The piano part itself is not a simple feat so i was blown away seeing this transcribed credibly for guitar. I wonder if Fagen and Becker have seen this. If not, they really should. Any major artist with half a heart surely would want to, my friend.
This is fantastic, I keep coming back to this, prefer it to the original which is incredible because Steely Dan are one of those perfect bands but this goes beyond perfection.
I post about three comments a decade on here, so if I write, you really got me. I love the tune, so I was leaning your way from the first chord, but here's the thing that you've really managed: to convey respect for the piece. I don't have your chops or that much to contribute, but in my wildest fantasies I hope that someone hears my efforts and thinks: that guy loves that tune and is totally synched with the original artist. That's what I hear here...all the best; keep posting.
Who are the douchenozzles they come here just to vote dislike.Especially a piece like this. I see this all over You Tube.
Brilliant guitar. Like all maestro's you make it look easy when its no such thing. I especially like the little break at the end. Besides its my favorite Dan song.
and he sings too!! nice job TC, love Steely Dan, got into them by accident when a friend bought me an album of theirs (i forget which one) not knowing at the time I was actually into Steeleye Span. An easy mistake to make I guess but a fortunate one none the less
My favorite group...sophisticated, melodic, and complicated, not to mention unique......in a class of their own...and you do them better than anyone...can't imagine tackling them solo...please do more!!
@airbus3006 Say Trebleclef, if you don't mind my asking, what model Taylor are you playing for this song? I recently bought a Taylor NS 24 and am very happy w/ it, even though it was made in Mexico...I couldn't tell what type of wood yours was made of, or if it's an American model...thanx, Bob
Very very very nice. I like Steely Dan's music but I never really tried to play it. This is very inspiring (although I'd never reach your level). Much kudos. Appreciate you played this and uploaded. Thx.
That's a great post Tony, thanks - and that's a well thought-out, musically aware accompaniment, I'd expect nothing less. And the singing was good. All-round brilliance, what else can I say?!
yeah, can't sing worth a damn. but like i said in the video details this one just seemed to need more than just instrument. I was going to do a "karaoke" version (all the instrument parts but not trying to also play the melody).
But I kinda like the words too. So I trotted out the voice! :D
A great tune, with beautiful chord voicing (as we all know from the Dan),very nice how you're introducing your voice with this tune, great. Saludos Vic.
i've got a couple of vocals of brazilian things up already for years. "corcovado' and 'pra dizer adeus' are still up. there were others but i've deleted a lot of the vocals i did.
You never cease to amaze me! The Dan is my 2nd favorite band. I've been hacking away at Deacon Blues for a while now, but I can never get past the second bridge. You've got the entire band in your hands here, and VOCALS? Yeah... very cool.
Would you ever consider taking requests? If so, try Deacon Blues so I can study your fingerings. Thanks for posting! ~Jon
@troubleclef That would be the Beatles, if for nothing more than shear output over the years. We both noodled. I made spaghetti, you probably made fettuccini Alfredo with lobster! Thanks ~Jon
but, heck, i can't sing much either. I did do several vocals long ago. you can see some are still posted, but i removed a bunch out of sheer embarrassment!
wow! Look who's singing now! :) You're such a brilliant guitarist (and a darn good singer after hearing this). Great job! I will definitely be buying your CD when I get the chance!
The really galling thing here is that you make it look so infuriatingly easy with only the standard numbers of fingers, and none of them in a rush. Thanks for all your posts, and thanks for always springing left-field surprises. Inspirational stuff.
thanks. yeah, all those add9 chords in this are a real bitch. the left forearm starts to hurt if i practice this for too long.
Adding a 9th in a piano chord is a piece of cake. Do it on guitar, in a key that doesn't allow for any open strings, and you've got tendonitis looking over your shoulder! :D
I thank you. Not everything. Mostly I just don't finish stuff that I start on. I get 80% of the way into working something out and I get bored with it or it's just too hard to finish. Or I get distracted and start working on 10 other things instead!
The piano part itself is not a simple feat so i was blown away seeing this transcribed credibly for guitar. I wonder if Fagen and Becker have seen this. If not, they really should. Any major artist with half a heart surely would want to, my friend.
CharlesinCharge991 1 month ago
This is fantastic, I keep coming back to this, prefer it to the original which is incredible because Steely Dan are one of those perfect bands but this goes beyond perfection.
TheNicholas0202 1 month ago
Truly excellent, to cover Steely Dan so well amazes me!
TheNicholas0202 2 months ago
Awesome ! I never thought that could be transposed to guitar and maintain much of the keyboard nuances.
Great work. If I was better adept I'd ask for the cords. Maybe you could send me anyway.
GaryLeventhal 4 months ago
Very good! :]
Maladjusted11 6 months ago
I post about three comments a decade on here, so if I write, you really got me. I love the tune, so I was leaning your way from the first chord, but here's the thing that you've really managed: to convey respect for the piece. I don't have your chops or that much to contribute, but in my wildest fantasies I hope that someone hears my efforts and thinks: that guy loves that tune and is totally synched with the original artist. That's what I hear here...all the best; keep posting.
Don
DonClardy65 8 months ago
@DonClardy65
thanks, Don. I really appreciate it.
troubleclef 8 months ago
Nice man. One of my favorite steely dan tunes.
sprinkler5802 11 months ago
you have a beautiful voice
profesoul 1 year ago
This is phenomenal! My favourite Steely Dan song. Please do a tutorial video for us beginner/intermediate guitar enthusiasts. Pretty please!
darthzydar 1 year ago
Allright. You nailed that one. If you put more Dan on here I just might piss my pants.
theivory1 1 year ago
@theivory1
ahem, well we wouldn't want that to happen! thanks.
troubleclef 1 year ago
beautiful!!! might be my new favorite!!
borninreverse 1 year ago
@borninreverse
thanks!
troubleclef 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It blown my mind men.
It's a song i'd never imagine that could be covered like this.
my respects.
Keep up!
shikokuerda 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It blown my mind men.
It's a song i'd never imagine that could be covered like this.
my respects.
Keep up!
shikokuerda 1 year ago
It blown my mind men.
It's a song i'd never imagine that could be covered like this.
my respects.
Keep up!
shikokuerda 1 year ago
Youre fucking awesome o.Ô.....=)
ThePheorix 1 year ago
wow really good
julymozart 1 year ago
@julymozart
thanks
troubleclef 1 year ago
Great playing ..... super vocals ! Brilliant !
mostlybossa 1 year ago
Who are the douchenozzles they come here just to vote dislike.Especially a piece like this. I see this all over You Tube.
Brilliant guitar. Like all maestro's you make it look easy when its no such thing. I especially like the little break at the end. Besides its my favorite Dan song.
Thanks man.
PlymouthVT 1 year ago 2
@PlymouthVT
thanks, Plymouth. Or should I call you Calvin? Nice town. Beautiful part of my native state. cheers.
troubleclef 1 year ago
and he sings too!! nice job TC, love Steely Dan, got into them by accident when a friend bought me an album of theirs (i forget which one) not knowing at the time I was actually into Steeleye Span. An easy mistake to make I guess but a fortunate one none the less
euth 1 year ago
Troubleclef, you're a gun mate. one of the best youtube guitarists, period.
matteovrizzi 1 year ago
My favorite group...sophisticated, melodic, and complicated, not to mention unique......in a class of their own...and you do them better than anyone...can't imagine tackling them solo...please do more!!
airbus3006 1 year ago
@airbus3006
thanks!
troubleclef 1 year ago
@airbus3006 Say Trebleclef, if you don't mind my asking, what model Taylor are you playing for this song? I recently bought a Taylor NS 24 and am very happy w/ it, even though it was made in Mexico...I couldn't tell what type of wood yours was made of, or if it's an American model...thanx, Bob
airbus3006 1 year ago
@airbus3006
it's a 54. believe it's a cedar top. not sure about the other woods though i read them somewhere on the web at one point.
troubleclef 1 year ago
That was nice. Seems like everything you do on the guitar is wonderful. And the vocals work well and sound great.
dianeb1020 1 year ago
Nice work! Great into and the sound quality is excellent!
kennethasnip 1 year ago
Amazing playing, nice voice, really great music taste. Who could ask for more?
rThorWenzel 1 year ago
one of my fav steely dan albums,songs...beautifully done!
rjkidd 1 year ago
Excellent!
craigbrandau 1 year ago
Very very very nice. I like Steely Dan's music but I never really tried to play it. This is very inspiring (although I'd never reach your level). Much kudos. Appreciate you played this and uploaded. Thx.
tonvenhuizen 1 year ago
Nice! This is the first one I've heard you sing.
kernalkorn 1 year ago
@kernalkorn
there's some older clips when i used to sing. in fact the other SD clip I did (the fez) has vocals (such as they are) as well.
thanks
troubleclef 1 year ago
I don't even like steely dan, but i liked that.
digitaldown 1 year ago
@digitaldown
thanks!
troubleclef 1 year ago
Brilliant arrangement and performance, as always, Mr. Trouble Clef. And the vocals worked!
twostikks1 1 year ago
A fellow Mac user and Dan fan. Nice.
Steakfinger 1 year ago
would you consider doing a version of "only a fool would say that"?
hutz13 1 year ago
@hutz13
it's conceivable. there are other things on that record or other SD records i'd do first probably, but it's not out of the question. thanks.
troubleclef 1 year ago
@troubleclef no problem ... it's likely not as complex a song as most of the ones you tackle, any SD songs are much appreciated in any event.
hutz13 1 year ago
would you do a version "of only a fool would say that" sometime?
hutz13 1 year ago
Very cool!! Nicely done and great to see you post again!
unclealbert72 1 year ago
@unclealbert72
thanks, man
troubleclef 1 year ago
Brave choice, but works pretty well in stripped back form. Tasty intro work especially !
Cheers,Jim
jimguitarfan 1 year ago
love THE DAN- nice job T
mrsullyrox 1 year ago
@mrsullyrox
thanks, buddy. Nice job on that Neil Young tune you did recently, btw. "round and round", love that song.
troubleclef 1 year ago
I take it that's a new microphone...Very nice. What is it?
BennyBlanc0FTB 1 year ago
@BennyBlanc0FTB
nope. same old AT3035 used in the last year or so of clips.
troubleclef 1 year ago
I liked it very much. Caught me by surprise. I will watch it and see if I can learn it. Looks like a hybrid Taylor nylon. Thanks
SiggyMe 1 year ago
@SiggyMe
yup. NS54-ce. love of my life. :D
troubleclef 1 year ago
@troubleclef I hear ya, if I find one used it might end up in my hands.
SiggyMe 1 year ago
Nicely done!
ThinkingDog06 1 year ago
That's a great post Tony, thanks - and that's a well thought-out, musically aware accompaniment, I'd expect nothing less. And the singing was good. All-round brilliance, what else can I say?!
ironmonger100 1 year ago
@ironmonger100
thanks, buddy
troubleclef 1 year ago
Very good, I like your interpretation (voice and guitar) !
All the best
Daniel
rdan06 1 year ago
Great stuff!
miaris 1 year ago
Great singing and playing!
Greetings from Germany
Werner
KasugaD400 1 year ago
@KasugaD400
well, not sure about "great" singing. but I appreciate it all the same! :D
troubleclef 1 year ago
Great to hear this Tony. Now that you did it, I might sing on my next video... or maybe not... And the recording quality is amazing.
Never knew the tune before but that is because I am so 'classic' educated. Sorry :-)
2 Thumbs up!
Per
AndanteLargo 1 year ago
@AndanteLargo
You should definitely check out the Dan. They have some remarkable stuff. Thanks so much, Peo. cheers.
troubleclef 1 year ago
Wow!! Fantastic job!
dohertykaki 1 year ago
good voice to, full of surprises =) as the guy below a few said, you seem to know what you can do with your voice
fingerpickups 1 year ago
You're not the best singer in the world, but it's all right.
You seem to know what you can and can't with your voice.
Thumbs up! :)
specthanatos 1 year ago
@specthanatos
yeah, can't sing worth a damn. but like i said in the video details this one just seemed to need more than just instrument. I was going to do a "karaoke" version (all the instrument parts but not trying to also play the melody).
But I kinda like the words too. So I trotted out the voice! :D
troubleclef 1 year ago
A great tune, with beautiful chord voicing (as we all know from the Dan),very nice how you're introducing your voice with this tune, great. Saludos Vic.
Jazzguts 1 year ago
@Jazzguts
thanks Vic. i did post several vocal clips years back but i've removed many of them. yeah, the chords in this are crazy on guitar! all those add9th's
troubleclef 1 year ago
OMG YOU SINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG AND YOUR VOICE IS AWESOME
can you sing in portuguese? I'd love to listen to something from clube da esquina? pleaaaase por favor. abraços
keixoun 1 year ago
@keixoun
i've got a couple of vocals of brazilian things up already for years. "corcovado' and 'pra dizer adeus' are still up. there were others but i've deleted a lot of the vocals i did.
thanks.
troubleclef 1 year ago
Awesome! never came to thought of you singing, but hey, do some more-it was great
mitchskater 1 year ago
@mitchskater
thanks Mitch
troubleclef 1 year ago
very nice! Thanks for sharing this!
drmlabs 1 year ago
You've got a great ear--beautiful job!
rohmer50 1 year ago
I love that first album... Beautifully done.
sonnenberg 1 year ago
nice one
paulo1410 1 year ago
It's very nice and Donald Fagen a great songwriter.
Amitiés
Olivier
reiviloguitare 1 year ago
@reiviloguitare
thanks. yes, he's a master songwriter.
troubleclef 1 year ago
Excellent
Blackmountainsider 1 year ago
Awesome Tony!
One track? guitar and voice toghether?
quicolic 1 year ago
Your Taylor sounds fantastic under your fingers! Great singing & playing!
amccann7 1 year ago
@amccann7
Thanks so much, Amy, for all the comments indeed.
troubleclef 1 year ago
wow - I always looked around me left and riht while listening... great stereo-effect! :)
EmsCD 1 year ago
Respond to this video...
thanks!
troubleclef 1 year ago
Sounds like you used adt,sounds really good
cast390 1 year ago
Fantastic, and nice to hear you singing now too! :-)
hedgewytche 1 year ago
bravo!!! parabens muito bom!!!
gotrance7 1 year ago
so great, Tony. Looking forward to more Steely. I agree re Brooklyn and Heartbeat.
sarabullard 1 year ago
@sarabullard
I did another one quite a while ago. look for 'the fez'. thanks, Sara!
troubleclef 1 year ago
very cool man,sounds real good,one of my favs
DrewAnti1960 1 year ago
Simply great, Tony!
Fine recording sound too, very intimate, just like sitting beside you!
More of it!
Cheers,
Bernd
BoeckmannLudwig 1 year ago
Very nice! I look forward to more! You have been inspiring me in my own play! Thanks!
smokinpoolshark420 1 year ago
@smokinpoolshark420
glad to hear it. thanks
troubleclef 1 year ago
your voice is very much enjoyable indeed. Your guitar playing sucks, so it compensates...lol:; just kidding , of course :-D
Have a great day and thanks for this.
P.
Qpidon 1 year ago
@Qpidon
heheh, funny man. thanks, buddy
troubleclef 1 year ago
Excellent!
Martin
BoeckmannLudwig 1 year ago
Great! you have an amazing mic - it sounded like your in the room!
MegMerrilies 1 year ago
You never cease to amaze me! The Dan is my 2nd favorite band. I've been hacking away at Deacon Blues for a while now, but I can never get past the second bridge. You've got the entire band in your hands here, and VOCALS? Yeah... very cool.
Would you ever consider taking requests? If so, try Deacon Blues so I can study your fingerings. Thanks for posting! ~Jon
FlyingHorseKnuckles 1 year ago
@FlyingHorseKnuckles
and your favorite band?
I think i noodled with Deacon Blues once. Everything on Aja is so *hard* to play. A challenge indeed. Keep trying. Maybe i'll take another look.
troubleclef 1 year ago
@troubleclef That would be the Beatles, if for nothing more than shear output over the years. We both noodled. I made spaghetti, you probably made fettuccini Alfredo with lobster! Thanks ~Jon
FlyingHorseKnuckles 1 year ago
Now you're singing too?! Darn, is there anything you can't do?!
Great job!
One day, I aspire to play the guitar as well as you.
ssbaum 1 year ago
@ssbaum
I can't swim. :D
but, heck, i can't sing much either. I did do several vocals long ago. you can see some are still posted, but i removed a bunch out of sheer embarrassment!
troubleclef 1 year ago
Cool.
gentlemanbagua 1 year ago
Very cool!
WeepingZeeGuitars 1 year ago
wow! Look who's singing now! :) You're such a brilliant guitarist (and a darn good singer after hearing this). Great job! I will definitely be buying your CD when I get the chance!
kris242 1 year ago
@kris242
thank you. thankfully, no vocals on the cd! :D
troubleclef 1 year ago
Your voice reminds me of John Wetton.
LIVEtoROCK86 1 year ago
@LIVEtoROCK86
really?? cause that guy can really sing. me, not so much.
troubleclef 1 year ago
@troubleclef Don't be so quick to doubt yourself. I think you sound pretty damn solid.
LIVEtoROCK86 1 year ago
The really galling thing here is that you make it look so infuriatingly easy with only the standard numbers of fingers, and none of them in a rush. Thanks for all your posts, and thanks for always springing left-field surprises. Inspirational stuff.
1bhaiya 1 year ago 4
@1bhaiya
thanks. yeah, all those add9 chords in this are a real bitch. the left forearm starts to hurt if i practice this for too long.
Adding a 9th in a piano chord is a piece of cake. Do it on guitar, in a key that doesn't allow for any open strings, and you've got tendonitis looking over your shoulder! :D
troubleclef 1 year ago
I didn't know you could sing... nice job!
jgariano3 1 year ago
Tell me where to send the money, I'm buying your CD.
nseston 1 year ago
You never fail to floor me - thanks so much for this, and please don't stop!
bobdeuel 1 year ago
This is such an antidote to the crap I'm forced to hear during an average night's telewatching :)
Pierre61 1 year ago
Never heard you sing before - fantastic job!
upst8 1 year ago
@upst8
thanks, buddy
troubleclef 1 year ago
Do you post everything you do or just your best? 'Cause it's amazing how good all the stuff you upload are!
tecoomexicano 1 year ago
@tecoomexicano
I thank you. Not everything. Mostly I just don't finish stuff that I start on. I get 80% of the way into working something out and I get bored with it or it's just too hard to finish. Or I get distracted and start working on 10 other things instead!
troubleclef 1 year ago
@troubleclef Hehehehehe, cool. I wish I had half your initiative to arrange such beautiful pieces.
tecoomexicano 1 year ago
My favorite Steely Dan song, very well done :)
damizia 1 year ago
@damizia
close to my favorite as well. favorite on that album for sure.
troubleclef 1 year ago
Well done, keep it up :)
Akarathyx 1 year ago
Haha, I never realized how good of a singing voice you have! Superb!
cavedweller1996 1 year ago
@cavedweller1996
i thank you
troubleclef 1 year ago
Mark me down for Deacon Blues also, if at all possible. I'd pay for a recording of your 'Life on Mars' arrangement.
Superb, as always.
lightsculler 1 year ago
Amazing! I would love to hear Deacon Blues.
jocko774 1 year ago
Sweet! You should do more Steely Dan covers. They are true perfectionists :)
VeEvey 1 year ago
@VeEvey
I did "The Fez" a long while back. You can still see it here on YT. thanks!
troubleclef 1 year ago
Good to have you back. Checking evey day to find out about the new cd. John :O)
terrierbw1 1 year ago
Well done lovely
GuildF40 1 year ago