Added: 3 years ago
From: jerryhcooke
Views: 2,274
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (47)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • UMG MUST FALL

  • The only thing that is messed up about this rant is this. The video was only blocked in YOUR country alone. I have a song from UMG in one of my videos, and it says video is blocked in the following countries. So the only reason your video was blocked was due to region. =[

  • I had a video with a Styx song and UMG allowed it. I uploaded another video with a different Styx song and UMG takes it down. Seriously wtf?!

  • Somebody should use one of UMG's Christian label groups on a video, like Trin-I-Tee 5:7 or whoever, and see if God strikes UMG dead for removing a song about Him. That'd be frickin awesome.

  • loool that would pwn

  • bit torrent, lime wire.

    Many companies have gone bankrupt in this economy make UMG one of them.

  • Surely using and crediting a song and the artist is free advertising for them? I think Youtube works in their favour, I've download hundreds of songs that I wouldn't have found if it wasn't for Youtube.

    These laws are bullshit.

  • The same has happened to me a few times before and it's so annoying. Why they can't just let you post them is beyond me.... I could understand if you have a free download link with it but if you don't there really shouldn't be a problem!

  • Copyright=fail

  • join my anti copyright group

  • Have you sent this to the YouTube Advocate?

  • lol hunky dory my old world cultures teacher said that

  • Copyright is copyright ... if you don't have the permission of UMG to use their music then you simply violate their copyright of that song.

    Even if UMG is uploading their music videos here doesn't mean that you're allowed to use their music without their permission.

    My suggestion: check for some CC licensed music. If their license don't allow derivative works then ask for their permission to use it otherwise you will again violate a copyright.

    Replace the music and post the video again

  • The copyright owner has four options:

    1. Statistics about the videos (this still means the video can get removed!)

    2. Putting advertisement of their SenseAd account on your video

    3. Keep it like it is and don't care

    4. Get the video removed

    Some labels already understood it makes sense to put advertisement on it ... It is not YouTube's choice ... they only react by order of the copyright owner.

    If you disagree you can send a Counter Notice to YouTube to get it solved with UMG

  • Is this the girl who lived in Saudi Arabia? Khadeja?

  • OMG! The same thing happened to me. -_-

  • Have you tried asking youtube or umg what the problem is?

    Maybe it was a mistake?

    You might wanna check!

  • YouTube... are you listening? Here's a guy who is trying to play by the rules as he understands them. Anybody out there? What's the story?

  • Loved that video of yours it blows that its pulled ...tear - maybe it was pulled because it was too epic and the band itself complained because ur youtube video got more views than possibly their actual video lol - i dunno ...

  • This happened to me as well... but my video was able to stay up longer than yours. I received the notice and thought it would continue to able to stay up but a month or so later, I was no longer able to have it posted due to the song chosen. So yes I too, wondered why it was ok at first with their requirements and then later not... but I thought possibly that maybe it was ok to post while they had time to review it and then give me the axe!!

  • Aww..I looved that video! I favorited it and everything :(

    I'm sorry Jerry! <3

  • youtube never has the decency to email people to tell them anything, and then they go and change things liek the infuriating background picture today which is CRAP!!!!!! I tried to change it and nooo it reverts to one i uploaded two pics ago and its just grrrrrrrrrrrrr. Their new features never work! Why mess with something if it isn't broken!!!!!! Mumbles under breath.

  • The same thing happened to me on my other channel (yrm84). I had a video up for over a year for the song "Discotech" by Young Love. All of a sudden about two moments ago I got a notice saying that I was violating copyright... well, they didn't block it. Just instead said they were putting up a banner on it... it was quite annoying

  • Poor Jerry! I can only imagine the time and effort you put into that video, I absolutely loved it! Those decepticons.

  • man, i really wish i would have downloaded that video now.

  • what a bummer.

  • That is so not fair! It was one of my favorite videos!

  • I'm sorry the lameness police are trying to down on your awesome.

  • curiouser and curiouser.

  • So sick of those YouTube jerks and all of their recent copyright crackdowns. I seriously cannot post a video without getting a personal e-mail saying, "Can you keep on explaining how this isn't copyrighted? If not, we gonna delete it, sucka."

  • Yeah, me too. They didn't even have the decency to email me - if I'd not noticed the black text on my video page, I'd never have known :(

  • hey baby i'm so sorry this happened! That video was one of my favourites (like 50 views are mine) <3 <3 <3

  • haha, hon - 1 person = 1 view, however many times you watch it :)

  • I can definatly make Sunday :)

    <3

    and copywrite stresses me out.

  • It kindof happendto me aswell, but I didn't knowif it wasokay. But I uploaded a music video thingy to let's dance by lady gaga and a week after i uploaded it it was copyright claimed :( Well,well, I'll survive. Hopefully.

  • Uh oh... Jerry got busted by the Copyright Police... Lol.

    I honestly don't know exactly what the deal is but from what I hear, there's a "we reserve the right to pretty much do whatever the hell we want" clause in that fine print in the contract between UMG and Youtube. Eek.

    I honestly don't get all the copyright laws, I mean, it's not like you were trying to steal the music and use it as your own, you were using your creativity to promote and re-imagine the music in your own way. <3

  • that's lame. i really enjoyed that video!!

    Copyright is stupid!!!!

  • that sounds really annoying.

    I hope you get the issue resolved because that was a really cool

  • omg ill be in London on Sunday- is there really a meet up? Email me! Woot!

  • I hate you Jerry making me put my legal hat on, when I just took it off for the weekend.

    Two possibles I can think of.

    1. The band have changed labels and so have the rights to said music, taking them out of the universal group deal.

    2. The deal itself probably includes a reservation that the label can object to certain uses they find offensive Happy slapping to sound of Rammstein anyone? (just a joke don't hurt me!)

  • You can use mine. ;)

  • hi, great vid

  • that kind of sucks.

    i liked that video

  • This copyright issue has brought time and time again on youtube. My friend one time did use music from UMG and thought he was ok to use it and made the same notices as you Jerry, the same thing happened to him. I think this is all bollocks of whats going on?

    Sadly I cant come on sunday but if there is another Harry Potter meet-up I will attend.

    By the way Great Rant Jerry.

  • one of the first 5 comments!!!! yay!!! <3 jerry!

  • This is why I don't use copywrited performances in my videos; even if I'm allowed under their usage rules, they've pulled it out from other people (YTAdvocates have discussed this in the past) and I don't trust it.

    Creative Commons and permission from indie bands are what I try to stick with. (although I haven't actually put in any music in my videos (I sing without back up music), this is what I would do if I did. Plus, I'm thinking up a music video for an indy band,so, um, yeah.Go indies!)

  • I liked that video..

    <3

    That sucks.

    :(

  • Unlucky everyone hates copyright claims, :(.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more