This song should never be sung by a woman, no disrespect, but since (Harold Melvin and the Blue Notes)Teddy Pendergrass' original version, I can't see anyone sing it better. Besides, American Idol always rushes thru their versions. Teddy sings it like his arguing with the chick at that moment....
duh then don't listen to this listen to your old 45's. I must have missed were someone asked your opinion. What do you expect contestants to do in a singing contest? Sing bad songs by bad singers? Its the very fact that it was such a beautiful recording that makes it challanging. She is not competing against harold Melvin and if you want to be a judge you can vote as many times as you like for the next american idol.
@scottduncan44 I really didn't listen to the whole thing. Only a few notes then I commented. Now I had to come back to reply to your dumb ass. I don't give a fuck if you like her song, GOOD ON YA...! Keep it to yourself. It's just an opinion. All you had to say was, "I disagree...your point, then get the fuck off....! I wouldn't been mad at ya...! It's your opinion. I might have given it another chance if you had something interesting to say. Now you fucked it all up.
Read this cause it actually works!! You will get kissed by the love of your life on the nearest Friday possible. Tomorrow will be the best day of your life. However if you don't post this comment on at least three videos you will die within two days. Now you started reading this don't stop. This is so scary. Put this on three videos in 143 minutes. When your done press f6 and your lovers name will appear in big letters. This I so scary it actually works
@cwgreen89 Jordan Sparks is a great singer, but I think she was a little too immature to win. She only won because she was so "cute" and had "such a powerful voice for one so young"
@KnowYourEnemys And also, listen to the song he sung to make it as a wilcard...I believe it was smoky norful's "I need you now"....Probably his best performance of the whole season....
you must now include Mr. Scotty McCreery as one who worked for and deserves the title. This young man will be as great as or GREATER than carrie and kelly
I'm sorry. Carrie Underwood can sing...but American Idol contestants, and just singers nowadays in general, lack style. I hear no soul, no uniqueness. They're a dime a dozen to me.
@rondot08 & @DanielDaniel1 Wow you guys did it really have to come to this? I agree Kelly and Carrie are the only ones who really continued there careers to the max. There have been other white winner too don't mean just because they're white that they get to be stars. At the end of the day talent is talent I don't see why you have to get stereotypical and pull the race card or even retaliate in such a crude manner.
@DownTownTilley stp talking as if you know anything. I'm a classical pianist who has received formal musical training for more than 8 years. and I know that she's good. who the hell are you to say that she ain't good
I love Stefano's version and Carrie's version equally :) The only problem is that I want to see Stefano go as far as Carrie :P I know it won't happen :(
@xxY2JLEDGENDKILLERxx hahaha this is funny!!! ur obviously tone deaf and dont kno what ur talken about becuz America has alot of talented singers and her bein a great example! so keep ur ignorant comments to urself!
@misnomersx3853 yoս can wаtϲհ tv from аll οvеr tհе ԝοrld οո yοur рc ϳuѕt by dοwոloadinց ѕοmе рrogram, іt's ցot thοuѕаոdѕ οf ϲհаոnelѕ οո it. ϳսst ցο to linevid com (put а . befοrе the сom οbvіously, it ԝοn't lеt me post lіnkѕ fοr some reaѕoո) іt's nοt ехаϲtly freе bսt іt'ѕ ϳust οոе time рaymеnt аnd іt ԝοrks really wеll
@BrettMariee i think idol has been broken for years it sucks that it took idol for people to see how talented adam lambert is. granted i'm not a fan of his i admire him he's a cool dude if l
Carrie Underwood is just like Elvis Presley was. THe best at it what they do and can sing any kind of song no matter what genre its from. sing it and own it with there style. And THERE WILL NEVER BE ANOTHER ELVIS NOR ANOTHER CARRIE> God has blessed us twice with a one of a kind singer.
Underwood was dissed by the judges TWICE, but it didn't matter. Bo Bice was the best that season and he had great performances every week. Notice the judges comments are off some of the Underwood performances? She got DISSED hard on two BAD performances, but the MAJORITY rules!!!
This is arguably one of her best performances and the best cover I have heard of this song, of course everything Carrie sings is the best, nobody will ever be as good again..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This was alright (not great though) 'til around 1:40 or so when she screamed that high note. Kinda went downhill after that. But still, even though this was one of her 'lesser' performances, it is still better than a lot of peoples best.
oh i'm shaking! A nigger is playing the race card, how original. how bout you get off the computer and do what your best at. NOTHING, well except for rape :D
Oh God...I am gonna' hurl my guts out. A dumb white honky no talent, except for her looks and her hoots, attempting to perform the classic Harold Melvin and the Blue Notes song. There ought to be a law against that type of behavior. Honey...go back to where you came from....white Wonder bread...white milk...Take a clue honey...About the only white artists that do soul music justice is the Average White Band....not you.
She looks so pretty here!
softballgirl100100 1 week ago
Years have passed and she has grown into who she was meant to be. And yet, years have passed and here I am loving her beginnings. <3
itsavirus47 3 weeks ago 2
Lejos ... lejos ... lejos de ser una copia de Simple Red .... eres una copia barata !!! ... Gracias por intentar cantar como SU SOMBRA
corsalinoccv 1 month ago
This song should never be sung by a woman, no disrespect, but since (Harold Melvin and the Blue Notes)Teddy Pendergrass' original version, I can't see anyone sing it better. Besides, American Idol always rushes thru their versions. Teddy sings it like his arguing with the chick at that moment....
ReekoChet 3 months ago
@ReekoChet
duh then don't listen to this listen to your old 45's. I must have missed were someone asked your opinion. What do you expect contestants to do in a singing contest? Sing bad songs by bad singers? Its the very fact that it was such a beautiful recording that makes it challanging. She is not competing against harold Melvin and if you want to be a judge you can vote as many times as you like for the next american idol.
scottduncan44 2 months ago
@scottduncan44 I really didn't listen to the whole thing. Only a few notes then I commented. Now I had to come back to reply to your dumb ass. I don't give a fuck if you like her song, GOOD ON YA...! Keep it to yourself. It's just an opinion. All you had to say was, "I disagree...your point, then get the fuck off....! I wouldn't been mad at ya...! It's your opinion. I might have given it another chance if you had something interesting to say. Now you fucked it all up.
ReekoChet 2 months ago
If u don't know me,don't judge me
-2pac Amaru Shakur
Best rapper ever!
theleetworldbest 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Read this cause it actually works!! You will get kissed by the love of your life on the nearest Friday possible. Tomorrow will be the best day of your life. However if you don't post this comment on at least three videos you will die within two days. Now you started reading this don't stop. This is so scary. Put this on three videos in 143 minutes. When your done press f6 and your lovers name will appear in big letters. This I so scary it actually works
Xaara1988 4 months ago
@cwgreen89 Jordan Sparks is a great singer, but I think she was a little too immature to win. She only won because she was so "cute" and had "such a powerful voice for one so young"
Loveboylove1989 4 months ago
This was good...but Stefano's version was a LOT better
dreman1970 5 months ago
@dreman1970 can Stefano even hold a note without going off key?
KnowYourEnemys 4 months ago
@KnowYourEnemys SOme songs NO...but his version of this song was actually pretty good..better than the Carrie version by far...
dreman1970 4 months ago
@KnowYourEnemys And also, listen to the song he sung to make it as a wilcard...I believe it was smoky norful's "I need you now"....Probably his best performance of the whole season....
dreman1970 4 months ago
@dreman1970 ok, but still. Carrie's worst is better than Stefano's best
KnowYourEnemys 3 months ago 2
and david cook too!
Mrmusiko04 6 months ago
OMG stefano version is much fresh and catchy
CAFEYLOUNGE 6 months ago
Stefano Did Way Better
SkylarGandy 7 months ago
Awesome, love U
BellaGartenLLC 8 months ago
Carrie needs to stick to country, cause she can't sing no soul.
mpope409 8 months ago
@mpope409 Country and Soul go hand in hand
mmmruff 5 months ago
@mmmruff Not necessarily. I'm talking about Soul, with a capital "S". The music that's rooted in black heritage.
mpope409 5 months ago
@cwgreen89 Fuck that. Fantasia and Ruben were both excellent singers. Get it straight.
mpope409 8 months ago
zion, put down the bottle. Better than Carrie ? come on now
mlammy 8 months ago 3
you must now include Mr. Scotty McCreery as one who worked for and deserves the title. This young man will be as great as or GREATER than carrie and kelly
zionsgirl7 8 months ago
@zionsgirl7 Scotty will be a legend, you watch. I love Scotty, Carrie and Lauren!
lildeegurrl 8 months ago
i love this song i love how sang it she definatly deserved to win that season
nicolejstarr2011 8 months ago
kelly, carrie and DAVID COOK are the deserving idols.
iskrew 9 months ago
I'm sorry. Carrie Underwood can sing...but American Idol contestants, and just singers nowadays in general, lack style. I hear no soul, no uniqueness. They're a dime a dozen to me.
KrfNYC2 9 months ago
@cwgreen89 yo, taylor hicks???!!! wadup??
gradhito 9 months ago
god she looks like such a little baby in this. XD
starshollowresident 10 months ago
@reesespieces I like David Cook better than Carrie. Carrie is very talented though.
jojoxx1231 10 months ago
@rondot08 & @DanielDaniel1 Wow you guys did it really have to come to this? I agree Kelly and Carrie are the only ones who really continued there careers to the max. There have been other white winner too don't mean just because they're white that they get to be stars. At the end of the day talent is talent I don't see why you have to get stereotypical and pull the race card or even retaliate in such a crude manner.
Shygiirl916 10 months ago
Ohhh man I love that voice of hers
Thisismebeingme7 10 months ago
She sounds flat. Most overrated singer on the planet. Close your eyes people and listen to her, she's not that good.
DownTownTilley 10 months ago
@DownTownTilley Truer words has never been spoken, ......
dendot57 10 months ago
@DownTownTilley
post a video of you singing
then we can talk.
marquise3817 9 months ago
@DownTownTilley stp talking as if you know anything. I'm a classical pianist who has received formal musical training for more than 8 years. and I know that she's good. who the hell are you to say that she ain't good
Sinf0nia 9 months ago
I love Stefano's version and Carrie's version equally :) The only problem is that I want to see Stefano go as far as Carrie :P I know it won't happen :(
RathadethFanClub 10 months ago
I can't see what other people see in her!!! So-so!
flowerbabyrose 10 months ago
@cwgreen89 I think David Cook is included in that too!
reesespieces22 11 months ago 8
Stefano just as good as Carrie singing this song yesterday
:)
sorry for my english btw :D
Gorgeous7169 11 months ago 3
America more and better talent then the UK accordin to Simon Cowell !!!
xHcivic00x 11 months ago
@xxY2JLEDGENDKILLERxx Simon Cowell someone who is actually from the UK admitted himself America has more talent! so think before u speak dumbass!!
xHcivic00x 11 months ago
Comment removed
jlp05 1 year ago
@jussayindonthate I know! She looked so hot when she did that! :)
G3TKN0CK3D0UT 1 year ago
this girl is just versatile!! she can adapt to any genre of music!!
Beyoncefan1000 1 year ago
I love when she looks back at the camera @1:00!
Jussayindonthate 1 year ago
Simply amazing!! If you dislike her or her singing please kill yourself right away. The world would be better off without your incorrect opinions.
G3TKN0CK3D0UT 1 year ago
Comment removed
xxY2JLEDGENDKILLERxx 1 year ago
@xxY2JLEDGENDKILLERxx Thats a stupid, small minded, and ignorant thing to say.
Jussayindonthate 1 year ago
@xxY2JLEDGENDKILLERxx hahaha this is funny!!! ur obviously tone deaf and dont kno what ur talken about becuz America has alot of talented singers and her bein a great example! so keep ur ignorant comments to urself!
xHcivic00x 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Simpy amazing =]\
VIC1007 1 year ago
Simpy amazing =]
VIC1007 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
disgusting version of the song...it sucks, it don`t give justice to the song...just like her voice coming from the grave....
danteVEC725 1 year ago
i love her!
1893odlanyer 1 year ago
I forgot one. Chris Daughtry. Can't forget him
dyantis1 1 year ago 2
I think David Cook is another good artist to come out of American Idol.
dyantis1 1 year ago 3
carrie and fantasia d=for me
MrWilks6 1 year ago
is it just me or is she rushing through the song ?
Txdon09 1 year ago
@Txdon09
She has to. They have a certain time limit to sing their songs.
kelceejofarra 1 year ago
Probably one of the top three female singers out there right now. She just consistently flawless.
jon1323 1 year ago 2
She was good then and has grown so much. One of the best singers of today!
Periwinkle6 1 year ago 3
@misnomersx3853 yoս can wаtϲհ tv from аll οvеr tհе ԝοrld οո yοur рc ϳuѕt by dοwոloadinց ѕοmе рrogram, іt's ցot thοuѕаոdѕ οf ϲհаոnelѕ οո it. ϳսst ցο to linevid com (put а . befοrе the сom οbvіously, it ԝοn't lеt me post lіnkѕ fοr some reaѕoո) іt's nοt ехаϲtly freе bսt іt'ѕ ϳust οոе time рaymеnt аnd іt ԝοrks really wеll
zksaltylolcat110 1 year ago
@cwgreen89 Agreed
xlitojessiex 1 year ago
@cwgreen89 Adam Lambert deserved it! American Idol is broken!
BrettMariee 1 year ago
@BrettMariee i think idol has been broken for years it sucks that it took idol for people to see how talented adam lambert is. granted i'm not a fan of his i admire him he's a cool dude if l
oNegLeEk 1 year ago
this sounds like crap
liquidfire411 1 year ago
@liquidfire411 ur face!!!
VIC1007 1 year ago
holy cats! i have always loved that song and Carrie did her thang! The band stunk but she didn't need em anyhow!
lkirby021 1 year ago
Comment removed
monikgol 1 year ago
Carrie Underwood is just like Elvis Presley was. THe best at it what they do and can sing any kind of song no matter what genre its from. sing it and own it with there style. And THERE WILL NEVER BE ANOTHER ELVIS NOR ANOTHER CARRIE> God has blessed us twice with a one of a kind singer.
themeanmachine17 1 year ago 3
IS TALENT
warmconan253 1 year ago
PRETTY GOOD, 4 A WHITE GIRL
gbreppin 1 year ago 3
she does it so effortlessly!! amazing singer and the BEST IDOL!!
VIC1007 1 year ago 2
Underwood was dissed by the judges TWICE, but it didn't matter. Bo Bice was the best that season and he had great performances every week. Notice the judges comments are off some of the Underwood performances? She got DISSED hard on two BAD performances, but the MAJORITY rules!!!
rkhufu7 1 year ago
Latoya killed it, guys...
jd8391 1 year ago
Anthony's was better
pheonixkami 1 year ago
This is arguably one of her best performances and the best cover I have heard of this song, of course everything Carrie sings is the best, nobody will ever be as good again..
Myra1991JR 1 year ago 5
....she's great!!! so great!!
msUniverse4lyf 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Seal's version is the best.
shermanxia 2 years ago
Simply Red has the only cover that I could take seriously enough.
monesv 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This was alright (not great though) 'til around 1:40 or so when she screamed that high note. Kinda went downhill after that. But still, even though this was one of her 'lesser' performances, it is still better than a lot of peoples best.
Recjus 2 years ago
Screamed? It wasn't screamed, and not even high for her lmao. But yeah, this was the week she started to get sick.
mellynumerounoo 2 years ago 5
@mellynumerounoo What do you consider high when it comes to the effortless Carrie Underwood? Just a random question?;-)
Myra1991JR 1 year ago 4
Jordin sparks deserved it
she worked her ass off to win.
rustydevilll 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wrong season.. she was season 7
4793Jesus61406 2 years ago
@4793Jesus61406 you're W R O N G! She was in season 4 for sure!!! David Cook won season 7 :)
crazysurf11 2 years ago 2
no Carrie WON season 4... I may be WRONG what season Jordin was in but I KNOW she was not in season 4... Carrie deserved to win as well
4793Jesus61406 2 years ago 4
@crazysurf11 She wasn't in season 4. She was in season 6, she won actually.
GinaGlocksenFan 2 years ago 3
Carrie won season 4, Taylor Hicks won in season 5, Jordin won in Season 6, David Cook won in season 7 and Kris won last year.
NiK1023 2 years ago 3
Agreed!
itisMeC 2 years ago
when i listen to carrie i get goose bumps. her voice is beautiful.
lykotasmom 2 years ago 9
This is a classic song... so beautiful that if you butchered it...you need to be shot...she did great...Thank God...
MonkeyGeek09 2 years ago 7
Beautiful girl, powerful voice, love this song! true American Idol....
heartfan82 2 years ago 7
Agreed, agreed! True American idol
itisMeC 2 years ago 3
i think this is the best & i'll stand by you <33
KnuDDaLe04 2 years ago 4
i agree, both have amazing vocals and true talent
jeperkins1222 2 years ago 5
Carrie!
MyGinevraAddict 2 years ago 4
What a flawless performance. I love Carrie
BurtonBoarding 2 years ago 6
really kelly clarkson and carrie are the only right ones
DanielDaniel1 2 years ago 90
of the winners? I agree. But Chris Daughtry is right up there even if he didn't win.
annoyingu4fun 2 years ago
@DanielDaniel1
As much as I hate to admit it... David Cook is Good too. So is Jordan Sparks
MsRouge13 1 year ago
@DanielDaniel1 Yoy are forgetting FANTASIA! Ans Adam Lambert deserved it too...
BrettMariee 1 year ago
@BrettMariee Right, They always forget about fantasia. Fantasia is Talented and anointed.
lilnay86 1 year ago
@DanielDaniel1 you only say that because there white you dumb bitch
rondot08 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@rondot08
oh i'm shaking! A nigger is playing the race card, how original. how bout you get off the computer and do what your best at. NOTHING, well except for rape :D
DanielDaniel1 11 months ago
i dont care what judges wer saying, for me, i love carrie, i love the song, and i love carrie! :))
kuuyu24 2 years ago 10
Great
Antamokboy 2 years ago
awesome version of this song!
CarrieJunkie 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
Now uv started readin dis dunt stop. This is so scary.
Copy and paste this to 5 videos in less than five mins. and u will die!
mermaidzrock101 2 years ago
damn she sang that song in perfect tune it was great!
livnlife4love 2 years ago 5
Such and underrated performance
SBunny5792 2 years ago 8
1:40 is amazing!
JayMe2823 2 years ago 2
I agree with you..
justsomegurl93 2 years ago
forget the judges not liking this I LOVED it!
JayMe2823 2 years ago 7
my favorite part is starting 1:15 to 1:31
TotalRapidFangirl4 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
TotalRapidFangirl4 2 years ago
Nice Modulation.
birddoggarton 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh God...I am gonna' hurl my guts out. A dumb white honky no talent, except for her looks and her hoots, attempting to perform the classic Harold Melvin and the Blue Notes song. There ought to be a law against that type of behavior. Honey...go back to where you came from....white Wonder bread...white milk...Take a clue honey...About the only white artists that do soul music justice is the Average White Band....not you.
dbowie007 3 years ago
damn she sang that in perfect tune. those notes were minor!
AlterIllusion 3 years ago 9
i lov ethis so much only the song and carrie a little bit
jennyR160 3 years ago