I take girls like Ana anytime. Cute and sexy at the same time, plus can you imagine the things you can talk to her? You can find different topics enough for your whole life with a girl like Ana, you don't get bored, your relationship stays fresh. Educated and down to earth girls like Ana are the best. Btw MeganFox is a down to earth girl, nerdy girl, I've watched some interviews of her and she definitely talks differently than what you expect from a hot girl. I used to have prejudice about her.
10) Megyn Kelly 9) Avril Lavigne 8) Ali Larter 7) Barbie Blank 6) Esther Baxter 5) Megan Good 4) Sofia Vergara 3) Julie Bandaras 2) Capri Cavalli 1) Megan Fox
obama is illegal, homosexual (he loves to fellate men, ask Larry Sinclair, Anderson Cooper, David Corn, Shepard Smith), illegal muslim porch monkey with a filthy, dirty pig of a wife. michelle wears size 14 shoes, she can't hide that. when she takes a dump, she has to lower her turds by hand, even break some in half to flush them
How can Cenk be sure of this? I know one girl how is definetly much more beautiful than all of the women on this list, no doubt about it. You heard it here first!
Mika Brzezinski makes me gag.The way she,s always looking for the camera,and then profiles.Paris Hilton is roadkill.If you want ,natural beauty,check out Olivia Munn and or Padma Lakshmi.Yum Yum to both.
The brunettes runnin' away w/it. Rosario's somewhere on my top 10 as well as Aliya Jasmine Sovani. Paris Hilton doesn't even get the slightest consideration. Cenk's #10 borders on bizarre, what was he thinking!
totally agree, mika brzezinski totally deserves to be on the list. i think shes totally smokin hot, but i can see how others might disagree. shes...got...something. lets just say shes an acquired taste
Not a fan of Cenks list. I believe in searching for character Cenk found mediocrity. In no particular order, my list would be: Alexandra Holden, Katherine Jenkins, Amira al-Taweel, Nina Dobrev, Scarlett Johansson, Cheryl Cole, Rihanna, Mila Kunis, Christina Hendricks, Emma Watson.
i have a friend megan tomei who is in my school top 10 te he 1 olivia wilde 2 Yvonne Strahovski 3 mommy tard 4 scarlett johansen 5 Katheryn Winnick 6 mila kunis 7 eva longoria 8 my girlfriend 9 emma watson 10 Rashida Jones thats my top 10
I don't have a top ten, but I really dig on Hayden Panettiere.
Candice Accola is really hot, too. And Jessica Alba, Frieda Pinto, and Kristin Kreuk. Also, I really like Christian Serratos. I'm actually seeing a girl who kinda looks like her. It's awesome. I make her call me Edward. Just kidding. God, I hate twilight. But maybe I should make a list.
By the way, Vicki Christina Barcelona did not suck!
Not bad adas... on the ethnic side I'd include Salma Hayek, Eva Longoria, Maggie Q, Elodie Yung and take out that bizarre #10 pick (might as well throw Sarah Palin on there then)
noooo i'm sorry cenk you got horrible taste! the only good ones he chose were kim kardashian, scharlett johansson, and eva mendes. the rest are all super skinny girls and sanjias sister is NOT gorgeous hell no!
noooo i'm sorry cenk you got horrible taste! the only good ones he chose were kim kardashian, scharlett johansson, and eva mendes. the rest are all super skiny girls and sanjias sister is NOT gorgeous hell no!
this is fucking BS, i have a brand new 3000 dollar PC, running on Verizon FIOS, and this fucking video wont load because the advertisement takes a god damn hour to load. Great job young turks
I love how Cenk goes on a quick rant at the beginning about SI and Victoria secret models not being anything special but then says that Paris Hilton used to be his #1 for a long time.
i don't think paris hilton's that pretty. maybe physically, but her attitude and personality get in the way. and drew barrymore is gorgeous, what are you talking about cenk??
I'm sorry Cenk, but the women you chose for the top 10 are aweful..lol I wouldn't mate Penelope cruise with my dog if I had one. Sanjias sister looks like she got hit by a truck. and I think the ones you discounted like Drew, and Jessica simpson even are hotter than most these girls, and who was that random news chick? she was nasty looking
What?! Sanjaya's sister looks like a monkey? unusual pick ... whats the 2nd audio clip Cenk plays after the Rocky theme from, the 1 that sounds like awesome gibberish?
"After years as one of Washington's most eligible bachelors, Rep. Anthony Weiner (D-Brooklyn, Queens) is engaged to Huma Abedin, a glamorous top aide to Secretary of State Clinton."
Okay, Eva Mendez needs to be banned from the list.
Furthermore, Cenk's number 1 pick should not be in the top 5.
That's freakin ridiculous that she's number 1.
And Myka deserves an honorable mention at best.
BUT EVERYTHING ELSE I AGREE WITH.
LossOfEternal 1 week ago
Nice list..few additions...Jennifer connelly, Ashwairya Rai, Monica Bellucci...
majesticmaniac 3 weeks ago
I take girls like Ana anytime. Cute and sexy at the same time, plus can you imagine the things you can talk to her? You can find different topics enough for your whole life with a girl like Ana, you don't get bored, your relationship stays fresh. Educated and down to earth girls like Ana are the best. Btw MeganFox is a down to earth girl, nerdy girl, I've watched some interviews of her and she definitely talks differently than what you expect from a hot girl. I used to have prejudice about her.
F355 4 weeks ago
Jenifer love Hewitt is soooooo hot and not slutty looking sexy she my number 1
JamesDavern12 1 month ago
rosario dawson is not hot
DeathStalkksu 2 months ago
wtf is up with his first three lmao
DeathStalkksu 2 months ago
1. Salma Hayek
2. Scarlett Johansson
DarthKrattus 2 months ago
Hes an all day masturbater really #10 some old woman
Telij38 3 months ago
I LIKE HIS TOP 3
MrJuandiego1988 3 months ago
huma adedin is weiner's wife surprised they did not mentioned that.
Xytos 3 months ago
@Xytos This video was made before their marriage, and even more before the Twitter scandal.
SkullOfYorick 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
10) Megyn Kelly 9) Avril Lavigne 8) Ali Larter 7) Barbie Blank 6) Esther Baxter 5) Megan Good 4) Sofia Vergara 3) Julie Bandaras 2) Capri Cavalli 1) Megan Fox
StanHowser 4 months ago
Comment removed
StanHowser 4 months ago
Dude I think ur gay bro like come on or ur dick is small
TheCodilicious 4 months ago
I don't understand your taste in women, Cenk :P
QueenTox 4 months ago
where are girls like katy perry, avril lavign, britney spears, miley cyrus, christina aguiliara?? this list sucks
ilikepiegoravens 5 months ago
@ilikepiegoravens MILEY CYRUS ? LOL
AnnaSven1 4 months ago
@AnnaSven1 fuck yes. miley cyrus is the 2nd hottest girl in the world
ilikepiegoravens 4 months ago
This list sucks.
Wisemer8 5 months ago
of course no black girls
lilcp3ify 5 months ago
top 2 are cuban! woot woot!
omgfaglolz 5 months ago
WTF is with the subtitles?
ChloeCharm17 5 months ago
lol number 8 was fucking UGLY!! ewwww man this guy has a really BAD taste in girls
XxBl3nderxX 5 months ago
Hmmm Wonder why Cenk likes the middle eastern look ?
Camponhoyle 6 months ago
Number one isn't even as hot as Megan fox
monkeymadness1011 6 months ago
On Mika: Cenk, are you high or something? - Ana
Too funny!!!
meganmooresvideos 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
obama is illegal, homosexual (he loves to fellate men, ask Larry Sinclair, Anderson Cooper, David Corn, Shepard Smith), illegal muslim porch monkey with a filthy, dirty pig of a wife. michelle wears size 14 shoes, she can't hide that. when she takes a dump, she has to lower her turds by hand, even break some in half to flush them
Petekiv 6 months ago
How can Cenk be sure of this? I know one girl how is definetly much more beautiful than all of the women on this list, no doubt about it. You heard it here first!
WTF9657489 6 months ago
what about penny from big bang theory
saintsFlow 6 months ago
WHERE THE FUCK IS MARINA ORLOVA?!?!?!?!?!
Om71Om 7 months ago
shyamali is super ugly she looks like a clown u have no taste
GaKSuPrEmE 7 months ago
I think Miranda Kerr is the best Victoria's Secret model. She'd definitely make my top 5.
whiteliongate 7 months ago
Mika Brzezinski makes me gag.The way she,s always looking for the camera,and then profiles.Paris Hilton is roadkill.If you want ,natural beauty,check out Olivia Munn and or Padma Lakshmi.Yum Yum to both.
MrMic1146 7 months ago
Monica Bellucci...she's always been my lesbian crush
Deedovich 7 months ago
ana should be on the list!!
TheRarre93 8 months ago
Ewa Sonnet .. hottest woman ever
mgoblue8687 8 months ago
Take Penelope Cruz off that list and replace her with Ana. Ana's a total package with a gorgeous face, smoking body and a great personality.
HawkeyeGGK 8 months ago 9
The brunettes runnin' away w/it. Rosario's somewhere on my top 10 as well as Aliya Jasmine Sovani. Paris Hilton doesn't even get the slightest consideration. Cenk's #10 borders on bizarre, what was he thinking!
tchimmerroks 8 months ago
#10 beats Megan fox.........fml
willxx81 8 months ago
Charlize Theron should be on that list.
kamilmytnik 9 months ago
Damn, I love Penelope Cruz, she's so hot.
kodatastical 9 months ago
ok cenk lost it now
IamLegendTV22 9 months ago
OMG I was thinking all along I LOve Rosario Dawson but I though it wasnt gonna be on the list She is so Underrated!!
davidkozat88 9 months ago
ana rules.
Ledvolta 9 months ago
haha,,,cenk #10 WTF!!!! :D
TheAbhi1990 9 months ago
mika brazinski made it but marissa tomei didn't! makes no sense!
megeles 9 months ago
Huma Abedin is now Anthony Wieners wife.
JImmy4336 9 months ago
I don't really find Scarlett Johansson or Love Hewitt attractive at all.
Ian7570 9 months ago
@Ian7570 because u gotta see the picture from near
IamLegendTV22 9 months ago
totally agree, mika brzezinski totally deserves to be on the list. i think shes totally smokin hot, but i can see how others might disagree. shes...got...something. lets just say shes an acquired taste
sagmann20 10 months ago
Where's Ana on that list!
tstruss912 10 months ago
RIGHT ON agreed with comments about Kate sucky Hudson and Drew Barrymore...
moonlightonariver 10 months ago
drew barrymore is smoking bitch
killallsuvivors 11 months ago
"Oh yeah Huma Abedin! Yeah~!!! :D"
"Do you know her?"
"No of course not n_n"
hirothemouse 11 months ago
Love Hewitt has no Audry Hepburn face
wildhias 11 months ago
is ther one from 2010
Thohon 11 months ago
What about Hayden Panitierre? She is adorable!
PeculiarPaul 11 months ago
@PeculiarPaul you dont know how wrong you are my good man
sagmann20 10 months ago
Marisa Tomei is way hotter than Mika Brzenski
4turrold5 1 year ago
so ugly
Lovejit2323 1 year ago
WTF was with number 10 hahahah how is she hot?????????
vcownzraptors 1 year ago
you have bad taste. how is halle berry not on this list >____<
PumpkinIceCream 1 year ago
at 2:44 her head looks too small for her body
PumpkinIceCream 1 year ago
huma abedin + anthony weiner?
ABisopht 1 year ago
boo bad taste.
I thought scarlett was just average lookin.
BadBoyBoyzz 1 year ago
Kristin Kreuk ;)
jin37uk 1 year ago
Not a fan of Cenks list. I believe in searching for character Cenk found mediocrity. In no particular order, my list would be: Alexandra Holden, Katherine Jenkins, Amira al-Taweel, Nina Dobrev, Scarlett Johansson, Cheryl Cole, Rihanna, Mila Kunis, Christina Hendricks, Emma Watson.
adronias 1 year ago
@adronias ew nina dobrev has a hairy upper lip D: Alexandra Holden? ew!
PumpkinIceCream 1 year ago
cruz looks like a mouse
txteabagger 1 year ago
How about Monica Bellucci?
jcifv1 1 year ago 31
@jcifv1 I kinda feel like she fits in that too hot category.
JaYrRaMPaGe 1 month ago
when are we getting 2010 and 11 ??
dakotahnova 1 year ago
What the fuck was that blasphemous satanic inhuman chanting in the beginning?
YouFoolWarrenIsDead 1 year ago
Paris Hilton is NOT hot
ThiaLam 1 year ago 85
@ThiaLam yeah she is !
dakotahnova 1 year ago
@ThiaLam in your opinion
dakotahnova 11 months ago
My List:(10)Hayden Panettiere(9)Victoria Azarenka(8)Maria Sharapova(7)Megan Fox(6)Ana Ivanovic(5)Adriana Lima(4)Jessica Alba(3)Natalie Portman(2)Aishwarya Rai(1)Emma Watson
hussein2050 1 year ago
@hussein2050 this works
southsidesman 1 year ago
@southsidesman Thanx
hussein2050 1 year ago
@hussein2050 russian tennis players = the best
dakotahnova 1 year ago
@dakotahnova yes definitely...i wish i had russian girlfriend! i admired russia 4 keep producing these beautiful women:-)
hussein2050 1 year ago
anibioman 1 year ago
WHAT YOU TALKIN ABOUT WILLIS! #1,#7 AND #10
Irregulation 1 year ago
roxanne!
maristsp 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Mika is a milf.
JOHNLENNONWINZ 1 year ago
Comment removed
JOHNLENNONWINZ 1 year ago
MIKA BRZEZINSKI?! Really? Jesus!
I don't have a top ten, but I really dig on Hayden Panettiere.
Candice Accola is really hot, too. And Jessica Alba, Frieda Pinto, and Kristin Kreuk. Also, I really like Christian Serratos. I'm actually seeing a girl who kinda looks like her. It's awesome. I make her call me Edward. Just kidding. God, I hate twilight. But maybe I should make a list.
By the way, Vicki Christina Barcelona did not suck!
xJoeEDangerouslyx 1 year ago
10. eva longoria
9. kylie minouge
8. kristin kreuk (lana)
7. rihanna
6. angelina jolie
5. christina aguilera
4. shakira
3. victoria beckham
1. (a tie) Jennifer Love Hewitt & Penolepe Cruz
reeeally hard to chose between them
jackass4569 1 year ago
Not bad adas... on the ethnic side I'd include Salma Hayek, Eva Longoria, Maggie Q, Elodie Yung and take out that bizarre #10 pick (might as well throw Sarah Palin on there then)
Tallturk 1 year ago
melissa theuriau
Number 1 in the world.
kaey69 1 year ago
c'mon, 7-10 all muslim.
crazyozzyking 1 year ago
How did Shakira not make this list?
lostineuphoria 1 year ago
emma watson and taylor swift are the best mmmmmmm all night
159753JK1 1 year ago
shimaly malakar NOOOOOOOOOOO
dnlxl 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
noooo i'm sorry cenk you got horrible taste! the only good ones he chose were kim kardashian, scharlett johansson, and eva mendes. the rest are all super skinny girls and sanjias sister is NOT gorgeous hell no!
hotsizzleakadafizz 1 year ago
noooo i'm sorry cenk you got horrible taste! the only good ones he chose were kim kardashian, scharlett johansson, and eva mendes. the rest are all super skiny girls and sanjias sister is NOT gorgeous hell no!
hotsizzleakadafizz 1 year ago
skinny*
hotsizzleakadafizz 1 year ago
rihanna is #1 for me. shes built to take all my money
SpecialJay3 1 year ago
@SpecialJay3 Rihanna is SOOOOO hot :D
rolingpingu 1 year ago
@SpecialJay3
rihanna looks like alien
BadBoyBoyzz 1 year ago
Kim Kardashian is too dumb and too much of a slut.
MyTotalRemedy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
haha 2:30 been there done that, and then you look at her and you say shes actually..... well, she looks pretty smokin hot there.
BrianG769 1 year ago
Comment removed
BrianG769 1 year ago
If Anna Torv doesn't make the list for 2010, I'm gonna be very disappointed Cenk.
NavarCrowbarr 1 year ago
Ana would be on my list too. But I completely agree with Rosario Dawson at #1.
NavarCrowbarr 1 year ago 2
switch your list around and add marissa miller
alexworksfromhome99 1 year ago
Penelope Cruz!!!!!!!
ChristianHHS1016 1 year ago
Scarlett Johansson at the top for me.
Iron Man 2 sealed the deal on her. Damn, shes smoking in that movie.
StirItUP1973 1 year ago
Mika does have hot legs. Martha MacCallum of ye olde Fox News, even hotter.
loupgarou5z3w 1 year ago
F5 PROOF ADS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
brainiac554 1 year ago
Cenk you suck
BuschTek 1 year ago
cenk really wants that msnbc slut... i mean slot XD
suchAnoob 1 year ago
this is fucking BS, i have a brand new 3000 dollar PC, running on Verizon FIOS, and this fucking video wont load because the advertisement takes a god damn hour to load. Great job young turks
inospeakenglay 1 year ago
Ana didn't make the list? Your list sucks.
Orlando2914 1 year ago
!-Kate beckinsale
2-Zoe Saldana
3-Marley Shelton
4-Olga Kurylenko
5-Diane kruger
6-Milla Jovovich
7-Rachel Weisz
8-Rachel McAdams
9-Jennifer Connelly
10-Shannon Elizabeth
QuebecBabesTV 1 year ago
Cenk, may I suggest you add Akira Lane to your list??
cwongchung 1 year ago
where can i find his other lists?
horbergaren 1 year ago
CENK HAD DOPE AND BEER!
EVA MENDES has to be no 1.... And don't worry CENK we won't have to hear it anywhere else....
InfernalMonarch 1 year ago
CENK ARE YOU HIGH OR SOMETHING? lol
Karzaveer 1 year ago
I love how Cenk goes on a quick rant at the beginning about SI and Victoria secret models not being anything special but then says that Paris Hilton used to be his #1 for a long time.
TotalBogie 1 year ago
i never knew cenk was fat under his suit
SuperJacker123 1 year ago
i don't think paris hilton's that pretty. maybe physically, but her attitude and personality get in the way. and drew barrymore is gorgeous, what are you talking about cenk??
LMA629 1 year ago
I think Im Yoona is the hottest girl in existence.
Jussimania 1 year ago
pretty much all those girls are hot (save #10 of course)
TheOnlyAttrition 1 year ago
Rosario Dawson's lips are too big. The rest of his picks aren't bad.
scottvska 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
My number 1 is the girl from underworld and click
sammemqandil 1 year ago
this is literally one of the worst lists i've seen... worse than new yorks abortion list.
AmazinMaz1 1 year ago
#10 was a bad choice.
Rainmaker1113 1 year ago
#8 BUTTAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH FACE
AN0TH3RM0F0 1 year ago
ahh tyt what a bunch of mindless homos trying to act smart haha
316lawdog 1 year ago
I'm sorry Cenk, but the women you chose for the top 10 are aweful..lol I wouldn't mate Penelope cruise with my dog if I had one. Sanjias sister looks like she got hit by a truck. and I think the ones you discounted like Drew, and Jessica simpson even are hotter than most these girls, and who was that random news chick? she was nasty looking
Pam4Rob 1 year ago
wow Cenk, go with the women that no one knows
houchi69 1 year ago
im fine with you cenk, because its your apinion
Vuretas 1 year ago
the first 3 were gross
mellvins0059 1 year ago
this is crap, i only liked Scarlett Johansson from that list. looks like Cenk is into brown skin, middle eastern, west asian women.
faisalm1991 1 year ago
@faisalm1991 Why shouldn't he be into "brown skin, middle eastern, west asian women". After all it says "Cenk's hottest girls top 10 list".
nutsbutdum 1 year ago
@nutsbutdum i'm not against him, this is just my observation and my opinion about the list according to what i like.
faisalm1991 1 year ago
OMG I own the movie in the add!!
Wolfgirl2help 1 year ago
I've never understood the Paris Hilton thing.
broncojuan 1 year ago
@broncojuan Me neither
hanoc101 1 year ago
oh my gosh Cenk, shyamali malakar, COME ONNN!!!!!
sigma407 1 year ago
What?! Sanjaya's sister looks like a monkey? unusual pick ... whats the 2nd audio clip Cenk plays after the Rocky theme from, the 1 that sounds like awesome gibberish?
mrsnizz20XL 1 year ago
@mrsnizz20XL think you're referring to the Gladiator one. Some barbarian chief shouts it out before the first battle.
Kougeki1000 1 year ago
@Kougeki1000 YESSS! THANK U! it was driving me crazy
mrsnizz20XL 1 year ago
the first 3, were absolutely retarded, the #1 pick was retarded.
TheCagedTiger 1 year ago
3. megan fox
2. Scarlett Johansson
1. Jennifer Love Hewitt ;)
lolpizza14 1 year ago
what about your wife cenk? lol
missbean1997 1 year ago
ROSARIO!!!
dope1 1 year ago
This is the first time Cenks has totally let me down.
dhrdan 1 year ago
1= kate beckinsale
2 = megan fox
3 = adriana lima
4 = elizabeth hurley
5 = Aishwarya Rai
6 = penelope cruz
tigerfedor 1 year ago
I don't know about the order of my list, but I know Ana would be in the top 3 for sure. She's smart to boot. Mmm...Smexy.
TehKoolaidkid 1 year ago
marisa tomei , penelope cruz, eva mendez, r hottt!!!
scarlett johanensen is butt ugly ewww lol
yeh3amwantpizza 1 year ago
airjordan910 1 year ago 14
@airjordan910
Im liking this list...Id arrange some names...but I approve this list
dope1 1 year ago
@airjordan910 eww to #1 and # 5
FlyinSpaghettiMnstr7 1 year ago
number 8 maaan shes not hot :D
MakeSensePlz 1 year ago
no-10,8
monkeyrahha 1 year ago
what song is that it sounds cool
xredflamebihxx 1 year ago
On the strength of her Wikipedia photo, Marisa Tomei will definitely not be getting another honourable mention anytime soon.
weejockpoopongmcplop 1 year ago
Paris Hilton is horrible, surprised she ever made the list.
iamthe1337est 1 year ago
Come on. Megan Fox? She's not hot at all!
occupiedbytim 1 year ago
Horrible! the only hot ones were kardashian and Eva mendez! and what was up with #10 WTF!
Bridgeport203ful 1 year ago
i never knew this guy was such a sexist asshole. Stick to politics, TYT!
electrodread 1 year ago
@electrodread ana did her hottest guys....im a girl and dont find it sexist...hes just naming the girls he finds attractive
LaurenisinWonderland 1 year ago
Ana is not #1? Fucking prick. this is rigged.
Rac665 1 year ago 11
rosario dawson looks like a horse, not buying it
yellowcakeur 1 year ago
@yellowcakeur
You evil skank hahahaha, what a evil comment.
Reqrezentin 1 year ago
What was Cenk thinking?! He didn't list Ana! ;)
CanadianAspergian 1 year ago 2
number 10 how high are you
slash91197 1 year ago
I love rosario dawson!
haha and she can sing her ass off. (Rent)
kind of addicted to rent . hah
xBananaSurferx 1 year ago
yes = 10, 9, 7, 5
falconfira 1 year ago
loves brunettes lol
pershyia16 1 year ago
.
tiny (dot) cc/h12x4
.
July 11, 2009
"After years as one of Washington's most eligible bachelors, Rep. Anthony Weiner (D-Brooklyn, Queens) is engaged to Huma Abedin, a glamorous top aide to Secretary of State Clinton."
wfmkk 1 year ago
He likes PAris Hilton, but not adriana Lima? freakin weirdo!
JLHans07 1 year ago
I think Megon Fox is the best. Right she is realllly hot so she shoulda been #1.
cjomalley24 1 year ago
wuts this song called?
Standup42003 1 year ago
Helped me to surge LoL
JAKThaRapper 1 year ago
Cenk likes dark haired woman, it think.
emmyjo720 1 year ago
Testify Cenk-Loving the hot-but smart-so even hotter as a result of women
Smart women are hot!
TJis16 1 year ago
Frieda Pinto and Ana!
mavishill 1 year ago
How can you not have Jessica Alba in any list. She is probably better than all the girls here besides Megan Foxx.
shotta0121 1 year ago
where's ana on that list?
gillbatesiii 1 year ago
When are you gonna have the top 10 for 2010?
flotte0924 1 year ago
Jessic Alba I'd probably cut a nut off for. As good as it gets baby.
niemanickurwa 1 year ago