It seems my comment caused a some confusion.After reading your reply,I went back 2 my comment,& realized it was worded kinda awkwardly.I had intended to say that most singers I would deem to be better than Carrie have passed away,but there are also a few singers that r still alive that I deem better(this being where Martina comes in).That said,I think it looks pretty good on Carrie that in order 2 find a suitable comparison 4 her talent,I must look toward someone with 10 years more experience.
Either one would do great with thise song. There's nothing wrong with either of them. Neither of them are mannish or mean in any way. I'd love to hear Kelly do a version of this, as well as I loved hearing Carries version. They both are awesome.
I prefer Carrie's voice and Carrie all around I like the grace and vulnerability Carrie brings to her songs - Kelly is way to mannish and harsh for me to appreciate her
the reason i said kelly wud be better on this song is because her voice is more suited for these kinds of pop/rock stuff.
FYI i love carrie... even more than kelly. wen it comes to rock, carrie's a heavy rocker. i love that about her. this song should've used more guitars in the background of the verses or carrie should've made her voice a little bit more vulnerable. (just an opinion)
i agree that kelly would have done well on this song...but i think if kelly did it, it would be a mean song....but i think carrie makes it vulnerable...which is great
its hard to compare kelly and carrie...each have their own unique style and some poeple would lke carries version over kellys
it would be a mean song? dont buy into the publicity of her last album being "angry" and "dark" and "negative" cause the album is actually very uplifting and emotional. there are some very very inspiring non angry songs on there. and she could make this song whatever she felt like it should be. she has one of those voices. but you are right, its hard to compare them, they are very different, i meant kelly would tear it up with her vocals, i didnt say she would do it better.
Yeah.I've thought this through quite thouroughly,and I can honestly say with 100% confidence that Carrie is the best singer under 40 years old in the world (and that's being pretty generous to some singers that are over 40).Honestly,when I try to think about singers that are better than her,most of the ones that come to my mind right away are not even alive anymore(a few,such as Martina Mcbride,come to me as well).All things considered though,all of this speaks quite well to Carrie's talent.
wow first time i heard this, i guess i need to buy her album AGAIN cuz i need this song on my carrie album! lol i hate it when they do this, add songs to the album after its been out for awhile LOL!
i love this song i wish they'd put this on itunes so u wouldn't have to buy that card cuz i already have her album on my ipod and i don't wanna waste $13!
I love Kara's version, too! :D Both are great! Kara's is more slow and dark, though(:
kalifornialoveex 1 month ago
wait my favorite singer has a new song and I didn't even know it?!!
HaleyMartin11 7 months ago
Neither is Christina Aguilera
sbrna 2 years ago
It seems my comment caused a some confusion.After reading your reply,I went back 2 my comment,& realized it was worded kinda awkwardly.I had intended to say that most singers I would deem to be better than Carrie have passed away,but there are also a few singers that r still alive that I deem better(this being where Martina comes in).That said,I think it looks pretty good on Carrie that in order 2 find a suitable comparison 4 her talent,I must look toward someone with 10 years more experience.
horrorfan13666 2 years ago
Great song!!!!
lebradrian 3 years ago 2
Kara DioGuardi wrote this song. Never knew that until I just looked at her website and saw that!:)
jaymejean28 3 years ago 11
wow really?I didnt know that!thanks for telling us!
Carrie is amazing! cant wait to buy her 3rd album!
avabiancawoot2 2 years ago
Either one would do great with thise song. There's nothing wrong with either of them. Neither of them are mannish or mean in any way. I'd love to hear Kelly do a version of this, as well as I loved hearing Carries version. They both are awesome.
ilovekelly75 3 years ago 2
I prefer Carrie's voice and Carrie all around I like the grace and vulnerability Carrie brings to her songs - Kelly is way to mannish and harsh for me to appreciate her
fiddleDdee 3 years ago 3
i think that too!!
Tayyerr 3 years ago
the reason i said kelly wud be better on this song is because her voice is more suited for these kinds of pop/rock stuff.
FYI i love carrie... even more than kelly. wen it comes to rock, carrie's a heavy rocker. i love that about her. this song should've used more guitars in the background of the verses or carrie should've made her voice a little bit more vulnerable. (just an opinion)
coolnerdx3 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i like the song but like joepatrick55 said i can't help but think it wud've sounded better with kelly.
coolnerdx3 3 years ago
well she didnt get it so who cares
bigbluegrl23 3 years ago
this song is amazing. i hope carrie sings this live at some point. :)
Dreamer094 3 years ago 2
no offense to carrie fans, shes great, but kelly would have torn this song apart...i really like the song...
joepatrick55 3 years ago
im a carrie fan and not really a kelly fan
i agree that kelly would have done well on this song...but i think if kelly did it, it would be a mean song....but i think carrie makes it vulnerable...which is great
its hard to compare kelly and carrie...each have their own unique style and some poeple would lke carries version over kellys
wowthunder92 3 years ago
it would be a mean song? dont buy into the publicity of her last album being "angry" and "dark" and "negative" cause the album is actually very uplifting and emotional. there are some very very inspiring non angry songs on there. and she could make this song whatever she felt like it should be. she has one of those voices. but you are right, its hard to compare them, they are very different, i meant kelly would tear it up with her vocals, i didnt say she would do it better.
joepatrick55 3 years ago
I think this song was sound cool with both of them.
anywho, kellys last album was awesome and I didnt find it angry. I loved it!
jaymejean28 3 years ago
This is the bonus song on a downloadable Carnival Ride CD - you buy the Platinum Music Pass at Target and then you can download it
fiddleDdee 3 years ago 2
i think it's on the "newer" version of carnival ride. they give you a code or something and you download it. but idk if it's actually on the cd.
kris0715 3 years ago
i love this song :)
stargirlhyein 3 years ago
holy smokes. this song is incredible.
i hope she includes this on her next album!!!
perlonu777 3 years ago
i hope she includes this song on her next cd.
kris0715 3 years ago
i freaking love this song!!
Shanelle051 3 years ago 2
Love her so much!!!
CarrieIsDaBomb 3 years ago 4
lol are u related to James Gillespie?
luvstinks94 3 years ago
^^I love Carrie!!! Thanks sooo much for uploading!!!
FFfangirl67 3 years ago 5
can someone please make a download of this or a karaoke version of this? please it would be greatly appresheated
pinkventage 3 years ago 2
OHHHHH CARRIE!!! this should not have been left out of the carnival ride album!!!
carriesdawg 3 years ago 4
CARRIE UNDERWOOD FOREVER :].!
Topcarriefan94 3 years ago 4
STUNNING!!! She has one of the best voices in the WORLD!!
melody4god 3 years ago 3
Yeah.I've thought this through quite thouroughly,and I can honestly say with 100% confidence that Carrie is the best singer under 40 years old in the world (and that's being pretty generous to some singers that are over 40).Honestly,when I try to think about singers that are better than her,most of the ones that come to my mind right away are not even alive anymore(a few,such as Martina Mcbride,come to me as well).All things considered though,all of this speaks quite well to Carrie's talent.
horrorfan13666 3 years ago 6
i met her in june; face to face, she is absolutly amazing,
that was one of the best days of my life! and i love this song :]
Topcarriefan94 3 years ago 4
I LOVE LOVE LOVE this song!! I wish it was on iTunes... since it's not thanks sooooo much for putting it on youtube!!!
melody4god 3 years ago 5
This song is a bonus on the Carnival Ride CD you get at target with the Platinum Music Pass
fiddleDdee 3 years ago 2
carrie is one of hottest most beautiful and most talanted women right now i love her song is amazing even i heard it for first time she s great girl
tuse1991 3 years ago
I love this song!!!!!
her voice is the best
girlygirl2730 3 years ago 2
SHE IS SO PRETTY
like she has such a nice face and body why doesnt anyone ever say she is like her body is way better than katherine heigls and eva langoria and stuff
ugh just cuz shes country lol
HER VOICE ROCKS!@!!!!!!!!
CarrieIsDaBomb 3 years ago
loooooooooooove this song!!!!
girlegrl54 3 years ago 2
I have the album and I wish this song was on it! Carrie is the best! Luv her! =D
carrieandtaylorfan 3 years ago 2
i think genre-wise, it's a bit better suited for kelly, just because it's not very country at all. of course, carrie's great with it regardless.
lcswoosh 3 years ago
really love this song and it is better suited for carrie underwood vocals then kelly clarkson's ... i am so going to buy the album again lol
dilalva89 3 years ago 4
wow first time i heard this, i guess i need to buy her album AGAIN cuz i need this song on my carrie album! lol i hate it when they do this, add songs to the album after its been out for awhile LOL!
oh well, carrie's worth it =]
girlegrl54 3 years ago
i love this song:)
Shanelle051 3 years ago 2
LOVE this song!
middlecreek 3 years ago 4
Did anyone know this song was originally picked for Kelly Clarkson?
kwbnl 3 years ago 5
No...
codygillespie9 3 years ago
Clive Davis wanted it to go on My December, but she rejected it.
kwbnl 3 years ago 2
Yeah, it was, but Kelly didn't want the song so it was passed to Carrie.
sensnationvolchossa 3 years ago 2
where was she at :33? amazing video btw,love the songg
Dreamer094 3 years ago
i undstand what yu are saying 7 thank you i love it too
codygillespie9 3 years ago
i love this song i wish they'd put this on itunes so u wouldn't have to buy that card cuz i already have her album on my ipod and i don't wanna waste $13!
carrierox1031 3 years ago
i knnow
codygillespie9 3 years ago
ya. i bought the CD in stores and i don't have this song.
CaliGirl4ever123 3 years ago
thankv you
codygillespie9 3 years ago