Added: 6 years ago
From: Carriefan1985
Views: 204,183
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (233)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She's the best ever "Idol" winner!!!

  • wow shit.

    

  • Guy sebastians the original singer and song writer of this song =] as im glad to have been in the same school and class as him and his buddy =]

  • @TheCLK1987 you got one thing wrong, guy isn't the song writer, it's mark holden(one of his idol judges).

  • @OfficialTeezy ummm dumb fuck guy is the original song writer mark holden co wrote it with him u dick head ... so watch ure mouth ... p.s u obviously know fuck all bout it cause when it comes to the finale song for their release single its the contestants that write it and their judges that co-write it in other words they both do it ... ya DUMB FUCK =] have a nice day ya ass

  • @TheCLK1987 ummm fucknut go do some research on the fucking song and you won't find guys name on the songwriting list of it, so have a dumb fuck pill and suck on these nuts,, and no one gives a fuck if ya went school with him, all it proves is that your another one of his nut hangers, bitch ass... word to ya mama!

  • @TheCLK1987 you're an idiot, he's the original singer but not song writer dumb fuck

  • i love the high note and long! woooosh!

  • ummm i like guy sebastian version better because i cry when i listen to him singing this song, but not carrie, she sounds like she just wanted to sing it perfectly but Guy sings it with his heart.

  • carrie underwood looks like a barbie!!! =]]] <3<3

  • better than guy sebastian's version..

  • Carrie is a great singer no doubt- but for this song Guy Sebastian sings it better.

  • guy sebastian is way way way way way better than carrie underwood. you do the math. you compare their videos. guy sings from the heart while carrie sings like she's reading a line, she's sloppy but she's good though but my admiration goes to guy.

  • @aerowindggh2006 No. Carrie is fantastic. She is beautiful and soulful. You are wrong.

  • @ilboudreaux This is only my own opinion and no intention whatsoever but GUY SEBASTIAN is way way way better than CARRIE UNDERWOOD. If you compare them singing, Guy is singing from the heart and with emotions while Carrie is singing like she's reading each line of the lyrics, very sloppy and timing is of the essence.

  • @ilboudreaux This is only my own opinion and no intention whatsoever but GUY SEBASTIAN is way way way better than CARRIE UNDERWOOD. If you compare them singing, Guy is singing from the heart and with emotions while Carrie is singing like she's reading each line of the lyrics, very slappy and timing is of the essence.

  • LA DIVA= O.A!!

    CARRIE- PURE & STUNNING

    GUY- SOULFUL

    BUGOY- average

  • i like it :)

  • @MyPink19

    Are you kidding?.....La Diva's version was all falsetto.....

  • are you serious?!! Carrie is amazing!

  • i likes this version better than any other

  • Carrie is so awesome.... No one can out do her.

  • she's the best country dinger!

  • Great job !

  • Guy won too. Australian Idol

    .

  • I love this songs it's perfect .

  • Comment removed

  • STILL SHE WON!

  • She didn't sing it to give Guy "flattery". She sang it because it was the song that the judges picked for her.

  • Get this song at __RINGTONEBRANCH(.)COM__

    coolwanz^^

  • i love carrie beautiful video good job

  • Guy Sebastian is so much better, they never even acknowleged that he was the original.

  • I have to say, there wasn't much light and shade in that performance. But judging by this video, she's performed it more than once. Perhaps she did better in others. I do like Carrie, but I don't think this is her song.

  • Awesome ending! Great job I really enjoyed this! :D

  • Guy Sebastians version was better

  • I like Carrie...

    And all I can say is... Why are there so many people acting like they're God?? Telling people what to do... We have our own interests and opinions... It's a matter of respecting other's own choices... IF you want to be respected...

  • Everytime I hear this song,my hair stands out !!!! by the way Guy is more better sing this song !!!

  • ganda!

  • omg. shannon noll? guy and carrie did 2 versions which sounded AMAZING, but afterall guy is the original artist but carrie should also be credited to have made this song absolutely proud. shannon noll was like taking the song right off from guy's version.

  • is she really a singer?

  • isn't it obvious?

  • Im sorry but no one in the whole world could sing this song better than Guy Sebastian... And if you don't know of him then look him up on youtube. Thats what it's here for.

    Carrie is ok... Guy is Number ONE!!!

  • I have to agree, Carrie sounds a little karaoke singing "Angels brought me here"... shes strangely flat on this song like shes a half note below in most places but if you hadnt heard Guy sing this before youd think its pretty reasonable... to her credit she does a pretty good job, its truly a hard song to sing well... Id like to hear Shannon Nolls verson on youtube, from memory it was possibly even better than guys on the show, at the time.

  • great and beautiful Carrie,u are the best !!!

  • this is living proof that a copy can NEVER be better than the original.

    Guy Sebastian 4ever!

  • Carrie sings it great but Guy well its his song and its pretty damn special...

  • Guy sounds more original and belts in true spirits. Carrie belts like a lether belt and her spirit is like the sound coming out from the ANUS.

  • NOBODY does it better than Carrie. Now that is the END of the story. How the heck is this guy dude I have NEVER heard of him. Is he a queer????

  • well when Guy heads over to the States later this year to do some festivals in LA and Memphis with the Mgs YOU WILL KNOW HIM THEN!

  • If he isnt country I wont waste one second or a nickel on him

  • actually Guy can sing ANYTHING! even country! good luck to both of them!

  • carrie is for america as guy is for the world...end of story

  • good for you vitorionunca....want a brownie button now?? Sweetheart....do you not know of Carrie's success. Maybe you should do some research on her... Guy's success comes NOWHERE CLOSE to Carries...and he's been out two years before she has. So, stick that in your juice box, and suck it! Toodles :)

  • Aw sweety, how naive you are!

    Maybe I should tell you a secret...America is not the entire world!!!

    Just because some local stations play Carries songs (which I doubt she even wrote herself), doesn't mean she's great or worldclass.

    Now Guy Sebastian is, he has lots of dedicated fans overseas, while Carrie has yet to prove herself to the world.

    No other artist is comparable to him, whereas Carrie is just your typical american blond girl with a cute voice.

    Ciao :)

  • Well if he's sooooooooooo great worldwide...he sure in the hell aint too big in the U.S. And he should have lots of fans overseas, thats where this idol took place. Dirr da dirr....

  • Well that's the case, you don't have to make it in the U.S. to be fantastic

    And when I said he has lots of fans overseas, I meant outside of Australia. Not everything is about America.

    Ciao

  • you said he was great worldwide, moron....and the guy cant sing. Goes to show what talent they have in Australia....NONE!

  • This is getting boring, and so are you. But what else can I expect from someone who names herself kitty.

    Enjoy the rest of your life listening to sCarrie, hope you won't get even more deaf. Or actually, I do.

    Now you probably want to have the last word. So here, mizzkitty, take the last word. And cherish it, since it's the first and last thing you'll ever receive from a man.

    Ciao

  • it has nothing to do with "getting the last word" its defending myself. and as for kitty, its actually my name retard. and its the first and last thing i'll receive from a man? ooo got me there didnt ya. I have my opinion, u got yours, now go on with yur pathetic little life :)

  • Just had to have the last word, didn't ya...just as I predicted.

    And defending yourself? I thought this discussion was about sCarrie vs Guy???

    Getting a bit selfcenterd, aren't you?

    Ciao

  • Oh my fucking god can you just drop it? Like i said i was defending myself. We WERE discussing Carrie and Guy til yur last message. And as far as you predicting me getting the last word.......why did you reply to my last message?? hmm?? You're retarded and pointless. Like i said, i have my opinion you have yours, now why cant you just leave well enough alone?? Bye bitch.

  • How tacky are you, swearing and namecalling!

    And yes I was right about you desperately wanting the last word, you proved that a couple of times now, and probably will after this message.

    But like I said, you are tacky and above that are an unworthy discussionpartner. I suggest you grow up in stead of waisting your time listening to Carrie.

    Ciao

  • dont let this flatter you, you being right guessing i'll get the last word. I say something u keep replying. I dont care what i need to call you. I said you had your opinion, i had mine. If u dont like Carrie, then why did u come here to listen to her? I went to Guy's because i was suggested to go listen. With that said, WE BOTH HAVE DIFFERENT OPINIONS, BIG DEAL! GOODBYE!!

  • You say something and I keep replying, what about the other way around?

    There are a lot of ways to get your point across, but swearing and namecalling isn't one of them. I searched 'Angels brought me here' on youtube and came across Carries version, and simply stated that I didn't like it, without directly attacking other members.

    However you found it necessary to personally attack me. So you can skip the 'we all have different opinions-part' since you dont act by it.

    Ciao

  • damn..she sucks compared to Guy Sebastian's version. She's got not control of her voice, Guy rules!

  • to me.. Guy Sebastian n Carrie Underwood do the best.. both of them have a different voice.. both of them good in this song.. even thought this is Guy Sebastian song.. but Carrie Underwood did a good job.. well done Carrie!!

  • i actually like the rendition that she did on the finale itself when she was wearing the black colour dress. although this rendition has the last note corrected, i feel that the feeling and the power was much greater on the finale. This is excellent too ofcos..T.T

  • lol, Guy's rendition is more uplifting.

  • she and guy.... she did better... though the song is more suited to guy..

  • She is a great singer. Why are you watching this if you don't like her?

  • Guy sang the song so low on the finale you couldn't even hear it, but he did good. I still like Inside Your Heaven for Carrie better though.

  • I totally agree with you Canttahan

  • i just love her vocals so powerful and intimidating to other country singers. Yo Faith Hill watch out for ur new competitor in the country mucis industry.

  • A lousy rendition. Guy has a unique rendition of this song..but I like Carry. Inside Your Heaven was the song I love to see Carry sings, that's her winning piece I guess.

  • I CAN say that you cant compare Guy and Carrie's voice. Both are very different. I think Carrie was not the right person for this song. But then you of course dont like Guy's version. I CAN say that Guy is a better singer in context to this song for two reasons: This is HIS song and secondly he knows the material and the song was made for him in 2003. Other than that people need to come to their own conclusion as to what they like as both Guy and Carrie sing this song totally different.

  • Carrie is a good singer. But she did poorly in this case. At the beginning of the song she couldnt even sing the notes right including she had to yell out the chorus lines... oh well each to their own. Guy did a fantastic job. The song will always be his regardless.

  • Carrie screams it.. IMO Guy delivers it a lot better.. more control over his vocals

  • i don't like her until she sang this song in the idol final

    i like this song because of her

  • i love carrie ever since n i really luv diz video,,she sang it well,,i mean,,she's really deserving to be an idol

  • Yep guy sang it better. At least he has a singing voice. BAHAHAHAHHAHA @ America choosing a constipated-like voice they deem a 'good voice'

  • Gay sang it better

  • oops, GUY sang it better

  • It was good but I must say Guy sang it better. And before a yank decides to rate this as a poor comment, at least put in Guy Sebastion in the search bar and listen to him sing this song.

  • HEY GUYS!!! CHECK OUT the Carrie Underwood's new video ''So Small'' that the youtube it's not letting no one watch it and deleting it all the time!!! And also CHECK OUT on my channel the Rihanna's new video ''Hate That I Love You'' FEATURING NE-YO!! I just want to share it with everybody :)

    THE TWO ARE AMAZING!!

  • great video. And beautifully sung by Carrie.

  • gReat soNg!!! :-)

  • did this chick win the american idol?

  • yea. season 4.

  • No offense im not trying to be rude or anything.. but i think guy sang it better.. cuz carrie changed the tune of the song so yea..

  • i luv carrie after she sang this song

    beatiful song

  • Love Carrie, very impressed since she was sick when she sang this.

  • ->blackclown and all the others,

    Stop the f'cking spam now, would ya?

  • Guys Version puts this to shame. She should never sing this again especially considering that someone with Guys vocal Talent and control.

    And guy can sing high!!! Go listen to the Original Version he sung at the Opera House when he won. He dd all the high notes with ease and 100 times better then this version.

  • carrie's version is a tad better than guy's in my opinion

  • i luv this, it's kindof sad, but still awsome. Go Carrie!

  • sorry anyone who thinks guy did this better than carrie should go get their hearing sorted. different league. carrie is far superior.

  • thank u to the angel who brought her here

  • How is she a biatch? thats just about the stupidest thing ever..

  • the high note is brill and she is gorgeous

  • watch ur words... no manners!

  • A duet with Guy Sebastian..That will be something.

  • She is the ONLY Idol winner that I like. She is the best, and she is adorable and classy!!

  • Anybody has the performance and the judges comments of this song???

  • This is my favorite preformance by Carrie.

  • i don't like her until she sang this at ai final

  • this is amazing great job on the video! the song is great too and she sang it perfectly

  • If you havent fallen in love with Carrie by now you have major issues. Seek help right away. She is as real as it gets.

  • she's really sweet and humble, no dissing American Idol for her, I like that...she gives credit where credit is due.

  • FAITH-HILL-WAS-JUST-KIDDING!!!­!

  • BULLLLLLLLLLLL CRAPPPPPPPPP. If that was playing give the *itch an Oscar

  • I am an African American!!! When I watched the fourth season of American Idol, I always knew from Carrie's Could've Been performance that she would win!!! She's awesome!!! She also opened me up to country music as well!!!

  • LOVE CARRIE!!!!

  • I was hooked from her first audition. Show over. Carrie is mesmerizing. Have seen her live 3 times. Carrie is the ANGEL among us. She is the total package. Hey Faith Hill there is a new #1. Get the heck over it

  • awesone i love carrie

  • Her version of this song at the final show was just amazing. Angels were involved in that rendition cause she was out of this world. I can see why Randy gave her a standing ovation. I've heard Guy's version and in my opinion Carrie's final show version was far superior. Her voice really soars compared to Guy's as far as this particular song goes.

  • i was rooting for carrie from the audition...it was the first time i was rooting for someone or a team and they actually won the competition or game.... i love ya carrie...

  • voice wise...guy kicks bum bum

  • wow! awesome.

  • You're really good at these Carrie montages! I'm impressed! Great singer to make a montage of!

  • Carrie's tone , emotion and power is remarkable. Sorry , but Guy doesn't come close. I won't write why because I hope he does well in his career.

  • shes an average singer.

  • I don't think so..i thought its awesome..she did great..

  • I don't think so either. Do you know how hard it is to hold that long of a note?

  • That's why..furthermore..its holding a high note without going pitchy..even without the note..i think she did really awesome too..guy can never come close her..its just that originated singer always tends to be the best..but if this is Carrie's own single..i bet you guys are gonna say she did great..average singer? well..average singer can't even do this great..

  • OK, so list a few (in your humble opinion)above average singers.

  • I like Guy Sebastian's version better, but mainly because I'm used to it. I think Carrie's version is pretty cool too though.

  • yes. thanks for the reply. WE LOVE THEM BOTH!!!! yahuuuuuuuuu....

  • Great vid for those Carrie fans out there. I confess I stumbled upon it 'cause I typed in Angels Brought Me Here.

    I've also seen the Jed and Guy Sebastian clips and I've got to say they are all good but Guy's is just different. Alot of emotion went into his rendition of it and it came across really well. As for his voice being weak..it's my understanding he's got a 4 octave range...that is rare.

  • I love Carrie's -Jesus, Take The Wheel any vids on that? Luck to all idol winners, they're all great :)

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v­=7tnJyB1y24U - JTTW

  • WOW!

    Awesome Video :)

  • I LOVE CARRIE I AM A CARRIE FINATIC

  • I do not think there is anything unique about Guy's voice. In fact, he has one of the weakest voices with all those calisthenics that he does to conceal the obvious lack of range of his voice. Carrie did a much better rendition.

  • wooooooooooww

  • She is the best singer ever ever ever (hence my username)

  • Great montage.... and what phenomenal pipes she has.

  • jed madela's version of "angels brought me here" also is good, although the video quality is not

  • Unique doesnt mean good..or great..if it does, i can be the winner too..anyway Carrie did an awesome job..

  • i just realized today that i like carrie underwood. i really am amazed by this girl...i haven't heard much of her til regine sang a song of hers...am a bonafide fan now of carrie!!

  • YAY!!! Welcome to the Carebears and Carefans's big family! Warm welcome=)

  • Carrie sang it so well!

  • you go carrie 

  • carrie n guy have their own talent....

  • hahahahaha il just add to the "Guy is better" group lol! But Carrie's a pretty good singer!!!!

  • Nice video timing.. So great1 Like a PRO!

  • awesome

  • well, the two cannot be compared. they have the same song but different rendition. Guy is more of an R&B and Carrie is country music so better not argue okay? They are both wonderful singers!

  • She's better than guy sebastian..a whole lot better..

  • guy has a better rendition of this song :)

  • guy is better than carrie

  • This is my AMerican Idol...along with my other girl, KELLY CLARKSON!!!!!!!

  • guy is better