Added: 3 years ago
From: VancouverFilmSchool
Views: 117,128
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (370)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Shes a great actress tho everyone else sucked. And great story.

  • interesting, were those people who came to her door the second time meant to be christian prostitutes? weird, but cool

  • It Will be Better End If She Take the Cake to The Street and start Celebrating with 07:42 , for his birthday...

  • In the end you just wanna hug her and tell her everything´s gonna be fine...

  • <--- Cryed

    

  • that was sad

  • josh character: very entertaining.

  • ahhhhh, this is so good! see, i wanna be in films SOOOO bad, but i have no idea where to star :/ and im not near anywhere rich enough to go to a film school.......but it is sooooo my dream! u guys know a good place to start?

  • @ab10ification Students from around the world come to Vancouver to attend VFS. Your best place to start is to contact an Advisor at vfs(dot)com/startnow. They will be able to provide you with more details about programs and financial requirements. You can also find out more about our programs at vfs(dot)com/programs.

  • they didn't show the part where the husband gets hassled around all day at work by asshole bosses and idiot coworkers. that's what you get for being a nice person... nothing. same goes for the wife.

  • As part of an acting course, it would have been good to give her a more versatile role to play, rather than a purposely monotonous character. It was still played well, but a lot of an actors' ability needs to be shown through the right script.

  • The girl plays well. The black guys: get more confidence, drink a beer before you act, your nervousness can be felt.

    Jesus girls: well done, especially the main chick. You are such a j.whore.

    Jesus guy behind: well done as well, the sexy stuff can be felt. Keep developing your acting. Camera shows way more than theatre. Theatre sucks. It's worse than mimes. lol

  • Good acting, incredibly uninteresting and slow story, mediocre directing.

    Repetitive music. You know your actors don't always have to be in the shot, to tell a story. 7/10 For a student film. Oh and nice characters and clothing.

  • She didn't turn on the oven.

  • This was a good film! Not quite sure what was with the evangelizing prostitutes, but i will say this is one of the few VFS films that drew a tear.

  • What was with the Bible pedaling hoes? And why doesn't she check the peephole every time the door bell rings?

  • the reality is that you don't need no "film school" to make it in the business..Evangeline Lilly is just one example among thousands. But good luck cuz your gonna need it.

  • WOW!

  • I loove this short film. It has a lot of different meanings throughout it. I can't explain it but it's definitely symbolic in a way that she doesn't talk until the very end of the video.

  • I hate to be mean but the main girl is the only actor who seems like they'd be at vancouver film school, and not at GSCE drama where you fuck around making jokes.

    I hope she was the only actor being judged, and that her body language is enough to prove her talent.

    The filmmaking is decent and I hope that is what is being judged.

    Noonetheless as a normal viewer the whole piece is badly damaged by the gratingly annoying acting (or what seems like playing around on set) from everyone else.

  • religious stereotype fail

  • AHHHH !!!! WOW !!! speechless !!!!!!

  • giak

  • triggered emotions. this was brilliant! well done. :]

  • i just finished watching a bunch of these videos. this was the first one that choked me up. well done.

  • sad...

  • I thinks everyone will see it in the way they see the world and their life.

    For me, the people who are coming to her house, are actually symbolising her.

    The listener, the kindness when giving.

    And she's keep all in order at home, everything neat, doing all she can. But all this doesn't hide the fact she's unhappy.

    So she got a lot to give.

    No matter how good she's at listening, gives to her husband, making sure - her husband doesn't acknowledge and see it.

    Sad short story and excellent.

  • loved the use of light and dark imagery here! Fantastic!

  • i'm not sure, but i think the concept has to do w/ how she's cleaning up her life to perfection w/ all the meticulous details in the preparation, but how the most important part of her life (marriage) is a complete mess.

    and maybe the blood drop in the cake symbolizes that her blood and toil went into the cake and maybe the marriage? and it makes her husband brushing all her work off to the side even more awful

    sorry, im just so used to analyzing everything in english classxD

    & this was great!

  • the lady is so pretty

    i rly liked this, its like something i would do so its my style :) fer sure

  • Whoever directed this will be a great soap opera director :)

  • i guess this video so beatiful... if i understand anything without audio... thanks 2all! good night! :)

  • I enjoyed this :-) !

    It's a bit unclear 2 me thou ...

    What's up w/ the 3 groups of pple knocking @ the door ? What are they ? Temptation ? Users ? Just the daily effort U have 2 give ? What's up w/ the black haired woman ... is she she husband's mistress ? Does the wife know about the affair ?

    It's quite simple but it really got me hooked so I'll say good job there :-).

  • the enthusiastic women looks more like 3 vampires desesperated to rape her and suck her blood...  and the guy looks like the vampire pimp

  • i wonder how she will dress when she gets married

    XD

  • its cute, but girl wearing to much makeup it annoys me to lookk at her fakeness

  • the main actress will go a long way if she keeps up the good work

  • I would have strangled that bastard in his sleep. Just sayin'...

  • Time to inquire about that sucker 3000...

  • indeed! :D

  • hmmm, i was thinking about either spending thousands of dollars on VFS, or throwing the money into the river. After seeing this, I can see that the former is the waaaay better way of wasting money. Thx, see you there.

  • evilsnakes1 has a small 1.

  • the plot is good, the actors can be better,

    but..

    nice work, congrates..

    you are on the way to be great!

  • i liked it a lot.

    Well shot, and good plot!

  • the sucker 3000!! HAHAHA!!!! sounds like something "else"!!! ;]

  • good job on the boring French movie style. Merde!

  • who is john?

  • the husband

  • she couldve just said there was a cake... or a surprise or something..

  • amazing really!

  • This movie made me feel something inside...I dont know what it is, but I feel deeply moved for some reason.

  • Why?

  • who els threw up/cried during this magnificent piece of footage.

  • Well I didnt cry or throw up but this is a fucking great short film.

    I hope whoever made this goes on to make motion pictures someday.

  • Yes .... i didn't cry either..... I just had something in both my eyes. And im totally with you when you say this crew should go big!

  • I hate you John! I wanna stab your guts out!

  • I liked it. I liked the symbolism. The ending leavs you on a downer and it couldent be better for it. I loved that the women finnally talked at the end. *puts fingers to lips and kisses the air* Bravo

  • that was really cool how she helped the homeless guys. That was really sweet of them to thank here and stuff.

  • huh not a good story sorry

  • so sad man

  • loved it

  • At first I didn't get it... Until I saw the end, It tied it all up!

    For those of you who may be confused as well, just watch it until the end. Oh my gosh, AWESOME VIDEO!

  • i still don't get it...

  • This is sad, I wanted to give her a better life. Makes me think so much. Very good short indeed! Congratulartions.

  • cut herself on a butter knife?

  • whoa she spoke !

    well pretty nice shortmovie here, I liked the theme of the whole and she was a nice actress !

  • awesome.. i really like the story..

    but it somewhat annoys me, the man..

    (not the actor..^^ but the role..)stupid man.

    btw, the lead actress is soooo beautiful.. hehe..^^

  • its a bit long yes angree, but i think its has a meaning, and thats why its not borring, and others..

  • So well done.

  • PERFECT!

    CONGRATULATIONS!

  • Wow what a wonderful girl what a wonderful story...

  • flawless!

  • Wow. That was really good. All the different camera angles where awesome. I loved it!

  • she got this nicole kidman aura about her.. hmm

  • agree

  • Beautifully Done...

  • 4:40 Dorothya? Or maybe Diarrhoea?

  • I think, this video should show us, how important it is to give someone honestly the feeling, that he or she is important in our life, especially if it´s our housewife (or husband). She gets all this attention and compliments by this other guys but not from the man he is married with, all though he keeps his house clean, bakes and do a lot of effort for him.

  • I Completely agree. But there has to be more, it's bugging me so much. Why those people? I have to know.

  • That was sooo good! But I just felt so damn angry when he told her that he would just go to bed. What a prick

  • yal are cool

  • The lead actress has a striking resemblence to Nicole Kidman.

  • Nope

  • poor woman. but the sucker 3000 and the pimp reverend was funny.

  • She's a great example of the perfect housewife archetype. Everything about her seem to be flawless. Her teeth are perfectly white, her lips are lusciously red, and her skin is milky white. The only problem is obviously her relationship with her husband, who appears to have distanced himself from her.

    Needless to say, I'm quite angry towards the husband for not acknowledging this generous act from his wife. He should at least politely greet her even if he isn't in the mood for small talk.

  • @pochacco86 you mean white tall blonde in a maids dress.

  • @pochacco86 Your right except it was more stereotype than archetype

  • wow.. that was really good...

  • oh this woman is so beautiful.

  • my exact thoughts ;p ...

  • OMG!!! the girl is not dumb.

  • mmmmmmmm -- i want a girl-in-pearls to bake me a cake.

  • I think the idea of bickering, flawed relationships vs. zero communication/affection is what makes the film truly special. There is a close proximity and intimacy among all of the knockers with each other, which is contrasted with the lady and her husband. The knockers relationships and even beliefs are coarse and skewed, but they all nonetheless have someone beside them. Also in contrast, she is much better represented physically than all of them, yet suffers greatly inside.

  • Dude. i want a Sucker3000!

  • It was good, but i don't fully understand, could someone help me out ?

  • When she cryed, i understand everything that means the video, so amaizing

  • I love the double meanings of each speech ! Very well written and very funny !

    Bravo !

  • aww

  • i dont really get it......

    its confusing.....

  • Very nice work, thank you.

  • this is a kool short. :)

  • im still trying to figure out why someone like her will settle for someone like him?

  • the guy wid the three girls for the christians thing wooot he looked hott

  • First of all I loved the film. Very well made. Although, I did think a little more variation on that original musical theme would have been the Icing on the cake. I think her character became a lot less etherial when she spoke at the end. overall till excelent. 5/5

  • Very Complicated;

    The Salesman - is her way to clean up after killing her husband.

    The Christians - is her way toward salvation/forgiveness after killing her husband.

    The beggars - is her hired help to kill her husband.

    The Husband - is cheating on her.

    Her cut finger - is the bleeding-out of all the love she has.

    She will never enjoy peace until she gets rid of him, her outward appearance doesn't reflect how she truly feels.

  • I was wondering but you're absolutly right !

    Fine movie analysis !

  • Has anyone here taken acting for film and Tv from VFS? Is it worth the money? Or is the 4months program enough?

  • well done!! that was pro

  • Every time the doorbell rang before her husband, she saw at least one nice, attractive man who really paid attention to her. Everyone treated her with respect and kindness. But the only one she's excited to see is the same old husband who treats her like crap. Very sad social commentary.

    I took it to say that some people just believe deep down that they don't deserve better treatment, or don't want change. Or both.

  • i wish i understood.

  • Overall quite a nice project. Only thing I found a little bit off was that her hand felt really detatched when she was wiping the mess off the floor and it seemed like it was doing too much cutting between shots in that little bit. Loved the make-up on the main hobo. The Main Character had very captivating eyes which helped a lot when it came to portrayal of emotions. Gob well done!

  • taht was nice

  • hmm...

    the girl's who say they love jesus kinda made it sound like they were making fun of him or something..

    ehh...

    >_>

  • why she says "happy birthday John"? I know she wouldn't say happy birthday Tom 'cause she was sad 'cause he showed no fellings. And one of the guys that ask food said it was the birthday of his friend... is his friend John?

    Thank you!!

    And I loved the movie! =]

  • you have absolutely no respect do you?

  • Maybe he forgot his keys,and she knew this and was expecting him to ring the doorbell when he came. And maybe,depending on the time she was expecting him to come-she didn't have the time to make the cake by scratch, but she wanted to make the frosting special. Or maybe she has more art talent than cooking talent.

  • The acting from "the boss" was pretty weak; however, the main character was brilliant. She portrayed her hopes and let downs without a single word. It was rather powerful. I'm impressed.

  • i guess this is one of those things where its open for you to make your own interpretations about, like me, i thought, she kept getting excited when someone was at the door, thinking it was her beloved john, but happened to be other people, perhaps that john was just her imagination, maybe he passed away and she doesn't want to believe it

  • The actors are the same because they studied together in the same class in the VFS acting program. This is just one of their projects

  • that was brilliant - i loved it

  • She's a woman, she's drawn to men of his kind.

    And all those other 'attractive' and kind people who were willing to offer her some love she rejected. Women are afraid of moving on in their lives demanding a divorce, sad but true. They somehow feel that he will get better, women try to 'fix' guys and thats also one of the reasons they go for badasses, correct me if im wrong ladies;)

  • it kinda got me confused!!! what i got is.... she was a perfect wife who loved her husband.. it was her husband's b-day and.. what the guy didnt know or something??? was the husband stupid? or what!!!! damnnn i didn't undrstand it :S sorry por my stupidity :/

  • ok can someone give me a summary of this video because i seriously dont get it at all...and its getting on my nerves.

  • i also dont get this vid too and i dont get the idea that its supposed to be a sad story

  • a very nice lady dosent deserve that......

  • I would have liked it more had it been her own birthday that had been ignored/forgotten etc... that would have had some juice to it...

    or even if after John went to bed she left him... to find her own way in the world other then being the Perfect wife to a loser husband

  • well. this video was less confusing when i watched it a second time. it's more just about social issues. very sad. it made me cry!

    john is such an ass - i feel horrible 4 abby!

  • sorry guys/girls this was not 1 of ur better efforts, the cinematography is great but i got really confused about the story line or lines, what/where was the plot besides John not coming home for his bday cake? was he cheating?i just didn't get it. `:-/

  • The movie was weak on the plot / story. The story seemed to be an after thought or from the "make it up as you go" variety. The focus and attention seemed more on the visual composition and the the music. You didn't strike a balance in this one. Good films draw you in with the story and the quality of the acting. The art and music then become the icing on the cake. A weak story with better art/music is like icing barbeque sauce on bad fish.

  • Strike the word "icing" - I was going to say icing on broccoli. There are nice visuals in the clip, but film does not exist for the sake of good photography.

  • a very touched video.

  • I think it was Quite good.

    Videos, that make people think about social problems are always interesting.

    Nice Work!

  • The camera work was weird and annoying. Music was almost as annoying, but equally cheesy.

    This is like the worlds worst Paxil commercial.

    I'm not sure what was the worst part. Maybe the vacuum scene, possibly everything to do with the Husband (John).

    Good Luck to everyone at the VFS trying to live their dreams or what ever, but that was just straight crap.

  • Obviously bad acting.

    Poor, unrealistic dialogue.

    Can someone fix the lipstick on her bottom lip?

    Sucker 3000? Really, high school improv classes can do better than that.

    So everyone inside the house is living in the 50's, the black dude is from when? The 70's? Modern Day? The Bible whores were from the early 90's. Great continuity.

    Neither Jehovah's Witnesses nor Mormons are anything like this, so I don't know where you pulled this over-sexual missionary crap from.

  • You're an idiot. Because 90% of the people that read your stupid comment will actually agree with your idea and not get that you're just trying to stir the pot.

  • i really liked it. it was able to hole my attention, its just that the actors were very poor.

    They could have done a much better job considering the simplicity of the characters.

  • too often we are ignored in life...sad truth but its true

    great ideo

  • Z-Z-Z-Z. I lost my interest at 2:00 already.

  • Very well written. I enjoyed it.

  • this was a really good video. and in fact, it does say "john" on the cake, just in cursive.

  • I didnt get it

  • Message of this short film: don't answer your front door.

  • so very cold

  • Wher da rest o' dis film? I laik to see wad happens!

  • I interpet it as the paths in life and whatever anyone does you have the responsibility to chose your own path. Her husband is cheating and is an ass but she still see ppl whom has suffered more, and the different paths they have taken. Towards religion, begging, make a living by selling. She can chose to be miserable, take revenge (with the hose :D) or take any path. Very good movie!

  • I didnt get this vid !

    I thought he was dead ! :P

    And its stand stood tom on the cake and she said john!

    hehe

  • nooo...

    it said Jhon!

    clean that shit out of ur eyes man!

  • I loved it, it says lots of things but doesn't say them directly, it's really nice.

  • wtf...

  • its interesting

  • she is frome 70s or 60s women :/

  • 60s and 70s women are great, I love that style

  • aww...

  • it doesn't have to be funny to entertain you, but you probably would need at least one braincell...

  • oh man.. that poor woman

  • soz but could some1 explain it? i dont get it...

  • you gotta have your own interpretation man, that's what its for.

  • the title still confuses me even after watching the whole thing but very nice ending VERY VERY nice

  • I saw it as she was somewhat oblivious to the innapropriateness of the hookers that found Jesus and the vaccum cleaner salesman. She only saw people as good and felt compassion for them and could not see their flaws, but yet she knew her husband was flawed due to his decision to cheat. You see people that may be bad in nature trying to do good things, although I'm not too sure if they were really accomplishing that very well.

  • Great little film. Title fits the movie perfectly; she WAS, she isn't anymore.

    Buried alive.

    Listen to the old Dublinners song: Don't get married girl.

  • it was a confusing storyline at certain parts but it kept me watching. It didnt really make sense until the end but i enjoyed it.

  • I have never heard of VFS but if this is a school they are doing a good job. Peace I have to check a few more videos.

  • Also I find it weird that the hookers told her to have a wonerful evening, as if they knew what was going to happen.

    I also thought that she might have an ocd for cleaning/ tidying things? And every-time something happened that wasn't 'clean, 'ie she broke an egg, it made her think of her husband having an affair..

    I loved it anyway, very surreal.

    Does anyone know why the title is "and she was"? Couldn't figure that out..

  • Haha, watched this many times and I still don't completely get it. Don't know if it was intentional, but all of the people who visited her seemed relevant to each other.. the first salesman said "my hose" as in "my hoes"... the preachers were dressed like hookers, and told her that they used to live on the streets, and the last were orphans who lived on the streets...

  • Great Video!!!

  • aww that was sad :(

  • i dont get it

  • i had to watch this a second time

    to kinda get it

    basically she has a seemingly perfect life

    compared to the people at her doorstep (theme: appearance vs reality)

    did u notice that everytime something bad happens (ie accidentally cuts fingers, drops egg) she thinks of her husbands infedelity

  • and the only thing she said in the whole video was...

    'Happy Birthday John'