@ThePoliticalMusician You're right, sometimes the A was 425, sometimes 392, or 410. In this particular case it was tuned to around a 415. To @rootingfortaiwan, this was the precise reason it sounds like it's in A, but it really is Bb. :)
@rootingfortaiwan It's weird that people automatically assume everyone, everywhere, since the beginning of time tuned to A440, as though A440 tuning were a law of nature & everyone was born with his ears tuned to A440. A440 didn't become an international "standard" until the 1950s. This is a historically informed performance played in Bb@A415, which is the Late Baroque German chamber pitch. Baroque organs were tuned to A465. The reasons have to do with changes in the tuning of wind instruments.
to say baroque organs were tuned to A465 is a little misleading. very few towns. let alone countries tuned to the same pitch. even in the baroque era organs in different towns in the same country were tuned quite differently
@seamusnot Historically, the tuning of winds has dictated pitch. Most German Baroque organs are found tuned a 1/2 step to a m3 above A440. Analysis of organ pipes indicates that Schuetz performed his church music at A462. Around A465 was prevalent. These organ tunings derived from Renaissance wind pitch. The various "chamber" pitches since the late 17th c. were based on the new French winds. A440, an ISO std. adopted in the 1950s, was the result of decades of lobbying by American wind makers.
Thank for uploading all of these! Sort of straightforward-no-much-fussing performances, but without being too inflexible... Lovely rhythmic vitality. And the players seem to really savor the music. Ah, Bach, without you (and ice cream) life would certainly be a lesser state of affairs!
@duocontinuo ,thx , just googled her name, she's busy lady, a great artist.
is she lesbian?
zerarita 1 month ago
who's that gotic girl ( close encounter of the spooky kind ) with the big vertical violin. tempo is good music is rockin'
zerarita 1 month ago
@zerarita she is Hille Perl and she plays a bass viol....
DuoContinuo 1 month ago
A masterwork!
Sophiestelle 2 months ago
DAM BACH.....YOU GENIUS!!
superhrman 3 months ago
This isn't HOT -its MELTED... awesome cut, good transcribe. Keep up the good work.
vnrhoades 4 months ago
Comment removed
JamesLWirth 5 months ago
A vampire is playing the Viola da Gamba!
cellomad1 5 months ago 2
A little too fast but nice.
joyofcalcutta 5 months ago
Woohoo a rocking performance love the flexibility of tempo and colouring. Inspirational and no ugly audible position changes....
Chestnuttonno 5 months ago
What a beautiful, this is a Real Art!
Sophiestelle 6 months ago
It's weird that they played in A major, not Bb major......
rootingfortaiwan 6 months ago
@rootingfortaiwan Back then, an A was tuned to 425, now it's 440.
ThePoliticalMusician 6 months ago
@ThePoliticalMusician You're right, sometimes the A was 425, sometimes 392, or 410. In this particular case it was tuned to around a 415. To @rootingfortaiwan, this was the precise reason it sounds like it's in A, but it really is Bb. :)
Thunderbird1371 6 months ago
@rootingfortaiwan It's weird that people automatically assume everyone, everywhere, since the beginning of time tuned to A440, as though A440 tuning were a law of nature & everyone was born with his ears tuned to A440. A440 didn't become an international "standard" until the 1950s. This is a historically informed performance played in Bb@A415, which is the Late Baroque German chamber pitch. Baroque organs were tuned to A465. The reasons have to do with changes in the tuning of wind instruments.
1banders 4 months ago
to say baroque organs were tuned to A465 is a little misleading. very few towns. let alone countries tuned to the same pitch. even in the baroque era organs in different towns in the same country were tuned quite differently
seamusnot 1 month ago
@seamusnot Historically, the tuning of winds has dictated pitch. Most German Baroque organs are found tuned a 1/2 step to a m3 above A440. Analysis of organ pipes indicates that Schuetz performed his church music at A462. Around A465 was prevalent. These organ tunings derived from Renaissance wind pitch. The various "chamber" pitches since the late 17th c. were based on the new French winds. A440, an ISO std. adopted in the 1950s, was the result of decades of lobbying by American wind makers.
1banders 1 month ago
very fast!!!
serjaoba 1 year ago
yo quiero ser barroca como hille perl
themecanico 1 year ago
I love you, Hille Perl!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
themecanico 1 year ago
what is that the one the lady playing i though it was an cello??
sorrowfulrin180 2 years ago
@sorrowfulrin180
a viola da gamba (from Italian: leg viol)
Polluxgeminae 2 years ago
@sorrowfulrin180 violincello! :)
greenkng420 1 year ago
@greenkng420 Actually it is a viola da gamba (and I think you mean violoncello).
aabaker22 8 months ago
thank you for this video and others.
zamliyniyesuh 2 years ago
The perfect circle
funky639 2 years ago
Thank for uploading all of these! Sort of straightforward-no-much-fussing performances, but without being too inflexible... Lovely rhythmic vitality. And the players seem to really savor the music. Ah, Bach, without you (and ice cream) life would certainly be a lesser state of affairs!
bersa888 2 years ago
I couldn't agree more!
HahnPotterishFowlnut 2 years ago
my most favourite out of the brandenburg's. thanks!
buxheimerorgelbuch 3 years ago