song to sing.. but i think she's much better than beyonce..

  • @salind00018 @everisangkol Just to clarify, Charice has her own album (original songs made for her) since last year. She made the history as being the 1st Asian singer who made it to the US Top 10 (8th) in Billboards Top 200 Album Charts. Her Pyramid single went to #1 in Billboard Dance Charts.

    She's about the release her next album soon. She released a couple of singles late April.

  • can charice bend herself while singing like beyonce did at los angeles.....

  • @everisangkol LOL .. charice isn't Gymnast.. she's singer ;;; im assuming u'r a comedian ! XD

  • @everisangkol She did while singing another Beyonce song Halo in Bangkok, Thailand.

    watch?v=OrB5Nug0MtI

    LOL, Charice can even sing and belt while sitting. Check a 16 y.o. Charice sing this killer song, All By Myself.

    watch?v=iKPDR7nQIds

  • men charice is so cool!better than beyonce!

  • Charice- you are so Awesome. Charice, Fighting !

  • MY GOD CHARICE IS THE BEST!!

  • I've watched this maybe a hundred times but still i need a box of tissue besides me while watching! I love them both! But Charice is EXTRAORDINARY! She's only one and NO ONE will be like her!

  • love it

  • wow charice voice is stronger than beyonce's voice...electrifying!!!

  • WOW!!! She is natural, strong, perfect...she could sing without any instruments, only her voice, and still deliver an A+ performance. Congrats!

  • Charice is a VOCAL FREAK !!!!

  • Omg 1:36 beyonce's face XD awsome

    

  • beyonce cant sing her own song live the way she recorded it! i GO FOR CHARICE!

  • Both Beyonce and Charice are really good!! and Beyonce's SOOO SEXYYYY!!!!

  • They are both wonderful singer, Beyonce is my all time favorite but base n this performance each of them delivered the song straight from their heart but I'll go for my "kababayan" Charice!!! I dunno... I've got goosebumps all over my body she just simply entertained me a lot. I'm proud of you charice!

  • i think beyonce is on drugs while doing ds song..lav them both anyways

  • Halo - Charice at the Citadel Outlet - Nov. 20 2010

    watch?v=MZW6irNwfAQ

    Charice - HALO (Beyonce) Bangkok Thailand

    watch?v=OrB5Nug0MtI&feature=re­lated

    Charice sings Beyonce "Halo" cover Live US Weekly & Rolling Stone Interview

    watch?v=GrJHlqqCCaE&feature=re­lated

    *** She sang it here in their conference room with no mic. ***

  • BEYOND AMAZING PERFORMANCE!

    Charice is an OUT OF THIS WORLD SINGER! Mortal singers can't match or exceed her vocal prowess and GOOSEBUMP EFFECTS. She stands alone and simply incomparable. The rarest jewel in music land

    If Charice and Beyonce will have a diva face-off, B will be KO in the first few seconds of the 1st round. ;)

    Check her other cover of a Beyonce song HALO. Search "Charice Halo Citadel". It's WICKED!!!

  • If this were a 12-round boxing match between the champion (Beyonce) and the challenger (Charice)...then i would say that the challenger methodically dismantled the ironclad defenses of the champion from Round 1 to 11...and at the 12th round, the challenger unleashed a knockout punch...that claimed for her the most coveted crown...that is the real owner of this song "Listen"!!!

  • Just seeing her perform in front of all those hollywood is just so amazing!

  • charice sings a song coming from her heart and it feels to everyone of us,still she has a unique ability which every one of us also different,so she's one of the best singer...Love you..Charice..

  • Charice sang "Listen" on the GLEE Season 2 premier which was released as a single ranking #38 on the US Billboard Hot100 so both of these great artists can officially claim this song. In the next episode of GLEE ( April 19, 2011) Charice will sing "All By Myself" by Eric Carmen and a giant hit for Celine Dion. Let's see how well that goes. "All By Myself" has already been officially released as a Charice song on the new hit album, "Hitman Returns" - watch on PBS TV "Great Performances" in March

  • I love them both! Without comparing, i love how Charice sings her heart out whenever she sings! She gives me goosebumps everytime she sings... really great! God bless you!

  • cHarice is the next Whitney Houst0n.. Believe it!

  • Folks:

    If you watch American Idol - this is the type of performance that the judges have been telling the contestants to try or attempt to - FEARLESS AND DARING. That's why Charice is one of the rarest talents to come out of the music world.

  • @CC123174 I very much agree with you..

  • @CC123174

    totally agree! Charice can be a lengend! Such amazing powerful and emotional Voice! Go Charice!

    Beyonce is already a lengend at her age. Earlier super diva lengend will be Whitney!

    all of them represent different period of super divas...:)

  • @CC123174 yeah, you are right, though. in terms of being fearless and all, charice is actually better than most idol winners and contestants. she never hold something back whenever she performs

  • I Hope Charice Would Not Sing Beyonce Songs Anymore.

  • i go for queen of standing ovation and goose bumps.

  • BEYONCE IS SO BEAUTIFUL!

  • sorry, but beyonce stays the best :$

  • Charice has an incredible voice, and she can sing absolutely great!

    But When Beyonce sings you can really feel something, and that feeling cant you feel by every singer..

  • she looks like she feeds off her viewers

    the more they enjoy her performance, the more she looks to want to perform even better

  • i hope everybody found THAT CHARICE IS MORE MELODIOUS than beyonce,,,,,,,,,,,

    CHARICE winsssssssssss

  •  b for beyonce,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, and b for " BYE BYE".....whereas C for Champion and C for CHARICE ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, CHARICE is INCREDIBLE, check out the difference between beyonce and CHARICE in my comment,

  • of course?... mine is the queen of standing ovation.love you...

  • What can I say..It's really different when charice sung Listen by Beyonce..I've been following Charice and I've seen her sing and perform but it still gives me GOOSEBUMPS! Listen may not be charice own but she really gives more when she sang this song. Beyonce is great, well it's because it's her song, it's her original and she's been born in USA and already made a name. But if only Charice born in US and in an early time maybe she already made a name for herself..

  • Charice's voice is way better.

  • Beyonce Knowles is a great singer and dancer but Charice Pempengco has a God-gifted voice, i've have never heard a brilliant voice since Whitney Houston.Sorry BK fans but i can't compare beyonce's voice to the likes of Whitney,Celine and Mariah but this girl Charice has a remarkable / seasoned voice at such a young age truely blessed.

  • Charice is light years ahead of Beyonce.

  • Charice = Emotions and Goose Bumps

    Beyonce = Visual Looks

    Simple as that!

  • Superb Beyonceeee....

    

  • I disagree with that! Beyonce is incomparable she's the only BEE..and THE ONE! She's the great performer ever!!!!

  • wtf. beyonce and charice? being compared? i dont think so. charice is very far from beyonce..... i like charice too but not if it is in line with beyonce.

  • Charice is Awesome cause she have !17 years old and she have a incredible voice... She isn't A DIVA but yes is a STAR cause Beyonce have a great career and have experience.. Charice need more experience..thats says that charice in a future be the #1 DIVA of Course!! And I LOVE BEYONCE no body like her!

  • I feel bad for Beyonce she was always thought by me to be amazing but here is a girl thats like 16 maybe!!!! and can hit the same notes almost better :)

  • great singer is charice,

  • AWESOME !!!

  • amazing charice!...really the gifted child!...more power to you charice!...

  • I love this music more byonce nothing compares to this bright girl Charice nothing compares to it in this song.

  • Adoro a byonce mais nessa musica nada se compara a charice essa menina brilhante nada se compara a ela nessa musica.

  • charice not a DIVA like beyonce..!!

    alot pitch and snorg nouse sound... but beyonce very clear voice.. she is real diva..

  • @xtmozzy who said that Charice is not a diva? she can sustain high notes like a real diva like Whitney and Celine. a real diva can hit high notes and sustain it and the very low notes as well.. aside from it can give you goosebumps and chills only Charice can do that. btw i am a fan of Beyonce but i do love Charice as well. so peace out!

  • GO CHARICE ..!!!

    fantastic

  • wow... a filipina who sings like that... amazing i m a fan of beyonce bt hers was awesome... Philippines land of talented people...

  • oh my gosh dude i got some serious chills !!!! holy shit Charice you are one hell of a vocal freak shit dude AHMAZING !!!!

  • the last note in the end was Charice invention...

    nobody did it before and nobody will do it better than her...

  • and the winner is CHARICE!!!! yo dogs!!! this mama can sing!!! thumbs up if ya all agree yo!!!

  • Charise - is Seriously Above and Beyond by Far the Best and most Beautiful VOICE of all (I don't think there is anyon out there right now that can out-sing her and she's got so much Heart and Soul ) - The PROOF is OBVIOUS:) Wow

  • Charise - is Seriously Above and Beyond by Far the Best and most Beautiful VOICE of all (I don't think there is anyon out there right now that can out-sing her and she's got so much Heart and Soul ) - The PROOF is OBVIOUS:) Wow

  • 2:30-2:33 IS AMAZING!!!! gives me goosebumps!

  • you're amazing Charice.....

  • a millions of Wow, she gave me goosebumps.

    

  • i love the last part of charice .. wow

  • guys.. focus on the part 2:09-2:11 Beyonce gives a different blow on that part....

  • @thenightmessenger15 yep .. she wanted it to sound more rnb :)

  • guys.. focus on the part 2:09-2:11 Beyonce gives a different blow on that part....

  • omg my mouth was agape the whole time

  • beyonce is better at the moment. But if you see how good charice already is at this point, then imagine how good she can be when she's older and more mature!

  • listen  by:tomadudz---he is a guy singing the listen lady voice....hope u guys like it:)

  • Sarah Geronimo - Listen (Full Version) kaizabala...please listen to it for another version....they are all amazing in different way:)

  • Comment removed

  • God Bless you Charice, Give Thanks o God for your beautiful voice.

  • Two thumbs up with WOW!

  • beyonce..original singer...charice...the new original singer...lol

  • i get goosebumps when charice started to sing..ohemgee thank you lord for charice :)

  • QUEEN BEYONCE - is the better performer AMAZING CHARICE - has better vocals

  • i like the way beyonce sings it better in the movie... here it sounds like shes in church lol...but i like charice and beyonce's version

  • both have an excellent voice and talent. 

  • i'm celine, whitney, mariah's, bouceli fan, charice now, i love them all. i respect beyonce as artist very professional.

  • just be honest i'm 5 yrs in the school band. So i know exactly the exact tune, who make it and who don't.

  • they are AMAZING !!!!!

  • Alright Charice is better in this one :O WOW that was AMAZING!

  • Ohhh charice is the best !!!1

  • For me charice is better that Beyonce :)

  • @28venice,don't forget about lady gaga,britney spears.and she's 18 yrs. old to date.

  • charice is better than beyonce^^

    GO CHARICE !!!

  • absolutley brilliant!!

    even though iv never herd anyone sing this like charice, listen is beyonce's songg an no1 will ever compare.. GO CHARICE thou, your amazin :') goosebumps!! <3

  • charice, they can't ignore you anymore!! i'm also a beyonce fan but "listen' is already a charice song!

  • @elainearce .. i so agree!!!

  • @elainearce Can You See Something Below The Likes And Dislikes In The Views Section?So Who The Hell Can Say It's A Charice Song?