Harpers Island Theories 2

[biAnCAFaLlEnHuSh]

i feel sad for trish, she loved henry... but he was just using her the whole time.

[TobiWobi7]

you are so damn right!!! henry being the murderer is the worst possible oportunity...

its just ILLEGITIMATE.

He turned out being evil just out of nowhere and it doesent even fit with the previous stroy...-.-

[bloodyprince126]

@TobiWobi7 he lived on the island..

[666CaoCao]

I liked Trish she was firery, Madison was soo creepy I felt Chills every time she appeared. The best non violent scene was when Chloe set up the guy who gave his wife the ring meant for her.

[001FredRox100]

Cal and Chloe were my favorite, but seriously "ok Chloe lets run across this bridge where theres a dead end!" they had a chance to run away into the woods and possibly be on of the survivors!

[CatGreenRiver]

This little girl - is she crazy or stupid??? Or she wanted to help kill all of them with her lies about "who took her"???

He said, it was only a play for Abbey, great. And if he will give her a gun to play?

Poor Abbey, poor Chloe and Cal. I think, Chloe could run, but she choose to stay...

[SuperSm4ever]

it was soooo sad when cal and chloe died :'( I cried soooooo much! :'(

[heizgoth]

is this a Slasher tv series? my friend told me abo0ut it and im plannin on getting it on dvd.

[Tikkariheppu3]

Fuck why shane died

[Tilly199418]

cal and chlos death was the saddest ;(

so emotional

but the murders are awwesome

[manimomo87]

Agreed. Cal and Chloe's deaths made me cry so much.

[Georgiag94]

Wish it wasnt overr it was sooooo good.

[19gord]

i was sad when trish got killed :(

[dantunes112]

i cant see if wakefield dies? does he?

send me the link of the video

[spamtye]

yes he does it turns out henry is wakefields son and he dies

[spaZxx157]

uum wait...

is this show coming back in general?

or..

was that whole 2 hour episode the series finale!?

does anyone know what im saying..?q:

[djkonix69]

the 2 hour episode was the finale as it tied up all loose ends

[HarpersIslandFan1]

I have a question..? Where did you get the opening to Harer's Island.

0:00 to 0:38

[djkonix69]

first episode

[HarpersIslandFan1]

No like where did you find it?

[AnimalCircle]

Like Why Did Henry Kill Them all? And How Did They Get Back To The Island? The Wedding? And How did they get there 7years ago. D;

i Ddint watch like 5Episodes of it d:

[HarpersIslandFan1]

Well Henry killed them becuase John Wakefield is Henrys Dad.

They got back to the island on boats cuz of the wedding for Trish and Henry.

Abbey lived in Harper's Island when she was little.

Does that help you?

[CraigBass1988]

And Abbey and Henry are half brother and sister too! And Henrys "parents" weren't his real ones.

[twilighter047]

loved this show. all eps are on my ipod :) i guessed it was henry 4 eps in. ah yeah, im that level of good. jimmy, cal, danny and henry are...BABES! :) just sayin.

[koolkidaustin]

Madison costed alot of lives...

She should go to jail.

[JayCutlerOWNSy0utube]

I cant believe Henry put it in her butt

[cutiehmn]

wheere did u guys see the last episode???

[FledByFlight]

It airs two days before in Canada.

[TheBrushy10]

is it me or is madison the biggest creeper in the world !?!

[XxxmrsjeffhardyxxX]

He dosn't shoot him he stabs him. Really he did it because he chose abby over his father. His father said in order to be complete you have to kill the one you love and henry said he wasn't like his father. And he cose abby over his dad. But abby did not want henry. And it shocked my because henry said she didnt have it in her to kill but yet she killed him. For god sakes Henry was her brother and still she killed him. That kind of made me mad

[LovingWhoIReallyAm]

but gosh henry killed just about everyone!

[dynamitegrlz]

She didn't really do it on purpose.

[spockatier]

Why the hell did cousin Ben died, that wasnt explained. It was awesome to see Abby kill Henry. I am still sad that he had to die. The writers should make like that he fell in the cave and survived at the end. And that videotape. Henry should say. Trish If you are watching this, that means that i have failed. I have never loved you, wanted to kill you for a long time. The truth is that I love Abby. Anyway I hope that I see all of you soon and the evil look that would be scary.

[terysat]

umm... yeah I love the show and all... but if henry were still alive that would be the stupidest thing ever... I was just expecting everyone to die. I thought that that wouldve been a better ending. :D

[Dguy95]

HENRY IS A PSYCHO KILLER

[XxxmrsjeffhardyxxX]

Alot of people are saying that Henry is the killer but it makes no sense because wakefield shot him. Why would he shoot someone he was working with?

[seansilveiro13]

it is henry just finished watchin ........viva Montreal. i quess he shot him just for clearence to prove he wasnt working with him

[cherrymuffinlove]

I think it's Jimmy. Madison is incapable to take down grown men. That would be fairly unrealistic and ridiculous. The only thing Madison is guilthy of is being creepy and super weird, and also possible the reason to Abby's dad's murder. I hated her at that moment.

[SockRocker967]

its not danny.. its jimmy o.o

[rockingreject]

Does anyone else think that little girl is really creepy?

[SurfOrDieForever]

yes!!!

[nothingspecial1997]

i was so upset that cal died he was like my fave character sept 4 J.D and jimmy i throught he would escape :-(

[lallnivek]

first of all i think henry is wakefields son, and we know john wakefield was firing the rifle but did u guys notice at 2:53-2:55

henry looks back and everyone else running to save there ass....and remember when henry wrote a letter pretending to be hunter to trish, The H was thee same thing on a letter the killer left behind for the sheriff

[Ahlesha1017]

good observation. i think the samme tooo!

[wegersfour]

Someone has to be extremely strong, to

tie the first victim under the boat. All

of the suspects were also some of the

killer's victims. I'm sure, there will be

a twist on this show. I have already

pre-ordered this show when it comes

out on DVD. I can't wait to see it again,

to see what I missed, like little clues to

who is the real accomplice to John Wake-

field.

[Ahlesha1017]

THE KILLER IS HENRY!

because first of all i think hes wakefeild chld because it never sed anything bout his parents, wen lucy died the matches were from ther candlewick inn, and some one had to be on the boat before they went to harpers island tht was the 2nd killer. besides shea and trish arent from the island how can they be wakefeilds children!?

[88Featured]

To Ahlesha, neither was Henry, he and J.C only came to the island in summer. They're not from the island. and Henry doesn't own the candlewick inn

[Ahlesha1017]

henry is from the island!

and henry could have got the matches from the candlewick cause he was staying there. but jimmy couldnt.

[88Featured]

He's not. That's why Shane hated J.D, because he wasn't a local, but he tolerated Henry because he was good friends with Abby. They only came to the island during summer.

And a majority of the guests were staying at the inn.

[Ahlesha1017]

who'd he come to the island w/ over the summmer?

[88Featured]

J.D. Anyway, my point is that he's not from the island

[Ahlesha1017]

w/e.

then how did abby & henry meet?

there like best friends.

[88Featured]

Well, Abby was a local, they prolly met when he would come over.

Does it really matter? Henry's not from the island.

[Ahlesha1017]

well then who is wakefeild's son ?

it had to be someone from the island.

[Improft101]

ya i think its henery. hes the onlyone with no alibi.

[kwizkid1]

Jimmy is and Henry had a brother J.D. remember? But yea it could be Henry for sum weird reason we will find out juily 11th

[lallnivek]

ahlesha1017 i think shea and trish grew up on the island because remember in the first episode someone told henry that he used to was boats for the wellingtons and now he is marrying a wellington

[Ahlesha1017]

oh, i mean like a recent episode trish saw a pictue of wakefeild and said " is this him"?

i woulda thought she woulda known?

maybe?

i dont know?!

i didnt think that they did.

i just thought they met after henry left the island.

but i guess what you sed is true!!!

[savieandkay]

Well, I do doubt that Trish is Wakefield's kid, but if she was, do you really think she would've pointed at the photo and said "Oh look there's my daddy!'

[Ahlesha1017]

that doesnt even make sense.

i didnt say it was trish?

[88Featured]

I don't know who's wakefield kid, But i can't be bothered speculating with the finale so close. I have three people in mind for the second killer: Trish, Henry and Danny.

I hope it's not Henry because everyone thinks it's him. i want it to be a big surprise.

[Ahlesha1017]

yeah, true.

this script was like brillintly written.

[88Featured]

The script is a bit corny at times, but the story is so friggin suspenseful, I'm like dying for the finale

[cherrymuffinlove]

Not if she's hiding it she wouldn't. She wouldn't say for that particular reason. Just think about it for a sec.

[xOxLiKeOmGxOx]

The gun was aimed at Trish for a second and then moved to Henry.. hmm..

[88Featured]

I've been suspicious of Trish for a while, not as the second killer but as to why wakefield doesn't kill her.

He had a chance when he cornered her in the bathroom, and when she was drowning in the pool, it's suspicious as to why that was the only failed murder attempt when wakefield was in hiding.

[djkonix69]

trishs failed murder was a richard thing cos ti said her killer was also her saviour..i think he was trying to scare her into not saying anything.

And jimmy delivered seafood to the candlewick inn so he could have easily got matches..but alas it cant be jimmy anymore, they wont twist it that way

[88Featured]

The Psychic said that the person who betrayed her family was also her saviour, not the killer.

Wow, I just realised how closely I pay attention to this show

[sheldon805]

the top 3 suspects... 1. henry 2. sully 3. booth

henry= he had all kinds of chances of being killed but he didnt.

sully= when wakefield was shooting after the docks exploed, he had a chance to snipe sully but didnt.

booth= he might have not died

[himrockerchic]

i think it might be henry...

but then i also think it might be booth....

and if it is jimmy why would abby's father tell her if she ends this she and jimmy could have a real if??? he would have never said that if he new jimmy was dangerous....

but then i also like that whole shea thing too guess i'll just have to wait and see..

[Hammotastic]

The fact that the people who are left are the people who are in the wedding:

Henry: The Groom

Trish: The Bride

Sully: The Best Man

Shea: The maid of Honor

Madison: The Flower Girl.

...suspiscious?

I think Wakefield is Shea or Trish's Dad, and that Shea or Trish is the other killer, and we find out Wellington was killed because of that.

[zodythekuraikodomo13]

it hink it is trish or maybe madison cause she found the jimmy stuff

[mikeyfresh758]

I think it is Shea and Madison working together with Wakefield. Whenever anyone tries to talk about the murders to her or Madison, Shea gets all uptight like she has sand up her vagina. It's kinda obvious to me.

[ubersamtron]

she gets uptight because her daughter was missing and almost died and people are dying all over the place. she already lose her dad, husband, and step mom. she doesn't want to lose her daughter

[dcbriteyes]

My moneys on Wakefield being the only murderer but framing ppl to create a divide b/c. When ppl thought it was Henry's brother they turned on him he's dead. When everyone thought it was the sheriff they turned on Abby and the sheriff, sheriff's dead and abby alomost ended up dead. So now that Wakefield has set it up so Jimmy looks suspect, I bet ppl will turn on him and Jimmy's gonna go next. Also I find it a little strange that Wakefield had chance after chance to kill Henry but didn't.

[zodythekuraikodomo13]

that could be and i believe Henry has something to do with it all

[ubersamtron]

i think this is a really good theory

[SNEEBLoo]

who here thinks Madison will be killed? I think her and (for some reason) Sulley will be the only ones that live.

I think Danny will kill himself from the stress, if you notice, hes going a funny...

[CheerXXOGirlies23]

Henry always holds Abby back.

Like when Jimmy was in the fire.

I think that's because he knows Wakefield is in there getting Jimmy

for the whole trade with Abby's dad.

[ubersamtron]

henry held abby back so she wouldn't throw herself in the fire and therefore kill herself

[CheerXXOGirlies23]

yeahh, i just figured out that. Haha, like when Chloe was on the bridge, she didn't realize the mountain was there so she almost fell, and everyone thought that he pulled her back because JW and Chloe were there.

[4jkx]

i think that its henry that is the killer, along wiht wakefield. also jimmy looks like henry(brothers maybe?) and the two of them always seem so friendly toward eachother, as if they know whgat to do, and when wakefield comes by, henrys always so brave. wakefield ran when henry came, instead of killing him and abby along with the others that came too. maybe hes afraid to hurt him.

[4jkx]

actually, i think it may be Sully whos wakefields kid. he resembles him, and wanted chloe to himself, and cal then got shot. wakefield just taunted chloe on the brige, but he looked suprised when she jumped. he locked her in some place underground, maybe wakefield was keeping her there for sully, so that she wouldnt get in the way of the killings, but she died. Sully was also in Seatle when the uncle died

[zodythekuraikodomo13]

wasnt sully born somewhere else tho

[4jkx]

i dont know. but he was on the boat in seatle in the first episode.

[zodythekuraikodomo13]

yeah tu\rue but i think teh killer was someone who was on the boat

[max170185]

it' s jimmy also because he makes the others guy belive that he was dead during the explosion at the marina, meanwhile he went to the other side of the Island and hides the other boat...

[vijaya78]

actually it was henry who sent jimmy to the boat which was going to explode

[Stileseey]

It's Jimmy. He had motive, intent and in one of the earlier episodes when the old man asked him to look under the boat (the same boat that Henry's cousin Ben was tied to the rudder of) he missed his corpse and only picked up sea weed. Plus there are a lot more hints like the cuts on his hands and why was he was the only one of wakefields victims to survive? And how did he escape from the cannery? And Chloe and Cal died where Abbey and him used to camp. Too much coincidence for me.

[spockatier]

Trish will die to save Henry. That blonde dude, whats his name, will die to save Madison, that black dude to. In the end it will be Henry, Abby and Jimmy, Wakefield. Henry will kill Jimmy and Wakefield will revail shocking secret. Why he went on the island in first place. And then he will burn. Look episode 2 final clips 3 final scenes.

[spockatier]

What are you writing people. That is just a bull of crap. Henry is not a killer, he is Abbys friend from childhood. And he would suppose to marry on the island. So yeah, henrys out. Jimmy. Booth, Cousin Ben. These are the prime suspects to be wakefields child. There will pe 4 deaths in episode 12. The last scene will be Henry and Abby five years later in LA. Believe it

[JayCutlerOWNSy0utube]

lol.. you were wrong.. Fucking pwnage.

[djkonix69]

my top three are 1. Henry 2, Jimmy and 3. Booth

[DracoBabe88]

I'm confused didn't booth die because he shot himself in the leg and bleed to death?!?...

[bklyngalNY]

I can't wait till these Jimmy is the killer people are proven wrong. Which they will be, since they reveal the real killer on Episode 13. Henry or Sully will be Wakefield's child.

[circa1394]

What if jimmy is wakefields son,

[amandama86]

It is so Henry. Wakefield is Henry's dad. That is why Abby and Henry are so clues b/c Henry knows they are siblings. That is what I think!

[bklyngalNY]

That thought comes to mind, why he lurks over Abby and ripped into Shane about his remarks about the child of the devil.

He ignored Trish's question about the scars on his hand. Didn't show emotion over JD killed.

[tyminush]

but in one of em first episodes, when someone asked, abby admitted they sort of flirted at some stage yeah?

[jasmeetsidhu1234]

who is the killer??? Wakefield is the only killer!

[bubblerelie]

One thing is runing in my mind... before getting hung the sherriff said something like if Wakefield was killing them one by one with their love... what about if Wakefield is making, by hints and pressure, secrets coming out so adding to him killing people, the wedding crew are killing each other thinking it's gonna pass on the killer's fault anyway... maybe it's stupid but everyone can be a suspect to someone else death!

[resgirly4VA]

IF the other killer is John Wakefields child, there's no way CBS, I don't think, would allow even kissing between half siblings. Henry left JD alone while he was dying, even if Henry's not the mass killer, I think he killed JD for Trish. The fact that the shooter allowed Niki to get into the bar also is suggestive.  Because of Henry's behavior while JD was dying, beyond bizarre? I think it's pretty implausible that there's a 3rd Wakefield roaming, unless Abby's mom aborted. Henry or Niki?

[BookWorm5510]

At first when it started I thought it was shane, but then he got arrested for trying to hang one of my favorite characters, JD. Now I think it's Jimmy. I think he is working with Wakefeild (well duh we know its wakefeild now). When they took Madison they were told if they left Madison would die- and Jimmy dosen't want Abby to leave him again.

a few other things: I LOVE THIS SHOW! Cal is the BEST! (Cal is the british guy's name, right?) I can't believe he got show but he LIVED! (i think)

[jasmeetsidhu1234]

jimmy is not the killer or the son of wakefield

[oOpengusruleOo]

I think Jimmy isn't the killer BUT i think he is Wakefield's child and Abby isn't then that wouldn't make them related and CBS would allow that.

[jasmeetsidhu1234]

he is not Wakefield's child either i think it is Henry

[tyminush]

they still would have the same mom (wakefield had an affair with abby's mom and had that child) which makes em half-sibblings

[brontes88]

He is the killer. Did you watch the whole preview. Did you see how Jimmy looked at everyone else while he was hugging Abby at the end. Henry was going to shoot him. Jimmy is probably holing a grudge against Abby. I think he is the killer.

[xClubPenguinVidsx]

first i thought Nikki was the killer, then i thought it was Jimmy and we was just pretending to be dead, then its just John Wakefield darn it

[jelly425]

im fuckin pissed becuase john wakefield is a killer and the whole time hes been "dead" but not only that their advertising that there might be two killers WTF it even says on cbs '13 weeks 25 suspects ONE killer' i cant believe they werent creative enough to make one of the 25 suspects the one and only killer

anyways i also thought it was wierd that wakefield didnt shoot trish but tried to shoot henry thats gotta say something wierd about henry

[brontes88]

So now we know that Maggie and Sheriff are dead. We also know that John Wakefield is alive and that he has been killing people, but in the preview it said that 1 killer was revealed, but that there was another and why would Wakefield keep Jimmy alive? Because Jimmy is the killer.I t was all an act. In the preview, Madison and Shea found pictures of Jimmy in jail and at the end of the preview, they showed Abby hugging Jimmy and Jimmy had an evil look on his face and everyone told Abby No get away

[jasmeetsidhu1234]

kkk, the reason the sheriff had a picture of Jimmy in jail bc if u look back in episode 5 when jimmy, abby the sherfiff were talking at the resturetent in the morning and Abby said to her dad you put jimmy in jail for a hour that night bc he was on wellingtons boat and stealing his beer? go back and watch that episode again kkk! that is why he has a picture of Jimmy bc wanted to know if he was good for Abby and he is good for Abby! he is not the killer at all!

[youtuguru]

I think it's Shea. Remember how Katherine died? Stabbed in the back. The same episode that Richard died was when Shea found out his husband was cheating.

Plus, what are the odds, in all honesty, of Shea randomly seeing her daughter's hand reaching out from a sewer grate... unless she was checking to see if anyone was getting out?

[jasmeetsidhu1234]

i also think it might be shea too but why will she let her daughter get kidnapped?? it does look wierd when katherina was killed but Shea was near the truck and outside i dont think it is shea i think it is her daughter MADISON helpin the killer

[hsr89]

stop on the frame showing the sniper's hands....don't they look like a woman's?

[angelprnss]

omg ur right! the person has nails!

[gotrb314]

ok man heres how i see it, henry wants to save lives, and the sniper even hit him while sooting into the crowd, but the sniper could have killed henry if he wanted to, he easily hit cal behind the car, i have that feeling that cal is going to be saved by sully or made stable and just after that my fav character sully is going to die, the jury is out on the killer right now tho,

[angelprnss]

i dont want sully to die.