The pussycat dolls when i grow up live las vegas 24th may 08

[Pinkstar4life]

So they really arn't without Nicole they have a pre-recorded track in the background with NICOLE singing so yeah they are still singing with her............ they know they can't do it without her, especially the high note at 2:16 FAIL!!!!!!

[Nicole90696]

err...WTF?! They are nothing without Nicole.She is the only one!

[CCreativeful]

Actually ppl nicole may be a good singer, but melody is the best of them , i think it's proven with the word domination tour,,,WOW melody have pipes:P

[DanielFuscoMusic]

See they were ACTUALLY singing live in this. Maybe they sound good cause they didnt have to dance. but still why have them even have mics when they dont get to sing. only Melody and Jessica. And in this performance they all had their mics on. and sounded FINE. sooo... idk.

[Bradstuart777]

they r noting without fabulous NICOLE!

[tcptcp123]

lolsx look at robin. just bouncin up and down

[da69erboi]

they sound good live. so why keep them lypsincing?!

[DanielFuscoMusic]

I fell like this performance the girls have like alot more energy, maybe it's because they know they can do what they want in this performance without having to be behind Nicole.

[mehmechielikduh]

They don't need nichole pleas

[budakpondan]

dont blame nicole...they just follow what the writer song ask...

[DanielFuscoMusic]

@budakpondan No, it's not up to the writer, it's up to the executive roles in their record label that control the group and who sings, ohh and it just happens to be that Nicole is 3rd in charge of PCD's management, so if she doesn't want to be the only girl singing really, than why doesn't she change that, cuz she has ALOT of poer in the group to do so.

[manulasat]

May nik name best friends smale heppy lol party pies love heart tu you smale beautiful baby.

love tu you, love pies love Rihanna

[beboy12003]

It's great performance. it sounds different with Melody singing in the lead posititon. This is something that should be done on PCD's 3rd album.

[wythorugo]

nicole was out, melody is leading

[mimi0babe]

wheres nicole??

[Natasss1994]

it's pcd i see kimberly and jessica and robin antin

and melody sings

[rihannarocks6]

not pcd

[AmiAmiAmiZ]

oh lil sis it is PCD

[2009MINORITY]

Team Melody!! Go search Melody singing the first verse of Buttons live in Indonesia, here on Youtube.

[marcus30291]

melody!!! xxx

[Salomeetje]

they don't need nicole, they do better without her =). Go mel!

[majornbbfan180]

nicole isnt even there?? caz that extra girl isnt her!

[Ladyfaux]

its an ok remix but i like the normal one more...xx

[klepetar]

not very good here..but the sound sucks and the stage is tiny..

[xMariahxLoverx]

robin antin lol

[casperlecroix]

lol what's the point of this?

all their songs have Nicole on most of the vocals T_T

[estela007]

that woman is robin???

[chica096]

NiCe vIdEo

[Leahsbff]

They sound horrible!

[DonKapotas]

Its not live .. lol

[chaotic1985]

lol robin antin boppin around

[samoy10]

yes they are very poor performing alive

[Rye669000]

waaaaaaaaaaaaahhh what a performance,,.. VERY P0or without nicole. i dont care what you say bout nicole. see,, without nicole its so bo00ring.without nicole pussycat dolls is very poor in performance think about it. for who hate nicole,,.. fucking shit you my dear.

love nicole ^_~. luv ya nicole.

woman of my dreamz.

[NikkiScherzingerFan]

People Melody doesnt sing the whole song! She sings the same lil parts like she would in the performances with Nicole. Nicole voice is in bg and Melody just pretends to sing Nicole's line when she actually mimes. Like just might get it, wigu, etc. She doesnt sing anything new, she just mimes.

[bruno5161p]

nice meeeeeeel!

I wanna see meel as lead singer now!!

Bye nicole, bye..

[franklincitto]

lindo

[diamondz1989]

melody singin yh i love her

[Clara3332]

where did they sing?

[Paulwander]

I swear this song is for little girls.....

[arigrap]

No!:P

[gerrarditto4u]

true...

[xocheer49]

its awesome i love it lol hahaha

[allahissatan2]

does chesea korka in pcd now....

[meedy2beyonce]

nope .. it's robin antin X

[tamw123]

WOW

[Magmax101]

see jessica can sing!!!!

[xiaolinwudaiwarrior]

where was Nicole here?

[zzrickyperezzz]

the both r awsome

[Yun33K]

love it! melody rawks!!!

[PrinsToris]

enjoy

[SFxShelbyAj]

no no...nicole must be in this group...coz if no nicole there will be no PCD!

[ValentinaBojic]

she is better than nicole...nicole sucks

[allstarr357]

hope you know they are singing to the track..

[vonernest09]

melody is good in leading

but nicole is d one and only lead singer

of pussycat dolls

nicole is d best she got the voice

[aaronz92]

what sucks is that Nicole needs the Dolls since we know she won't go anywhere solo wise

and the Dolls need Nicole since no one has yet to hear them singing their songs without Nicole leading

[lmh315]

i actually like melody singing this theres something cool in her voice...nicole is good but yea melody needs more parts and the other chicks too

[milton216]

no nicole?

[Pixiebabylove]

i'm sorry bt when melody sings lead it's better and u can hear the other dolls more, i think they shud be a four piece without nicole

[Cishney026]

i hate it, pussycat dolls are not good w/o nicole, it's totally bad! the 4 dolls ruin the show!

[DanielAien]

don't judge the dolls is bad without nicole..

they have they own talent so why don't show it..

melody have a beautiful voice also..

same like the other dolls...

[nianatasya]

where's nicole?

[edalem]

WWOOOAAA

BETHER THAN NICOLE

[crocgurl]

Bad...they cant survive without nicole.

[jopacangrie]

PLEASEEE WHAT IS THIS!!!!!!

[evilgeniusnick327]

L-R: Robin Antin, Jessica, Melody (singing over the playback of Nicole's voice), Ashley, Kimberly.

[Nvrbther4u]

wow melody and the dolls are singing without nicole sounds good melody sounds good

[anasturlesi01]

hate it

[afay]

this is so not live, i can still hear nicole

[xxCuttiexx96]

whoa robin is working it up there!

[yezzir05]

YAYYY!!! NICOLE ISN'T THERE!!

[katsac]

wujuuu!

robin is thereee!

it was so good to meet you!

[fofob]

melody is awsome

[arquilui]

mmm...is not the same without Nicole

[irincheto92]

it is not melody singing, it's playback - so it's nicole singing, though she's missing... melody only screams and we don't even hear her, we hear nicole's playback voice!!!

[Prettyfresh20]

I did not know that that was melody singing wow. I'm impress.

[kekeangeldiamonds]

I love all the pussycatdolls and all, I know alot of us get tired of seeing nicole in the front but nicole didnt make the dolls robin did and she chose to put her as the lead singer..... But i still do like melody's voice better and i love all of them as a group.... AND YOU TOO CARMIT!!!! LOL!!!

[zenoobah]

WWTTFF is robin antin doing on stage!?!?! she needs 2 shut the hell off and get off the stage!!!

[Hanniii4Jesse]

I liked this, and melody sounds really great! =)

[girlicousNicoLovVM]

where is nicole ?????

[ssssssae]

Gooo pcd i love you so much ,,,, Go blondies .,,.,.

[Kawasaki05]

thats not pussycat dolls

[drummerboii06]

GONE MELODY

[algebraz911]

nicole can't sing live!!!

[lirigzonlirigzon]

(¯`·´¯)

`·.,(¯`·´¯)(¯`·´¯)

(¯`·´¯).·´_­`·.,.·´­­

`·.,.·´ ­Luv it

[brownskyn10]

loved melody sounds great

[leeannnum25]

Jessica and Ashley Are Very Beautiful and Amazing

[tinapa37]

in this per4mance,nicole at that time went 2 monaco 2 support lewis H,so d other dolls continued dis show 2 promote their new song..at least,they r tryin their best..GO PCD DOLLS!

[Mac5t]

I want to hear the other girls sing more, but not at a party bouncin' around. They were okay, but I wanna hear them SING!! ya know?

[83839689]

where is NICOLE!!!

nicole is the star of the grpoup!!!!!!

[xKimBerLeix]

never mind, it'd not her but it really looks like her until you look closely. Melody did better than her anyway.

[xKimBerLeix]

nicole is there she's next to Melody. She just isn't doing anything. I think Melody did really good.

[Kmauricioip]

That is Jessica!

[npsaila]

yhat is not nicole is Robin

[NikkiScherzingerFan]

They sound awful! If Nicole is not there they should cancel their performances! If Melody is taking lead it is a disaster! Melody makes these horrible sounds! The rest of the girls are ok but Melody..! This proves that none of them can replace Nicole and that Melody cant sing a song all by herself!

[abecc]

it looks like melody is singing nicole's part...

[wickedinuniform]

yea it does i think they are all sharing the lead part

[JuzHot]

Ashaming...

[memyma2]

lol Robin antin is there too lol!!!!

[lolfunnylol]

NICOLES NOT THERE! where is she?

[tvocake]

kimberly

[ChaosCassi]

whats the gurls name wiff the short blonde hair?

[ShesMajorOx]

Kimberley

[annjulio]

nice song!!!

[jay8832]

nicole is the group and i dont like that

[mirtzea]

You go MELODY!!! wooohoo...anyway..w/e you guys say, i think that this is their first song where everyone gets a rather "fair" part. I mean, the way Melody sings the whole chorus along with Nicole, the Ha-ha-ha part and the last part of the chorus sang by the other 3 girls. Idk, i think it's a step forward and from now on they will really look like and sound like a group. Still, this has been a great performance, even without Nicole. It shows that they can handle themselves =) Still like them =D

[brownaay101]

how come they dont all sing?

[memyma2]

only nicole and melody are trained to sing

[beemau]

i dont like nicole..

i preffer melody.

[josh82000]

i dont like melody, she sounds like a little girl crying. all she says is ohohohohohohho

[tweetybabymama1]

They sound really better without nicole

[nolacarverram]

melody should h@ve hit tht note plus robin get the fuck off the St@ge plus melody should h@ve origin@lly h@d @ prt in the song or sumtin people gettin sick of nicole

[Kurumi818]

I have to say. I like this group but Nicole monopolizes it too much. Even with her not there she's still monopolizing. No offence! I like her, just not the way she dictates.

[gymnasticchick12]

plus they didnt even do the dance in the middle of it so its not them

[gymnasticchick12]

ok im sorry but that doesnt look like the pussycat dolls because its a radio on and their just lipsinging and when they sing u could tell......ITS HORRIBLE!!

[MissInfamous01]

Melody should be the main singer,

Nicole sucks in my opinion.

[sarajevomika]

totally agree.. melody is younger fresher and more amazing... its just nichole dont sound that good live.. and she umm just got uglier.. maybe its bcuz shes getting older and thats natrual. but idk

[5conbo]

It doesn't matter who is the main singer, the point is how they sing :D

[mauradicta20]

i so love Robin!!! she's perfect even when she's dancing

[LittleDevil7]

they all singggggggg yeah

[09181975]

Where the F**K is Nicole? She's "the star" of the group!!!!!! But, it still looks and sounds "okay." LOL!!!!!!!!!!!

[richyjg]

they are the pussycats but nichole was not present.... the one singing all the son is melody i think

[alyshanaresh26]

were u at las vegas and got the vidoe

?

[xoxmellymelxox]

LMFAO @ how loud Nicole's voice is in the background. what a pointless performance.

[darsee31]

that is not the pussyct dolls i went there and thats not the pussycat dolls

[08musikfreak08]

that is the pussycat dolls

[wetsitfamily]

by the time this year is over the pussycat dolls are gonna have to be a one person act, have to call them last doll standing, They have a great thing why would they want there own album, the only person that has had a successful album after a group is Justin Timberlake. It doesnt happen alot

[alonzolerone]

where the hell is nicole? i hope not promotin her album that is set to come out in 2017 (from what cdnowdotcom says ) lol

[xxmwahmwahmwahxx]

nicole is singing in the background

[s20t17]

anybody else find it funny that people are saying its so good without nicole and the title says its live but you can clearly hear the back track with nicole voice loud as hell LOL

[MARJUOON]

she is robin antin, the creator of the pussycat dolls

[afr2006]

well it's true melody did it as good or better than nicole hehehehe she has a pretty voice and it's cool my only question and

sorry for the ignorance it's who's that other

with the four pussycat dolls? well that's all great vid ^^

[afr2006]

forget it reading i answer myself i still don't kow who she is but i know her name xD

[spermato182]

q porqueria... :D

[ShakiraFanRockInRio]

Hey read the comment I wrote on your channel

[dcwb]

i did thanks:)

[diamondareforever123]

You know, after I saw this, they just proved that they don't need Nicole.

Oh, have you saw the new girl band called Girlicious? The creator of that girl band also created Pussycat Dolls. Sorry I can't remember her name.

The main difference to that band is that everyone has the chance to sing. And, I have watched the reality tv show called 'Pussycat Dolls present : Girlicious'

[diamondareforever123]

And the four lucky women who won the show are : Nicole, Natalie, Chrystina and Tiffanie.

And some of them doesn't really sing good (I watched the reality tv show and saw them singing ok-ish) but at their first music video, I saw all of them taking part. They all have equal amount of singing and dancing part. And that shows them that they don't have to sing or dance that good to shine.

You can watch their first music video here on Youtube by typing 'Girlicious like me'

[rai452]

How does this prove they don't need Nicole. Even though Nicole wasn't physically there, her voice on the back track was louder than any of theirs.

[cescagag00h]

HEY Y'ALL Nicole sherzinger look a like:

watch?v=vTTsEfnOFs8

[DJIRRemixes]

love them im there number 1 fan! and non of you can tell me other wise!

[2sxc4myowngood]

wheres nichole shes the only 1 who sings it looks so stupid for them 2 be there on too sing the word when i grow up, i mean come on i heard on there new album they all sing, and i mean sing lines, not one word, i love them but why be a group just for it too be all about nichole

[ilovemeapingu]

nicole sucks.

and does anyone else think that this song has absolutely no point!?

[BryanAC03]

WHAT?! this song is awesome. you're dumb :)

[diamondareforever123]

I like this song. But you know, people got different opinions...

[09181975]

Where's Nicole? She IS the Pussaycat Dolls!!!! LOL!!!!!!

[BrettRoxMyWorld]

i love this song....oh ya where is Nicole??

[jmc0001]

this just proved that the pussycat dolls dont need nicole to get the crowd going, i myself would of rather seen melody sing this song, i do like nicole, but it is time for the other pcd's to shine

[jo55jo]

thank u! melody sounds so good singin lead! all the dolls should get solos on dis album! Nic bores me! her voice iz sooooo bland!

[franp1982]

where is nicole??

[Shasha2]

I quote : " this is the pussycat dolls minus nicole singing when i grow up "

[Msault]

Who is that singing that singing second to the left?

[dcwb]

jessica at the beginning!!!

[iRock092]

Is this Robin Antin on the complete left?cause whoever it was the girl was really not dancing well and almost looked stupid...

[dcwb]

Lol yeah thats robin:)

x

[MitchyJaffa]

what is robin antin doing

or whatever her name is.

lol

[jessemccartney4]

wheres nicole?

[play1tsafe]

i think that whenever nicole isnt there, melody should ALWAYS replace her and sing lead.

:]

[1991keith]

OMG melody is singing..yes

[melodyfan15]

i kno robin need to stop she a bit too old

[1991keith]

seriously

[bangush33]

u r sooo right,they r not machines.singing & dancing at d same time is sooo hard!d credit shld all go to dolls-PCDs!!they r AMAZING..all of them

[DominicanBlackBoi]

they sing good live and everyone sayin about so you think u can dance performance u have to remember they r tired they just got finish doin a 12 hour video for three days so dont say they cannot sing at which they can they r not sum fuckin machines and they wouldnt be this popular if they didnt where is danity kane?? my point like i said these girls work hard every single day to plz fans and everyone is complain about that performance that just piss me off

[chanelxoxlove9]

IM SOO HAPPYYY omg nicole is always hogging that mic its like give the other girls a chanceee geezz

SHES ROTTENNN :)

WELL SHES GORGEOUSSS BUT SHE ACTS ROTTTEN LOL

[Camthecamera]

LoL

I agree... it would be great to hear the other girls sometimes... :P

[BumboreD123]

Believe me, its not great to hear them. Search for their performance of this song on "So You Think You Can Dance" and you'll hear how awful they sound live. I'm their biggest fan, and I was most critical of Nicole hogging all the microphone, but after hearing them live, I say give Nicole and Melody the mic. The rest shud NOT sing. Before you give me thumbs down or nasty responses, just go listen to them.

[dcwb]

thanks for your comment, just saw the video and i regret to say i actually agree with you!

[Camthecamera]

When they performed When I Grow up or Buttons?

[dcwb]

when i grow up:) x

[BumboreD123]

I clearly stated "this song" which obviously means "When I Grow Up".

[Camthecamera]

OMG Don't be pissed off.. this was just a question because they BOTH sang live on SYTYCD. And you should read the comment I left earlier. I was saying that maybe they aren't the greatest singers of all time, they are great entertainers and performers and we can't deny it...

[BumboreD123]

I wasn't pissed off :)

[JessicaKristyMarieXo]

You're not their biggest fan. Also, while dancing that much of course Ash/Jess are gonna sound bad. But I hope they work on it and build up stamina.