Added: 4 years ago
From: kiddd06
Views: 46,785
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (80)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Smashing pumpkins beat the fuck out of MCR they sound nothing alike so fuck off. Gerrard way is a stuck up emo fag.

  • +1 dude well said

  • @richyc1983 glad you agree :D

  • one of the bands that has really touched my teenage times and my life, my existence and so on.. they were simply great.. I see them now as a new band, who plays covers of the original band although having billy and the drummer playing with them, and has new songs

  • That really sux, all too often the Great band always, always break up, and when they do reunite, its not always the same line up. But billy corgan did say himself that, 97 percent of pumpkin material, it was just him and chaimberlain who wrote the material.

  • @indiebird12 Billy Corgan=Pumpkins, just like Robert Smith =The Cure; Zwan, etc....anything with Billy Corgan is SP, he IS SP!

  • Eh, to be honest I love the studio version, but billy's singing live isn't so great.

    This'll probably get a few thumbs down, but I'm afraid it's the truth =/

  • except that smashing pumpkins sound way better!!

  • and MCR suck.

  • It would be the other way MCR sounds like SP... and I think they said the where big fans of SP.

  • what is the next song who begins at the end of this viedeo

  • the song name is: Untitled

  • lol wtever maralyn manson sucks. all those bands rule /m/

  • Dude manson fucking owns.... MCr linkin park GC suck a fat cock.... Best bands in 2007 there had to have been KoRn Lamb of god and smashing pumpkins!! i would love to see any of those emo shit bands play a quarter of the riffs those bands play...

  • I agree with you totally except, dude...Korn? Theyre fucking shit! They were alright in the nineties, but now theyre just fucking losers.

  • @Rollin1989 Korn? um...no...they were not "alright" ever

  • rock am ring 2oo7 was the show of the faggots,good charlote, MY chemical romance, likin park,30 Seconds to Mars etc i hope the 2008 play coll rock and roll like marilyn manson at least

  • Dude shut the fuck up yea the was some shit bands there but I wish I had a gone. Like you had fucking Smashing pumpkins Machine head Korn and so on. I wouldn't be complain with Smashing Pumpkins and stone sour Love this song so much

  • What did Darcy and James do that was so good? All the did was what Billy told them to do, so you not missing anything. The Sp are and all ways be Billy and Jimmy.

  • actually i think iha was a really good guitarist and added alot to the band personally, hes in a perfect circle now and had a pretty good solo album that was 10 times better than corgan's solo album

  • i really think iha's album sucked. it just seems as he never actually cared for anything corgan musically could offer, his songs sound so corny and empty, compared to billy's

  • Nice jazzmaster!

  • Please, can you write me the songs that he has played that night?

    thanks

  • it's a calm song for fucks sake, not enter sandman

  • amen to that!

  • i think this is nice :P

  • billy sounds bored and tired or is it just me?

  • Yeah, he seemed really tired and worn out. Maybe he's letting age get to him.

  • Who's the guitarist it is not James Iha?

  • Jesus I've always loved this song but this wouldn't be fun to see live.

  • yeah something about this just isnt quite right, and it doesnt sound that good

  • i assume you mean the sound is not synchronized with the picture. it just sounds different

  • no i meant the performance, and the arrangement

    and billy's voice, god, billy's voice

  • great song, weak crowd, October Detroit...I'll be there

  • Ginger Reyes mmmmmmm mamy!!

  • BORING!

  • good one

    NOT

    you're boring

  • billy sounds kinda drunk :P :]

  • my favorite song of all time

    GREAT SONG!!!!!!!!!!!

  • SOngs performed on this concert were great, but this falls a little short! I wish they would have played it the way they did in tha "Adore" era! The song was played with so much energy back then!

  • Sorry to be negative, but this track sounds tired as fuck.

  • I love D'arcy but I think Ginger rocks too...I am very pleased with the new lineup and can't wait to see them, they sound amazing

  • It's Ginger Reyes!

  • Ginger wasn't even born yet in 1979

  • and she's hot as hell dude

  • Do they still have the basist from the machina records?

  • No. Gingel Sling is the new bass girl.

  • D'arcy supposedly played on some of machina and melissa from hole on the tour. They still have them both to answer your question, locked inside Jimmy's kick drums getting the headache of a lifetime.

  • Both bands, machine head and smashing pumpkins are good, they may not like each other, big dick over nothing.

    Anyways corgans voice is shite to what it used to be, lacking a good few guitar parts I noticed during the songs.

  • I've listened to a few Machine Head albums because I had a friend who liked them, and to be honest I thought it was all a bunch of shite same goes for other metal bands like Metallica, metal is just one repetitive bunch of noise. Can't bands have a bit of variety nowadays, does everything always have to sound the same. Pumpkins forever I say!!

  • that comment that "thecollectfew" just said could possibly be the DUMBEST comment I've ever heard in my life on youtube...REPETITIVE NOISE IS METAL??????? REPETITIVE NOISE IS METALLICA AND MACHINE HEAD? God I hate 14 year old posers.

  • Ok so what having an opinion is dumb is it. I find Metallica and Machine Head to be boring, I've listened to their albums, I don't like metal therefore I shall say I don't like metal. Not everyone likes it, and why is it always the metal fans that get so touchy if you diss the metal. Oh no!!!! And by the way Im no 14 year old poser my friend. And it is repetitive, I mean listen to Metallicas Ride the Lightning and Master of Puppets, they are practically the same album.

  • oh my god...now metallica ride the lightning and master of puppets are the same album...dude your doing a dis-service to all Smashing Pumpkin fans by acting like a music illiterate. It's too bad too because I like Smashing Pumpkins a lot as well. You have to recognize talent when talent is there.

  • Hey, would just like to apologize on behalf of my little brother who is in fact Yarmouth Youth. I am the one who goes under the name TheCollectFew. Why he's using my youtube account is beyond me. I thought I'd add my two cents into this whole argument, I love the Smashing Pumpkins too. As for the topic of metal, I'm not a huge fan either, but I can respect the impact it had. But yeah my brother  won't be bothering anyone again, well not under my fucking account anyway

  • Obviously the guy out of Machine Head is jealous because his band sucks balls and plays mono tone metal shite and the Pumpkins are a much better band in terms of originality and alternative styles.

  • greatest concert @ rar 07 :D

  • wrong! ^^

    i've seen it on tv and this one was nice, but beatsteaks have been much better- croud agrees!

  • well.. it's nice that you've seen it on TV!... but to understand it you had to be there! it was so fuckin great... and yes I've seen beatsteaks too, and I thought no one could be better... but then came smashing pumpkins..... :D .. sorry for my english.. i'm so fuckin' drunken.....

  • Billy And Jimmy. These guy`s is legends...

  • Not the pumpkins without James Iha? thats bullshit, he did fuck all except piss people off with his taser gun sounds in the corner. Also the songs he did write were written out of massive inferiority issues. Also, since Billy wrote all of the songs, he should be able to play at any venue or in any format he deems fit. His heart and soul went into those songs, it would be unfair if he was unable to play them without reprimand.

  • Machine Head said shut up Smashing Pumpkins??!?! Billy should go and pull that guy's noise ring out!

  • billy corgan and his pumpkins-coverband...

  • machine head.. lol..

  • i loved when the singer and guitarist of machine head said "shut up, Smashing Pumpkins"

    i think they suck

  • you suck!!

  • They suck? So why do you watch it anyway?

  • so why are you watching a pumpkins video you dickhole? you know something? machine head suck - you suck - die

  • great performance, the pumpkins are back!!

  • It's not the Pumkins without James Iha.

  • Yeah, the audio is off on ALL of the videos I ripped. I watched the concert via Realplayer stream and Replayer formats suck to convert to other formats (Youtube doesn't accept Realplay movie formats). I'll make some of the videos downloadable soon (along with audio) so you don't have to suffer anymore! haha

  • the beatsteaks rocked much better^^

    rock am ring rulez^^

  • Actually this is the first new video I've seen where Billy doesn't seem too into singing it. He looks bored with the song. The rest are awesome though

  • cant wait till reading now- only 2 months away!

  • deadbabyfootball why are you just watching the videos if you think they suck? the pumpkins rock!!

  • I think the audio is off a bit with the video. Man, I wish I could've been there for this.

  • sounds ok

  • are you tone deaf?

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more