@OpsTeam14 I'm calling BS on that one. There's no way you could've improved from playing this Handel sonata to the Bonneau Caprice in one year, especially as a ninth grader. If you did, you must've practiced for at least eight hours a day, everyday, and even then you would only be able to play it technically well. To really play that piece, you need the musical maturity that accompanies years and years of playing, something that a even a virtuoso 12-13 would have no way of grasping.
I'm playing this song.....and I love it. It's very pretty and technical. It takes a lot of air and embouchure to play. I like the way you have played it. It was very fun to listen to. I like the dynamics and am going to listen to this recording for my "tutor". Now, I have the song I can listen to so that I can hear how the song and tempo should be played.
Age has no correlation to musical talent. All of those commenting thinking your extra good because you're playing this song earlier in age than this man are wrong. Both a child of 10 and a man of 30 can pick up an instrument and be at the same stage- neither is automatically better. It takes mental work to be great. If you HAVE to compare musicality listen, rather than looking at titles like age. Maybe compare the amount of years the instrument has been played.
It's a musical performance, especially considering the player was probably a first year student of about 18 years old.
The one big complaint I have is the poor intonation. The instrument doesn't play in tune...it's up to the performer to identify the notes that are out of tune, and CORRECT them. Don't choose to ignore the problem and just play them out of tune!
The sometimes0brittle tone and the difficulty with the low notes are due to the performer's choice of a square-chambered mouthpiece.
Very good tone, but you do need to watch out on the break parts and the phrasing needs a little work. Oh and be careful rushing note 16th notes in the first movement.
Don't say something like that. This person obviously worked hard to produce the type of tone that is presented in these parts of Handels Sonata. Even though there were some obvious mistakes in the performance this person made a quiet good performance.
Go fuck yourself erikster if you think you are better then you need some hearing aids now go cry to your mom or daddy unless you have two moms you faggot why dont you post a video to prove it and stop putting this nice musician down. oh by the way, your sister gives great head!
dude chiil out and quite being a douche, whenever im better than someone i dont just flat out be a jerk and tell them, you need to learn consideration, this is a hard piece for the most part
Awesome job!! I'm on junior high and I am working on this piece for an upcoming solo and ensemble competition!! I'm glad u posted this.. It helps alot to listen to this.
pretty good but on the last movement i would suggest adding some of own crescendos and decrescendos it make the music more interesting and more enjoyable and dynamic for the listener to keep their attention
even though the music says everything should be tongued sometimes musically it is better played differently as long as it makes sense to do so...its called musicality...
as for speed...maybe at the time of the performance that was as fast as the person could go and make it sound decent...anyone think of that....
hey guys i need some help. i have to play the second movement of this at quarter note = 112 for all-state. for a reference, he is playing the 2nd movement at about 90. help!!!
I was having trouble with the sections that are just straight 16ths, but I have the movement at about 120 now for all south jersey. Make sure you keep your air pressure up, and keep your tounge light. It also helps to accent the notes that aren't pedel tones, so the notes on 1 and 2 and, as opposed to the notes on e and a. One last tip, you can keep the B flats, A's, and C sharps from cracking by dropping your jaw a tad right before playing them.
hey man thank you sooo much i will try that the next time i get a chance, bc the straight 16ths are the only thing that i cant get up to 112. u dont no how much it means to me that you gave me these tips. Thank you
no problem "man" (I'm female, haha). One more thing to keep in mind that I forgot to mention. The Rascher arrangement doesn't say sim. over the repeated sections of 16ths notes, but they should all be slur two tongue two just like the first set. That might help a lot...sorry if you already knew that. I didn't at first, and it was basically impossible.
i think personally think that the beginning was way too slow. and the trill in the first movment shuldnt be there and im not talkin at end. alittle sloppy in the seconnd movement. the 3/2 part a bit fast and stay wit the piano in the begginging. the last movement was pretty good. and nice sound
beginning was way too clow. Work on a better tone and better technique. I played this when I was a freshmen in highschool and loved the piece. What type of horn and mouthpiece do you use?
i know this is a solo and all, but you need to have just a bit more of a steady tempo. it's ok to push and pull with it here and there once in a while, but sometimes it dragged and rushed just a little bit too much. you also need to work on the response on your low notes. dynamic contrast was a little lacking. try not to cut off your eighth notes when they come right after a sixteenth note phrase. everything pretty much comes down to phrasing.
You need a lot more work on the section before A in the second movement. There were places throughout the piece with wrong rhythms, and either rushing or dragging. There was almost no phrasing on anything that had sixteenth notes in all the movements. Articulation was plain wrong in many areas.You do have nice tone, though.
first movemetn sounded great but its rele slow lol. im playing the same piece but im takin it a little bit faster. but good sound too. im rele tenor player.
Has a decent tone, work on the vibrato. But, you weren't playing lots of rythms correctly, your accompianist had to pause many times to figure out where you were. You need more expression, not just articulation. But overall, probably a c+ to a b-.
No, obviously not. First off, it says Sonata No.3... G.F.Handel/arr. Sigurd Rascher, then I could that the melodies are the same. I know this because I have played it. All of the notes are the same (except for the mistakes). I can tell this from experience in playing the alto saxaphone.
i think the fourth movement needed quite a bit of work. you have a nice tone, but dynamic contrast was lacking. only a few minor intonation errors. i would have liked a lot bigger sound in the end of the first movement. i played this song for my high school solo/ensemble competition, and i went to state. i know how tough it can be when there are no rests in the piece! its annoying! anyway, it was a very confident performance, and you did a good job.
Thank you so much for posting this! You did a great job and now I now how it's supposed to sound when I start learning this piece on alto as well. That always makes it easier! Great job again!
The staccato in the second movement is unnoticeable. It is no different than your other notes. You have a great tone and vibrato however. Also, the wrong notes and such are a sign of lack of practice. Try working on your interpretation with emphasis on the articulations and dyamics of the piece and you'll be great!
I did this solo 8th grade year! Sure was a shock when I played "Caprice en Forme de Valse" the next year... very fun!
OpsTeam14 5 months ago
@OpsTeam14 I'm calling BS on that one. There's no way you could've improved from playing this Handel sonata to the Bonneau Caprice in one year, especially as a ninth grader. If you did, you must've practiced for at least eight hours a day, everyday, and even then you would only be able to play it technically well. To really play that piece, you need the musical maturity that accompanies years and years of playing, something that a even a virtuoso 12-13 would have no way of grasping.
TheJeffDing 4 months ago
@TheJeffDing Sorry I meant the next next year. 2 years after. I played "Diversion" in between.
OpsTeam14 4 months ago
The four movement from handel in No. 3 is what im auditioning for college and this is my first song.
atrwick 1 year ago
I'm playing this song.....and I love it. It's very pretty and technical. It takes a lot of air and embouchure to play. I like the way you have played it. It was very fun to listen to. I like the dynamics and am going to listen to this recording for my "tutor". Now, I have the song I can listen to so that I can hear how the song and tempo should be played.
MexicanLover200 1 year ago
Comment removed
MexicanLover200 1 year ago
Age has no correlation to musical talent. All of those commenting thinking your extra good because you're playing this song earlier in age than this man are wrong. Both a child of 10 and a man of 30 can pick up an instrument and be at the same stage- neither is automatically better. It takes mental work to be great. If you HAVE to compare musicality listen, rather than looking at titles like age. Maybe compare the amount of years the instrument has been played.
Azturien94 1 year ago
your good
rockyroyzhang 1 year ago
im 12 and im playin this for a solo and ensemble competition next week
rockyroyzhang 1 year ago
It's a musical performance, especially considering the player was probably a first year student of about 18 years old.
The one big complaint I have is the poor intonation. The instrument doesn't play in tune...it's up to the performer to identify the notes that are out of tune, and CORRECT them. Don't choose to ignore the problem and just play them out of tune!
The sometimes0brittle tone and the difficulty with the low notes are due to the performer's choice of a square-chambered mouthpiece.
mdickinson 1 year ago
I love the tone
whirlwind278 1 year ago
Very good tone, but you do need to watch out on the break parts and the phrasing needs a little work. Oh and be careful rushing note 16th notes in the first movement.
musicmaniacs1113 1 year ago
very good. I'm playing this peise for NYSSMA and im 10 years old!!!!
thephindog 1 year ago
@thephindog WTF. im 16 and im doing this. :| prodigy, much?
XxconversegirlxX 1 year ago
it sounds a little slow but i flayed it faster than this, good job
rudygolfer101 2 years ago
good tone quality. however the general piece is moving a little bit to slow.
byrdmastere 2 years ago
Don't say something like that. This person obviously worked hard to produce the type of tone that is presented in these parts of Handels Sonata. Even though there were some obvious mistakes in the performance this person made a quiet good performance.
cameronknutson 2 years ago
Comment removed
alexringer501 2 years ago
shut up
djfranzel 2 years ago
you did very good
you messed up on the Allegro part a little
but you did VERY good!
maroonmystique 2 years ago
Lol ok?
Erikster140 2 years ago
I didn't mean it like that... There's bound to be someone better than him and there also someone better than me out there. It's just how it is
Erikster140 2 years ago
Go fuck yourself erikster if you think you are better then you need some hearing aids now go cry to your mom or daddy unless you have two moms you faggot why dont you post a video to prove it and stop putting this nice musician down. oh by the way, your sister gives great head!
mission10106 2 years ago
Lol you need to chill guy below.. Seriously.
Erikster140 2 years ago
@Erikster140 I understand the want to show how good you are but no one likes when you make others look like crap to do so.
Soh962 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lol nice.. How old are you?? I'm in 8th and better lol nice tho
Erikster140 2 years ago
and you're a cocky ass.
sup2u 2 years ago
Lol I'm better than u and I'm still just in eighth lol nice tho
Erikster140 2 years ago
dude chiil out and quite being a douche, whenever im better than someone i dont just flat out be a jerk and tell them, you need to learn consideration, this is a hard piece for the most part
arrourasanti2 2 years ago
Awesome job!! I'm on junior high and I am working on this piece for an upcoming solo and ensemble competition!! I'm glad u posted this.. It helps alot to listen to this.
Erikster140 2 years ago
No way! This was played on my b-day
Jasper1342 2 years ago
Using this piece for a scholarship audition. hope it comes out alright.
MushuPork13 2 years ago
THANKS! im accompanying a girl who is playing this and i'm so happy i actually found someone else playing it!
AwkwardExpression 2 years ago
pretty good but on the last movement i would suggest adding some of own crescendos and decrescendos it make the music more interesting and more enjoyable and dynamic for the listener to keep their attention
snotrocketgreenchick 2 years ago
air leakage under tempo
carcarrahrah 2 years ago
for starters marian paulson is a chick.
the shirt is a tad big.
wtf cares if its a girl or a guy
even though the music says everything should be tongued sometimes musically it is better played differently as long as it makes sense to do so...its called musicality...
as for speed...maybe at the time of the performance that was as fast as the person could go and make it sound decent...anyone think of that....
saxxy86 2 years ago
actually he's playing most of the staccatos correctly . Sorry but ur solo ensemble 007 grog3 was playing it wrong. (=
you are way slow on ur second movement, second movement is a lot more imppressive played fast.
good dynamics although last movement is kind of boring when you play it (no offense)
haoorecon 2 years ago
I liked it (: bravo
I'm working on this solo atm
xXbassisloveXx 2 years ago
Is that a boy or girl????
phillyphan3622 2 years ago
no its a flat chested girl...
I'm not really sure myself because i dont know if "Marian Paulson" is a girl name its probably a guy since guys have the hair out long now adays
chuns00 2 years ago
this beatiful. why did it get a low rating?
gothichero123 3 years ago
he's actualy going at the right speed...
Adagio->mov. 1
Allegro->mov. 2
Largo->mov. 3
Allegro->mov. 4
one comment tho, put some vibrato into it
foeofeternity 3 years ago
Dude go faster and dont trip up as much on the second movement
markerworld 3 years ago
What letter or section does he start on?
Hagelmiester5673 3 years ago
dude i have to play this only 7 grade
exept so much faster at around 112
laxpat1014 3 years ago
Thanks for posting.
paulgrutherford 3 years ago
hey guys i need some help. i have to play the second movement of this at quarter note = 112 for all-state. for a reference, he is playing the 2nd movement at about 90. help!!!
sparkync18 3 years ago
I was having trouble with the sections that are just straight 16ths, but I have the movement at about 120 now for all south jersey. Make sure you keep your air pressure up, and keep your tounge light. It also helps to accent the notes that aren't pedel tones, so the notes on 1 and 2 and, as opposed to the notes on e and a. One last tip, you can keep the B flats, A's, and C sharps from cracking by dropping your jaw a tad right before playing them.
saxinett 3 years ago
hey man thank you sooo much i will try that the next time i get a chance, bc the straight 16ths are the only thing that i cant get up to 112. u dont no how much it means to me that you gave me these tips. Thank you
sparkync18 3 years ago
no problem "man" (I'm female, haha). One more thing to keep in mind that I forgot to mention. The Rascher arrangement doesn't say sim. over the repeated sections of 16ths notes, but they should all be slur two tongue two just like the first set. That might help a lot...sorry if you already knew that. I didn't at first, and it was basically impossible.
saxinett 3 years ago
oh sry lol. r u serious? bc thts what was gettin me. i couldnt do the tonguing all of them, but i no that i could do the slur 2 tongue 2. thanks alot
sparkync18 3 years ago
I played the Rascher version for solo onsemble, and and everything from 2 measures after B on is supposed to be tongued in the first movement...
007grog3 3 years ago
Also, measure 23 , the 16th notes that aren't slured should be staccato...
007grog3 3 years ago
the sheet music doesn't have any staccatos, on 16, or anywwhere else
dhtjlghks 2 years ago
o jese
laxpat1014 3 years ago
i think personally think that the beginning was way too slow. and the trill in the first movment shuldnt be there and im not talkin at end. alittle sloppy in the seconnd movement. the 3/2 part a bit fast and stay wit the piano in the begginging. the last movement was pretty good. and nice sound
saxbetch 3 years ago
there are a lot of mistakes in there. alot of wrong notes and rythms. the only good thing was your tone
Sariasphs 3 years ago
that was supposed to say slow, not clow, Im sorry
BlackFoxx777 3 years ago
beginning was way too clow. Work on a better tone and better technique. I played this when I was a freshmen in highschool and loved the piece. What type of horn and mouthpiece do you use?
BlackFoxx777 3 years ago
i know this is a solo and all, but you need to have just a bit more of a steady tempo. it's ok to push and pull with it here and there once in a while, but sometimes it dragged and rushed just a little bit too much. you also need to work on the response on your low notes. dynamic contrast was a little lacking. try not to cut off your eighth notes when they come right after a sixteenth note phrase. everything pretty much comes down to phrasing.
MassHysteria92 3 years ago
You need a lot more work on the section before A in the second movement. There were places throughout the piece with wrong rhythms, and either rushing or dragging. There was almost no phrasing on anything that had sixteenth notes in all the movements. Articulation was plain wrong in many areas.You do have nice tone, though.
Gr0mmet 3 years ago
first movemetn sounded great but its rele slow lol. im playing the same piece but im takin it a little bit faster. but good sound too. im rele tenor player.
saxbetch 3 years ago
Has a decent tone, work on the vibrato. But, you weren't playing lots of rythms correctly, your accompianist had to pause many times to figure out where you were. You need more expression, not just articulation. But overall, probably a c+ to a b-.
diversion22 3 years ago
He might be using a different arrangement
Gr0mmet 3 years ago
No, obviously not. First off, it says Sonata No.3... G.F.Handel/arr. Sigurd Rascher, then I could that the melodies are the same. I know this because I have played it. All of the notes are the same (except for the mistakes). I can tell this from experience in playing the alto saxaphone.
diversion22 3 years ago
oh yeah, you're right.
Gr0mmet 3 years ago
i think the fourth movement needed quite a bit of work. you have a nice tone, but dynamic contrast was lacking. only a few minor intonation errors. i would have liked a lot bigger sound in the end of the first movement. i played this song for my high school solo/ensemble competition, and i went to state. i know how tough it can be when there are no rests in the piece! its annoying! anyway, it was a very confident performance, and you did a good job.
SaxymanMLC 3 years ago
Thank you so much for posting this! You did a great job and now I now how it's supposed to sound when I start learning this piece on alto as well. That always makes it easier! Great job again!
Jainy16 3 years ago
i also am working on that peice for saxophone and this was a great help :P
thnx!!!
carlyisaperson 3 years ago
The staccato in the second movement is unnoticeable. It is no different than your other notes. You have a great tone and vibrato however. Also, the wrong notes and such are a sign of lack of practice. Try working on your interpretation with emphasis on the articulations and dyamics of the piece and you'll be great!
SpicyLaxer18 3 years ago
sweet dude i play the sax to and im workin on that piece but NICE PLAYING!!!!
musicdude159 3 years ago
Very nice job. I'm playing the second movement on my own right now, and your performance is good to go by.
xplosneer 3 years ago
I have to play this for private lessons, it is actually pretty easy.
jmanextreme99 3 years ago
nicely done! does anybody knows where i can get the sheets for such a song?
assaia12 3 years ago
Really good. Doing this soon for a try out
stacey12sax 3 years ago
Veery good I'm doing this as a solo too. It's pretty hard!
rockstarziplobob2 4 years ago
Wow, that's pretty good! I'm playing this solo this year for solo and ensemble, it's REALLY HARD!!!! AHHHH!!!! FREAKING OUT!!!!!!
nolarin 4 years ago