Added: 4 years ago
From: ThePurpleBus
Views: 83,629
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (197)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • boy simon cowell ended up having to eat a big fat crow way to go taylor

  • He sounds like Johnny Cash when he speaks :) I love Johnny Cash

  • Is paula stoned ? Look at her face ... :\

  • I love his Joe Cocker-comment.

  • For ME this was the " BOLT OUT OF THE BLUE", (Ashforth shirt? heh) changed my life fer the bettah obviously. All the music that I have ever heard prior left me somehow missing something, PASSION and this "guy" had it in spades (complement). AND when he laid the harp on us all, it was like I never heard it before, FOR REAL. It's only now that I notice it "sprinkled" all throughout rocknroll but NEVER EVER AFFECTED ME THE WAY HE DOES WHEN HE PLAYS IT. B'ham has gotta be the musical Garden of Eden.

  • wow

  • I remember when I first saw this I was mildly impressed...now, with a few years and a better ear and understanding of music, I think this was an outstanding audition, very faithful to the songs without just being karaoke

  • you have to admit that Simon was right though... Taylor hasn't sold many albums at all and he's one of the least selling of all time on Idol..

    Hey Simon was right Admit it.. love him or hate him, he's usally always right..

  • @mddale31 Taylor has sold about 900K albums since 2006. If you consider that 'not many', then you really high expectatons. 1st album also has a RIAA platinum certification.

  • i feel really bad because before i was saying chris dauhtry or elliot yamin sholdve won but as i hear him sing i realize they may be good but he deserved to win and ill add him to my faves

  • Haha and Simon didnt think he would make it... can you say season 5 WINNER!!?? Haha LOVE TAYLOR!!

    

  • Daughtry should've won.

  • Why did he win.

  • I think Katherine Mcphee should have won

  • Taylor Hicks is awesome!!!

  • Download the audio from this clip at soundnabber doht cohm.

  • i was soooo close 2 meeting him!!! :)

  • I love Simon's expression at 2:00. It's like 'OH SHIT He's gonna win this show' AND HE WON!!! Taylor Hicks = THE BEST IDOL EVER. FUCK commercialism

  • @trach1978- the best idol ever? you've gotta be kidding me

  • I love him!

    Except I did he hear he turned a little too cocky after the win.

  • The coolest white dude.

  • If he wanted to. He could wear a lip ring, dye his hair black. Modern, post modernistic bullshit clothes that everyone wears in hollywood. And they can blow him up to epic proportions but nope. I respect he wants to do and sing what his feelings and heart want.

  • @ROWRdinosowr Because what Simon wants is someone that stands still and sings, mainly people like Kathryn on this season, I think that's how you spell her name. Regardless, he wants the boring but really nice voice vs an entertainer with a great voice. I seen him live and he sounded amazing.

    Simon is the mainstream punk basically.

  • if ray charles played the harmonica and was white he would be taylor hicks

  • lol SImon loooks so stupid in this audition ... and look in the grand final hes the american idol 2005....

  • Basically, Simon didn't like his appearance. He definitely looks better when he's more slender, as he is today. One of the best performers to come out of Idol. Made millions of $ 's last year. He's not mainstream so doesn't have a ready made audience waiting for his recordings. Hope his next album is country. He is now and will always be my favorite Idol.

  • Why does this guy move like he's having a seizure when he sings? I agree with Simon & look what happened after he won. Nothing. Absolutely nothing. What a big waste that season was.

  • SImon was right from the beginning. America made this guy the winner, but he hasn't been commercial enough to sell records.

  • @Shakester71 I thinks its just because Taylor's in the wrong Genre. There is a huge market from the southern fried rocker in the country music world. However Taylor was never marketed as a country music artist his albums were put up against the Metallicas and it didnt work. Plus his abum that was released wasnt an album of new recordings it was all music he released prior to AI (which was gawd awful) Taylor shold have landed on CMT from the start maybe even put in a band a la Nickelback

  • @Shakester71 "hasn't been commercial enough to sell records" Really? His debut album went platinum.

  • @gotham61 Um. I'm not sure where you're getting your information from. You may want to look it up before you open your mouth. His debut album was Certified Platinum, meaning the record company shipped out a million copies, but he sold 700,000 which doesn't make it a Platinum selling album. In fact, it was the second lowest selling album in American Idol winner history.

  • @Shakester71 Congratulations on being a pedantic douche who somehow managed to locate the "Wikipedia" button on your Interweb machine.

    Google "Taylor Hicks' Self-Titled debut album is certified platinum," then tell me his album didn't "go platinum." He's got the freakin' award hanging on his wall.

    Hicks' record sales have been higher than both Idol winners Lee DeWyze and Kris Allen...combined.

  • @gotham61 I can google "bigfoot" and "aliens" and get as many results.

  • haha simon HE WON :P

  • if you watch all the winning idols auditions like most of them sing 2 songs...hmm that must be a good sign :P

  • during soundchecks he sing the parody of his song 'do I make you proud' ... he sings it 'do I creep you out' he pokes fun at himself a lot.

  • whats the second song he sings?

  • Swanee River Rock (Ray Charles)

  • thankyou :)

    been trying to find it for ages

  • @crazychristianguy777 Vote for the worst & the state of alabama.....

  • he is also a good singer although not as good, but his edge was being able for the audience to relate with him. a kindhearted-down-to-earth man, and people always loves the underdogs........ remember he won by the votes of people not just by the judges...

  • well.... he won this season american idol!

  • liked the second song of his audition... shud NOT hav done sam cooke...

  • Simon was correct about him not being commercial, but fuck commercialism. He has an amazing voice, yet miley's the untalented shit making money. Go figure.

    Fuck the music industry! Real talent always shines despite how much money it makes.

  • @VioletSpanxx Taylor's makin' plenty himself, I believe he pulled in $3.5 mil last year - good for him!!

  • @mermaidofsuburbia Every penny deserved..or cent :)

  • @VioletSpanxx if you say "fuck commercialism" then you shouldn't be watching American Idol

  • @kh2freek Surely if you can come up with such a succinct point you should have the sense to infer that I was making a commentary on how terrible it is that 'commercial appeal' is viewed as more important than raw talent?? The very fact I commented on the vid as a fan should be a clue in itself :)

  • Soul Soul Soul......Daughtry, Katherine McPhee, Kellie Pickler, and Mandisa sound like every other artist I listen to...music is not what it used to be and sadly because of today's artists it won't ever be that way again :(

  • Why see anything he does if you don't like him. If I dislike a performer, I'm not interested in anything they do - now or in the future. Why would an admitted hater go out of their way to look at a video of him? Probably so they could vent their dislike of him. But venting doesn't change history. Like it or not - he still won!! Too Bad, How Sad - but live with it, because I'm tired of hearing the old song, Daughtry Should Have Won. He didn't - he came in 4th. Boo, Hoo. Live with it!!

  • I totally agree with Simon... I hate to say it, but I really wish Taylor hadn't gotten through.

  • song please?

  • A Change is Gonna Come (Sam Cooke)

    and

    Swanee River Rock (Ray Charles)

  • at 0:19 thats my aunt in the black on the right.

  • Taylor is the definition of doing it your way.

    He owns his own soul, his own record label, is doing well despite what some think. And he has one of the best voices around. We enjoy him and follow his career every day.. Hes in it for the long haul.

  • $imon probably saw him as an oddity - a hayseed, straight from the cornfields, singing dated songs, with a dated sound to his voice. To make matters worse, he had grey hair & was overweight. $imon probably felt that the major record buyers (the 13 to 25 year olds) wouldn't like him. Hey, it's all about money, after all. Paula & Randy judged him on his voice & performance & as every AI fan knows, he won.

  • But has he been successful since he won?

  • Daughtry should have won this season but i guess their careers have done the talking...hicks doesn't have that bad of a voice but without his whole little performances his voice can't really stand alone

  • i never really liked him and I think Katherine McPhee would have been a better idol

  • chris daughtry shouldve won

  • nah bro elliott yamin shud've won... daughtry for runner-up...

  • Never really liked him..sorry. And I never usually say this, but Simon was right.

  • Well, this is cute (:

    He looks super nervous

  • I would like Paula to be my teacher or examiner any time look at her big smile 1:19 she is so nice !

  • She was woo-struck big time! :D Paula and Randy "got" taylor right from the beginning...you can see it in their smiles. :D

  • i love how he moves like he's retarded it's cute!

  • 2:55... Simon, he won it

  • decent...

  • hahahah Simonnnn got owned when Taylor won hahaa

  • But Taylor's done crap with his win

  • great voice

  • My favorite winner ever. He looked really nervous in the second song.

  • kinda emulating/channeling Joe Cocker's manneurisms during the second song.

  • right right right

    Ray Charles

  • Oh okay. I didn't know he was sort of doing an impression (and because I didn't know who Joe Cocker is, but now I do).

  • I disagree- Worst winner ever!

  • :( I don't see him anywere anymore...

    :( what happened to him?

  • He is doing a national tour with Grease...he just released a new album a month ago "The Distance"...it is great!!! He's doing some shadow gigs on the Grease tour cities...go check out his official sites for more info taylorhicks (dot) com

  • Thanks so much! I seirously thought that he just dissapeared.

  • You should check out his new CD.

  • I will, but it still is really wierd that he is an AMERICAN Idol and is in Grease...

    just seems wierd to me.

    but yeah ill check out his CD :)

  • Haha HE WON. I love Taylor!

  • hes totally over :O

  • Has Album Sold 1.7 Million !!! Pretty Good Given The Fact His Style Of Music Has Been Dead For Like 10 Or 20 Years Now And He Had Damn Near No Promotion After Idol.

  • i thought he was incredible!

    his style is too different and too good for what american idol is looking for.

  • hehe, he looks like he's got autism when he's performing. but i love him as he is! He was my American Idol from the start. :D

  • Simon says, "They will NOT put you in the final group to be judged by the population!"

    Ummmm has he ever eaten his crow for that idiotic comment?

  • Simon was being a bitchh to him. ):

    Youu all know it's truee. =_=

    Lmaoo.

    I loved him for the wholee season. :P

    Still do. (:

  • i used to hate himm

    aww now i like him now that ive watched his 1st auditon

  • sadly...simon turned out 2b right in the long run....he won but he is like the least successful american idol....i mean where is he now? he wasnt too popular after the show

  • You know whats so funny

    No matter how much you insult him

    He still won?

    Do I see you winning American Idol?

    No.

  • he looks like he is having a seziure on the beginning of his second song...lol:(

  • LMAO simon

  • his voice is good - but i think he would sound so much better singing jazz...

  • When my sister saw his audition, she told me that he is going to win. She introduced me to him and i liked him.

  • i cant believe he won and beat out daughtry

  • he sings really bad ehh!!!

  • This guy is so young why does he have white hair?

  • shame simon thinks he sucks and he won! the whole comp bummaged to simon

  • where's taylor now???????????

  • In motherfucking Birmingham, AL, that's where.

  • hey dont knock alabama i am from montgomery its where the most prominent civil rights movements went on

  • I'm from Mobile, not knocking it at all.

  • i been there drive through all the time lovely bridges

  • I've only been to the Montgomery Zoo. Its floral plaza is spectacular.

  • i freaking love him!!! he's cool! X3

  • I was never really that impressed with Taylor Hicks, nor ANY of the season 5 contestants, really.

  • So why are you watching his Audition again? LOL

  • when i first seen this in Ireland I turned round to my mum and said "Hes going win"

  • i seriously have no idea how the hell he won

  • love him

  • the only successful american idol's were KELLY CLARKSON,CARRIE UNDERWOOD,AND JORDIN SPARKS shez doin her thing !

  • Jordan is still new, so wait for her second album to come out to test her real durability. Kelly has already proved herself.

  • Tay's CD sold fine for zero promotion. RCA surly made a few bucks off him. Anyway, his audition is better than most and I like his Sam Cooke better than Syesha's overblown version.

  • I'll admit everytime I watch Taylors audition, Simon said he would never be put through to the finals but he wound up winning American Idol lol that was awesome, it looks like Simon is not always right! =]

  • It was cool he won and all but sadly Taylor is nothing now ever since the american idols live tour ended =[ I was really hoping he was going to be one of the most successful winners ever on idol.

  • After the American Idol tour Taylor released his cd called Taylor Hicks. Then He Had a spring and summer Tour and a few fall dates. Alot of the shows were sold out. He is taking time of to write and record his next cd.

  • So it's possible we'll hear a comeback from Taylor?! Yayyy!!! =]

  • It is very possible. He is hopeing to have his new cd out in the fall. He will also have a live dvd called "Whomp at the Warfield". He also is going to release a cd with his music before American Ideal called "Early Works". So keep an eye out.

  • Yayyyyyyyyyyyy!!!!!

  • Taylor "Early Works" CD is out now. You Can get it at Target.

  • I hate Simon for this..

  • Nice call Simon

    How many CDs has he sold???

    2

  • yeah

    1st one he bought

    2nd his mother bought

  • Taylor has sold 850,000 CD's........ and btw Simon passed on Daughtry too if I recall.

  • 850 thousand CDs over 2 years is not a good # you know. High School Musical beat that in like 2 and a half weeks. And Chris Daughtry was already in a band. He doesnt count. He wasnt undiscovered talent.

  • Taylors album has been out since Dec. 2006, so not two years. He did sell in the top 12%. His album was not supported by his label or radio,one and the same sometimes. At times it was hard to find. For someone to sell that many albums with little radio play and no video, is very successful. Taylor had several bands before Idol, and Daughtry's band pre-Idol is not the one he has now. He was undiscovered talent as well, but he has been more highly marketed. Rock beats soul anyday!

  • Fair Point

    But that jsut raises more questions for me. Why didnt they back him like they backed Ruben (also didnt do so hot) or Jordan? Or even Clay who didnt even win the show. What the hell is wrong with Taylor? I dont back him as hard as U do but I kinda like him. Why didnt they like him? No matter how U slice it, dude isnt sellin as many albums as he should.

    P.S.

    I also like Simon and agree with about 95% of what he says, but I cant defend him for saying no to Daughtry. Guy's a star.

  • tthoe......no one can answer the question you have asked,and fans are puzzled too, but Taylor has a really great fan base and has been writing a new CD with some heavy duty writers. He is definitely best seen in concert and spent all of 2007 doing that. He will never be a "pop" star tho. I listen to him on internet radio where they play all of his songs including pre-idol. BTW, on Amazon yesterday, he is #2 under So. Soul and #17 and 18 under So. Rock and BlueEyed Soul after 503 days.

  • Real Mature

    Im not takin shots at U and U go and make fun of my name. Dick

    Anyway

    Im still not impressed. As succesfull as the show is and was, he should be doing better sales wise than he is. Period. Justify all U want Old boy (if thats even Ur real name). I kind of like him but I guess thats not enough. He's a hack. 5 years we wont know his face.

  • tt0the.....you may not believe this, but I apologize for the misspell of your username. Not enough caffeine this morning. I was not intending to make fun of you at all.I don't do things like that. I was just giving info.

  • Who cares how many it sold?

  • I agree, but he has a decent voice, she's gotten more attention than he has though, kinda like Clay and Ruben.

  • Billboards top albums of 2007,#74 Taylor Hicks, #95 Kellie Pickler, #105 Fantasia, #114 Elloit Yamin, #159 Katherine Mcphee

  • what about kelly clarkson? carrie underwood?

  • i definetly agree

  • When I first saw this a couple years ago, I thought it was gonna be another bad audition too. Boy, did he prove me wrong.

  • simon never said a wronger word

  • why does he shake so much>?

  • i like how he twitches, tis weird, but fitting in some way, good talent

  • Simon is an asshole, but they pay him to be one.

  • Simon judged him on his looks. Totally wrong. You could tell he was really nervous. YOU DID GOOD TAYLOR! GREAT SONGS. GREAT! GREAT! GREAT! A NATURAL! GOD BLESS!

  • taylor hicks blew me away! wow... sooooo inspiring

  • How old is he?

  • Taylor is 30, he was 29 when he auditioned.

  • I though the age limit in A.I. is until 28?

  • He was 28 when the audition started. Taylor and Mandisa both turn 29 shortly after the auditions started.

  • Simon is ridiculous, lol says no to a winner of idol and says yes to sanjaya...

  • Simon knows what he is talking about... It still boggles my mind that he got to hollywood at all... let alone that he WON the show!!!! I think the show is rigged... they like to keep the element of suprise...

  • lol.

  • Taylor is so precious, a breath of fresh air in the entertainment world.He wanted his voice heard & I am so thankful I got to hear it. Keep on rockin' us Taylor baby!

  • I think its his hair that gets him to be famous. Its like Heraldo Rivera and his moustache.

  • The first time I saw him on this audition I knew he had a chance..and I was right..

  • wth. Taylor friken rocks..this video may not show his best but if you don't like him don't watch. TAYLOR'S AWESOME!! Even Simon admits he was wrong

  • this guy was the worst Idol winner ever!!....aka "the man with the twitch!!" oh and the gray hair!!

  • he's amazing.

  • I think Kathrine shoulda won. I havent heard much from him since he won. but he still is a good singer and I loved his spirit on the show. :)

  • Simon is so wrong! Tayler won the whole thing!

  • Taylor Hicks sings like a 90 year old man. He shouldnt have won. It should have been Chris Daughtry.

  • Agreed.

  • No way! man. I like Taylor Hicks better and I'm a rock guy lol. Daughtrys alright.

  • Haha you apparently know NOTHING about music. 90 year old man? You're retarded.

  • That is the voice that stopped me in my tracks,he is freaken awesome ! A change has come,thanks Taylor !

  • He's actually really good.. I never watched Season 5. Wow.

  • I love his accent...haha.

  • ahaha in your face simon! he won! wahahaha!!!

  • Of course hes going to the finals, he won!

  • i like it how he totally burned simon!!! GO TAYLOR!!

  • Boy did he make Simon eat his words!

  • he looked so nervous and scared.

  • yah...but he's good.

  • yap.

  • he sucks and he's ugly!!

  • Taylors my favorite of all the American idols.

  • awe :]

    hes ugly, but hes kindaï