Added: 3 years ago
From: 500110069
Views: 2,375,394
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,671)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wow!! I Think I Like Her Better Live(:

  • Beyoncé Made me cry for the fisrt time in my whole life! Amazing*

  • lol, Beyonce is already a legend.

  • How can she (or anyone) do any better than this? Have we heard the "best" of Beyonce? Hope not.

  • This is an incredible vocal performance

  • she`s the queen !!

  • Nobody sings this better than Beyonce :)

  • @grantalex31 next to mariah ofcourse.

  • GOOSEBUMPS.

  • if beyonce sings this song now she will KILL it

  • She's from the planet earth ?!!!!!!!!

  • Beyonce is just so amazing

  • @armwatcharachai Melanie was the winner if X Factor. And she auditioned with this song..

  • I love you Beyonce

    most beautiful voice in the world must always howl so beautiful it is, it rests me again and again

  • The greatest. Dot.

  • Yaaaaaaaaaaas!

  • fake sax player

  • owh! very awesome .. i can't believe, she has a great voice ..

    LOL!! she's very talented girl in this generation ..

  • Holy shit! x2

  • Holy shit!

  • Speechless. She's so beautiful and omg, her voice. If Beyonce and Hyorin did a collab, i would be able to die in peace. srsly.

  • @Normatovai Same here! lol

  • flawless

  • i like this song its so beautiful

  • Música Linda

  • best live singer !!!!!!

  • great version

  • and she was sick that day lol

  • She gave me chills

  • ...g..go..goosebumps

  • @tandavid15 are you kidding me? Beyonce is beyond famous..

  • This beyonce can be a famious singer

  • yall need to calm down and get a more mature perspective...there is more than one great female singer, room for everyone.

  • Beyonce broke 70 people's speaker and they couldnt listen

  • Who's Melenie ?????

  • She is such a role model :) So beautiful ♥

  • MELANIE WHO CHARICE WHO GURL PURLEASE NOONE CAN SING A BEYONCE SONG LIKE BEYONCE

  • @gwenstefani1001 calm down

  • Safe to say theres only ONE B.

  • I had to listen to this to cleanse myself of Melanie's voice.

  • @shahror09 fuck that x factor bitch? her performance was amazing hands down no question ignorant ass people.

  • fuck that x factor bitch

  • she just doesn't make music... she IS music

  • She has so much class!

  • owh damn it! her powerful voice cant be defeating! she always going to be remembered as a greatest singer...

  • This is sooo weird.. i was waiting for the part where it's at the highest.. but I missed it because she made it sound so effortless I guess i didn't catch it. Usually when i hear covers.. I think "Oh, are they gonna hit those notes?!" But when Beyonce sings it I'm like... omg.. I don't even question it. I just KNOW. She will, and always does..

  • @gsvetcos thats why I hate covers because they try to put their own "twist" to the song and ruin it because they know they cant hit those high notes

  • @gsvetcos She made that note lower octave , but still amazing

  • in 50 years beyonce will be a legend

  • @SwIfTyRoXMySoXIeS no in 10 years!!!

  • @fredcrockett07 haha true :)

  • @SwIfTyRoXMySoXIeS shes a legend NOW! psh lol

  • @SwIfTyRoXMySoXIeS she already is!

  • I think she already is!!

  • @SwIfTyRoXMySoXIeS she already is a legend.

  • melaine is just sung this song really well...

  • Comment removed

  • she keeps amazing me EVERY TIME, loveyou B

  • ooh myy goshhh <3

  • BEYONCE BEST PERFORMANCE OF LISTEN!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Completely on point. This, kids, is something you will not see often. Truly amazing.

  • Oh shit, goosebump.

  • just love her to death. ugh

  • WOW.

  • :O..BEYONCE!!!!..eres grande

  • why can't i sound like that??!!!

  • Classic Beyonce!!!! I LOVE HER!!!!

  • @toriaaaxox you cant say Rihanna is worse or better because they're both amazing!!! I think Beyonce could not sing "whats my name" better than Rihanna does and Rihanna could not sing "listen" like Beyonce does because they have different voices and thats it!

  • me arrepiayyyyyy!

  • Bey slayed and she was hoarse!!!!!!! There will never be another Beyonce.

  • sang, girl

  • I love it!

  • Este Si Que Es Un Bozarrón :D

  • She killedd it !!!!! Go Beyoncee

  • I've said this before and I will say it again, the best voice of our generation. Thank God for Beyonce

  • Stunning

  • diva. could anyone tell me in what year was this? thanks!

  • beyonce is the only singer which gives me goosebumps. she is absolutely amazing and doesnt get enough credit. whoever says rihanna is better clearly doesnt have great taste in music. she has class and she is an inspiration to everyone..

  • Bey took me to church !

  • Melanie and Beyonce are both AMAZING and we should be happy for having them in our life! Their voices are both shocking and beautiful! So everyone please stop fighting! Thanks

  • so many ppl sing beyonce and whitney houston songs i guess that happens wen ur legendary

  • Agree, Melanie doesn't even come close to that in every aspect, but a good singer though.

  • Some people are just too funny. First Beyonce's against Charice's version, and now against Melanie's? No comparison at all. All three ladies sang this song beautifully in their own ways.

  • @samoantahine1 beyonce was first anyway

  • @jerritopia You don't have to remind me. I know that. Beyonce sang it first before Charice and Melanie, but there's no need to COMPARE them because they ALL sang the song beautifully.

  • diva eterna

  • How the fuck did Melanie Fiona come up on a Beyonce video? o__O OH.

  • i love this, but Melanie might be could be the next beyoncé...

    by the way, new youtube look, amazing (y) (y)

  • Melanie's voice is not better than Beyonce's voice every time Beyonce sings this song she sounds more and more beautiful. Melanie could never sing listen again because she will sound the same and she would try to focus on doing better then her first performance.

  • C'mon guys! we know Beyoncé is the best but Melanie is amazing for her age!!! Both are awesome guyss!!!

  • melanie brings something new for the song but beyone's still the best!

  • @90tuancuong no she didnt covered it unoriginally

  • i still think melanie sings this better

  • Even when she talks it's music to my ears :) Beyonce is beyond amazing, beautiful, talented, intelligent, and more. She is diversified in her music, and more often than not, brilliant. Some examples of what I mean are Listen, If I were a boy, and 1+1.

  • I felt like crying..oh my god, she's the most talented girl I've ever seen

  • Oprah's face at the end says it all

  • Melanie is really pushing too hard when singing this, it's too big a song for her voice. Beyonce pulls it off so naturally.

  • Non ci sono parole ! Strepitosa!

  • not the biggest fan but she killed it here. people can talk shit about her all they want but one thing they can't deny is that she can sing. this video proves it here.

  • I think this is one of the best versions of this song. When she sings, she puts so much feeling into it. A great inspiration for everyone.

  • the thing i loved about this performance, apart from it obviously being amazing, was that in a mtv special documentary of beyonce she was really scared for this performance, had a bad throat and thought she was gonna fuck it up! look at her now!

  • Beyonce transmite tanto con esta cancion, Uff me encanta;

  • Ok best live singers Beyonce, Whitney,Mariah Carey,Celine Dion,Jennifer Hudson,Lady GaGa,Christina Aguilera,Leona Lewis!

  • mooie heupen! :K

  • 66 people are jealous

    

  • best singe in the world

  • Queen B. She is the whole package sorry melanie. Looks, personality, can be a diva as well as feirce. Love her so much!

  • I just love her so much. She's beautiful inside and out.

  • @itsMUSICKY its so she can stay on key...

  • All I'm seeing everytime she performs this song is ppl talking bout how she was sick...is she sick everytime she performs this song?! wth.

  • @huski09 lol ikr. But its true. She was sick and said she was worried abt her voice... pfft yeah right she was flawless

  • @XxRednBlackxX during every performance of this song? like everytime she sings this they say she was sick..excuses! lol

  • @huski09 lol No just this performance. Ppl are just shocked at how amazing she was while she was sick. But it was only for this performance

  • this is her best performance vocally. ever. period.

  • where the fuck is melanie now hahhaahahha

  • Her magnificent voice! Such no one else!!!!!

  • Melanie who?

  • @slayer3to10

    This was the first time I've heard this performance and up until now I really liked Melanie's version over Beyonce's but O-M-G, that poor girl definitely does not compare to this at all!

  • @slayer3to10 melenie only 18yrs of age.....

  • @aleef133 AND? Beyonce was only 17 when DC released their debut album.

  • @MissBeyGKnowles

    ...B didn't sing like this @ 17, don't try to lie

  • @GUURL101 hahah well you cant compare the R&B that beyonce was doing at 17 with this song, theyre completely different. that R&B was more about the mellow harmonies...when she started to go into complete pop for B'Day, yeah, she had an extremely strong pop voice. but that doesn't change the fact her CD's were selling out when she was 17.

  • @MissBeyGKnowles

    ...actually DC's debut album sold about 1 mil copies in the US(not bad), but it wasn't just B, it was four people and Melanie is Melanie, I dont' really care for any of them but I think that B's voice has grown over the years and she's a better singer, I think Melanie's voice will obviously grow...and possibly reach B's level btw, I also think B should stick to R&B, the pop genre isn't really for singers(ex: Gaga, Ke$ha, Brit) so her voice is too big 4 pop

  • @aleef133 MELANIE IS 19....

  • @slayer3to10 Melanie AMARO. Remember the name

  • @2harrison3 dude, melanie is NO beyonce...dont even....please and literally don't even...its funny how melanie hasn't done an original song or production. its because she lacks the creativity or charisma to become a superstar.... melanie is another jordin sparks....and wont be relevant in 3 years. but i mean, she's still a millionaire

  • @ihofaerefa i never said she was better than beyonce. beyonces freaking awesome. but so is melanie. she hasn't had an original song or production because she JUST won xfactor? you don't think she's gonna make an album and sell millions of records? i'll be sure to think of you when it happens

  • Wow Beyonce. Your soooo stunning! And your voice is breath taking!

  • @truewoman100 and Mariah Carey

  • Amazing performance but that string behind her ear  annoys the FUCK out of me!

  • love it did u see jamie whipn the tears way and oprah seemed stunned

  • love it

  • this is the most amazing thing i have ever heard....

  • I come back to this every few weeks :L <3

  • This is truly amazing. She sounds unbelievable live! Brings me to tears everytime :..)

  • ç.ç I'm crying... :(

  • 2 words: BEYOND. PERFECTION.!! =')

  • I cry every time I watch this, she's breathtaking!

  • Gaaaaawd AMAZING! lol look how she bounced baack up at 2:38

  • Para mi, la mejor voz del mundo.

  • Beyonce is not only singing she gives emotion in each performance. It's an artist. And she got one of the best female pop singer voice.

  • 66 people are crazy retards, or youtube time wasters

  • La mejor de todas;) sinn duda alguuna!!!

  • Love love love this had to be the very first performance I witnessed of this song & fell in love with ever since.!

  • Completely blown away !!!!!

  • Why is it That everytime someone is doing Great.. Or just gave a really amazing performance.. Somebody would say.. " she was sick that day.. But did her best.. " what is that all about? Can't u just say.. Daymn!! That was a great live performance!!! Period!!!

  • One Word: YASSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!

  • i don't get it.Rihanna can have 20 top 10 singles when we have a diva like this.

  • @jjj123g because mainstream has gone completely down the drain. people nowadays could care less if someone's good live, or even lyrics. all people want are nice beats, nothing else. the song could be singing about waiting for grass to die..as long as it has a good beat people will love it. It's pathetic really..but all i know is nothing stops me from blasting beyonce's CDs in my car.

  • jay-z is so lucky

  • Best live singers: Beyonce,Christina Aguilera,Jennifer Hudson l,Leona Lewis,Adele!

  • @truewoman100 christina don't sing good in live performances, she always mess up in something.

  • @truewoman100 mariah carey, toni braxton, celine dion, whitney houston and rihanna too :)

  • @etxhioVEVO Rihanna? LOL,rihanna cant even sing,leona lewis and adele are the REAL singers and ofc... beyonce,celinde dion....

  • @gaga7777lady i dont think so :)

  • @truewoman100 Whitney Houston ?

  • @0neShawty I think truewoman100 just counts the singers who pops up in this generation.mariah carey and whitney have been wellknown for their best live for many decades so it is tedious to mentioned something that has already been a part of the knowledge of public.

  • @iamaveryuglyboy Yes you're right. But whitney houston is a legend :)

  • @truewoman100 u forgot mariah carey and whitney houston :)

  • @truewoman100 Celine Dion!

  • @truewoman100 You forgot Whitney Houston and Celin Dion!

  • @truewoman100 and Lady Gaga

  • @truewoman100 You forgot Mariah Carey.

  • @truewoman100 But Beyonces much betetr than the rest of them!!!! shes on a higher level than them as well!! jhud busy doing irrelevant weight loss commercials as if shes a has been and xtina??? just pray for her!

  • ♥ she looks so good & her voice . Amazing ! ♥

  • OMG she is sooo good! thank the lord she exist

  • Beyoncé is the best. She's the Queen and Diva. LEGEND! ♥

  • คุณเก่งมากคัฟ สุดยอดเลยคัฟผม

  • everytime someone try to cover this song, it is not even close to her vocal ability and interpretation, it is something that you can not explain *-*

  • This is the Queen sorry Melanie! Best rendition!

  • Beyonce was sick that day and still deliver 1 of the most epic vocal performance of her career.

  • Sorry but none of the recent performances in years by different artists and talent show contestants have come close to this epic performance.

  • she's the only woman who I can hand down singing this song, she start soft and the she make that growls, in this song nobody beats her.

  • This is the only version I have seen in which she matches Melanie Amaro. And notice I said matches. Melanie is still better.