Added: 3 years ago
From: zincm0use
Views: 151,609
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (195)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • It's a great song! I'm such a tool I just noticed after adding this beautiful video to my favorites over a year ago, that she is supposed to be in the water .... wow

  • Wow, she looks more beautiful than ever- nice song too... not her best, but good.

  • Wow! Pure sex appeal!

  • So incredible soultry and mistic... this video is so greatly atmospheric and spiritual... and when she's asking you " U want me 2 ".. what could you say...?

  • Yes. . . .I argee with you. . :)

    But. .I also think this song is very. .very peaceful. .I like the piano. .

  • I adore that song!

  • Sure reminds me of Mad World by Gary Jules, and the chord scheme is somewhat similar to Sonnet by The Verve. However, still a great song by the best female singer of Canada (IMHO).

  • yeh, 'cept 'Mad World' is not Jules' song. so if anything it sounds like Tears for Fears' song. which it sounds nothing like. except for some simple chord progressions.

  • Sure, you are right. Actually I knew that, but forgot about it. Thanks for pointing me at it.

  • I really like this video it so passionate and it upbeat although it's like inner torment and fustration , I think i says what I just wrote for itself nicely,

  • pretttyyyy song (: and cool viddy 8P

  • lovely songg<3

  • I love the single and the video is interesting..

  • Such a beautiful song.

  • It does sound like mad world but I still love the song to death, the music video is kinda wierd tho...

  • I for one will say that i am dissapointed with this single. I never liked this sort ofmusic but I have always admired Sarah Mclachlan. The intro is a shamesless rip off of madworld but the rest of the song seems just okay and we've heard it all before. I hope her new album is better and that she tries to re-invent herself without taking parts of other songs.

  • I swear I heard the piano riff in a Final Fantasy game somewhere....Am I the only one? D:

    Either way, it's truly beautiful, it touches the soul.

  • So true, so deliver us all a beautul record w/ some rock G-tar youknow! Lost husbands will just won't do.

  • Holy red dress Batman!!!!!

  • i like the song, but the beginning piss me off, its not only similar its the same to mad world

  • The opening does sound too similar to Gary Jules version of Mad World, rest of the song doesn't. She shoulda edited the opening doesn't need it anyway. It does seem kinda cheesy to have the melody be that close to such a bit hit by another artist. When I 1st heard it, I thought I was going to listen to Mad World & was sorry it wassn't. Song doesn't do it for me.

  • Just when you think an artist cant get any better. This song is beautiful!

  • Ah!! You like Sarah! We are going to get on just fine!!!

  • "Rip-off Mad World?? Really? I don't see that at all."

    The Gary Jules version. The opening piano melody is exactly the same.

  • same key and same melody yes but the notes are completely different

  • Rip-off Mad World?? Really? I don't see that at all.

  • Massive rip-off of Mad World. Massive.

  • ehh. Not the best of her work...

  • Very beautiful! I have been looking for the double album of Sarah's Closer: Best of CD in Australia and haven't been able to find it.

  • i absolutely LOVE this video :D

  • Good Song

  • If you put down the knife, everything's fine

  • Always, an interesting guitar solo. mix.

  • wow i dont dig sara much but this is good

  • She rulez! Canadians are the best. And just for the record, I'm not one... unfortunately.

  • wow the beginning melody REALLY sounds like "mad world" by Gary Jules. but only that part.

  • That is what I thought when I first heard it!

  • Yeah, it does sound like Gary Jules cover of the brilliant Tears For Fears song.

  • Comment removed

  • On the A&E show "Private Sessions" she mentioned that it will probably be another year or so for another album. Apparently it is due to what is currently happening in her life and this song certainly explains what is happening.

  • My favorite ever <3

  • i got the new cd, its what i expected, but i need a new one cd, please sarah

  • All around me are familiar places.....

  • Canada may not have as many singers as the US have but we have quality here, and that's what's about!

  • simply beautiful fits excatly how i feel right now

    i love how you can always relate to her music she writes so beautifully i love listening to her and seeing her in concert was even more amazing for me cant wait to do it again

    :)

  • lo mejor de Sarah McLachlan!

    :)

    we l8v ya1

  • One of her best song in ages, and quite a lovely video.

  • Que linda Sarah

  • this song is for u amor,besitos.......I love u.

  • me gusta la voz de esta mujer

  • i heard this song before...just don't know where lol. anyone of u guys know? anyways, great song and great vocals!

  • on the radio...

  • welcome back!!!

  • never mind, just saw the jellyfish.

  • ermmm sorry to burst your bubble but...its special effects added to the vid.

  • therez a simple solution to that proplem of yours.....DONT WACH THE VIDEO!!...Duhhh

  • Comment removed

  • is she under water?

  • I have liked Sarah's music for many years,

    every since "building a mistery", I know She's

    one of the best, but this one song blew me away and just made me fall in love for Her.

  • Hermosa canción de amor, de lo mejor que he escuchado en el último tiempo

  • I just LOVE Sarah

  • I don't know any other musician I ALWAYS love listening to - over years and years. This song - again - can make you feel both sad (not "depressive") or/and feel good. Hope she'll get happy again, so sorry her marriage went wrong now :o(

  • Sarah's just amazing. I think her old stuff is just golden. I love this song, and video, i don't think she could have a bad song.

  • Great song Sarah ! I love ya Babe !

  • My sister sent this to me as I deal with a relationship situation...a very good song.

  • I heard it on the radio tonight and I loved it.

  • I love this video and song it's beautiful :)

  • hot lady nice singer video looks great

  • excellent singer, excellent song, gives me a sorrowful but beatiful taste..and I did not know she was born in 68 either..she doesnt seem any older than 35 sth..shes so cute and beautiful, I love and admire her..wish I could see her live too.

  • I like this song ...she has a great voice and my god I thought she was younger...but still, shes great!

  • OK so it's mainstream but what happened to stuff like possesion or ice?

  • Wasn't Possession rather mainstream, also? Unless you're referring to the piano version...

    Anyway, I think this song is a wise move. It's mainstream, sure. If it draws people into buying her "best of" album, though..they'll likely look back for the albums they came from, and they'll find a ton of less-mainstream stuff to enjoy. =)

  • I agree with the statement about new fans discovering her old stuff. I guess I'm just disapointed that we don't get to enjoy a new, full album from her.

  • best song everrrr!!!!!

  • Absolument magnifique*****

    Merciiiiiiii

  • the intro really does sound like 'mad world'

  • I agree, the piano does sound like it was sampled from Gary Jules's cover of Mad World. It's a good song but she has WAY too much talent to be borrowing other artists' material.

  • too bad it didnt work out...

  • married life for Sarah brought uninspiring

    stuff in here music....now that she's divorced bet your ass she's gonna write something special...like this track...one

    of the best since Surfacing.

  • Sad that's how it has to be for songwriters. They need to write from a painful place, otherwise the music is crap. Except for a few select geniuses.

  • there is no words to explain how simply amazing this song is. i loves it so much. :_:

  • U want me 2.... don't you? We are still made for each other. I ask for forgiveness in the distance between us. I miss U so much... It hurts. Tu n'es pas n'importe qui et ce n'était pas n'importe quoi.  Juste ma peur.

  • i understand this so well.

  • She's soo fantanstic :)

    I love her

  • awsome song

  • wait what happened to her 15$ music video theory lol

  • this song is hottt:) I love ittt

  • Im so in love with this song !!

  • im so touch with this song coz' she made this song to her husband after they got divorsed.....reeallllyyy saaddd!!!!!! you guys should read her article.......

  • Sarah Brightman? i really feel that this video is similar to Enya's Amarantine Video. Of course Enya's version is brighter and this version is darker...

  • This song just played on the radio, but once is not enough; I want to hear it again. And again, and again...

  • everytime I listen to this song it makes me cry ....

  • Wow! Sarah Mclachlan has an amazing...one of the most beautiful voices in the world you go Sarah..for some reason every time I see this video it reminds me English Soprano Sarah Brightman inside,outside cover "Symphony" new

    album,with the red dress and the dark side...is like Sarah Brightman

  • your an asshole

  • i don't understand the video.... it doesn't go with the song.... but this song is AMAZING!!! she has such a pretty voice, she was the perfect person for this song, and i like the beat too

  • I like your comment but obviously the video representece that she feels lonly stranded and sad that he is gone

  • lol i figured that out whenever i heard about this guy she is talking about... i saw her on tv talking about it... thanks for the comment!

  • I can't get enough of this song!!

  • everything this womans touches is a hit! LOVE IT!

  • I can't stop playing this song, I love it so much!

  • I stil think this da bomb song. sorry if i sound old school

  • ITA. Old school is good, why apologize?

    Now that I'm here to reply to your comment I can play this song another 10 times. LOL.

  • She's so original. She lets it

    all out. And don't we all feel

    like that some times? Thank you

    Sarah. What a beautiful video.

  • the beginning & the main tune whatever ... of the song drives me crazy cause it sounds exactly like Mad World by Gary Jules.

    Aside from that i love the song. =P

  • I also think the melody which is like the beginning of the Mad World by Gary Jules and also love this song。

    So it's purely similar or copy?

    I heared the live version from youtube,she didn't play this part.

    I also like the song Don't Give Up On Us from this album.

  • Mad World is a Tears for Fears song, written by Roland Orzabal.

  • she sang this song at me to we .....she sounds the same live which means she is awsome live or in studio

  • She has never looked so Beautiful! I LOVE the red dress!

  • I love this

  • Always so lovely, so deep, so meaningful songs from Sarah. LOVE it!

  • love the song -video is not working for me

  • Well. she isn't a very good waitress, so no I wouldn't hire her.

  • Love this song! =)

  • I hear dthis song in the shower last night and fel in love with it. where ca i d/l this?

  • O.o

  • Such a calming song. Love it.

  • The beginning reminds me a little bit of 'Mad World' by Gary Jules :s

  • definetly

    I thought that too!

  • Exactly what I thought when I first heard it

  • love it...kinda cowboy junkie esq? beginning reminds me of Fumbling.....

  • RAP...I will always want you.

  • i love sarah.

    i'm glad she's canadian.

    this song is beautiful.

    :)

  • p.s. I was referring to 'Stupid' for clarification

  • Sarah, to the best of my knowledge, always writes her songs about things she knows from personal experience and when she tells a story about someone she's heard about rather than her own life she usually says so (e.g. 'Angel', 'Hold On', 'Sweet Surrender' etc.)

    - it seemed really odd to me that she wrote a song about someone having an affair and then claimed that the song just came to her and was nothing to do with her life at all. I could be very wrong but that's just my thoughts on it.

  • U want me 2.... don't you? We are still made for each other. I ask for forgiveness in the distance between us. I miss U so much... It hurts

  • great song!

  • I Love her voice!!!

  • My fave song at the mo........

  • Love Her!!!! I guess we all know now that her husband cheated on her!!! Stay strong love!

  • this is so beautiful wow, especially the piano loop and the beautiful lyrics.

  • i like this piano sound!!

  • Yes I do want me2. You would never know how much.

  • for*

  • i love the part that where she says "we were made you each other is fovever over now?" so honest and true

  • Brilliant.

  • Haunting! I love this song. It kind or reminds me of a song by Ivy - I worry about you. Can't wait until cd release!

  • This sounds like a Grey's Anatomy song and so beautiful.

  • this is beautiful

  • i'm going through a break up too, sarah! keep strong! i was so afraid to listen this track knowing i would cry. but you gotta feel your emotions to finally put them to rest.

  • Just one of the most gorgeous voices...Wonderful song.Its been too long and glad to a hear a new song from her "Best of" set...

  • Sarah, magnifica cancion. Esperamos mucho tiempo por un nuevo tema y realmente nos sorprendiste. Voz angelical y video espectacular. I love Sarah

  • Great song, stupid title.

  • I thought so too, but then I listened to the lyrics and wondered if she wanted to be ambiguous after the line "do you want me to stay and say I still want you", it could be "you want me to" or "you want me too"

  • Of course that is why she used "2" because it can have quite different meanings if it were "you want me to, don't you?" versus "you want me too, don't you?"...it reflects her ambivalence about the end of the relationship.

  • I thought so too, but then I listened to the line "Do you want me to stay and say I still want you", is it "you want me to" or "you want me too"?

  • The beginning of this song reminds me of Mad world from Donnie Darko.

  • I agree

  • I think it may be the same exact beginning. That was the first thing I thought of when I heard it.

  • well not the exact beginning to mad world. mad world is a little slower but close enough :P

  • I've been playing this video over and over for about an hour now... It's so hauntingly beautiful... Her voice is amazing...

  • greaaaat song... so many time waiting for some new !

  • What an angelic voice, great video! Her hair looks great, she's so beautiful!

  • I just LOVE Sarah...she's so artistic!

  • I really like this song and video. Trying to make things work when they are just not, like her trying to set the table under water...Sad :(

  • aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah nice nice.. the perfect song 2 me!!! snif snif :'(

  • Fantastic video!! Wonderful song!!

  • Thanks for posting...

  • yeah, i guess we shouldn't be complaining that she's been happy for the past... well, a kinda long time now. i hope she'll deliver on that "dark, textured album" though :)

  • her voice is amazing so relaxing

  • awesome song, but lame the offical vid has been blocked in australia by youtube. big thanks for providing an alternate source

  • you don't like the pop direction she's heading towards? honey she's been there since 1997. she's finally coming around from it, recently, after announcing her divorce and subsequent depression, she stated that her new album (which comes out in 2009) is a very dark, textured album which should delight her older fans an potentially alienate those who loved "Adia"

    so just be patient. she writes whats in her heart, she was happy on the last 2 records. let her be

  • well-said, Kiss!

    still, I support her in whatever direction she goes. It's a treat to listen to her voice, and empathy for the complexity of human emotions... regardless of the genre

  • where did you hear this? do you have some evidence? i'm not at all saying that you are lying--i have just been waiting to hear those words...and well, it makes me super excited to think she'll have a new album...even if it is in 2009.

  • i just love the beginning piano but overall i dont like the pop direction sarah is heading towards!!

  • the video + the song is veryyy soothing and relaxing :)well made