20100409 超級星光大道 21.閻奕格:讓

[BrusselsSouth]

Great song in whatever language !

[miyavi779]

桃子 還真敢講 贏卓義峰那場根本是作弊贏的 有耳朵都馬聽得出來是誰贏

[frankkkyyyy]

實力派歌手

不過唱得不好 沒feel

還是愛楊宗偉

[wweeii1020]

我一直不懂為什麼小胖在某集

叮噹唱我是一隻小小小小鳥不按下第五顆燈

主持人陶子問他為什麼

他講"叮噹!你應該來的~叮噹!"..........

結果還是不知道為什麼他不按

討厭小胖!!吐!

[kkchoy100]

唱得很有味道...

[qwer1475123]

@kkchoy100 你聾了?

[luvjinglun]

hmmm..i agree that she might have the wrong interpretation of the song...eg. the last sentence of the chorus....

[ihhsinchen]

為什麼只得17分? 點閱率將還格格一個公道!

[fNeBatisa]

現實就是我想買中文專輯

再見了 外國人

[annoyingfever]

@fNeBatisa wtf?

[linritzica]

I don't care if people say her interpretation is off or this rendition wasn't as good, but it was after listening to this song that I fell in love with her voice. <3

[MrFuwah]

很有個人風格！

[nathanhube]

Good voice + wrong interpretation

This song is about a person in a very low low low mood.

[2010samsamsam]

@nathanhube 你是否有病!? 她唱出來的不正就是"low low mood" 嗎?

聽2:10 "讓你飛翔, 又讓你說謊..." 是多麽的豪邁奔放, 感情澎湃...这首歌並没有选错，同意評審被閻奕格之前的唱法綁­住了...絕對應該超過20分

[roselovejack2010]

其實某些方面要感謝曾治豪、如果這一場他勝了、也許就沒有後面的­閻奕格了、因為pk者只要輸一場就要打包了………但不是說曾治豪­唱的多麼差、但還是要謝謝他



[sya8635]

@roselovejack2010 還要謝謝胡夏，胡夏鬼打牆，製作單位爲了保他，只能犧牲曾志豪了­，如果他們2個表現都正常的話，下去的絕對是奕格，唱這樣只給1­7分？

[LEEmirage]

我覺得很好聽呀!閻亦格的聲線超美超好聽的~更有不同於男歌手的­動人風格呀!!!

[ebat5]

唱的很棒啊。我個人比較閻奕格的版本。很好聽

不明白為什麼只得17分。

[Lu34345]

我覺得不錯阿!!

[624kelly]

好听啊！！

[ctlim8818]

奕格，这首歌妳並没有选错，只有这首歌能让我深深感动过，希望将­来妳能把这首"让"收錄在妳新专辑里，在此祝妳一路顺风。

[scorpioo]

唱的很好啊？怎么分数那么低？

[justinwong02714]

可以試試放輕一點來唱

[xdivisionx]

Her singing is so.............freaking amazing!

[wade77805]

滿分都不為過...

[james208555]

前面有點不穩 後面有拉上來



[tc3181]

根本唱得不錯，不知什麼只給17分。

可能想給閻小姐一點打擊

使她不要自滿不段努力。

[worryhero]

這首歌有什麼不好？只是很多人們只會聽高音什麼的所以會覺得這首­歌不好聽沒特色，但蕭煌奇寫的這首歌還是很好呀。重點是能唱好它­的歌手真的沒幾個。

[helen0music]

歌曲没错，唱的人也没错，只是他们彼此不适合彼此，所以起不了共­鸣。两个都是很棒的歌手和歌曲，但是就是没办法结合~

[hot2000gboy]

唱的有很差嗎？分數給的太低了吧！

[3LD3VIL]

im in love whit this blue dress girl shes hot

[bnbnbnbn350]

唱片出來我一定買 哈!!

格格加油~~~~~~~~~~~

[Wendyjp6]

雖然格格唱得不錯

但還是比較喜歡原唱的版本

[kennybill]

選錯歌了!

這首曲嚴格來說是不合格!作曲人犯了很多錯誤!

只是楊宗緯很懂唱歌.讓人有錯覺!

意圖從熱門歌星中身上發掘冷門好歌,是必定失敗的!

請參賽者去理解這原理!

[cxyian]

@kennybill 这首歌有什么不合格的地方？萧煌奇犯了什么错误？

[KIT7732KIT]

另一味道 , 不錯 , 好聽

[looiwc123]

Is a good song depend on how to sing.what type of skill & pitch using .Front part of the song janice don well.I think mark deduct due to during singing middle part especially at 2:35-2:45, let judge see that her weakness to showing that how hard she perform this song.if she using different pitch a bit showing taugh to improve this song .Is a touching song can record as CD album

[MozillaEgg]

這首歌她唱的"平平', 這樣難怪, 本來就是一首爛歌, 一首爛製作人草草塞給楊宗緯唱的爛歌, 要不是楊宗緯太會唱, 這首爛歌本來跟本没人會聽的. 選錯歌了....(楊和閻都選錯了...) 歌錯了, 就... 很難....

[looiwc123]

Wonder y this time listen part of the yang mv song .In my mind just occur some shadow of janice voice ,perhap i still had not enough level of skill to distinguish between 2 singer that who r singing better or touching.But My ears just told me that i rather like janice voice than Yang.Her great voice oledy attract me to listen & listen without bore.

[roger3793]

我聽了楊宗緯版本後大概知道為何只有十七分了

她的音準沒問題也很有畫面

但她的畫面似乎是當面對愛人傾訴

而楊宗緯則是自怨自艾的自敘

不過這首歌未必一定要楊宗緯那樣唱才對

歌詞的描述她那樣唱也能成立吧

我想這應該就是她只有十七分的原因吧



[wade77805]

星光評分真的問題很大

這首我聽了好多次......

唱的不比原唱差了.....

閻奕格 真的太厲害了!! 快出專輯吧~~

[looiwc123]

@wade77805 judge only listen 1 time,didn't feel it,if they listen & listen few time.the mark wil be different,at least 22 above.If she more practice & correct it.Next time perform this song again .I believe that she sing this song  will better than original singer.

[venia6913]

真不知道她受過多少的曲折

聽她的歌就感覺得出來

很讓人心疼~

如果你要當最好的 就不要怕受傷

敢接受競爭的人 才是最棒的!

[LGP91102]

我很喜歡看她唱歌,只不過她的哭腔能在時機放!不要一直放太多,­這樣會覺得不好聽:)

加油阿閻格~

[oliveryaya]

聽完好感傷

[cj30156]

不知道為什麼 明明都唱的很好 一定要說誰唱的比誰好?

從來就沒人最好過 最好的就只是在個人的內心裡 別因為這樣就拿別的好聲音來做比較跟批評 這樣只會傷到其他喜歡聽好聲音的人ˋˊ

[b5292710]

星光不是超偶

給分沒有那摩膚淺

17分我覺得給的理所當然

這首唱的不好

對她來講

就是不穩

[vicky114608]

老實說也許是選歌的關係，

這首表現是稍不如她其他首，

但十七分太誇張了，

我覺得差不多二十分左右。

[amy1237896]

讓我第一個喜歡的魔王是Alisa

他是第二個了!

[MyFilm100]

看過那些評審的評語後，很明顯是針對著閻小姐而來的，因為曾治豪­的父親是藝人，所以看得出他們是有私心的，想伺機打擊閻，可惜曾­徧徧又嚴重失誤。

天意啊！！

[tomtang510728]

這首歌根本就唱得很好.以過去評審標準至少應該20分以上.

估計評審這場原就有意要打壓閻的氣焰.所以才對曾的失誤非常懊惱­.因為他破壞了計劃.

評審真是會誤導歌手及觀眾.一方面鼓勵要有變化.歌手照辦了又吝­嗇給正確評價.

希望閻小姐未來還能堅持偶而唱些溫柔的情歌.別被評審誤導了.

[anron1234]

不錯丫...........................­...

[asbala123]

評審被閻奕格之前的唱法綁住了...所以...~_~

[lovesmile57]

拜託

明明就唱的超好的

超有它自己的味道

!!

[889justine]

她唱得好用力,感覺不是"讓"而是"恨"

[frankmu714]

她在星光我給她排前五名，有外表、有實力!!~

[MyFilm100]

真不明白為何只有17分，這首是詮釋感情的歌，閻小姐絕對做到內­心的無奈，演譯得非常好！深受感動。

[siuma0015]

楊宗緯的感情較自然,有點無奈的FEEL

她唱得不輸楊宗緯, 但是感情方面還差一點

[rock75711]

我這門感覺楊宗偉輸ㄚ..

[chiuph1220]

她真的不會輸楊宗鍏,同一首歌比楊宗緯有味道多了.

[YngYing]

我個人覺得 她唱的好有感情 應該有20分吧

[SilentJay2u]

很稳的唱功

[beefpatty2go]

janice yan's voice is better for english songs like christina and kelly clarkson. I feel like her voice is a bit of a waste on a song like this one because it doesnt really show her full potential.

[b5292710]

這屆可能是因為太弱的關係了

所以才會找一堆強的明星

連pk也強成這樣..

[kin313810]

真的要謝謝曾治豪,不是他突然有失誤就聽到不閻奕格的今晚想念的­人是不是我和walk away,17分如果錯沒失誤很有可能會輸@@

[clown0102]

很有感情及畫面

[wakeup]

So she's not a normal contestant? She's a 踢館者... what's that?

[islandboy55100]

I like her voice. She will be a super star.

[leewanlls]

就是喜歡她不亂飆, 不亂飆高音不亂飆技巧

唱歌是應該先感情後技巧的

可能在比賽裡有點失色

但能忠於歌曲把歌曲的感覺好好唱出來

自然而實在的美更脫俗更耐聽！:):)

[bradandy15]

小胖畢竟是男生吧 難度是很高的

不然難不成閻唱低音會比男歌手更勝一籌嗎?

林育群本身還是算非常有實力的

[MessageOfTheWind]

唱得很好啊！

[whateveryouyouyou]

很不明白星光的評審, 在人唱歌時聊天, 就算多重要, 都不好吧! 好不尊重!

[birdking721]

........我好喜歡他皺眉頭的樣子....哈哈哈哈

[monotonkid]

fxck小胖

[Akayuki0328]

聽完她最新唱的中文歌再來做批評吧。很明顯這次只是選錯歌了，後­來她選Alin那首真是太棒啦! 再者，她不是ABC。不要連百度或Google一下都懶得去，真­是浪費Youtube的bandwidth.

[teatea5489]

星光這麼多屆的魔王~我最喜歡閻奕格^^

[yu58905047tw]

有點油

[SmartBlackCat]

太強了 ..

[duncan0391]

幹麻要有什麼恨英文聯盟= =

她本來最厲害的就是英文歌阿

又不是選手，幹麻要被侷限住

討厭小胖!!

[jibikao]

@duncan0391 Because 小胖 is a record producer and most of the PKers CARE what 小胖 thinks. If you ask 閻奕格, I guarantee you that she cares what 小胖 thinks. 閻奕格 already said she will focus on the Taiwan market and that's why 小胖 needs to hear her sing in Chinese. She can sing English songs but she will never sell that well.

[kame6788]

@duncan0391 I thought this is a CHINESE singing competition, NO??

[Masked8407]

@kame6788

actually, no, it's TAIWANESE

[yautheone]

@Masked8407 no......she born in Beijing......went to singapore..... and then.............lived in Hk for many yrs and went to North America= ="""

[Masked8407]

@yautheone I know that

why dont you take a look at who i replied to?

he was talking about THE SHOW.......

make sure you know what you are replying about before you do.

[Masked8407]

@yautheone yes, why are you telling me information i already know?

you may want to read all things that came before my reply.

I was talking about THE SHOW not the person.........

honestly, some people just dont read and assume that they know what the heck they are talking about

[p960881]

@duncan0391 上次坐在那裡的不是小胖...是左安安

[egg2201]

她唱歌真的很好聽

[mxchau520]

我媽媽說 她唱得很好聽!!!

[i790408]

其實聽她唱有想哭的感覺耶

感覺他壓力也好大...

[snkbook2001]

You are good!!Keep going!!

[o0yeaho0]

妳們那嚜會批評的自己本身有唱的比她好嗎?? 我個人覺得很棒! 真的 奕格! 加油!

如果有1%的人批評你! 別忘了還有99%的人支持你!

還有 歌要怎麼唱 該由歌曲本身的意境來抉擇! 妳們嫌不夠放

這條歌本身就不是很放的歌! 我認為奕格 拿捏的很好! 歌很多種

什麼歌就適合什麼唱法 難道他唱什麼歌都要飆高音嗎 不懂不要裝懂

[lambchop820]

比小胖強多了！讚！

[Hzonehum]

She's really good already, we shall sit & relax. and not typing those negatives comments about her. we should support her here(:

and she's quite pretty hahah!

[jibikao]

I have to say she was very brave. I want to see her singing Chinese song on this show but she picked one of the hardest song to PK. Who dare to choose Aska's song to PK? She could have just chosen an A-Mei or A-Lin song to PK. She really wanted to impress the audience but this song just doesn't fit her. She was a bit "over" in her "crying voice". Hopefully she can pick another Chinese song that fits her personality. We all know she can sing English songs!

[waybung]

我覺得還不錯啊 越來越喜歡她了

[rainuknow]

我覺得她唱英文歌跟中文歌差很多啊= =

[zone1203]

amazing! :D

[katy651029]

哭腔太多了些 少掉一些會更好~!

[highburycatherine]

说真的也就还好。脸上的表情太多了。一开始就是那样痛苦的样子，­结束时还是。

[Rocklobsterport]

kinda short of breath........  However, I still consider her a strong competitor.

[Superstar0828]

I've never heard Aska's version so I dno what it's like originally but I want to say that I think her Fighter was sang too well.. which is why the judges expect a lot from her. No matter what, I think she sang this song pretty well and I really support her =)

P.S: I REALLY REALLY hope you can defeat Dudu coz I hate it when 'tao zhe' refers her to 'the queen' and says to the PK team that 'it is your pride to be able to be on the same stage as her'

+Oil Janice!

[acechoo]

一直断句， 听到想skip! -.-

[rhmlulu]

I think she sang this song pretty well, I don't get why you guys are all dissing her for not singing this mandarin song as to par as you guys expected.

[kenjiingap]

@rhmlulu

I don't really think anyone is really dissing her. I guess she did so well in English so ppl expected her to do the same on mandarin song. But if u ever heard Aska sing this song, there is a great difference. I didn't get that sad and sorrow feeling from her. I just think she pick the wrong song, just doesn't fit her style. Don't get me wrong, i truthfully believe she is a great singer.

[rhmlulu]

@kenjiingap Haha nah, I didn't mean you, in fact I agree with you about picking the wrong song. But some comments are saying that 'She doesn't sound good singing Chinese songs'...etc. Which is definitely not true because it's just the style of the song that doesn't fit her voice.

[baddayvbguy]

@rhmlulu

no worries, janice and you will prove them wrong next week with her kicked-ass performance.

[kaiotes]

this is the ABC girl right?

[LadyLight]

@kaiotes She's not ABC.

[kaiotes]

@LadyLight K王争霸 2009 北美, where was this showed taped? i rewatched the clip, superstar said she is from beijing? her english is soooo good

[kenjiingap]

As i said before, u can't really tell how good she is until she sing mandarin. She def picked the wrong song bc Aska has that "sad" voice in him. I would like to see her sing more mandarin song. Overall, i def think she is a great singer. Gluck

[Oxlip36]

其实也没有不好吧 只不过和她之前的表现比有落差而已

[fireboylsg]

閻奕格唱中文歌不好聼也......

像小鳥沒翅膀飛不起來.....

[dillonelva1]

怎麼唱中文感覺虛虛的

[charlenemama]

聽了好想念楊宗緯哩 好怪 閻奕格唱中文歌是不是氣不足啊?

[ANDYGO2010]

哭腔太多哩~

[KeithHuiK]

目前個人覺得唱最好，另外，林育群也不夠她好，如果按照美聲唱法­，林育群的聲音的本質很一般

[v0810622]

@KeithHuiK 我覺得林育群真的沒她好 感覺他都用假音 閻奕格是真真實實的真音!! 好聽!!

[mo1990117]

太over了吧

最後兩個字明明一個詞 全部都切開了

感覺感情跟著一起斷開 = =