Sheikh Ahmed Deedat used to celebrate Mawlid un Nabi Sal Allah u Alaeh e Wasalam

[Yasmin742]

where is the full video? this is just another cut and paste.. He usually explains himself after!

[myyou1]

Shaikh Al Islam Ibn Tymiyyah had the best ruling:

"And like this is what some of the people have innovated, either in opposition to the Christian celebration of the birthday of Jesus, or out of love for the Prophet (sallallaahu `alaihi wasallam) and in honour of him. And Allaah will reward them for this love and ijtihaad, but NOT FOR THE BID'AH of taking the day of the birth of the Prophet (sallallaahu `alaihi wasallam) as an eed " Iqtida Siraat Al Mustaqeem

Search the text for complet article

[imsmarteven]

@smilecheeseklik yes this is the point my friend, the majority of the ummah still celebrate it :)

[smilecheeseklik]

@imsmarteven just curious, are you the studnt of tahir ul Qadri?. I thought he too celebrate Mawlid. Btw i hv just deleted my comments. There are some typo error and I don't want ppl to get the wrong message.I strongly against Mawlid but encourage greatly for ummah to read the sirah of Rasulullah and his sahabah, inshaallah we will be a strong ummah and continue to uphold his sunnah.

[imsmarteven]

@smilecheeseklik y r u against celebration of mawlid?

[PeacefulRaindrops]

Shaykh Ahmad Deedat might have some wrong things, but I still love him very much for the sake of Allaah. I benefit from his knowledge in terms of debates with non-Muslims especially Christians, but I will not take things in terms of aqeedah like this.

[nakhatoo]

@imsmarteven Shame on you brother, your portraying to be the student of Sheikh Tahir ul Qadri and uploading videos against a man who is past away. U need to delete this video and say astaghfar to ALLAH. ALLAH s.w.t said , if you hide your brother sins , ALLAH will hide yours. May ALLAH grant highest Jannah to Shiekh Ahmad Deedat. Ameen

[imsmarteven]

@nakhatoo I am not against Sheikh Ahmed Deedat, He was a great muslim scholar,I will say aameen to your dua

[1DON90]

@nakhatoo which sin has to be hidden of shaykh deedat?

[nakhatoo]

@1DON90

My whole reason ofommenting to the brother was to not to expose anybody's sins and now you asking me about his sins........ I think , as a Muslims i will refrain myself to say anything about anybody's sins.

[RoadToJennah]

It's a shame that this brother laughed at Ahmed Deedat, but.. The thing is! Celebrating Mawlid an Nabi is indeed a Bid3a and the only way we can celebrate this, is to fast every monday like RasulAllah (SalAllahu 3alaihis Wasalaam) Did..Why? Just look for Cheikh Mohammed Said raslan (hafidahullah) about this topic.

[imsmarteven]

@RoadToJennah If the Prophet peace be upon Him himself celebrated it by fasting on mondays how is it a bidah than? dont distort Islam to your likings

[RoadToJennah]

@imsmarteven

Did you read my reply?

SubhanAllah,

THE ONLY WAY the prophet SalAllahu 3alaihis Wasalaam did 'celebrate' his Birthday, was by fasting, EVERY MONDAY! But if we fast, do we celebrate it? Or do we mourn? Because? Prophet Muhammed SalAllahu 3alaihis Wasalaam did also DIE on a monday!!! Do you get my point?

Every other way is a bid3a! Just watch the video I told you about before

[imsmarteven]

@RoadToJennah how in the world is fasting become mourning? The Prophet Peace be upon him wanted to signify that day by fasting, so as fasting is an Ibadah, similarly is expressing the praise of the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him in speeches and lectures, and saying poetry that has praise of the Prophet Peace be upon him, This is also Ibadah and Sunnah of the companions, now you call it mourning or celebrating, whatever you wanna call it, but this is all that is done in Mawlid Celebration.

[RoadToJennah]

@imsmarteven

SubhanAllah, READ MY REPLIES!!!

I only said, that if you celebrate, you need to mourn as well.. WHY? Because Prophet Mohammed (SalAllahu 3alaihis Wasalaam) DIED on a Monday!!

Yes, fasting is 3ibada! I know that, but that's not what I meant..

[RoadToJennah]

@imsmarteven

You know what?

You don't even understand, what i'm saying, so just do whatever you want, in Judgement day, we'll find out!

[imsmarteven]

@RoadToJennah The majority of the Muslim world in the whole history and even today understand what I have said, there is a small group of Muslims who says what you are saying, but anyway we'll find out insha Allah

[atif1030]

@imsmarteven basically if you wanna celebrate the birth of the prophet pbuh you should fast every monday, many muslims dont do this as its just easier to celebrate the birth of the Prophet pbuh annually. Monday was the day the Prophet pbuh was born, the Prophet pbuh or sahaaba didnt practice an annual celebration.

[1DON90]

@RoadToJennah its about the happiness we share on that day. on that day the Rahmatun lil aalameen came on earth. and we tell the people his life story and everything.

[RoadToJennah]

@1DON90

Happiness? Prophet Mohammed (SalAllahu 3alaihis Wasalaam) also died on a monday, so..

Telling stories about RasulAllah (SalAllahu 3alaihis Wasalaam) is never wrong, but why only (specific) on that day?

[1DON90]

@RoadToJennah you know that a martyr is alive according the Qur'an.he Prophet is alive also because he has bigger status than the shuhadaa',He left the world, we are not celebrating that. and why is it forbidden to celebrate that day? many ulamaa including jalaludding suyuti Rahimahullah approvedMawlid nabawi.In Qur'an is written Surah 10.Yunus Ayah.58. 'Say: in the bounty of Allah and his MERCY in that let hem rejoice.' and Prophet is MERCY to the worlds.Surah 21 ambiyaa. ayah107

[RoadToJennah]

@1DON90

Why? Because Prophet Muhammad (SalAllahu 3alaihis Wasalaam) never did it, said that birthday's aren't allowed to celebrate, so what do we call it? A Bid3a!

Bin Baaz (Rahimahullah) said it's a bid3a, Mohammed Said Raslan and many, many more! I don't want to be a know it all, I try to keep you from that which is Harmfull..

khair inchaAllah, just do what you want.. Following our Needs, that's what it is..

[1DON90]

@RoadToJennah Bin baaz was misguided my friend.the wahhabis broke the grave of sahaabah with bulldozers. thats enough. albani said that the green dome must be destroyed and the grave of holy prophet peace be upon him must be removed from Masjid nabawi. Ashtaghfirullah.

[RoadToJennah]

@1DON90

I'm not going to discuss any further, calling 3ulama these things :S

There's no such thing as a Wahabi, so .. keep it with you!

Destroying the Ummah by saying this things Astaghfirullah!!!!!!!!

Don't reply please, I'm done with you!

[1DON90]

@RoadToJennah ey follower of horn of shaytaan. your teachers and scholars say that there is no such thing as wahabi, because they want to misguid you and they say its forbidden to say Wahabi or something. destroying the wahabi sect you mean. the ummah is for the most sunni. they arent wahabi like u. wahabi go to sunni mosques to spread their wahabism and everything. like spies

[RoadToJennah]

@1DON90

Go preach this bull elsewhere

[1DON90]

@RoadToJennah Road to jehannam, shut up

[Reinabil]

@RoadToJennah

Bi'dah does'nt mean something bad.It just means something new.If you say Maulid is a Bid'ah, I agree with you but It's a GOOD Bid'ah.

Bid'ah comes in two forms, Good Bid'ah and Bad Bid'ah. Imam Syafie rhm said this.

There are many Mujtahid Scholars before us that said Maulid is allowed so it's best you don't condemn their words and learn to respect them.If you don't celebrate then it's ok, just keep it to yourself.

[RoadToJennah]

@Reinabil

A Bid3a means, that something is an innovation. An innovation is leading to hellfire. The hadith says something like? ''Every new matter is an innovation and every innovation is misguidance.” You say things like: Good and Bad Bid3a..

EVERY BID3A is bad, or didn't Islam came in a PERFECT way, in a PERFECT form? In every khutbah you hear the Hadith...

[Reinabil]

@RoadToJennah

That is what you understand from the hadith.Great Imams like Imam Syafie rhm, Imam Nawawi and Imam Ibnu hajar Asqalany all said Bid'ah is given in two forms.I am sure you are aware of the hadith where sayidina Umar r.a said "This is a Good Bid'ah." When they prayed tarawih under one Imam.I have many more proofs.If you say Bi'dah is bad in nature or in language then Sayidina Umar r.a would not have used that word to describe it.Simple as that.

[RoadToJennah]

@Reinabil

Narrated Aisha:

Allah's Apostle said, "If somebody innovates something which is not in harmony with the principles of our religion, that thing is rejected."

'A'isha reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying:

He who innovates things in our affairs for which there is no valid (reason) (commits sin) and these are to be rejected.

[Reinabil]

@RoadToJennah

The hadith states "ma laisa minhu",What ever that we are doing are not against the syariah.It doesnt go against the syariah.

[RoadToJennah]

@Reinabil

Okay..

But Mawlid an Nabi is against the Shariah, so .. these words has to been fit in the right place there.

[Reinabil]

@RoadToJennah

Bring me a hadith that says celebrating maulid is Against the Shariah.

[RoadToJennah]

@Reinabil

Show me the proofs :)

I like to learn. But I never hear about the things you say, so..

[MohiTal2e3]

People misunderstand the meaning of Bid'ah.

[MBS786]

I like to read 11 Qur'an ayahs everyday. Bid'ah?

I like to read subhanallah 3x every night before I go to sleep. Bid'ah?

I like watching videos of haram sharif on youtube. Bid'ah? But every ibadah needs proof - when did the prophet watch videos on youtube? Only quran and authentic sunnah plz.

One of us has to be wrong in our understanding. Have you stopped to consider it might be you?

[MBS786]

Remembering his life and expressing love for him is encouraged in Islam. That's what mawlid is. Why is it wrong? Where does it say you can't have a specific day to do it. An innovation is something that goes AGAINST the teachings of Islam. Mawlid doesn't. If it does prove it.

[MBS786]

Why do you insist on reading only 8 rakahs for tarwih when hazrat Umar ra read 20?

[MBS786]

Why do you follow Saudi when it comes to Eid?

--> Evidence from the Qur'an and Sunnah only please. No reply means it's a bid'ah for sure. Every bid'ah is in the fire, no?

[mrAsim7]

And Zakir Naik doesnt!!

[alithelin1234]

He wasnt a scholar may Allah forgive him for this mistake.

[imsmarteven]

@alithelin1234 o great! whoever say something contrary to ur opinion is not a scholar, feel pity for you

[alithelin1234]

@imsmarteven

No he was never a scholar, he was a da'ee not an aalim.

[imsmarteven]

@alithelin1234 how do you define da'ee

[alithelin1234]

@imsmarteven

someone who call to islam. 

[H4rryy]

@alithelin1234 oh please you salafi / wahbi people are the biggest threat to islam.

[alithelin1234]

@H4rryy

There is no such thing as a "Wahhabi" you are mocking Allahs name when you say that. And what is wrong with what I said? He wasn't a scholar, but was a caller to Islam... he himself said he was not a scholar.

[imsmarteven]

@alithelin1234 If he is not a scholar than what do you say about dr zakir naik?

[alithelin1234]

@imsmarteven

Zakir naik is a caller to islam not an aalim. He himself says it...

[imsmarteven]

@alithelin1234 yes I agree with this, but I don't think he consider himself as a caller to Islam only, because he keep giving his verdicts over many issues pertaining to the Islamic jurisprudence and beliefs.

[regul8n]

its bid3a to call it islam and make the mawlid as part of the religion, but to get together and remember our prophet on that day, that would not be regarded as bid3a

[tikkka1]

Everything is bud3a with you wahabis . You guys are called ahlal bud3a. Cant believe you are faceing ahmed deedat the man that has changed many muslims and non muslims lives , I bet you havent changed 1 persons life and you are challenging him ? . Dont quit your day job !

[megapad100]

@tikkka1 we shouldnt be calling each other wahabis e.t.c. we are promoting segragations, which the west loves, and started

[PigeonZ44]

Ever heard of bidaeat ulhasana? I'm appalled by the manners of this questioner, laughing and mocking style is a sign of lacking ilm ul aglaak. That the mawlid is a bidae is true, but so are many things, including the writing style, tajwiid and compilation of the Holy Quraan. A good bidaeat is allowed.

[muj143]

I REALY FEEL SORY FOR AHMED DEEDAT'S DEATH

AND DR ZAKIR NAIK GONA DIE MORE HORIBLE DEATH THEN SHAIKH AHMED DEEDAT.

DO YOU KNOW HOW HE DIED ,

[Mashluv]

What PROOF do the WAHAIS have on the inpermissibility of Milad Nabii.... if Maulid is haram, 3 types of Tawheed is also bid3ah, the prophet didnt say tawheed Rububiya, and 3ubudiyyah and so on..... these guys are stupid and have hatred......

[StrangerGHAREEB]

@Mashluv

Akhi Deen isn't a place for you and me to judge, and I'm just a new student of Ilm and all the saying of the Salaaf, and Hadith NEVER mentioned this, hence, we shouldn't not do something that against the Deen. Check other sheikhs[Zakir Naik I know he is his student, Abu Isaac Al heweny, Muhammad HAssan, Khalid Yasin, Imam Siraj Wahaj, etc...]

[StrangerGHAREEB]

The guy is right it's Biddah

[termilane]

@StrangerGHAREEB y are bid ah! everything y diong is bid ah, internet is bid ah!

[Dawah2Islam]

I am no longer part of this argument - too much homework, and yes im 14, and now I know ur next argument-

"Your too young to understand anything, I know this because my parents told me it"

Jahil.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam i knew my arguments against nadjis like yourself when i was your age so age means nothing here....there are old fools just like you too. See i don't mind differences but they annoy me when people like yourself shout your old 'bidah/shirk/kufr' mantra at anything you cannot comprehend. There were and still are jews just like guys too and we know what they did.....

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone stop calling me a najdi man, u probably don't even know what it is ur self. and Shaykh Muhammad Ibn Abdul-Wahab FOUGHT AGAINST THE EVIL IN NAJD, na3am there was great evil comming from an-najd. research it more b4 u start calling me one.

Im a bit like u, I don't mind people having differences in opinion either. So I don't mind a brother who says videos with faces are haram or halal, because there is a difference of opinion, I have a problem when the consensus of Scholars agree

[Dawah2Islam]

that something is Haram and then people go and say "we know better than such and such a Shaykh" and "we have such and such a proof" when really u don't have enough to back it up. Also I can comprehend the Mawlid. I've grown up in a society where it is celebrated, so yh, i understand why people do it.

But that still doesn't make it right, purely because there is no evidence for it.

I really don't like arguing, and yh i know where u were coming from, but no evidence- no ibadah.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam look, 'consensus of scholars' has no place here because that argument is false. The fact is that most muslims celebrate the mawlid...and it isn't limited to 'brelwis', even deobandis allow it deep down but they're stance is more based on their differences with brelwis. it's like when muslims do eid on diff days EVEN when they know the correct day, why? just to be different. This isn't good.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam but to answer you about ibn wahab, you can say whatever you like about his actions but i disagree with you. He was allied with the very people who created Saudi arabia, fought and killed their own brothers and allied with the british........in short, wahabism created israel. The Prophet SAW must have known this, that's why he refused to pray for Najd. There are many more hadith on this topic but that's for you to decide.

[Dawah2Islam]

I am waaaaaay to bussy to continue this argument,

-an Ibadah needs proof

-gathering to learn about the prophet sallahu 'alayhe wa salam is permissable as long as no "Islamic" conditions are put on it which arn't shown in the Qur'an and Sunnah

-if u hav no proof for doing an act of ibadah it becomes a bida'h

END OF. Wallahu 3alam.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam by it's very defenition ie commemorating a Prophet.......is an act of ibadah, it's in the Quran you tool.

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone apparently im now a hammer, and by commemorating, it doesn't give u a certain way to commemorate, all that commemorating is, is remembering a person. Khalas. If Allah wanted us to gather EACH YEAR on an EXACT DATE, He azawajal, or His Messenger Sallahu 'alayhe wa salam would have informed us.

And the Prophet Sallahu 'alayhe wa salam said:

"Do not raise me above my status like the Christians did"

-The Christians celebrate Christmas and even made it a national holiday.

Wallahu3alam

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam

you clown, the christians worship Jesus and call him GOD.....we don't so there's no comparison and furthermore i've already proven to you that 'Attending events' isn't even bidah. It's more your own explanation as to what that entails. No one said going to a gathering is FARD or even sunnah but is a 'praiseworthy' action, which means u get reward for it........which i can't disagree with. There's nothing wrong as long as it's done in a manner according to Shariah.

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone You think that the ONLY SIN Christians commit, u clown, u havn't prooven anything, when u "proove" something you back it up with "proof" - YOU HAVN'T ONCE REFERENCED QUR'AN OR SUNNAH.

IF U GET REWARD FROM IT, IT HAS TO BE SUNNAH OR FARD, Sunnah is just something that the prophet sallahu'alayhe wa salam said or did or told us to do. And just to finnish of, the Mawlid is not done according to the Shariah because ITS NOT IN THE SHARIAH.

Wallahu 3alam

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam HAHA IGNORANCE, The JEWS celebrated during Ashura.....the Prophet accepted it? why? it's because it was RIGHT TO DO IT. The Christians celebrate Xmas, islam rejects it, why? because its a pagan festival adopted by Xtians. What muslims do has nothing to do with that, the only connection is both claim to commemoerate the birth of a Prophet.......which is NOT HARTAM.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam you literalist morons are so flipping thick it's beyond me. The Shariah tells us what's halal, haram, questionable, in our actions for example. So if i was to attend an event and openly mix with women.......then it's against Shariah, but if i did it according to the rules of Shariah then i've done nothing wrong. Furthermore something can be Liked but not sunnah or fard. For example Taraveeh jamaat was neither, but it was done by the Sahaba in Jamaat all the time, why?

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam answer: because they understood islam and how it works, they weren;'t thick like you, they didn't take everything so literally. They knew that 'now it won't be taken as FARD so we can now do it because it's a GOOD INNOVATION' but they knew that a good innovation is according to Shariah, not opposed to it, so it is within Shariah that i can walk on the Street right now if i wanted to and hand out islamic leaflets or speak about the Prophet etc. It's all my choice.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam but i guarantee you some najdi tool like you would ask me 'where does it say in the Quran or KHHAAADITH that you can do it IN THIS WAY?' and that just means you're proper little textbook literalists who have no mind beyond what is written.

[imsmarteven]

skeptics watch this and just knock off the abysmal arguments

1/3: watch?v=ZKgFFEiCdp4

2/3: watch?v=Cj4u_Vxb7R0

3/3: watch?v=564KO4KGrsY

[molvicorleone]

the creation of seperate muslim nations and kingdoms is also Bidah then, since 'The Prophet SAW didn't do it'......in otherwords you're an idiot for thinking this way. bidah only concerns out religion and it's laws, if a women leads the Prayer, this is an example of Bidah, but creating muslim events for a good purpose isn't a bidah ie the ISNA event in N.America.

[molvicorleone]

official event in Saudi Arabia: The Saudi National Day.

That's right, they gather, they celebrate, the date of the creation of a kingdom, it's 'birthday; but when it comes to the Prophet himself, the same Saudi najdis cry 'bidah' 'kufr'.

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone Celebrate the prophets birthday is an act of 'worship' which is why its an innovation EVERYTHING THATS AN IBADAH thats not none by the sahabah or prophet sallahu 'alayhe wa salam is an INNOVATION:

Wa sharul or ummuri muduhaduha "wa kula bid'adin zalalah, wa kula zalalah tul fin naar"

AND EVERY INNOVATION IS A GOING ASTRAY, AND EVERY GOING ASTRAY IS IN THE FIRE.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam no one has declared it a religious obligation........but tell me, is going to school to learn, a religious obligation? an act of jihad? Yes? but apparently attending a gathering where people display their love for the Prophet, talk about his birth and life etc, to you is WRONG? that just shows me that you're a literalist who has no understanding.

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone Ibadah doesn't have to be a relgious 'obligation', a Sunnah action like the 2 sunnah before Fajr is compulsory but is an Ibadah. If we didn't have proof that the prophet Sallahu 'alayhe wa salam or one of the companions did it, then it would be an innovation. But we have proof and it is a Sunnah.

The birthday has no proof what so ever and is an ibadah because it is to do with the deen and earning good deeds, but no evidence is given so it becomes an innovation.

Wallahu 3alam.

[Dawah2Islam]

@Dawah2Islam "the 2 sunnah before Fajr is compulsory" - I meant isn't

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam any good act is an act of worship and attending this event is a good act. You cannot prove that wrong, you can only repeat 'bidah' which again smacks of your ignorant literalist, blind, parrotted, dogmatic views you've borrowed from your najdi masters.....hypocritical because i don't see anyone condemn muslims for celebrating the creation of pakistan, or the kingdom of saudi arabia etc but you're angry when it's done to remember the Prophet SAW.

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone Laa, an example of a good thing that is an ibadah is saying a certain dua before entering the toilet, we have proof for this, saying bismillah before eating we have proof for, and they are within the religion, meaning from them you gain rewards and blessing and you are 'trying to please Allah'.

When you attend a gathering to commemorate the birthday of the prophet sallahu 'alayhe wa salam, you are 'trying to please Allah' but there is no proof for it and therefore it is rejected

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam so if you decided to save someone from a fire, it isn't an act of 'ibadah' because it wasn't literally mentioned in the islamic texts? It seems you're more concerned about the literal interpretation of islamic rules and have forgotten the spirit of islam for which the laws were created for. A good act is a good act and brings you towards inner purity, attending a gathering where the Birth of the Prophet is commemorated is a good act. end of.

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone tell me, how do u save sum1 from the fire?, if it is your parents you can preform ibdadah on their behalf, if you are giving Dawah this is also an Ibadah, of course saving sum1 from the fire is from Islamic texts as the prophet sallahu 'alayhe wa salam said spread even one word Islaam you have learnt from me, when u are telling people about Islaam you are trying to save them from the fire and this too becomes an Ibadah.

Back urself up with evidence. end of.

Wallahu 3alam.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam If we simplify your views then you're basically attacking muslims for 'gathering for a good purpose' under the guise of 'bidah' but when you're refuted you argue 'it's because you've made it an act of ibadah', yet we (the majority ie ahle-sunnat) don't claim it as 'obligatory' but rather, as 'a praiseworthy action' so you're point is very weak. A good act is a good act, end of. An ex. of bidah=women leading the Salah...but 'doing a good act' cannot be bidah.

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone 'majority of ahle-sunnat' I AM TIRED OF 'AHLUL-BIDD'AH CLAIMING TO FOLLOW THE SUNNAH

troughout the whole conversation, NOT ONCE have you referenced the Qur'an or the Sunnah, you are following ur desires instead of reading what He and His Messenger have said. How can I trust you without any proof?

furthermore IBADAH DOESN'T HAVE TO BE OBLIGATORY, A SUNNAH RAKKAH IS NOT OBLIGATORY BUT IS STILL AN IBADAH.

The kufar say that killing innocents in afagan is a good act, just because

[Dawah2Islam]

u call it a good act, its DOESN'T MAKE IT A GOOD ACT, everything in caps is just so you READ IT CAREFULLY.

Wallahu 3alam.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam can you explain to me then, how gathering in a mosque and talking about the Prophet is a bad act then? show me in what way it's against Shariah please, because clearly you are an expert here.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam then why is it practiced in Africa, the balkans, turkey and throughout asia? are they all 'brelvis'? you need to get out and see the world and learn more about your religion. a good act is a good act, gathering in droves to praise the Prophet of Islam doesn't need literal justification, you don't need to pinpoint an ayat stating 'you must do this in such and such way'. The quran teaches us right from wrong and it tells us to 'commemorate the days of Allah'.....

[AL15L4M]

Salam

Please Can I Have The Permmision To Re-Upload This Video To My Profile, InshaAllah. I Would Love For The Wahabis And Dr Zakir Naik Followers And Peace TV Viewers To See This

JazakAllah For The Video

[imsmarteven]

@AL15L4M wasalam, :) sure u can

[AL15L4M]

@imsmarteven JazakAllah

[immyovuk]

@AL15L4M AS. why are you being disrespectful towards your orthodox muslim brothers? the great Ahmed deedat may have done milad he was an scholar in comparative religion not in aqeedah and fiqh. No sahabah, tabiun, tabi tabiun did it. Non of the 4 imams did it. It is a bid;ah. everyone after the prophet saws was prone to human error, and i have made many more. We have to stick to the quran and the way of the holy prophet and his rightly guided khalifa. They who loved him most never celebrated it!

[AL15L4M]

@immyovuk Salafis/Wahabis Are Not Orthodox

[saira5868]

@AL15L4M

Who are you to judge anyone??

[Dawah2Islam]

@AL15L4M get a dictionary(smile)

[muslimallday]

@AL15L4M why theres no proof in this vid . all he does is laugh and say no no no no hadith no quran nothing just nafs. and whats a wahabi? what does it mean? no one calls themselve wahhabi?

[muslimallday]

@AL15L4M 

[muslimallday]

@AL15L4M all he says is leave it to Allah and he laughs and says no no no. He doesnt bring no evidence Mawlid is bida . and theres no such person called wahhabi?

[Dawah2Islam]

@AL15L4M Wahabi-ism doesn't exsist, its a myth and there isn't a person on this Earth who says I am Wahabi, plus this shows the brothers ignorance with regards to the deen, as the prophet Sallahu 'alayhe wa salam, NEVER told ANY of the Sahabah to celebrate his birthday, and he didn't with his own, and this innovation came after the salaf, who were the 1st three generation of Muslims, and the prophet Sallahu 'alayhe wa salam said that they are the best of nations.

[AL15L4M]

@Dawah2Islam I Know People Who Call Themselves Wahabi And You Answer Me This Did The Prophet SAW Forbid Anyone Celebrating Births..? And When A Child Is Born A Aqeeqa Is Done Even By Salafis, Isnt That Celebrating Birthday. Fridays Are A Special Day To Us Why..? It Was The Birth Of Adam AS And Also Read Below The Comments About The Prophet SAW Fasting On Mondays And The Birth Of Isa As.

[Dawah2Islam]

@AL15L4M Answer me this then Akhi, do u think celebrating the Mawlid is a Khayr? A good thing? How is it possible the prophet Muhammad Sallahu 'alayhe wa salam didn't inform us about this "good thing", and how comes the Sahabah didn't ever celebrate it, and nor did the Tabi'een and nor did the Tabi Tabi'een, and the prophet sallahu 'alayhe wa salam mensioned them as the best of all nations and not a single one of the Muslims celebrated the Mawlid, it is a clear innovation.

-Classic Al Abani

[Dawah2Islam]

with regards to friday, this is also when Allah has prescribed the end of the world, it is both the first and last day on earth for all of the Humans, it isn't a matter of the birthday, the aqiqah isn't a celebration. Having a party on the day of the birth or on the 7th day isn't A sunnah, rather, you salughter an animal for the child, how on earth is that celebrating? Wallahu 3alam, my baby brother was born and Wallahi It was a random party,

Birthday = Bid'ah tul Jahilliyah

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam well the Jews celebrated passover on the 10th of Muharram (i think) and the Prophet SAW upon witnessing the Jews celebrate that event, decided to also celebrate it because 'Moses is nearer to us than them'. This does show that good events in islamic history are certainly remembered. The Prophet SAW also fasted on Mondays because he was born on that day. Furthermore, the event is just that, an event, a gathering etc, it isn't a prescribed FESTIVAL since we have 2 Ids for that.

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone gathering? when did the companions 'gather' on this certain date? they didn't, birthdays are not from Islam, especially the way they are celebrated now, as you said we have 2 'Eids for that and there is a hadith to back that, I wish you to bring me proof that the companions or the prophet sallahu 'alayhe wa salam specificially gathered on that exact date + we don't even know the exact date.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam

people celebrate the independence or creation of their country, muslims do this all the time. They attend annual meetings, gathering for all kinds of events and you Literalist Najdis say nothing but when muslims gather to remember the Prophet, you call it innovation. You hypocrites.

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone I am not a Najdi, so don't call me one, and the ruling on ANY type of Ibadah is that if we havn't seen it done specifically by either the prophet Sallahu 'alayhe wa salam or one of the companions(because they were in direct contact with the prophet sallahu 'alayhe wa salam) then it is Haram and it is an innovation in Islaam. As you probably know the Ayah of Allah saying that this day His religion is perfect, if it is perfect then no new "IBADAH" can be done. Wallahu 3alam.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam either way you're a literalist who can't get this simply concept through his head. It's irrelevant whether the sahabas did it, simply because the Sahabas didn't gather for the ISNA event they hold in America too.....but does that mean the Isna event is haram/bidah OR is it just a gathering of muslims for a specific purpose? in other words if muslims chose to gather on an event to commemorate a good event ie 'the blessed birth and life of the Prophet' then it is a good event.

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam and we don't even consider it a religious obligation, it's basically something people are encouraged to attend due to it's significance especially given the world today. FACT Kafirs are openly hating the Prophet more than anyone today, FACT a lot of muslims are totally against this event and even killed muslims due to their silly anger ie Karachi bombings on the day of the event where people died.

So real sunnis choose to demonstrate their purpose further to show unity.

[Dawah2Islam]

@molvicorleone ha ha ha, in that sense im a paki, yes my family are ALL from Pakistan. Wallahi I know the innovations that go on over there, Iv been there a million times, I live with Pakistani's! Well-done the kafir hate the prophet sallahu 'alayhe wa salam more than us.

A TRUE Sunni would NEVER celebrate it because it means someone who follows the Sunnah and it is NOT FOUND IN THE SUNNAH so a SUNNI will never do it!

[molvicorleone]

@Dawah2Islam besides you're wrong anyway. The Quran itself instructs us to 'commemorate' the lives of Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Ismail etc..........Yet when sunnis commemorate the birth of the Prophet and his life, people like you cry about it, are you stupid? Also, for the record, the Majority of muslims ie proper sunnis take part in this event throughout the muslim world, from East to West. It isn't limited to 'pakis' either but i know you probably assume that.

[MissConceptions1]

@AL15L4M Assalam-u-Alaikum.. also the Hadith Rejectors who falsely claim that Ahmed Deedat (ra) was a Quranist!

[2jkraj]

so sikk of hearing the word bida'ah bida'ah is that the onli word you people knw??

[BosnaIslamBoston]

It is very easy to attack someone saying BIDA^(meaning bad inovation). My brothers, open our Holly book and ask yourselves: Are the vowels in Qur’an as in the time of our beloved Muhammed saws??? Would you then agree that Qur’an with the vowels is BIDA^-bad innovation???

Yes, it is BIDA^, but good BIDA^ which helps me as nonarab to read Qur’an correctly.

[waqasahmedamin]

Evidence for celebrating the Prophet's birthday from Hadith:

Abū Qatāda al-Anṣārī narrates that Allahs Apostle was asked about the fasts on Monday to which he replied: That is the DAY IN WHICH I WAS BORN, and the day in which I was raised [as a prophet].

Muslim, aṣ-Ṣaḥīḥ, 2:819 (Kitāb aṣ-Ṣiyām, Bāb: Istiḥbāb ṣiyām thalātha ayyām min kulli shahr) #1162;

Nisāī, as-Sunan al-Kubrā, 2:146, #2777

Aḥmed bin Ḥanbal, al-Musnad, 5:296, #22590

[basitkhansanabili]

@waqasahmedamin If Prophet (PBUH) asked to fast on Monday because of His birth.Then why u don't celebrate Prophet's birthday on every Monday. Prophet (PBUH) asked to fast on Monday not one day in a year .Follow Sunna . My Barelvi Brothesrs!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[imsmarteven]

@basitkhansanabili yes we celebrate every monday, there are many people who fast on every monday, .. and this hadith mentioned by bro waqasahmedamin is enough to declare that there is noting wrong in celebrating Prophet Muhammad Sal Allah u Alaehe wasallam's birthday because he himself did that, now how can anybody call it biddat e saeah ??? .. do u have any answer???

[MrGrandDragon]

@imsmarteven

To celebrate in the sense of giving shukr, by doing an act of humility such as fasting and NOT jumping and marching on the streets, raising insults to those who don't follow them whilst waving Pakistani flags like they do in Blackburn.

There are extremes on both sides, the IndoPak region has been fighting over this small issue for almost a hundred years.

[waqasahmedamin]

Evidence for celebrating birthdays in the Quran: the Birthday of Jesus:

Peace be upon him [i.e. John, Yaḥyā] on the day he was born, the day he will die, and the day he will be raised up alive. (Maryam 19:15)

[Jesus, son of Mary, (ʿĪsā) said:] Peace be upon me on the day I was born, the day that I will die, and the die that I will be raised up alive. (Maryam 19:33)