No matter what other people say Char, you did absolutely amazing! And you deserved to win! You worked your but off for this, and you didn't do it just to get ragged on by absolute strangers!
Well, everyone sings better than me :D But there is no need to bashing on others and be sour about people's comments when you already "won". So be happy, you won. So there.
I'm surprised Charlotte won. Her voice is rather grating, her pronunciation isn't great, and she hit a bunch of off notes. She was moving around the stage and that gave her presence, but I just didn't feel the emotion in her singing.
i agree - there was better singers - the finalist were horrible this year except for one - who should of won. other singers i heard in the try outs were actually good - why the hell did they not make it to the finals - i actually got mad when she won - just because she jump up and down - does not make her a good singer - i dont give a shit about u jumping up and down i want to here an actually good singer
I'm sorry that you're a bitter person with no understanding of how to type in the English language. I'm sorry that you didn't like my performance, and it's true that I thought Jane had won it, because she did a great job. But I'm not a horrible singer, and I should hope that all bias aside, you can still learn to be nice to other people.
wow nice to know people think im a bitter person just because a honest opinion and i did not try to cake up with bullshit niceness. And i did not say ur a horrible singer it is just not what i want and i personally felt Jane had a better voice. some like brintney spears and others dont something. And about judges having more experience than i have well duh of course but than again its not them buying the cd/ song its me and the public.
So I was going to stay out of this, but you shouldn't contradict yourself when you want to talk about "honest opinions"...
"the finalist were horrible this year except for one"
"And i did not say ur a horrible singer"
The way you come off bitter are the little comments like "except for one - who should of won." "other singers...were actually good", "why the hell did they not make it[?]" "i actually got mad" "i want to here an actually good singer"...
It's the general feeling one gets from reading your post.
I personally believe at least one person did better than Charlotte, but I'm not going to go around saying the other finalists were horrible. Charlotte's voice is beautiful, and Jane's is as well.
You don't win favor by going around saying everyone but your favorite sucked. Nobody wants to hear that - especially not the finalists. If there was little competition, then it devalues their efforts.
actually...yes...you did call her a horrible singer! And if you think that, you either have to get your ears checked, or you just dislike yours and like bagging on others
You have to take into account that some people aren't accustomed to the way Japanese music requires the voice to be. If I had heard this for the very first time without knowing how Japanese music is, I would thought her voice was bad. So maybe to some people her voice isn't attractive, but by Japanese standards, I thought she was really good.
And honestly the reason i like Jane was because when she song i truelly felt the emotion to the point that i got goosebumps. For me that makes me love the singer. but if it were not for Jane i would say you would of been my favorite . Do understand that some people will not like ur singing and some will love it.
Hey, if you want to support your favorite singer, the right thing to do is go to her video and say something supportive, like: "Jane, I thought you were the best singer. I wish you had won!"
It's an entirely different thing to go to someone else's video and rag on them, directly OR indirectly. That's the very definition of bitter, and it's really, really sad.
Take care, and maybe try niceness out once in a while. You might like it.
Charlotte, we all know you are not a horrible singer. You did amazing out there. Just believe in yourself and ignore comments that are not constructive.
The judges were impartial, and one of them was a music producer from Japan. I'm far more likely to believe his opinion of talent than some random scrub from the internet. Speaking from behind your favoritism, of course you're upset, but that's no reason to be bitter or spiteful - that just makes you an ass.
Hi Dreaming, though I thank you for your support, I think it is unfair for you to think that way of Charlotte. She did win fair and square in my honest opinion. She tried her best and her efforts totally paid off! The judges obviously had their reasons why the picked Charlotte and I think they made a wonderful choice.
I love my cousin's voice I need to work on my voice to reach her level but I guess singing runs in our family :) GO CHARLOTTE!
XTatteredXSouls66X 1 year ago
Voice isn't amazing, but she's definitely got presence. She needs to enunciate a WEE bit more.
superskh 1 year ago
wow she`s really good :)
Kathlinia 1 year ago
Comment removed
Naturerocks411 1 year ago
Comment removed
Naturerocks411 1 year ago
Gurren Lagann is waaaaay better then gundam seed $ destiny
ChaosBackup 2 years ago
Seems like people like to sing this song. Anyway nice singing and i enjoy the anime.
-Jessica J
Go Anime and 2pm!
remethankssuju 2 years ago
Uhaaaaaaaaaaaa- She's so talented oAo-
her accent-
is adorabl-SHOT-
ThumperMiggles 2 years ago
OMGAH ITS TSUNKU!!!!
she's very good :) I'm not surprised she won, even though there was a lot of good competition
akinoxhikari 2 years ago
TSUKUN? Where?!!!
BucketxMizu 2 years ago
I think at 1:39
abyssinheaven 2 years ago
@abyssinheaven lmao did you see the asian guy shake his head he's all like"wtf is this.."
gilfandubs 1 year ago 3
I wish I could've been there to see this performance. She was phenominal!~
:D
I can't wait to see what AX Idol brings her.
SnickerzAnime14 2 years ago
i love himeka and she sings very good too
ayumistic 2 years ago
who??? HIMEKA FROM CANADA??? ARE U TALKING ABOUT HIMEKA FROM CANADA?? TEL MEE
ayumistic 2 years ago
HIMEKA sings better. =D!
otaruaj 2 years ago 3
Is there somewhere I can find the Himeka cover? I really want to hear it!
yuricat 2 years ago
She sings well in comparison with other people. =D However, I like HIMEKA's cover of this song more.
otaruaj 2 years ago 3
OMG!! it's really tsunku!!!! OMG.. i can't believe this.. he is one of the judges!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OMG. OMG.OMG.OMG.OMG.
one of my greatest dreams is that tsunku could hear me singing any of his H!P song compositions!! even though if i didn't won in that contest!!! XD
leyah18 2 years ago
who is the japanese judge?? is it tsunku?
o.0
leyah18 2 years ago
Yes. He worked for the H!P group
KIRA01JaP 2 years ago
Oh! Her voice is Very very beautiful & perfect japanese pronounce like HIMEKA!
I think that she is suitable as the winner of AX Expo!
himekafan2009 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
omg she is amazing!!!
EnchantixEnergy 2 years ago
P.S. Love the outfit! ;0
94vampiregurl 2 years ago
No matter what other people say Char, you did absolutely amazing! And you deserved to win! You worked your but off for this, and you didn't do it just to get ragged on by absolute strangers!
I love you Charlotte!
P.S. This is your littlest sissy! :)
xOxO
94vampiregurl 2 years ago
OMG. That comment coming out of Tsunku's mouth is heaven. xD I would stop breathing if he gave me a comment like that. xDD
iMisaProduction 2 years ago
Well, everyone sings better than me :D But there is no need to bashing on others and be sour about people's comments when you already "won". So be happy, you won. So there.
MugiBunny 2 years ago
I'm surprised Charlotte won. Her voice is rather grating, her pronunciation isn't great, and she hit a bunch of off notes. She was moving around the stage and that gave her presence, but I just didn't feel the emotion in her singing.
ChibiSabbath 2 years ago 19
Cool
xZICAx 2 years ago 3
YOU KICKED MY ASS CHARLOTTE!! <3
~Victoria
Rider4Z 2 years ago 2
Did they have to sing songs in Japanese?
Jnsparrow 2 years ago
"Singers may choose any song related to anime and/or video games, English or Japanese."
Most people choose to sing in Japanese. I think it's more from what you hear more often as opposed to anything else...
LifeOutsideTheBox 2 years ago
She wasn't that great. Gah.
Zangya 2 years ago
i agree - there was better singers - the finalist were horrible this year except for one - who should of won. other singers i heard in the try outs were actually good - why the hell did they not make it to the finals - i actually got mad when she won - just because she jump up and down - does not make her a good singer - i dont give a shit about u jumping up and down i want to here an actually good singer
cough Jane Estantino should of won Jane cough
dreamingdead13 2 years ago
I'm sorry that you're a bitter person with no understanding of how to type in the English language. I'm sorry that you didn't like my performance, and it's true that I thought Jane had won it, because she did a great job. But I'm not a horrible singer, and I should hope that all bias aside, you can still learn to be nice to other people.
yuricat 2 years ago
wow nice to know people think im a bitter person just because a honest opinion and i did not try to cake up with bullshit niceness. And i did not say ur a horrible singer it is just not what i want and i personally felt Jane had a better voice. some like brintney spears and others dont something. And about judges having more experience than i have well duh of course but than again its not them buying the cd/ song its me and the public.
dreamingdead13 2 years ago
Niceness is bullshit now, huh? Wow...I guess that explains why the world is going down the toilet.
captainimpulse 2 years ago
So I was going to stay out of this, but you shouldn't contradict yourself when you want to talk about "honest opinions"...
"the finalist were horrible this year except for one"
"And i did not say ur a horrible singer"
The way you come off bitter are the little comments like "except for one - who should of won." "other singers...were actually good", "why the hell did they not make it[?]" "i actually got mad" "i want to here an actually good singer"...
LifeOutsideTheBox 2 years ago
It's the general feeling one gets from reading your post.
I personally believe at least one person did better than Charlotte, but I'm not going to go around saying the other finalists were horrible. Charlotte's voice is beautiful, and Jane's is as well.
You don't win favor by going around saying everyone but your favorite sucked. Nobody wants to hear that - especially not the finalists. If there was little competition, then it devalues their efforts.
LifeOutsideTheBox 2 years ago
actually...yes...you did call her a horrible singer! And if you think that, you either have to get your ears checked, or you just dislike yours and like bagging on others
94vampiregurl 2 years ago
You have to take into account that some people aren't accustomed to the way Japanese music requires the voice to be. If I had heard this for the very first time without knowing how Japanese music is, I would thought her voice was bad. So maybe to some people her voice isn't attractive, but by Japanese standards, I thought she was really good.
jjaapp18 2 years ago
And honestly the reason i like Jane was because when she song i truelly felt the emotion to the point that i got goosebumps. For me that makes me love the singer. but if it were not for Jane i would say you would of been my favorite . Do understand that some people will not like ur singing and some will love it.
dreamingdead13 2 years ago
Hey, if you want to support your favorite singer, the right thing to do is go to her video and say something supportive, like: "Jane, I thought you were the best singer. I wish you had won!"
It's an entirely different thing to go to someone else's video and rag on them, directly OR indirectly. That's the very definition of bitter, and it's really, really sad.
Take care, and maybe try niceness out once in a while. You might like it.
captainimpulse 2 years ago 11
@captainimpulse I totally agree with you
starj0y 1 year ago
i will be bias - liking a song or singer is being bias.
really ? attacking my english typing and i thought after so many years people would get use to youtubers crapy typing / grammar. lol
in just being honest and if you dont like it is not my problem and ignore me. im just one opinion among thousands get over it.
now someone explain to me how expressing my opinion is some how bitter ?
dreamingdead13 2 years ago
Charlotte, we all know you are not a horrible singer. You did amazing out there. Just believe in yourself and ignore comments that are not constructive.
-Pam
pamechan9 2 years ago
Good job! Stand up for yourself! That's how to do it!
By the way! You did an amazing job!
94vampiregurl 2 years ago
Comment removed
yuricat 2 years ago
The judges were impartial, and one of them was a music producer from Japan. I'm far more likely to believe his opinion of talent than some random scrub from the internet. Speaking from behind your favoritism, of course you're upset, but that's no reason to be bitter or spiteful - that just makes you an ass.
The best act won. Congratulations, Charlotte!
captainimpulse 2 years ago
Hi Dreaming, though I thank you for your support, I think it is unfair for you to think that way of Charlotte. She did win fair and square in my honest opinion. She tried her best and her efforts totally paid off! The judges obviously had their reasons why the picked Charlotte and I think they made a wonderful choice.
janeypoox2 2 years ago
Congratulations on winning Charlotte :D You did great on the high notes. I sounds better on this vid than it did backstage :)
This is Pamela (AX Idol 08) *hugs
pamechan9 2 years ago 3
hmmm.. She really sings well o.ó
When I saw the auditions I just noticed that This year isnt going to be better than the last.. To be Honest, I did not like the finalist..
But Her Performance was great..
Congratulations To her for Winning n.n
laloki5 2 years ago 3