la musica de ELO es envolvente,si nada que sobre salga,la virtuosidad no es lo suyo,pero evidentemente creando melodias jeff es único,la época de "TIME" recuerdo,maravilloso el lp,desde el principio hasta el final,pero la que más me dió en el corazón fué ELDORADO. sin duda un grandioso trabajo. muy buenos arreglos y unas melodias que me acompañarán por el resto de mi vida.
A brilliant song which sounds like it could have come from the mid seventies. It is such a shame that Secret Messages was not released as a double album. The single album is so lame and with the extra songs would have been so much more immense.
the evolution of beatles their sound it shall be like ELO . my inglish is not good, I repeat you but in spanish.ok, la evolución de los beatles en su sonido hubiéra sido como la ELO.
CASI CASI TE CREO! pero los beatles no tocaron tanto tiempo instrumentos como lo ha hacho ELO,
ELO ES ELO. super diferente, especiales, fuera de tiempo, adelantandose a su era con el album Time que esta tambien buenisimo!! sigo escuchando ELO desde finales de los 70s. Saludos
evidentemente que eran diferentes,¿sabes unoa de las bandas similar que descubrí cual fué? pues fueron los moody blues en long distance boyager. una de las badsa bandas de esa epoca que compartí y son parte de mi vida.
You're very welcome 70sDreamer. I'm still happy to have found and posted this great song. It needed sharing with the world wide web for sure. If you'd like to hear the audio done 10 times better than mine, go to rayflute's post for this song. Not only is the audio better, it's a video showing Birmingham. The city Jeff is singing about.
recorded for the proposed 1983 double album 'Secret Messages' but was axed froM the album along with a lot of other good songs, Great song! and No it doesn't sound like 'I am the walrus' open your ears guys
I'm glad someone else said it finally. I thought maybe I wasn't a big music fan after reading the comments that I posted a Walrus remake. I like The Beatles, but I never heard it in this song. For me, this song is about a story. The opening lyrics are happy and the music is sad-ish, droning even, but just the opposite later. Everything he remembered from childhood is changed or gone, but the music is lifting. I don't know what he was saying, but I like it.
"I am the walrus" is based on the same effect, but is a harmonic song. This song is not, if you listen to the track at 4'30'' or 6'35'' you can hear a lot of very well aranged cacophony, but after some it turns into "harmonic cacophony" - which does not exist. This song is not just a slower version of "I am the walrus", it is a very creative, progressive successor. This song shows up, Jeff Lynne is an inspired songwriter and composer.
It's a great and moving song, and I guess Jeff wouldn't mind the comparison to Lennon's unique masterpiece, as you might remember Jeff saying that '10538 Overtures' takes over where 'I Am The Walrus' ends :-)
I think this is a great piece of music. I seem to remember reading that, inspired by Penny Lane & Strawberry Fields, Jeff wanted to do his own song about his childhood environment and came up with this.
i've never compared it directly to that song, but i've thought it sounded like a late beatles era song...a great unknown track, one of my favorite ELO/Jeff Lynne tracks
beatles all over still love it
salford1945 5 months ago
They have never disappointed.
JuanOmegaIota 1 year ago
I can definitely hear the Lennon influence. ELO and the Beatles are my two favourite bands.
bunchie1966 1 year ago
I'didn't know it. The first movement is pure ELO.
Maybe so large... but is ELO.
GOOD GOOD... and MORE.
Good Bye ELOFANS
pantaruja 1 year ago
yes its off afterglow mandalay also on it i have it great isn`t it
cobbity 1 year ago
la musica de ELO es envolvente,si nada que sobre salga,la virtuosidad no es lo suyo,pero evidentemente creando melodias jeff es único,la época de "TIME" recuerdo,maravilloso el lp,desde el principio hasta el final,pero la que más me dió en el corazón fué ELDORADO. sin duda un grandioso trabajo. muy buenos arreglos y unas melodias que me acompañarán por el resto de mi vida.
jcamontflor 2 years ago
Amazing! I've never come across this one before - how on earth have I missed this? One of the better Jeff Lynne songs without a doubt... great stuff!
trvkent 2 years ago 2
Wow - never heard this before from an ELO fan, just shows what he said, carry on from the beatles!
Sportzzmadz 2 years ago
A brilliant song which sounds like it could have come from the mid seventies. It is such a shame that Secret Messages was not released as a double album. The single album is so lame and with the extra songs would have been so much more immense.
bobby666666 2 years ago
Another thing I like about the tune is the trippy Beatles part. When I hear I think I'm traveling through a time portal.
swarlock 2 years ago
this sounds musically like a mixture of dear prudence and I am The Walrus
kingmixer 2 years ago
Yes.
It was written as a last look at his hometown Birmingham. I know how he feels.
swarlock 2 years ago
Thanks for sharing this song. A Great "Grazie" from an ELO'S fan.
GIMAGIMA70 2 years ago 2
You think this sounds like the beatles. Bollocks!!
nollypra 2 years ago 4
the evolution of beatles their sound it shall be like ELO . my inglish is not good, I repeat you but in spanish.ok, la evolución de los beatles en su sonido hubiéra sido como la ELO.
jcamontflor 2 years ago
CASI CASI TE CREO! pero los beatles no tocaron tanto tiempo instrumentos como lo ha hacho ELO,
ELO ES ELO. super diferente, especiales, fuera de tiempo, adelantandose a su era con el album Time que esta tambien buenisimo!! sigo escuchando ELO desde finales de los 70s. Saludos
miguelonzky 2 years ago
evidentemente que eran diferentes,¿sabes unoa de las bandas similar que descubrí cual fué? pues fueron los moody blues en long distance boyager. una de las badsa bandas de esa epoca que compartí y son parte de mi vida.
jcamontflor 2 years ago
Thanks for posting this one! Even if I'm a big ELO fan, I didn't know this song at all... It's great!
70sDreamer 2 years ago 2
You're very welcome 70sDreamer. I'm still happy to have found and posted this great song. It needed sharing with the world wide web for sure. If you'd like to hear the audio done 10 times better than mine, go to rayflute's post for this song. Not only is the audio better, it's a video showing Birmingham. The city Jeff is singing about.
QueenGoofy 2 years ago
A criminally underrated song.
Maybe the best in the 1980´s.
FinnMove 3 years ago 5
As a double album Secret Messages would have
been a fine one.
Hello My Old Friend and Mandalay are
the best ELO songs in 1980, s.
FinnMove 3 years ago
this is a rarely and specially magical sounding tune by the great jeff the other one is mandalay.two obscure jewels
thanks and a hug my friend.
endrizo 3 years ago 2
You're more than welcome, and thanks for posting. I think Mandalay is great as well. :D
QueenGoofy 3 years ago
I know why the double album Secret Messages
was not released. But I don´t know why
the best songs ( like this ) were cut off.
FinnMove 3 years ago
I just met these songs in 1994 with Afterglow.
Never had idea these kind of great songs exit.
FinnMove 3 years ago
recorded for the proposed 1983 double album 'Secret Messages' but was axed froM the album along with a lot of other good songs, Great song! and No it doesn't sound like 'I am the walrus' open your ears guys
ELONut 3 years ago
Thanks for the comment ELONut :)
I'm glad someone else said it finally. I thought maybe I wasn't a big music fan after reading the comments that I posted a Walrus remake. I like The Beatles, but I never heard it in this song. For me, this song is about a story. The opening lyrics are happy and the music is sad-ish, droning even, but just the opposite later. Everything he remembered from childhood is changed or gone, but the music is lifting. I don't know what he was saying, but I like it.
QueenGoofy 3 years ago
Well, Yes and No. Towards the end Jeff throws in a Beatles riff in it.
swarlock 3 years ago
What the Blue Bollocks is this?
This is fucking great. How come I haven't heard this before?
When did they do this? Sounds early.
VictorianSquire 3 years ago 4
a slower version of i am the walrus
princesschrissy555 3 years ago
"I am the walrus" is based on the same effect, but is a harmonic song. This song is not, if you listen to the track at 4'30'' or 6'35'' you can hear a lot of very well aranged cacophony, but after some it turns into "harmonic cacophony" - which does not exist. This song is not just a slower version of "I am the walrus", it is a very creative, progressive successor. This song shows up, Jeff Lynne is an inspired songwriter and composer.
FarFromZero 3 years ago 2
well yeah but in the beginning it sounds alot like it and im not saying that he isnt im just saying it sounds like a slower version of the song
princesschrissy555 3 years ago
Excellent observation!
Gorgnop 3 years ago
It's a great and moving song, and I guess Jeff wouldn't mind the comparison to Lennon's unique masterpiece, as you might remember Jeff saying that '10538 Overtures' takes over where 'I Am The Walrus' ends :-)
41805230 3 years ago 2
I think this is a great piece of music. I seem to remember reading that, inspired by Penny Lane & Strawberry Fields, Jeff wanted to do his own song about his childhood environment and came up with this.
andrewelo 3 years ago 4
I think it's a haunting tune, and a great one as well.
QueenGoofy 3 years ago
No, it sounds like solo John Lennon. To me
Mrwirez 3 years ago
bueno similar a los beatles.. pero no igual .. sim embargo es el trabajo de LYnne siempre apegado a al estilo de los chicos de Liverpool
merolillo 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Im pretty sure I am the walrus came out '67. This doesnt just sound like i am the walrus this is i am the walrus but with different lyrics
BebopCoIa 3 years ago
anyone notice how this SOUNDS almost exactly like The Beatles '69 hit "I Am The Walrus"???
zurg13 3 years ago
i've never compared it directly to that song, but i've thought it sounded like a late beatles era song...a great unknown track, one of my favorite ELO/Jeff Lynne tracks
fr556 3 years ago 2
Sounds more like a later Green Day song, not sure of the title. "On my own, here we go" or something like, that is the main lyric.
walrus108 3 years ago